User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Season 4 changes ARE going to cost this game alot of dedicated players.
Page:
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RunningMn9
Originally posted by Ken1

RunningMn, if you don't want to play the game when it's still under development, then don't.

Retire your players (when you can, as they have contracts, I'm sure), keep your account, and check back in a year to see if it's out of Beta. Then use the FP's you got from retiring your players to start playing the non-Beta version.

If you want to play now, you have to put up with the Beta changes.


I only have to put up with this BS as long as Bort wants to continue spinning his wheels. There are reasons why no other game company would ever approach making a game like this. I'm offering specific ways to solve these fundamental problems with how Bort is going about getting this game tested.

Is it really not coming across how EASY it is to correct this on Bort's end? Test servers that work out the kinks in new code, public servers that play the latest stable build of the code, with occasional updates of well-tested code. This isn't rocket science. It's how the rest of the world develops MMOs.


At this point, I kind of think it's unfair to be calling this a "company." It doesn't exactly have the resources of an EA or something.

He did try testing the new changes on a separate server; but when people came in with things he didn't anticipate, Bort found a whole bunch of new bugs that he incredibly fixed the vast majority of during a four day preseason.

I do think, as I've said many times, that Bort needs to hire some help, just so that things can be added faster. The kinks are probably out of this game version, which may be the last truly major change to the game engine itself that's needed (there will be relatively minor tweaks, but there may be no need for any further major changes), and that might allow Bort to start working on more things for agents to do, which is a needed upgrade for those who don't GM or own.

But, with help that could have been started already.

So, I won't say it's perfect. I think Bort needs an assistant developer or someone similar. He might also be well-served to hire someone to write a manual for players, and to keep it updated. He'd have to fill that person in on changes when made.

But Bort's done some amazing things here, and with the recent changes has made this a truly great sim. Things often don't move as fast as I'd like; but I'm very, very satisfied overall.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
By the time Bort finds a programmer to hire and trains him in the GLB code to the point where he feels comfortable letting him program without having to go over every line of code that goes in, a) the game will be in an uproar because "Bort's not doing anything" and b) Bort could have fixed most of the issues himself.
 
shield.bearer
offline
Link
 
Funny.

Last season, my team was 14-2 with a balanced, team concept. We built our players to work well together.

Flash forward to Season 4: We are 3-0. Both our HB's are averaging over 100ypg. Our QB went 26 for 30 with 3 TD's and 0 INT's in our last game and has a QB rating well over 100. Our D is giving up less than 11PPG and our O is the 5th rated Scoring Offense with the 2nd fewest offensive plays per game.

Apparently, building with common sense was all it required all along...
 
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
SteelCity,

The DE came about because of the offensive line code was put in and it made every DE useless as they ran straight into the Oline, that was changed with the ability to dictate what kind of pass rush you want to use.

Speed was too dominant, mainly in WR. As far as the running game working, it was a combination of things that made it non workable last year, wrap up tackling being way too powerful, and having no outside running game for any team mainly, the two things that changed that was tackling made more realistic, and now the Oline pulls a bit more which opened up the running game more to the outside.

The same people who complain are always gonna complain, some legit, some not.

As far as continuity goes, I guess that might be slightly your fault, as we in Stockholm have had the same team pretty much from the word go, you will always get 2-3 guys who leave, we had 4 go to their own team etc, but we have been pretty much a continuous unit, with the odd exception, and you recruit on builds, and fill the holes you have with the builds you want, not saying that isn't what you did, but if you look at things being realistic, it is a much better sim now than it was in season 3.


On PSK, we have 12 new guys. Most were just added to last years roster. I traded away 3 guys, 1 left to FA and I'm letting another non-booster leave once his contract is up. On Steel, we have 7 new player, all were added on and none was lost. I'm not talking about the continuity of the roster, but more so the playing style and identity of the team.

As for the DE's and O-line. Obviously there was no problem. I never seen it. They're beating a dead horse on that ordeal. The "new O-line code" never needed added.

As for running not working, I really, really beg to differ. My Steel team led the league last season with 4,275 yards on the ground. On my PSK team, we had the leagues leading rusher with over 2,000 yards, and our back-up was close behind him and led the league in TD's. The running game wasn't broke, people just did't know how to use it. And just a FYI, on PSK, they're both elusive backs. On Steel, we have one elusive and one power back. Both teams walked to the league championship on our running games.

My point is, as it was when I started posting, a lot of these changes (not all of them, because I agree with some of them) are meaningless and didn't need to be done. All they're doing (the changes) is wasting time they could be using to make the AI better. Things like strength being a more dominant factor to a DE is useless. (By the way, I'm not worried about my DE's or my teams DE's. Watch them this season and you'll see why) That all came from a change that didn't need to be made. As for the running game, my results of our running games (from last season) shows it wasn't broken.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
By the time Bort finds a programmer to hire and trains him in the GLB code to the point where he feels comfortable letting him program without having to go over every line of code that goes in, a) the game will be in an uproar because "Bort's not doing anything" and b) Bort could have fixed most of the issues himself.


