User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
SmithersOT
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CapnCrunch
he did quote someone saying that the dt wont break a double team, which once again goes back to why is there the break thru SA. thats like having the first step skill and it doesnt do anything. I appreciate that the guy is busy but I would think that 2 minutes to give some answer or thought to something as critical as SA's shouldnt be out of the question.


It's not just Break Through that's a lame SA for DT's. Let's review:

Run Blocking Some say that this is the NT's reason for existance.

WALL: If this makes the NT harder to push back, as the description suggests, then I damn sure am not seeing it.

Break Through: as the replays posted in this thread (and over a hundred posts) indicate, this skill currently does nothing against single or double teams. And Bort himself has indicated (in this thread) that it doesn't work against double teams. In short, it's broken.

Snarl: if you happen to tackle the same guy a bunch of times this apparently lowers their morale. Since NT's rarely tackle anyone at all, let alone multiple times in the same game, this skill serves no other purpose than to raise the cost of later skills.

Big Hit: as above, this skill theoretically does something if you happen to repeatedly tackle the same guy over and over again. Since this never happens this skill is pointless.

D-Line General: Who knows?

PASS RUSH

The Glare: in theory this skill lowers QB morale. In practice this probably has no effect at all, as QB's are going to have good confidence.

Shed Block: The only functioning NT special. How well it's functioning this season is debatable, but it does apparently do something sometimes.

Swat Ball: You don't see a whole lot of swatted balls on the D-line. It's a safe bet this skill does little.

Strong Base: Who knows?

Big Sack: Pointless.
 
SmithersOT
offline
Link
 
By the way, and this is telling...

In over a hundred replies not one NT has posted in here saying that break through is working for him against roughly equal level opponents. Not one. Instead we see level 26 NT's getting bitch slapped by level 6 Centers.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SmithersOT
By the way, and this is telling...

In over a hundred replies not one NT has posted in here saying that break through is working for him against roughly equal level opponents. Not one. Instead we see level 26 NT's getting bitch slapped by level 6 Centers.


Untrue.
 
cbo0485
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SmithersOT
By the way, and this is telling...

In over a hundred replies not one NT has posted in here saying that break through is working for him against roughly equal level opponents. Not one. Instead we see level 26 NT's getting bitch slapped by level 6 Centers.


It obviously isn't a glorious position, but a good NT will take up 2, and sometimes 3 blockers in one play. Unless Bort decides to make them stronger, which I doubt it, then the best thing to do would be to price them on the same level as the O-lineman. But again, the DT position, if build right, will get sacks and hurries and get the "good stats", where as the NT usually doesn't. So they'd have to be made into two separate player creation positions, NT and DT. And then there'd have to be a penalty from one to the other so people don't pay less for a NT and just build a DT to save FP.
 
arteryman
offline
Link
 
There is a difference between the pointless Big Sack and Snarl, and a SA plain not working. I think out of all the SA's Break Thru has proven to never come into effect and needs a fix now. I don't care that NT's aren't racking up the stats, at least let our linemen get past the blocks every now and then. The problem isn't with the position as Datongw has said over and over, it's with Break Thru never comming into action.
Last edited Aug 16, 2008 23:25:40
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cbo0485
Originally posted by SmithersOT

By the way, and this is telling...

In over a hundred replies not one NT has posted in here saying that break through is working for him against roughly equal level opponents. Not one. Instead we see level 26 NT's getting bitch slapped by level 6 Centers.


It obviously isn't a glorious position, but a good NT will take up 2, and sometimes 3 blockers in one play. Unless Bort decides to make them stronger, which I doubt it, then the best thing to do would be to price them on the same level as the O-lineman. But again, the DT position, if build right, will get sacks and hurries and get the "good stats", where as the NT usually doesn't. So they'd have to be made into two separate player creation positions, NT and DT. And then there'd have to be a penalty from one to the other so people don't pay less for a NT and just build a DT to save FP.


Agree with you, but again this thread is about the effectiveness of the SA abilities rather than the effectiveness of the NT in general. Honestly right now I am not putting any points into my NT's SA tree because I'm just not seeing the benefits of it.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by SmithersOT
Originally posted by CapnCrunch

he did quote someone saying that the dt wont break a double team, which once again goes back to why is there the break thru SA. thats like having the first step skill and it doesnt do anything. I appreciate that the guy is busy but I would think that 2 minutes to give some answer or thought to something as critical as SA's shouldnt be out of the question.


It's not just Break Through that's a lame SA for DT's. Let's review:

Run Blocking Some say that this is the NT's reason for existance.

WALL: If this makes the NT harder to push back, as the description suggests, then I damn sure am not seeing it.

Break Through: as the replays posted in this thread (and over a hundred posts) indicate, this skill currently does nothing against single or double teams. And Bort himself has indicated (in this thread) that it doesn't work against double teams. In short, it's broken.

Snarl: if you happen to tackle the same guy a bunch of times this apparently lowers their morale. Since NT's rarely tackle anyone at all, let alone multiple times in the same game, this skill serves no other purpose than to raise the cost of later skills.

Big Hit: as above, this skill theoretically does something if you happen to repeatedly tackle the same guy over and over again. Since this never happens this skill is pointless.

D-Line General: Who knows?

PASS RUSH

The Glare: in theory this skill lowers QB morale. In practice this probably has no effect at all, as QB's are going to have good confidence.

Shed Block: The only functioning NT special. How well it's functioning this season is debatable, but it does apparently do something sometimes.

Swat Ball: You don't see a whole lot of swatted balls on the D-line. It's a safe bet this skill does little.

