User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Kicker Inexplicably Unable to Hit XPs Consistently
Page:
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Robbnva
anyone think it is funny that this thread is 7 pages long and no bort? I believe bort is aware but can't or won't do anything to fix it.


Jesus, here comes the "Bort didn't immediately answer, WHY HATH HE FORSAKEN US WAAAAAAAAAAAH" garbage. Good lord.

If anything he's just going to smack you with the nerf stick again because kicking's still too easy. Nobody should be nailing 90% FGs around level 20.
 
Skanker irl
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool

If anything he's just going to smack you with the nerf stick again because kicking's still too easy. Nobody should be nailing 90% FGs around level 20.


This thread is not about field goals.

 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Skanker irl
Originally posted by oldskool


If anything he's just going to smack you with the nerf stick again because kicking's still too easy. Nobody should be nailing 90% FGs around level 20.


This thread is not about field goals.


Oh right, it's about wah i missed 2 XPs how not realistic. Most people don't have 70% of the "max" vision or confidence and there might be one or two with 100% kicking ability, but they still expect 100% precision on extra points. Bullplop, I say. Miss a kick once in a while and suck it up.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Auris
Also, by the way dude... really, it's really really broken.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=636565

He missed 1 XP out of 56 and he is a LVL 15! It was supposed to be IMPOSSIBLE for him to loose an XP. It must be broken!

Please Bort, change it!


[/sarcam]


I'm never complained about my kicker you useless troll. I was poking fun at the HORRIBLE sample size you used to try and "prove" your point that there is nothing wrong with the kicking game.

If you bothered to read any of my countless posts on this site, you'd know I don't whine about anything. In fact, I correct a lot of users who think there are bugs when there aren't.

In this case, I said XP's are missed too frequently on the whole, and FG's are hit too easily on the whole. Others are asking for XP's to be hit at a higher rate and want their kickers to be gods at kicking FG's as well.

Last thing - you obviously don't understand this game well enough if you think level means much of anything. It is all about the build, and my kicker is currently built to handle the short stuff easily, and as you can see from his stats, he isn't anywhere near hitting the long bomb consistently yet.

But keep trolling, trolling, trolling. If you didn't have a user I respect as a GM on your team, I'd keep going
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
Originally posted by Robbnva

he just got lucky with the random number generator


We have a winner. Let's say that a well built kicker at level 20 has a 1% chance to miss an XP.

If you kick two XPs you have a 2% chance of missing one! Kick three and now you have a 3% chance! By the time you are up to 10 XPs you have a 9.6% chance of having missed one of them and it only goes up from there.

So, If we have 1,000 kickers in the room that have kicked 10 XPs, 96 of them will have missed 10% of their XP's! Holy Smokes, that's a lot.

Well, not really...the problem is probability and a large sample means that if it CAN happen, it will!

The other issue is what we think is a good build, may not be.


Horrible math...statistics much.

If you have a 1% chance of missing an XP, it is 1% every time you kick an extra point. It doesn't increase the likelihood you'll miss an XP later on, as each roll, in your example, is out of 100, with only 1 number causing a missed XP.

Just wow...
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MMcBee
Originally posted by PackMan97

Well...in the NFL a kicker can easily have a 15-20 year career with no decline in skills. Perhaps we should petition bort to make an exception to the 10 year decline?


Definitely, yet... most kickers once they get past about 34 start declining in terms of power rather rapidly. I motion that Kickers more slowly degrade in skills than other positions. That way, they can still be effective and can have longer career's while not being overpowering in the wee years of their career's, mimicing the NFL where kickers/punters can still be effective up until age 40 Hanson, Feagles, ect.


Problem is that this is a game, and if you let certain positions "outlive" others, or stay effective for a longer time, you'll end up with a glut of that position, and decrease the time a later build gets to be at the top of the game (also increasing the competition for jobs when he is at the top)
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
Originally posted by Robbnva

anyone think it is funny that this thread is 7 pages long and no bort? I believe bort is aware but can't or won't do anything to fix it.


Jesus, here comes the "Bort didn't immediately answer, WHY HATH HE FORSAKEN US WAAAAAAAAAAAH" garbage. Good lord.

If anything he's just going to smack you with the nerf stick again because kicking's still too easy. Nobody should be nailing 90% FGs around level 20.


I agree 100% with this, which is rare OS
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE

Horrible math...statistics much.

If you have a 1% chance of missing an XP, it is 1% every time you kick an extra point. It doesn't increase the likelihood you'll miss an XP later on, as each roll, in your example, is out of 100, with only 1 number causing a missed XP.

Just wow...


What's wrong with my math? If you have a 1% chance of missing, you have a 99% chance of making.

If you take two in a row, your chances are .99 * .99 = 98.01% of making both, or 2% (rounded) chance of missing at least one.

If you kick 10, your chance of making all 10 is .99 ^ 10 = 90.4% or 9.5% of missing at least once.

I stand by my math, do you stand by yours?

Perhaps we are cross talking. I'm discussing the probability of out of 10 kicks, you'll miss at least once. Not if you've already made 10, what is the chance you'll make the next, which is also different than the chance you'll make 11 in a row.

