User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=117284&pbp_id=3744182

Oh my, look at the horrid coverage Kung Foo Grip applies. Wait, that looks realistic. But he caught the ball so it's broken, obviously.
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=117284&pbp_id=3744182

Oh my, look at the horrid coverage Kung Foo Grip applies. Wait, that looks realistic. But he caught the ball so it's broken, obviously.


LOL. That's actually a great example to prove my point. Look how ridiculously bad the coverage is by Barber.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
What IS true is that you would support a completely randomized sim if the final averages were realisitc.


False, although anything Bort would ever consider doing (which wouldn't include complete randomization) that would make averages more realistic is something I'd support over highly unrealistic averages.

Originally posted by thunderdoozer
EDIT: Averages were definitely off last season. I won't argue that. Well, they were off for rushing, not so much for passing. And you were the one bitching all season and who finally got their way, to the detriment of the game.


They were way, way off for both. You admit they were way off for rushing and power backs were useless, yet when the logical thing was done-- make people have to have tackling skill to tackle-- man, do you bitch about that.

Originally posted by thunderdoozer
But at least last season, build and strategy made sense, and actually meant something.


Build and strategy made no sense, although there was no real strategy with no advanced AI. Build made no sense as it was all about Speed.
Last edited Aug 16, 2008 13:18:47
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
Bort,

I played around with my settings a bit on my corners and safeties. I still believe the receivers simply catch too many passes when the dots are on top of the dots, BUT as a whole, I cannot say that the secondary play didn't look pretty decent, on both the offensive and defensive side of the ball.

People need to understand that if you have your corners on close coverage/go for the interception, they are going to get beat a lot, and that does follow the realistic game. I think I'd rather see the WR make a break and get open to make the catch versus that catch roll, but this is nowhere near as bad as I originally thought.

PinTBC
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay

Isn't football itself, a bit random? Granted you are dealing with human skill and talent, but at the end of the day, aren't most events random in a game?


LOL. No.

Strategy and skill is actually relevant in football. A high school team won't beat a Pro team because the game is random.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
Originally posted by oldskool

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=117284&pbp_id=3744182

Oh my, look at the horrid coverage Kung Foo Grip applies. Wait, that looks realistic. But he caught the ball so it's broken, obviously.


LOL. That's actually a great example to prove my point. Look how ridiculously bad the coverage is by Barber.


It's called "off coverage", or better yet, "corners don't get to glue themselves to receivers". It was a short curl route, the CB was backing up, the WR stopped and the CB appeared to stumble in the process of redirecting himself forward.
 
DaRealest
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
Originally posted by thunderdoozer

Originally posted by oldskool


http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=117284&pbp_id=3744182

Oh my, look at the horrid coverage Kung Foo Grip applies. Wait, that looks realistic. But he caught the ball so it's broken, obviously.


LOL. That's actually a great example to prove my point. Look how ridiculously bad the coverage is by Barber.


It's called "off coverage", or better yet, "corners don't get to glue themselves to receivers". It was a short curl route, the CB was backing up, the WR stopped and the CB appeared to stumble in the process of redirecting himself forward.


You do realize your wasting your time with this guy, right?
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1

Originally posted by thunderdoozer

EDIT: Averages were definitely off last season. I won't argue that. Well, they were off for rushing, not so much for passing. And you were the one bitching all season and who finally got their way, to the detriment of the game.


They were way, way off for both. You admit they were way off for rushing and power backs were useless, yet when the logical thing was done-- make people have to have tackling skill to tackle-- man, do you bitch about that.


Talk about losing respect for someone. You've done nothing but put words in my mouth this whole discussion. I never said that power backs were useless last season. Rushing in general was off, mostly because of the OL-DL dynamic.

I don't have a problem with people having to have TAC to be able to tackle, but they need to have a lot of other skills to be successful on defense that they don't need on offense. Right now, a WR with 80 catching and 40 vision and 20 everything else would beat a DB with 60s in everything because of how imbalanced the game is.
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
Originally posted by thunderdoozer

Originally posted by oldskool


http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=117284&pbp_id=3744182

Oh my, look at the horrid coverage Kung Foo Grip applies. Wait, that looks realistic. But he caught the ball so it's broken, obviously.


LOL. That's actually a great example to prove my point. Look how ridiculously bad the coverage is by Barber.


It's called "off coverage", or better yet, "corners don't get to glue themselves to receivers". It was a short curl route, the CB was backing up, the WR stopped and the CB appeared to stumble in the process of redirecting himself forward.


LOL. "Glue themselves to receivers?" The guy gives a four yard cushion and then ACCELERATES BACKWARDS when the WR stops. It's not like his momentum carries him backwards. Watch the play again. He ACCELERATES the WRONG WAY when the WR slows down.