Personally, I think its dangerous to encourage Bort to keep the "Go it Alone" mentality. It would be my guess that somewhere locked in some MEGA company's basement is a team of programmers and gamers that have been tossed a handsome amount of coin to develop a rival to GLB. If Bort is lead to believe that he has 10 or 12 "seasons" to get this thing right, he might wake one morning to find that the landscape has changed dramatically.
 
Sahoj
offline
Link
 
The changes and great updates this season have made me a much more dedicated
player. I don't mind that there are problems or bumps along the way when it's
so blatant that the game is moving forward and on a steady road to improvement.

I'm sure there are many other players who like to see the game evolve as well
and the blanket statement by the OP is easily an exaggeration.

Cheers,
Sahoj
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
The real question, regarding the need or lack thereof for additional programmers, is what the plans are for GLB a year from now. If the goal is to get the game to a "steady state" that is enjoyable in it's own right to not need constant additional content - then Bort probably doesn't need or want another Programmer. He'd build the game to how he envisions it and then revisit the code to fix things as bugs are discovered - while he turns his attention to another project.

If the goal is to have a game that constantly has new content and expands the options available for people to participate - then it might be that Bort would want one or more other Programmers working on the upcomming content.. as the expectation of new content would put a damper on his ability to take a break from it.. and after a year of daily dealing with the forums and the code - my guess is Bort will need a break.. and I'm talking more than just a week away.. he'll want to turn his attention to something else, atleast temporarily, so he didn't burn out.
Last edited Aug 7, 2008 16:28:00
 
Night Dragon
offline
Link
 
To go back to what the original poster said, I only have one freakish speed WR who is a worthless duck now. We built this team with one poss, one speed, and one tweaner. The problem was WR2 and 3 couldn't get open, but the fast guy could and catch balls. Any smart person will realize the only way to catch balls was to get open/separation and speed became the answer. The other two guys went after speed because that was the final logical approach to season 2. They stopped at the first soft cap because they still wanted to make the team specific builds. The speed guy kept hammering speed. That was our teams approach.

I don't sit online reading thread after thread to find out what is going on. I don't have the time, but there was a nice feature that allowed us to 'stalk Bort' that was taken out because it slowed the site down or whatever. I didn't realize there was some outcry about uber fast WR's. Our fast WR wasn't even dominating the league, just keeping defenses honest. That's all I needed from him and he loved that roll.

Ten days before S4 rolls out and speed is going to be handicapped by agility. I don't have a problem with the change, but what about the guys who took out the logical approach to getting open? There was no warning except a small window of ten days. How the is a L20+ guy going to fix his now broken build? Everyone says use your boosts to fix them. It's not that easy at these higher levels.

I wish there was some compensation for S1 and S2 guys (maybe even S3, but they should be low enough level to fix them). They should be given a small portion of their skill points a chance to be move somewhere else. I would be satisfied with even a small amount of 10 points to be moved. Maybe only allow the ones who spent actually money or whatever you guys come up with, but their needs to be a level of fairness to those who only did what was logical because they wanted to be competitive.

The bottom line is, some people feel like Bort ran up to said player with a mask on, took $9 dollars out of their pocket and ran off into the woods with it.
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Night Dragon
The bottom line is, some people feel like Bort ran up to said player with a mask on, took $9 dollars out of their pocket and ran off into the woods with it.


There is a name for those people, we call them idiots. It's like the girl (or guy) who is perfectly willing at the party, but feels guilty about it the next day and starts to describe the events as being forced. If you want to be the victim - nothing anyone can do about it.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
The real question, regarding the need or lack thereof for additional programmers, is what the plans are for GLB a year from now. If the goal is to get the game to a "steady state" that is enjoyable in it's own right to not need constant additional content - then Bort probably doesn't need or want another Programmer. He'd build the game to how he envisions it and then revisit the code to fix things as bugs are discovered - while he turns his attention to another project.

If the goal is to have a game that constantly has new content and expands the options available for people to participate - then it might be that Bort would want one or more other Programmers working on the upcomming content.. as the expectation of new content would put a damper on his ability to take a break from it.. and after a year of daily dealing with the forums and the code - my guess is Bort will need a break.. and I'm talking more than just a week away.. he'll want to turn his attention to something else, atleast temporarily, so he didn't burn out.


I think it's the second, in that all MMORPG's are always adding new content. The football sim engine itself might be fairly close to hitting a "steady state," although the AI will probably get somewhat more detailed.

But there will always need to be lots of things for players to do.

I think that's the part that Bort could have delegated to an assistant while Bort did the game engine things, such as the AI and bug fixes. The whole "daily planner" and player personalities, Bort could have worked out with the assistant, as well DD, and people who post what sorts of options should exist, worked on balancing the options, etc., and then let the assistant work on that aspect.

