User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > GLB Insider: The truth behind all the teams leaving.
Page:
 
LordEvil
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Steelyeye
Originally posted by papabear

Can we really blame the cost of a team for the fact it fails? If we make the cost of owning a team lets say $100 a year, aprox. 3 times what it is now, would that solve it? Or would it make things more difficult for players since owners will have some real money invested and could they then in turn make it harder on players?


If it cost that much I would not want to buy a team.


I would have to chose between my players or a team, I would take the team because I like challenges.
 
papabear
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fittybuk
Originally posted by papabear

So where does the majority of the chips fall? Can we put the blame for failed teams on any one person? Should we place blame on any one person?


I don't know if this has been posted yet or not.. I didn't read the whole thread.. but like every online game.. there is a HUGE influx of players/people in the summer months because all the kids are out of school. Once school starts again... whoosh... they vanish. So my guess is that a bunch of "school kids" are buying teams to get them through the summer months.. then back to school then they are more interested in "other stuff"


Interesting point:

Does the influx of younger players into a game in which real $$ is an issue, knowing that they will be less responsible with their teams, knowing they will give them up in 2 months, cause problems that could easily be avoided by making an age limit for team ownership?

ORIGINAL POST UPDATED
Last edited Aug 29, 2008 10:17:16
 
Link
 
Originally posted by papabear


EDIT: (8/29/08 9:55 am CDT)WHAT HAVE WE LEARNED SO FAR:
1. One of the main reasons team owners are leaving is because of the difficulty of AI tactics. Making it much more difficult for teams to compete.



But you don't have to use it. My CPL team doesn't use the Def. AI and we're doing fine.

Originally posted by


2. Owners are buying teams with no intent to continue beyond one season.


This is probably very true.

Originally posted by

3. Once in a loosing spiral there is no way to get out. (This one I am unsure of but will post the thought anyway)


That's not really true, although if it is, it's likely a relection of the player market.

Originally posted by

4. Owners feel creators (i.e. management) do not care if they are struggling.


I'm not sure what this means. Is this saying that the Admins should bail out poor teams, or that the Admins don't do anything to prevent teams from losing.

Originally posted by

5. (10:15 AM CDT) Owners are leaving due to the frustration of dealing with FA's and the hassle of having to spend so much time dealing with players who do not care.


QFT
Originally posted by

6. Gutted teams make more gutted teams. Meaning the spiral of one gutted team in a league makes it harder for all the other owners, which in turns causes more gutted teams.


This doesn't sound true. My league had 2 gutted teams (and Dong), and we still have that number. I don't think gutting is contagious.
Originally posted by

7. Too many changes too fast. Staying above the curve of changes was too much for some owners to deal with. What was once a winning team now doesn't have the build to be able to compete.


I agree here, there are a ton of updates, and I'd like to be able to gather more data to analize them. Still, I consider myself warned.
Originally posted by

8. (11:00AM CDT)Teams being purchased by people without fully realizing what they are getting into thus setting them up for failure from the start.


QFT yet again.

The biggest issue of the game isn't parity, the AI, or even the SIM code. It's the player base.

The survival of this game depends on a players willingness to be a 10-6 team that loses in the first round of the playoffs 3 years in a row. People have to be willing to spend time in Football Purgatory along with the Buffalo Bills and Seattle Seahawks.

Many players come into the game with experience in Madden and WoW and expect to instantly be able to not only compete but to progress at their own pace and reach some sort of endgame. Sadly, GLB isn't like that, it's a competitive MMORPG and we're going to need players for all levels of the pyramid, not just the top.
 
LordEvil
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by papabear
Originally posted by fittybuk

Originally posted by papabear


So where does the majority of the chips fall? Can we put the blame for failed teams on any one person? Should we place blame on any one person?


I don't know if this has been posted yet or not.. I didn't read the whole thread.. but like every online game.. there is a HUGE influx of players/people in the summer months because all the kids are out of school. Once school starts again... whoosh... they vanish. So my guess is that a bunch of "school kids" are buying teams to get them through the summer months.. then back to school then they are more interested in "other stuff"


Interesting point:

Does the influx of younger players into a game in which real $$ is an issue, knowing that they will be less responsible with their teams, knowing they will give them up in 2 months, cause problems that could easily be avoided by making an age limit for team ownership?

ORIGINAL POST UPDATED


Shopuld also be required by the players name, I wouldnt want to be signing 13 year old kids players on my team knowing what I have spent months building they will just flat out quit once school starts back up.
 
Kwill-bot
offline
Link
 
Well, what's the better solution to the dropped teams? Does Bort try to proactively forbid younger/less committed people from getting teams by increasing the cost?
Or do you develop a quick, effective way to remove and relegate the teams that fail?

I think the second option is probably a better one.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Owners want what's best for their investment, agents want what's best for their investment, and the two don't coincide often enough. That's the big problem.

In "the real game" players can take one for the team because they're getting paid millions of dollars, and teams can take chances on players because their team is making millions of dollars; in GLB owners are paying money to own their team and agents are paying money to own their player so there's no give, only take.
 
Tito716
offline
Link
 
Vanilla Thunder, what league had 2 guttd teams?

Canada Pro?

2 gutted teams since when? This season? 2 gutted teams every season?
 
Krunchy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

The biggest issue of the game isn't parity, the AI, or even the SIM code. It's the player base.

The survival of this game depends on a players willingness to be a 10-6 team that loses in the first round of the playoffs 3 years in a row. People have to be willing to spend time in Football Purgatory along with the Buffalo Bills and Seattle Seahawks.


