User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Prestige Attributes - A way to reduce the "stagnation plateau" for higher level players and add more differentiation among cookie cutter builds
Page:
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Some others:

Comeback Kid: Provides a bonus to offensive players' making big plays when behind. This isn't Clutch, as it's when behind by 1 or by 40, and it only applies to big play potential.

So a QB or WR or TE would get bonuses from this, when behind, on long passes (but only long passes), or a HB when in the clear or trying a move or broken tackle that will put him in the clear for a big play.

Special Teamer: Bonuses across the board when playing on special teams as something other than a returner.

Energy Bounceback: When a player isn't in the game, he recovers energy faster (both "breath" and "freshness"). Not the same as Stamina as it doesn't affect how fast it's lost when in the game.

Thick Skin: The player is affected less by intimidation abilities (not the same as Confidence, because it doesn't help a player who, say, just fumbled maintain morale).



DIdn't see this before I posted my underdog one. Comeback kid could be a separate one. Underdog when you are outmatched. Comeback kind when you are down. I like it.


 
amo368
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi


Heck, even having reached some stat milestones could be a good idea.


Hmm, like if you score 10 rushing TDs in a season you unlock the "rushing TD" skills or something like that?


Don't think that's a good idea. Encouraging stat padding will backfire in the long run.


Yup.
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
You already admitted to playing EVE - or atleast understanding a bit about it - which means you understand that "EVERYTHING happens at the margins" So the idea that effects are fairly minor doesn't really convince me of anything. Minor effects, when stacked, can have pretty large impacts.

My statement regarding the importance of boosting is similar to this scenario: Imagine GLB if you removed nightly experience gains... think about how effective it would be to get game time. Now add back in the nightly experience gains - Game time is still important, but it would be relatively less important than it was in a situation of no nightly exp gains.

The Increasing cap isn't the same as 1 point in an attribute -- I'm off in my own world - but in my own world, it might work better to just have each 5 levels of the new ability just plop 1 point into the base attribute, very much as if it was equipment bonuses.
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi


Heck, even having reached some stat milestones could be a good idea.


Hmm, like if you score 10 rushing TDs in a season you unlock the "rushing TD" skills or something like that?


Don't think that's a good idea. Encouraging stat padding will backfire in the long run.


Encouraging stat Padding? How many Players out there try to avoid getting 10 rushing TD's in a season? Everyone who intentionally avoids it, in the current game, please raise their hands. Anyone?

Everyone already has as much incentive for stat padding as you could possibly need to always try to play as best you can. my initial point was actually to try and create some incentives for Players to join teams that are rebuilding... but there is no reason why Players that have achieved "excellent" milestones shouldn't also unlock skills.
 
Seric
offline
Link
 
I like this idea.
 
Amyrlin
offline
Link
 
Good Actor: Increases the probability of a penalty being called on an opposing player. Preferably an opposing player that makes sense. i.e. a center with Good Actor would be more likely to draw the opposing NT offsides, and slightly more likely to draw other opposing linemen offsides. A quarterback with Good Actor would be more likely to get a roughing the passer penalty called when he throws under pressure. Everyone would be more likely to get personal fouls called on opposing players they are matched up with.

If you want an example of this from the NFL... watch what Tom Brady does whenever a defensive player gets within a foot of him - he throws the ball then falls to the ground as if he'd just been trucked over.

Play Through Pain: For when injuries are implemented... makes it less likely for that player to miss playing time due to injury.

Pep Talk: When this player is on the bench, he increases the morale of every other player on the bench.

Unshakeable: Makes low morale affect this player's performance less. (Different from Confidence in that it doesn't affect the player's morale directly and doesn't speed up morale gain/slow down morale loss... and even with a bunch of points in Unshakeable a player with low morale will play worse than a player with high morale.)

Touchdown Maker (or Nose For The Endzone): On offense, this player gets a boost to performance when close to the endzone. On defense, this player gets a (much larger) boost to performance when the defense forces a turnover.

High Spirits: This player loses game-to-game morale slower from losses, and gains it faster from victories. (Or does Confidence already do this?)

Fan Favorite: When playing at home, this player's presence will draw more spectators to the game. (Might be made outdated by the Fame system.)

Own Agent: This player is his own agent... so he gets a slight boost to his salary (no agent fees).

Locker Room Presence: This player is a good influence on the locker room environment. The rest of the team gets a morale boost at halftime. Additionally, the rest of the team gets the same effects as this player would get from High Spirits.