The assistant wouldn't have had to know all about the game engine to do that, as it's mostly about building player personalities through choices of activities. Then the personalities themselves would affect the game. Bort might have to code that part himself, but the building of the personalities could be done by an assistant IMO.

Then more and more will be needed, to keep things interesting for non-GM/owner players, etc..
 
Revel8
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Signalsgt
Originally posted by Revelation

Originally posted by Signalsgt


Lets see:

1. This game runs me MAYBE 20 bucks a month.
2. I can play from work
3. Takes me 15 minutes to do. (Unless I'm being a forum rat)
4. Bugs are identified and addressed.
5. Code is being changed in a logical manner with good intent to improve the game.
6. Its entertaining brain candy.

I honestly pay more attention and have a higher vested interest in what the Cafe on the first floor of my building has as the daily special then GLB.

It's a game, there is no return on investment. Your paying money for the enjoyment. Talking trash about a sim'd football game is like proudly proclaiming you have an extra chromosome.

So in the immortal words Sgt. Hulka from Stripes "Lighten up Francis"


Heh, how are you supposed to lighten up when you're paying for enjoyment and are not enjoying the game?


Quit completely or stop investing money.



It was a bit of a joke, but I don't expect dedicated players just to quit cold turkey. However, as I see it, they should have more of a say than those who rarely play with the investment of time and money they put in.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by Johnny_Johnson

Look, it's this simple. All I want is Build versus Build when it comes to DBs and Receivers.

I don't want any 5 yard cushion BS or delayed reaction times. My CBs build is good enough to cover most of the receivers in this game regardless of the speed nerf. I just want a fair shake against guys I match up against or outmatch!


The very best corners in football will get beaten at times when matched up against top WR's.

That's why you don't see that tight of coverage most of the time in real life, that's why you rarely see a pure 0-man used in real life (and if it is, there's usually a cushion), and that's why zones get used plenty in real life.

If you want a CB who can play everyone close and never get burned by anyone, you won't and shouldn't succeed in getting one.


I totally agree. There are WRs in GLB that my CB shouldn't be able to touch. That is fine.

My issues is that I shouldn't have my abilities impaired to make WRs lives easier. The "5 yd cushion" and "delayed reaction times" that Bort put in had nothing to do with the build of my CB.

What I am getting at is...If my CB and your WR are equal in every way, you will beat me every time because I HAVE to give you a cushion, and my guy is partially retarded.

Now how is that fair???

I understand Bort is addressing this issue, and that's cool. I just don't agree with his original fix of the problem and I want him to know why.
 
Night Dragon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Originally posted by Night Dragon

The bottom line is, some people feel like Bort ran up to said player with a mask on, took $9 dollars out of their pocket and ran off into the woods with it.


There is a name for those people, we call them idiots. It's like the girl (or guy) who is perfectly willing at the party, but feels guilty about it the next day and starts to describe the events as being forced. If you want to be the victim - nothing anyone can do about it.


We are talking about being misled, not being guilty.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Night Dragon
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi

Originally posted by Night Dragon


The bottom line is, some people feel like Bort ran up to said player with a mask on, took $9 dollars out of their pocket and ran off into the woods with it.


There is a name for those people, we call them idiots. It's like the girl (or guy) who is perfectly willing at the party, but feels guilty about it the next day and starts to describe the events as being forced. If you want to be the victim - nothing anyone can do about it.


We are talking about being misled, not being guilty.


Misled about what?
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Johnny_Johnson
Originally posted by Ken1

Originally posted by Johnny_Johnson


Look, it's this simple. All I want is Build versus Build when it comes to DBs and Receivers.

I don't want any 5 yard cushion BS or delayed reaction times. My CBs build is good enough to cover most of the receivers in this game regardless of the speed nerf. I just want a fair shake against guys I match up against or outmatch!


The very best corners in football will get beaten at times when matched up against top WR's.

That's why you don't see that tight of coverage most of the time in real life, that's why you rarely see a pure 0-man used in real life (and if it is, there's usually a cushion), and that's why zones get used plenty in real life.

If you want a CB who can play everyone close and never get burned by anyone, you won't and shouldn't succeed in getting one.


I totally agree. There are WRs in GLB that my CB shouldn't be able to touch. That is fine.

My issues is that I shouldn't have my abilities impaired to make WRs lives easier. The "5 yd cushion" and "delayed reaction times" that Bort put in had nothing to do with the build of my CB.

What I am getting at is...If my CB and your WR are equal in every way, you will beat me every time because I HAVE to give you a cushion, and my guy is partially retarded.

Now how is that fair???

I understand Bort is addressing this issue, and that's cool. I just don't agree with his original fix of the problem and I want him to know why.


My understanding is that if he hasn't gotten rid of the automatic cushion it's part of his plan to get rid of it.

I agree that you should be able to try to play anyone you want as tight as you want, just that it shouldn't always succeed.

Oh, and your guy isn't partially retarded. He's just not psychic. He doesn't know what the play is and the WR does, so he can't react instantaneously to the WR's moves.
Last edited Aug 7, 2008 17:10:51
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.