I think you can pretty much wrap up this thread now, because the above quote perfectly describes the Free Agent problem.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
As for:
Originally posted by OP
4. Owners feel creators (i.e. management) do not care if they are struggling.

It's the wrong feeling, but it's easy to see why they feel it. Losses bring morale, and making moves to improve your team via trades or recruiting lowers your chemistry bar.

With lower morale you'll probably lose some semi-close games, but if you made moves to improve your team the chemistry hit would totally offset the benefits of bringing in better players with higher morale.

Losing teams see the team morale drop when they lose and the chemistry bars drop when they try to improve. Even if those two bars were totally irrelevant to the actual sim, it gives the feeling of "I'm getting the shaft, no matter what I do a bar drops!".

Plus, look at all the stuff "in the works" just in the forum topic titles.
"Gutting/Collusion ideas" from early May is nearing 1450 replies; nothing yet.
"Moving sold teams to the bottom tier" is over 300 replies from late June; nothing yet.
"Known Bugs" last edited mid-May, several of those issues still exist.
The Harper Incident; old news now, but the end result was hidden in the middle of a massive topic and people still don't realize that he's no longer a mod (let alone why he's not a mod).

Bort's continually saying "We should do this, this is next, this needs dealing with, I acknowledge this is an issue" and making topics in the forums about them, but what actually gets done?
On the outside, it appears nothing is getting done; if and when something IS done, there's a good possibility you have to dig around a huge topic with hundreds of replies to figure out whatever was done, instead of being formally announced.
Last edited Aug 29, 2008 10:32:54
 
Tito716
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Krunchy
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder


The biggest issue of the game isn't parity, the AI, or even the SIM code. It's the player base.

The survival of this game depends on a players willingness to be a 10-6 team that loses in the first round of the playoffs 3 years in a row. People have to be willing to spend time in Football Purgatory along with the Buffalo Bills and Seattle Seahawks.


I think you can pretty much wrap up this thread now, because the above quote perfectly describes the Free Agent problem.


Its kind of true.

The problem is, GLB needs players that are willing to be on 3-13 teams for 2 or 3 seasons before they get relegated, and then still resign with the team and work to try to turn it around, even though there are 10-6 teams that lost in the first round of the playoffs 3 years in a row offering them contracts every season (even when they are already under contract).
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Tito716
Vanilla Thunder, what league had 2 guttd teams?

Canada Pro?

2 gutted teams since when? This season? 2 gutted teams every season?


Well you had 2 teams that were pretty much gutted last season and the new owners couldn't compete in CPL, so they'll be getting relegated. Then we had Donggate, so I don't really count that team.
Last edited Aug 29, 2008 10:27:58
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Tito716
Originally posted by Krunchy

Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder



The biggest issue of the game isn't parity, the AI, or even the SIM code. It's the player base.

The survival of this game depends on a players willingness to be a 10-6 team that loses in the first round of the playoffs 3 years in a row. People have to be willing to spend time in Football Purgatory along with the Buffalo Bills and Seattle Seahawks.


I think you can pretty much wrap up this thread now, because the above quote perfectly describes the Free Agent problem.


Its kind of true.

The problem is, GLB needs players that are willing to be on 3-13 teams for 2 or 3 seasons before they get relegated, and then still resign with the team and work to try to turn it around, even though there are 10-6 teams that lost in the first round of the playoffs 3 years in a row offering them contracts every season (even when they are already under contract).


THIS THIS THIS!
 
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
As for:
Originally posted by OP

4. Owners feel creators (i.e. management) do not care if they are struggling.

It's the wrong feeling, but it's easy to see why they feel it. Losses bring morale, and making moves to improve your team via trades or recruiting lowers your chemistry bar.

With lower morale you'll probably lose some semi-close games, but if you made moves to improve your team the chemistry hit would totally offset the benefits of bringing in better players with higher morale.

Losing teams see the team morale drop when they lose and the chemistry bars drop when they try to improve. Even if those two bars were totally irrelevant to the actual sim, it gives the feeling of "I'm getting the shaft, no matter what I do a bar drops!".


Sure, this season, but next you'll be much better off. It's a long-term game.
 
papabear
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Krunchy
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder


The biggest issue of the game isn't parity, the AI, or even the SIM code. It's the player base.

The survival of this game depends on a players willingness to be a 10-6 team that loses in the first round of the playoffs 3 years in a row. People have to be willing to spend time in Football Purgatory along with the Buffalo Bills and Seattle Seahawks.


I think you can pretty much wrap up this thread now, because the above quote perfectly describes the Free Agent problem.


Is this attributed by the game calling itself an MMORPG? Where one would expect to grow in level and achieve some sort of "top rank".
Last edited Aug 29, 2008 10:30:34
 
Link
 
Originally posted by papabear
Originally posted by Krunchy

Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder



The biggest issue of the game isn't parity, the AI, or even the SIM code. It's the player base.

The survival of this game depends on a players willingness to be a 10-6 team that loses in the first round of the playoffs 3 years in a row. People have to be willing to spend time in Football Purgatory along with the Buffalo Bills and Seattle Seahawks.


I think you can pretty much wrap up this thread now, because the above quote perfectly describes the Free Agent problem.


Is this attributed by the game calling itself an MMORPG? Where one would expect to grow in level and achieve some sort of "top rank".


That's actually a fair point, as I don't know of too many MMORPGs that are truely 100% PvP, so to speak.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.