Celebrity Girlfriend: This player has a hot celebrity girlfriend. He loses 75% of his salary. She comes to all of his games and distracts him, leading to poor performance on the field. But it's worth it because she's hot.

Playoff... something: This player performs better in the playoffs.

Media Darling: This player is beloved of the media and is on TV a lot, drawing attention to the team. The player's team loses fan support slower from losses and gains it faster from victories.

Tom Brady: This player is Tom Brady. He gets all of the above abilities.
 
El_Windex
Baby Executive
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Originally posted by drifter

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi



Heck, even having reached some stat milestones could be a good idea.


Hmm, like if you score 10 rushing TDs in a season you unlock the "rushing TD" skills or something like that?


Don't think that's a good idea. Encouraging stat padding will backfire in the long run.


Encouraging stat Padding? How many Players out there try to avoid getting 10 rushing TD's in a season? Everyone who intentionally avoids it, in the current game, please raise their hands. Anyone?

Everyone already has as much incentive for stat padding as you could possibly need to always try to play as best you can. my initial point was actually to try and create some incentives for Players to join teams that are rebuilding... but there is no reason why Players that have achieved "excellent" milestones shouldn't also unlock skills.


I think he meant to address the people who go to inferior leagues to stat pad and the owners who will skew energy settings so that their players can achieve the opportunities necessary to stat pad. As long as this prestige XP falls under the same sportsmanship restrictions as regular XP, I'm cool with it. The last thing I need to see is level 32s joining an inferior uncapped league to unlock their prestige abilities faster.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
I wouldn't mind extra VP's for milestones (I'll be calling them VP's = Veteran Points, the equivalent of XP's within the system), but they shouldn't be the only way to unlock abilities or to get VP's.

Whatever Bort likes from this set could unlock at Level 30 or 31, depending on when VP's can be gained (I'd start Level 1 of VP's at level 30).

Down the road people will likely have other suggestions, which could be implemented for for Season 6, that might be abilities that unlocked at VP Level 15 or something. They wouldn't necessarily be better, but just that if there are enough new suggestions, they could still be added and just unlock at higher levels.

Then, career milestones could give bonus VP's to help gain VP levels and spend on these attributes.

Edited to add: As of Page 9, GG hijacks the thread to filibuster his idea that's been repeatedly rejected. While there's also some worthwhile on-topic content in between all the hijacking posts, the real discussion (hopefully) continues on Page 19.
Last edited Aug 27, 2008 12:08:46
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Amyrlin
Good Actor: Increases the probability of a penalty being called on an opposing player. Preferably an opposing player that makes sense. i.e. a center with Good Actor would be more likely to draw the opposing NT offsides, and slightly more likely to draw other opposing linemen offsides. A quarterback with Good Actor would be more likely to get a roughing the passer penalty called when he throws under pressure. Everyone would be more likely to get personal fouls called on opposing players they are matched up with.

If you want an example of this from the NFL... watch what Tom Brady does whenever a defensive player gets within a foot of him - he throws the ball then falls to the ground as if he'd just been trucked over.

Play Through Pain: For when injuries are implemented... makes it less likely for that player to miss playing time due to injury.

Pep Talk: When this player is on the bench, he increases the morale of every other player on the bench.

Unshakeable: Makes low morale affect this player's performance less. (Different from Confidence in that it doesn't affect the player's morale directly and doesn't speed up morale gain/slow down morale loss... and even with a bunch of points in Unshakeable a player with low morale will play worse than a player with high morale.)

Touchdown Maker (or Nose For The Endzone): On offense, this player gets a boost to performance when close to the endzone. On defense, this player gets a (much larger) boost to performance when the defense forces a turnover.

High Spirits: This player loses game-to-game morale slower from losses, and gains it faster from victories. (Or does Confidence already do this?)

Fan Favorite: When playing at home, this player's presence will draw more spectators to the game. (Might be made outdated by the Fame system.)

Own Agent: This player is his own agent... so he gets a slight boost to his salary (no agent fees).

Locker Room Presence: This player is a good influence on the locker room environment. The rest of the team gets a morale boost at halftime. Additionally, the rest of the team gets the same effects as this player would get from High Spirits.

Celebrity Girlfriend: This player has a hot celebrity girlfriend. He loses 75% of his salary. She comes to all of his games and distracts him, leading to poor performance on the field. But it's worth it because she's hot.

Playoff... something: This player performs better in the playoffs.

