User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Serious Question: How much strength/tackling do you think SHOULD be required to stop a very strong power back?
Page:
 
cbtd10
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by TehKyou

Hey Bort, when someone tackles a runner who is currently being dragged, can the play by play be changed from [tackle: name] to [gang tackle: name], then we can know a gang tackle took place and the guy who latched on might be visible under the body of the plow man.


That's a decent idea. I currently don't track half tackles or anything like that, so the latched on guy doesn't get much to see that he did anything.


Would be pretty nice to have it like the NFL with half tackles.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by turnit643

Bort, after sleeping on it (I'm assuming you slept at some point), any conclusions about the original question you asked to start this thread?


I'm thinking where I have it currently is about right - looking around at most games today, YPC are ranging from 2-5 in general, with a few outliers. That seems about right to me.

The reduction of LB dropoff seems to have helped quite a bit to keep the rushing game in check, as well as the interior D line doing more.

As I've been looking around, I've seen an awful lot of 90% WR screen offenses too, with 90% completion pct but 2 yards per pass LOL.


I think where you have it is good, also. I definitely saw a difference with the reduction in LB dropoff, with a lot of plays being stopped for 2ish yards by LB's who couldn't have done that before.

Please don't let whiners push you into reversing this: Please keep Strength/Tackling important, as they are now.
 
turnit643
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by turnit643


Bort, after sleeping on it (I'm assuming you slept at some point), any conclusions about the original question you asked to start this thread?


I'm thinking where I have it currently is about right - looking around at most games today, YPC are ranging from 2-5 in general, with a few outliers. That seems about right to me.

The reduction of LB dropoff seems to have helped quite a bit to keep the rushing game in check, as well as the interior D line doing more.

As I've been looking around, I've seen an awful lot of 90% WR screen offenses too, with 90% completion pct but 2 yards per pass LOL.


I think where you have it is good, also. I definitely saw a difference with the reduction in LB dropoff, with a lot of plays being stopped for 2ish yards by LB's who couldn't have done that before.

Please don't let whiners push you into reversing this: Please keep Strength/Tackling important, as they are now.


This is about where I'm at with it too. As the agent for a handful of those "crappy" balanced build LBs, I've been waiting for the days that the CB's in LB's clothing would get brought back to Earth. Of course my guys will still never run down many 90-speed guys, but oh well, that's the trade off I suppose. LB-in' ain't easy.
 
Sigmaforce
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by turnit643


Bort, after sleeping on it (I'm assuming you slept at some point), any conclusions about the original question you asked to start this thread?


I'm thinking where I have it currently is about right - looking around at most games today, YPC are ranging from 2-5 in general, with a few outliers. That seems about right to me.

The reduction of LB dropoff seems to have helped quite a bit to keep the rushing game in check, as well as the interior D line doing more.

As I've been looking around, I've seen an awful lot of 90% WR screen offenses too, with 90% completion pct but 2 yards per pass LOL.


I think where you have it is good, also. I definitely saw a difference with the reduction in LB dropoff, with a lot of plays being stopped for 2ish yards by LB's who couldn't have done that before.

Please don't let whiners push you into reversing this: Please keep Strength/Tackling important, as they are now.


I agree with this. The LB dropoff has helped things greatly, and players who didn't neglect tackling/strength too much are doing fine I think. My 3 LBs are built appropriately, and have been doing fine tackling the power backs and haven't been burned much in the passing game either. People just want a LB who can easily get to the QB for a sack, cover a 90 speed receiver, force fumbles, and tackle a bulldozer 20 out of 20 times, and don't realize you can't be perfect at all 4 at our levels, maybe ever.
Last edited Dec 30, 2008 16:25:15
 
MrNomad
offline
Link
 
On the other end of this equation does the defenses think that a 50 speed 50 agi CB should be keeping up with the 100 speed 70 agi WRs with appropriate SAs to both. Cause basically that's what some people are crying about when a 100 STR HB with 65 carry and the appropriate SAs plows over their 50 50 str tackle guy and then cries about it.
Last edited Dec 30, 2008 16:28:55
 
RTS
offline
Link
 
A Power back that is that powerful isn't going to be stopped "consistently", however, once someone with a certain amount of tackling and strength does go for the tackle perhaps the could simply HOLD ON to the back until a 2nd tackler arrives... even a 3rd to bring them down.

Maybe the answer is not how much Strength and Tackling do you need, but how do you tackle someone that powerful. Sometimes just HOLDING on is the answer.
Last edited Dec 30, 2008 16:29:59
 
Sigmaforce
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tahl
A Power back that is that powerful isn't going to be stopped "consistently", however, once someone with a certain amount of tackling and strength does go for the tackle perhaps the could simply HOLD ON to the back until a 2nd tackler arrives... even a 3rd to bring them down.

Maybe the answer is not how much Strength and Tackling do you need, but how do you tackle someone that powerful. Sometimes just HOLDING on is the answer.


I think the slowdown when running through a group of players does this pretty well, whether or not there's actually group tackles so far I don't know (might be in this thread, haven't read it all). But having that HB slowdown when running through a pile of defenders allows other players to come in and make the tackle easier.
 
BDizzle80
BuCkEyEs
offline
Link
 
I haven't read anything after page 1 in this thread so sorry if someone has already mentioned, but why not add a feature to the defensive tactics:

Give us a slider bar for tackling such that we can adjust it depending on player position and competition.