It's absolutely horrifying.
Last edited Aug 16, 2008 13:25:38
 
Drago
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by stahu miguel
Originally posted by DWinsRespect

I don't know how many times people need to say that the replays you see are merely a best guess graphical representation of the play, not of what actually happened.


Okay, well let me be more clear:

Triple coverage on ANY player other than Randy Moss should not result in a completion, much less having it done repeatedly game after game.

That is complete and utter CRAP.


I'm sure it's been said, but you're retarded - it's not triple coverage.

Dakota Jackson (gay name, btw) is covering Ryan Bono.

Now go cry in the corner Shirley.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
LOL. "Glue themselves to receivers?" The guy gives a four yard cushion and then ACCELERATES BACKWARDS when the WR stops. It's not like his momentum carries him backwards. Watch the play again. He ACCELERATES the WRONG WAY when the WR slows down.

It's absolutely horrifying.


He doesn't accelerate backwards, he keeps going. He slants to the left of the field because the WR he's covering does the same thing, but since he's deeper down the field the CB's is more exaggerated than the WR's. Frame by frame looks a lot better than just watching the play.
 
Skinzfan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by stahu miguel
Originally posted by DWinsRespect

I don't know how many times people need to say that the replays you see are merely a best guess graphical representation of the play, not of what actually happened.


Okay, well let me be more clear:

Triple coverage on ANY player other than Randy Moss should not result in a completion, much less having it done repeatedly game after game.

That is complete and utter CRAP.



Remember this is still in BETA stage. It will improve as time goes. We are barely in Season 4. We have had alot of things fixed since season 1. It will improve please be patient.
 
DaRealest
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
Originally posted by thunderdoozer

LOL. "Glue themselves to receivers?" The guy gives a four yard cushion and then ACCELERATES BACKWARDS when the WR stops. It's not like his momentum carries him backwards. Watch the play again. He ACCELERATES the WRONG WAY when the WR slows down.

It's absolutely horrifying.


He doesn't accelerate backwards, he keeps going. He slants to the left of the field because the WR he's covering does the same thing, but since he's deeper down the field the CB's is more exaggerated than the WR's. Frame by frame looks a lot better than just watching the play.


Are you a father? Must be...you've got a LOT of patience!
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
Originally posted by thunderdoozer

LOL. "Glue themselves to receivers?" The guy gives a four yard cushion and then ACCELERATES BACKWARDS when the WR stops. It's not like his momentum carries him backwards. Watch the play again. He ACCELERATES the WRONG WAY when the WR slows down.

It's absolutely horrifying.


He doesn't accelerate backwards, he keeps going. He slants to the left of the field because the WR he's covering does the same thing, but since he's deeper down the field the CB's is more exaggerated than the WR's. Frame by frame looks a lot better than just watching the play.


No, his momentum clearly accelerates backwards.

And beyond that, the only reason you would ever give a 4 yard cushion to begin with is if you were planning to jump the route, which is something that has been completely removed from the sim.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
Originally posted by Ken1


Originally posted by thunderdoozer


EDIT: Averages were definitely off last season. I won't argue that. Well, they were off for rushing, not so much for passing. And you were the one bitching all season and who finally got their way, to the detriment of the game.


They were way, way off for both. You admit they were way off for rushing and power backs were useless, yet when the logical thing was done-- make people have to have tackling skill to tackle-- man, do you bitch about that.


Talk about losing respect for someone. You've done nothing but put words in my mouth this whole discussion. I never said that power backs were useless last season. Rushing in general was off, mostly because of the OL-DL dynamic.

I don't have a problem with people having to have TAC to be able to tackle, but they need to have a lot of other skills to be successful on defense that they don't need on offense. Right now, a WR with 80 catching and 40 vision and 20 everything else would beat a DB with 60s in everything because of how imbalanced the game is.


I worked to fix my post that misquoted your words as mine and mine as yours. I apologize for posting it that way, although people have done that to me many times without even trying to fix it.

Power backs were pretty much useless last season. Speed backs were a little better, but not a lot.

People still haven't adjusted to power backs and haven't soft-capped tackling rather than speed on LB's.

I won't deny that my first priority is that the averages be right, and I very much respect RAPB's differing view on that-- because he also wants realistic averages; it's just essential to him that they be achieved realistically, and he'd agree with you that in the passing game they aren't. But he has his own ideas as to how to make them realistic there without the areas he sees as unrealistic.

But to you, realistic averages don't even seem to matter much. Anyone who doesn't think this season is better than Season 3 isn't looking at things reasonably.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.