Media Darling: This player is beloved of the media and is on TV a lot, drawing attention to the team. The player's team loses fan support slower from losses and gains it faster from victories.

Tom Brady: This player is Tom Brady. He gets all of the above abilities.


Good stuff - I'd just comment that the media darling and fan favorite could be applied to the upcoming addition of fame. Also those ones and lockerroom presence are very similar to my "locker room attributes" concept which is a bit different from this. I encourage you to read it. It's good stuff

Your playoff one could be called "Postseason Performer".

I'm unsure of the ones tied to morale and confidence since this is all dictated simply by confidence. I think you need to avoid having something that will duplicate the results that a regular attribute or SA has.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
The OP.


I hate you and think very little of you. However this is the best thing you have ever said. This would make the game much more fun.
Last edited Aug 26, 2008 17:13:14
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by El_Windex

I think he meant to address the people who go to inferior leagues to stat pad and the owners who will skew energy settings so that their players can achieve the opportunities necessary to stat pad. As long as this prestige XP falls under the same sportsmanship restrictions as regular XP, I'm cool with it. The last thing I need to see is level 32s joining an inferior uncapped league to unlock their prestige abilities faster.


Ahh, I see - I go on the working premise that one of Bort's top goals is to increase the incentive for Players to play at the highest league possible to reduce the number of Players doing this. I might be wrong in that goal, but it's kinda like a doctor working on a critically injured patient - the doctor HAS to believe that there is a chance of survival, otherwise the doctor will realize that they are wasting effort that could be better spent on other patients. (a very good analogy when you think about it, I am placing myself into the role of doctor, with the game being the patient - you might not want me as the doctor.. but it explains why I am always trying to butt in and offer suggestions)
 
Snakebite99
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Amyrlin
Celebrity Girlfriend: This player has a hot celebrity girlfriend. He loses 75% of his salary. She comes to all of his games and distracts him, leading to poor performance on the field. But it's worth it because she's hot.



Tom Brady: This player is Tom Brady. He gets all of the above abilities.


Most of your ideas are decent, but these two SUCK tbqh .
 
GG
offline
Link
 
I'm not sure about this idea. It's just a smoke-and-mirrors way to give veteran players more attribute firepower to demolish low level players. All the skills discussed as part of "prestige" are going to have an affect inside the sim. It'll mean they just keep getting better faster, and not only maintain but increase the disparity between levels....more than it will address any cookie-cutter builds....as again, people will find those things that work or most help.

If this idea gets endorsed then it's a bit of a slap in the face to all those other ideas that got told "no that's too much of an overhaul". Specifically, ideas around creating a new SA area, that are free form and provide the flexibility of choosing different skills imo would do more for individualization of players than this idea.

 
Painmaker
offline
Link
 
Great idea presented well.... my hat's off to ya, drifter. I really like how you tied adding new player abilities (more content that's not a necessity but a nice-to-have) to filling the void of slower player leveling (something which should probably be addressed imo). Solving problems and adding content at the same time - genius!
Last edited Aug 26, 2008 17:26:05
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
I'm not sure about this idea. It's just a smoke-and-mirrors way to give veteran players more attribute firepower to demolish low level players. All the skills discussed as part of "prestige" are going to have an affect inside the sim. It'll mean they just keep getting better faster, and not only maintain but increase the disparity between levels....more than it will address any cookie-cutter builds....as again, people will find those things that work or most help.

If this idea gets endorsed then it's a bit of a slap in the face to all those other ideas that got told "no that's too much of an overhaul". Specifically, ideas around creating a new SA area, that are free form and provide the flexibility of choosing different skills imo would do more for individualization of players than this idea.


Oh, there is no doubt that this idea further increases the disparity between high level and low level Players.. BUT the reason this idea is better than the others I have seen is that this idea is outside of leveling. This idea actually decreases the value of going from level 34 to level 35, or from level 38 to 39 or whatever.

So yes, there would be a HUGE gap between level 29 and 30 (or 30 and 31), but the gaps between levels after that point would shrink considerably. Right now a big part of the problem with GLB is that the level gaps are too big. It makes the power differences of teams largely based upon the levels of the Players. I've argued for a while that it is the level gaps which cause gutting to be a problem... this idea, at least in the very long run, could lead to a situation where Players who want to play in the Pro leagues will boost to level 32, and then the option to boost isn't quite as mandatory because the majority of Player improvement comes from this new system.

Atleast that is how I am looking at this idea. Others might chime in and say I'm wrong - which will sour my support of the idea.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.