The slider could read: -100 tackle low..........0..........+100 tackle high.

Defensive backs might benefit from setting tackling to low (at players feet) since they generally have lower strength, while linemen could set to tackle high (waist or higher) because they tend to have high strength.


Just an idea. Thoughts???
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BDizzle80
I haven't read anything after page 1 in this thread so sorry if someone has already mentioned, but why not add a feature to the defensive tactics:

Give us a slider bar for tackling such that we can adjust it depending on player position and competition.

The slider could read: -100 tackle low..........0..........+100 tackle high.

Defensive backs might benefit from setting tackling to low (at players feet) since they generally have lower strength, while linemen could set to tackle high (waist or higher) because they tend to have high strength.


Just an idea. Thoughts???


but see, thats what the tackling SKILL is for. you don't need a bar for that, if you add to tackling, you will automatically tackle better.

trying to institute these bars or what not to get an advantage instead of having to put SPs into tackling is whats wrong.
 
RTS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sigmaforce
Originally posted by tahl

A Power back that is that powerful isn't going to be stopped "consistently", however, once someone with a certain amount of tackling and strength does go for the tackle perhaps the could simply HOLD ON to the back until a 2nd tackler arrives... even a 3rd to bring them down.

Maybe the answer is not how much Strength and Tackling do you need, but how do you tackle someone that powerful. Sometimes just HOLDING on is the answer.


I think the slowdown when running through a group of players does this pretty well, whether or not there's actually group tackles so far I don't know (might be in this thread, haven't read it all). But having that HB slowdown when running through a pile of defenders allows other players to come in and make the tackle easier.

That's a really good point... Hrmm, but what of the open field LB that catches him just after the RB get's through the line. He's probably strong enough to hold on to the RB if not bring him down. Could help the crazy yardage after he makes it through the slow down from the line.
 
cotterill101
offline
Link
 
I'd say about 65-100 STR and then ABOUT 70 TCK
 
GP1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cotterill101
I'd say about 65-100 STR and then ABOUT 70 TCK


Note to self, make powerback.
 
BDizzle80
BuCkEyEs
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rmiller517
Originally posted by BDizzle80

I haven't read anything after page 1 in this thread so sorry if someone has already mentioned, but why not add a feature to the defensive tactics:

Give us a slider bar for tackling such that we can adjust it depending on player position and competition.

The slider could read: -100 tackle low..........0..........+100 tackle high.

Defensive backs might benefit from setting tackling to low (at players feet) since they generally have lower strength, while linemen could set to tackle high (waist or higher) because they tend to have high strength.


Just an idea. Thoughts???


but see, thats what the tackling SKILL is for. you don't need a bar for that, if you add to tackling, you will automatically tackle better.

trying to institute these bars or what not to get an advantage instead of having to put SPs into tackling is whats wrong.


Why not have tactics for tackling? The running style and pass coverage have tactics.
 
cmj33
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by turnit643


Bort, after sleeping on it (I'm assuming you slept at some point), any conclusions about the original question you asked to start this thread?


I'm thinking where I have it currently is about right - looking around at most games today, YPC are ranging from 2-5 in general, with a few outliers. That seems about right to me.

The reduction of LB dropoff seems to have helped quite a bit to keep the rushing game in check, as well as the interior D line doing more.

As I've been looking around, I've seen an awful lot of 90% WR screen offenses too, with 90% completion pct but 2 yards per pass LOL.


I think where you have it is good, also. I definitely saw a difference with the reduction in LB dropoff, with a lot of plays being stopped for 2ish yards by LB's who couldn't have done that before.

Please don't let whiners push you into reversing this: Please keep Strength/Tackling important, as they are now.


Ken STR and TKL should be important I agree. But why was this not taken care of when the Galaxy Aces where putting every available SP into SPD? The sim looks much more realisic I will give you that. My point has been this entire time that such an extreme change is ridiculous. I did not say it does not need to be changed. MY LBers have faced power backs before and NEVER had 7 missed tackles in a game. If you want to compete then you must build your players according to who you are facing correct? So if most of the HB's in my league are 85-90 Speed then my LBer has to have speed to beat him to the hole, not because I want him to cover a WR thats the CB;s job and thats why you have depth at CB. My complaint here is that each and every season Bort finds something to change. And he doesn't just change it he totally redoes the entire system rendering some builds that where great in season 6 useless in season 7. Let us know before you make these changes that way we are not paying Bort our money to have a good product that we have built turned upside down because he wanted to kill the monster he created.

 
Sigmaforce
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tahl


That's a really good point... Hrmm, but what of the open field LB that catches him just after the RB get's through the line. He's probably strong enough to hold on to the RB if not bring him down. Could help the crazy yardage after he makes it through the slow down from the line.


It would be useful for that, but the HB does get stopped for a bit during these types of situations already (at least some of the time) the times when I see little slow down is usually from a FS or CB trying to make the tackle from behind, and they just get stopped dead.

I wouldn't mind seeing some general holding and slowing down the HB instead of the just make tackle or missed tackle we see now (that I can tell) Seeing the LB being dragged behind the HB for a short distance at reduced speed maybe, before getting shed and the HB can accelerate if there aren't other defenders in the area then.

I still don't think there's a whole lot that needs to be done to stop power backs though, my LBs are around 60 strength and 50 tackling, and they get the job done.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.