User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > South America A Leagues > South America A #3 > South America A #3: The Committee's Pro Bowl Thread
Page:
 
GMathiasf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tlsmith
Originally posted by GMathiasf

What do you think about the idea to have every ballot include at least 1 player from every team?


Mmm, I am not throwing any United Evolution players on my ballot. That is something I can say without even inspecting teams.


After quickly scanning their roster, they have a DE that I could vote for if necessary. I just think it brings the lower teams to be interested in the voting. Otherwise, why should they even vote in this? I don't really see why not? Just include reserves on the pro-bowl team.
 
lolShowtime
offline
Link
 
Count Bogota in.
 
dirkthe1
offline
Link
 
the only thing is that if players can vote for own team. and we could just do an MVP for the conference which includes all teams
 
Loco Moco
offline
Link
 
The owners in this conference should obviously have first say as to how this all works, but I'd like to make a suggestion FOR NEXT SEASON if possible.
I'm just throwing it out there because I feel this would lead to a more accurate Pro Bowl Selection process.

Based on how this is set up, it is obviously stat driven because we're being asked to judge players on other teams. Obviously stats are a good representation of performance, but they don't paint the complete picture of how good or valuable a player is to his team.

I think team owners should be nominating their best players (top 5 or so) and then voting should be based on that. They should state why each of their five best players are worthy of a Pro Bowl selection and what their major accomplishments were.

Right now, how else are we supposed to judge the other teams' players? Especially guys with very little stats to go off of.

It's just a suggestion and I leave it out there for you to ponder.

Thanks to MGood030 for all his efforts in putting together the rankings each week and for getting the ball rolling with the Pro Bowl.

Go Scorpions!
 
GMathiasf
offline
Link
 
I would say that this is the same way with most all-star teams at any level. They are stat driven. Of course, some people will be able to delve into the stats a little deeper like myself. When looking at DTs, I would first look at the yards rushing the TEAM allowed and then check each of the top teams contributors. Also, I look at who did what against us. I don't think it's a bad idea to nominate players but to be honest, I don't know how the Ligers could nominate only 5. Not trying to be arrogant, but we have at least 15 players that should be considered for their position. For instance, both our kicker and punter our at the top of the conference, we have the #1 and #2 half backs and of course the OLine that helped them get there. Oh shit, that's more than 5 already and I haven't even touched our defense. Honestly, I think that's a little too limiting of a concept.
 
dirkthe1
offline
Link
 
hes so modest
 
MGood030
offline
Link
 
First off..Amazon GM..are you guys in? I have not posted a format, in fact, I won't be posting a format. It will be through a PM to the Owner's whose teams have committed to doing this. It will be largely based on the ballot example Nance gave us (and thanks to him, btw).

Second off, I feel Loco's idea is a bit too limited as well. With the exception of a blocking FB, and a Shutdown CB, pretty much every other position you can get a good read on using stats. Most owners are also involved in gameplanning, so they know who's good in this league and who isn't.

I still want every team to be represented. I understand the arguement against this, but what message is it sending to teams when we just write them off because they're slow building or whatever. I want everyone to feel like they're a part of this league. I dunno.

 
navytexas1
offline
Link
 
if you have firebox. you can look at skill bar to see who has the best build. I refuse to take part in any bowl game now or in the future.
 
GMathiasf
offline
Link
 
it's not a game man, it's just recognition and trust me your players weren't going to be elected.
 
GMathiasf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MGood030
First off..Amazon GM..are you guys in? I have not posted a format, in fact, I won't be posting a format. It will be through a PM to the Owner's whose teams have committed to doing this. It will be largely based on the ballot example Nance gave us (and thanks to him, btw).

Second off, I feel Loco's idea is a bit too limited as well. With the exception of a blocking FB, and a Shutdown CB, pretty much every other position you can get a good read on using stats. Most owners are also involved in gameplanning, so they know who's good in this league and who isn't.

I still want every team to be represented. I understand the arguement against this, but what message is it sending to teams when we just write them off because they're slow building or whatever. I want everyone to feel like they're a part of this league. I dunno.



OK, we'll the Ligers will be at least voluntarily voting at least one player from every team to the pro bowl. If some owners do not want to do this because they feel that the players are not deserving, that is their prerogative. I will include at least one in our votes.
 
bsgilani
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MGood030
First off..Amazon GM..are you guys in? I have not posted a format, in fact, I won't be posting a format. It will be through a PM to the Owner's whose teams have committed to doing this. It will be largely based on the ballot example Nance gave us (and thanks to him, btw).

Second off, I feel Loco's idea is a bit too limited as well. With the exception of a blocking FB, and a Shutdown CB, pretty much every other position you can get a good read on using stats. Most owners are also involved in gameplanning, so they know who's good in this league and who isn't.

I still want every team to be represented. I understand the arguement against this, but what message is it sending to teams when we just write them off because they're slow building or whatever. I want everyone to feel like they're a part of this league. I dunno.



Yeah, stunzeed received your PM and asked me to set up our probowl list.
 
GMathiasf
offline
Link
 
Looks like we're closing in on about 50% of teams.
 
jmadsen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by adam321
31 touchdowns 3,730 yards per game is nasty


Amen.
 
Bobbito
offline
Link
 
Lets get to the heart of the matter and talk about what matters most.

The punters!

 
GMathiasf
offline
Link
 
haha, if only we would have let you punt more! ;P
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.