Strong Base: Who knows?

Big Sack: Pointless.


Bort needs to read this post. It's high on truth.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology


My DTs are not meant to get sacks, though they do get a fair number of hurries. They are meant to stop the run.

Case in point, my Hidden Dragons team is #1 in rushing defense, allowing fewer than 60 yards per game rushing.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/team_stats.pl?league_id=137&conference_id=273&stat=rushing&playoffs=0

This is not merely due to my DTs and NTs, but they play a big role. And I have had a very front loaded schedule so I have played most of the top of the league so far...the cupcake teams are at the end of my schedule (I think my opponents so far have a record of around 30-15 combined, if you subtract the losses I inflicted).

My 4 CBs lead my team in tackles of course (since many teams give up trying to rush on me, and because they get tackles on sweeps) but my 4 DTs are 6th, 8th, 9th, and 12th on the team in tackles.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/team_player_stats.pl?team_id=4392&stat=defense&playoffs=0

Consider that I rotate playing time evenly at every position, so I essentially have 22 starters.

73 tackles, 2 sacks, 7 hurries in 7 games from my 4 DTs combined against tough opponents (generally matched up against equal level offensive lines, maybe a 1 level advantage in some cases).

My whole team only has 387 tackles combined, so my DTs have accounted for almost 20%
of my tackles.

DTs work fine, Break Through works fine.

Edit:
Here is my level 16 (at the time) NT making a TFL on 3rd and inches against a level 16 HB, while triple teamed by a level 15 C, level 15 G, and a level 15 FB (all with high quality builds on a team that was undefeated until we met).

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=118286&pbp_id=3784377

(too bad they converted the 4th and short on the next play)


This post fails because anecdotes aren't useful in this discussion. For every play you show me where a NT does "something", I will show you one hundred where he gets double-teamed and blocked out. By lower level players.

See how useless anecdotes are?
 
arteryman
offline
Link
 
bump because the SA needs an answer.
 
CapnCrunch
offline
Link
 

wouldnt hold my breath...
 
jetsfan0327
offline
Link
 
I don't know much about this issue but I do know in real football that a Run Stopping DT isn't a guy that gets a lot of tackles anyway. What he does is help move the line of scrimmage back with his strength and command a double team by the offensive line so that the running lanes don't close up. Breaking off a block and wrapping up a ballcarrier at the right time isn't really all that common, but some of the best are very good at it. A linebacker will be there for the tackle much more often than a defensive tackle since the linebacker knows which rushing lanes are likely to be closed and can anticipate which hole the ballcarrier will be coming through.
 
Barnsie
offline
Link
 
jetsfan, that's well and good, but this is about break through working or not. I'd say if it worked once a game at this point, you'd be pretty happy, and I don't think it's unrealistic for a good NT to break a double team once a game.
 
CapnCrunch
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Barnsie
jetsfan, that's well and good, but this is about break through working or not. I'd say if it worked once a game at this point, you'd be pretty happy, and I don't think it's unrealistic for a good NT to break a double team once a game.



and if its not, get rid of the Break Thru SA
 
SmithersOT
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CapnCrunch
Originally posted by Barnsie

jetsfan, that's well and good, but this is about break through working or not. I'd say if it worked once a game at this point, you'd be pretty happy, and I don't think it's unrealistic for a good NT to break a double team once a game.



and if its not, get rid of the Break Thru SA


Right.

That's what's so silly about this thread (and Bort's response). The skill SAYS it helps break double team blocks. The folks defending the status quo are saying, "B-But you were double teamed!"
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Originally posted by tautology



My DTs are not meant to get sacks, though they do get a fair number of hurries. They are meant to stop the run.

Case in point, my Hidden Dragons team is #1 in rushing defense, allowing fewer than 60 yards per game rushing.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/team_stats.pl?league_id=137&conference_id=273&stat=rushing&playoffs=0

This is not merely due to my DTs and NTs, but they play a big role. And I have had a very front loaded schedule so I have played most of the top of the league so far...the cupcake teams are at the end of my schedule (I think my opponents so far have a record of around 30-15 combined, if you subtract the losses I inflicted).

My 4 CBs lead my team in tackles of course (since many teams give up trying to rush on me, and because they get tackles on sweeps) but my 4 DTs are 6th, 8th, 9th, and 12th on the team in tackles.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/team_player_stats.pl?team_id=4392&stat=defense&playoffs=0

Consider that I rotate playing time evenly at every position, so I essentially have 22 starters.

73 tackles, 2 sacks, 7 hurries in 7 games from my 4 DTs combined against tough opponents (generally matched up against equal level offensive lines, maybe a 1 level advantage in some cases).

My whole team only has 387 tackles combined, so my DTs have accounted for almost 20%
of my tackles.

DTs work fine, Break Through works fine.

Edit:
Here is my level 16 (at the time) NT making a TFL on 3rd and inches against a level 16 HB, while triple teamed by a level 15 C, level 15 G, and a level 15 FB (all with high quality builds on a team that was undefeated until we met).

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=118286&pbp_id=3784377

(too bad they converted the 4th and short on the next play)


This post fails because anecdotes aren't useful in this discussion. For every play you show me where a NT does "something", I will show you one hundred where he gets double-teamed and blocked out. By lower level players.

See how useless anecdotes are?


Anecdotes based on fact are, however, more useful than whining based on a lack of understanding
a) what comprises good performance from the NT position,
b) what the SAs actually look like in action
c) how the sim works in games where blowouts are occurring
d) what a good build for NT actually looks like.

See how useless whining is?

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.