<3 probability.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
I do -- I see where you are going, but each kick is its own single event. I don't believe the SIM takes into account how many kicks you have made or have not made in the past, it uses the RNG based on a number of factors for each event.

So each time you kick an XP, just using the example you started with, the kicker has a 99% chance of making the kick every single time out.

EDIT: I realize looking back at my post that I had let myself get frustrated at another post and it spilled over

I see what you are saying and in terms of probability, the chance of the same result happening over and over again decreases. But it is like flipping a coin - while it may be improbable that you keep flipping tails, each time you flip is a 50/50 chance.
Last edited Aug 22, 2008 12:26:49
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
SCACE, you are mixing two different questions.

A) Having flipped nine heads in a row, what is the chance the tenth will be heads? It is 50% chance since that single flip is a singular event.

B) What is the chance you will flip 10 heads in a row? 0.5 ^ 10 = 0.09% since each flip is dependent on the entire series of flips.

In question A, the flip is independent. In question B all the flips are dependent. Different math for each case.

You are talking about A, I'm talking about B.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Right, that is what I realized, as stated.

The fact remains that while the probability of flipping 10 heads in a row is very low, each flip is a singular event and what happened in the previous 9 flips doesn't matter.

The same is true in regards to XP's, to an even further degree as we aren't talking about a 50/50 chance.

Each kick after TD is a singular event with a high probability of success, and you have an equal chance to miss your first ever as you do to miss your 100th.
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
SCACE, we agree.
 
Luzod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Originally posted by Auris

Also, by the way dude... really, it's really really broken.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=636565

He missed 1 XP out of 56 and he is a LVL 15! It was supposed to be IMPOSSIBLE for him to loose an XP. It must be broken!

Please Bort, change it!


[/sarcam]


I'm never complained about my kicker you useless troll. I was poking fun at the HORRIBLE sample size you used to try and "prove" your point that there is nothing wrong with the kicking game.

If you bothered to read any of my countless posts on this site, you'd know I don't whine about anything. In fact, I correct a lot of users who think there are bugs when there aren't.

In this case, I said XP's are missed too frequently on the whole, and FG's are hit too easily on the whole. Others are asking for XP's to be hit at a higher rate and want their kickers to be gods at kicking FG's as well.

Last thing - you obviously don't understand this game well enough if you think level means much of anything. It is all about the build, and my kicker is currently built to handle the short stuff easily, and as you can see from his stats, he isn't anywhere near hitting the long bomb consistently yet.

But keep trolling, trolling, trolling. If you didn't have a user I respect as a GM on your team, I'd keep going


Looks like your lack of intelligence shows up in some of your ideas.

First, people must accept that this is NOT NFL. Would be silly to admit a level 15 can have the same strength as a lvl 30. As many low/mid levels have great %, I'd point out, as Auris already did, that it is about YOUR build and not the sim.

I have seen and could even point out how many of those high level kickers have more strength than kicking skill and I'm certain this is the reason they miss SOME of their XPA.

The confidence shall take place as well, as pointed out before. If you are going to attempt an XP that can define the game, you are under real pressure and this shall reduce your chances of success in case you are not confident. All this should take place when considering the success rate.

You must examine each build and each condition before coming out to say the "XP's are missed too frequently in a whole".

I'm certain also that some guys are lucky as other are unlucky, so for sure some good kickers may miss more XP than usual and some may make more XP than expected.

This is a game, and your build and choices define you. It'll be hard to see someone here who can either make all XPs and most of FGs for 50+ yards. This would be insane and ridiculous, once the idea of the game is to make your character as you want him to be and everyone has 'the same number of SP'. So you won't or shouldn't see some 'stars' in this game, unless their opponents or other players in their positions have either bad or different builds which can't compare/stop his. It IS all about builds. It's all about what you focus on, you can do a lot of things +- or one thing really well and the others bad. In this game, you must choose.
 
Skanker irl
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
Originally posted by Skanker irl

Originally posted by oldskool



If anything he's just going to smack you with the nerf stick again because kicking's still too easy. Nobody should be nailing 90% FGs around level 20.


This thread is not about field goals.


Oh right, it's about wah i missed 2 XPs how not realistic. Most people don't have 70% of the "max" vision or confidence and there might be one or two with 100% kicking ability, but they still expect 100% precision on extra points. Bullplop, I say. Miss a kick once in a while and suck it up.


No, actually it's about the top leveled kickers currently missing 7 or 8 extra points in a GLB season. Breaking down the numbers on the other kickers would be time consuming but I can only imagine the number is greater. I've broken the numbers down in my previous posts, which you obviously didn't read.

I don't believe anyone has argued that there needs to be 100% precision on extra points, I certainly haven't.
 
Skanker irl
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Skanker irl
Just did a search for the highest leveled kickers in GLB, level 29 and up (highest 32). I added up their extra points made and missed.

21 kickers total and they have missed 82 extra points combined.

That’s almost 4 per kicker on average or projected over the season between 7 and 8 extra points missed each.

Total extra points made (942)/total extra points missed (1024) = 91.9% on extra points.

I'd like to see the number for kickers of this caliber around 95% - 97%


 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.