User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Problem with Stamina/Substitution/Depth?
Page:
 
chevyman~Cult~
like a rock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GRiPSSL
Originally posted by chevyman

Originally posted by GRiPSSL



ya but owner's want to win...and limiting the amount of plays that you can get XP from isn't gonna make them play their back ups more.


Well playing a backup that will produce better because the starter is tired and will produce worse would have owners using backups more.


Just means onwers get back ups at the same level like they do now anyway so they dont have a drop off if the starter does get subbed out.


Well then that owner did a good job in getting guys to be able to do that.
 
GRiPSSL
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by hud
Originally posted by Kcirdor


Thats why it needs to be to where your starters where down so that the back ups can get more PT throughout the season. More realism will take this game to another level of fun. Also other ways to build your guy can be implemented in the near future. Offseason workout plans can be put into effect to give bonuses in certain areas. There are plenty of ideas to supplement the lose of Playing time by starters because they are tired and beat up.


So what you want is to have a team with everyone at the same level even if it is lower? Sounds boring to me. Just make leagues based on what day you make your player then.

This isnt a power gamer trying to find a glitch, this is what is fun to me. Filling up a roster, worring about more inactives, balancing PT isn't fun to me. I play Madden and I adjust the staminas importance so I can play the stars. I want to see T.O. on the field, not Patric Crayton. You might like to put it so it is more "realistic". we aren't arguring what is best for the game, we are arguing preference. New\ casual players want to see their guy in and growing, not sitting and building comrodary. More teams will balance this out.

And like Mr. Harper said, power gamers will just build up the stamina\ durabilty no matter how important you make it so that they can stay on the field and build faster than Joe Blow. If you make rules to prevent it, they will find ways around it. If you lose to them, the take solice in the fact that you got a fun team built your way. Don;t call them out and say its not fair becuase its not played your way.


More teams would balance it out to an extent, someone like me might carry what would look like a traditional roster but I bet most owners wouldn't. My take is since we can make any amount of player's I don't mind mine being a back up becasue of the 4 I have 1 is a starter for now. Surely once they add more teams everyone that wants to put time in and nurture their player and fall into or find or earn a starting job they could. Trick is make enough players and one is bound to land on a starting spot ,LOL.
 
GRiPSSL
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chevyman
Originally posted by GRiPSSL

Originally posted by chevyman


Originally posted by GRiPSSL




ya but owner's want to win...and limiting the amount of plays that you can get XP from isn't gonna make them play their back ups more.


Well playing a backup that will produce better because the starter is tired and will produce worse would have owners using backups more.


Just means onwers get back ups at the same level like they do now anyway so they dont have a drop off if the starter does get subbed out.


Well then that owner did a good job in getting guys to be able to do that.


agreed...I have people on my team that are just glad their on a team. quite refreshing actually.
 
Kcirdor
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by hud
Originally posted by Kcirdor


beat up.


Don;t call them out and say its not fair becuase its not played your way.


Never said it was unfair. Said it needed to be more realistic. Also said they can add stuff that will suppliment the loss of play time. And yea I play madden with fumbles and injuries. Because I want to be able to win with Joe Blow on the field. I want to see the underdog shine. I want to see the guy progress in his career. i want him to be able to step in and play when his starter leaves the team or retires. I want realism with my simulation...
Last edited Apr 18, 2008 02:18:41
 
hud
offline
Link
 
so my point is, it is a matter of preference. We are obviously people who are real active. For every one person that spends as much time in this game as we do, there will be 10 who don't and want it as simple as possible. And by realistic, you mean this one thing realistic. I dont care what yall say, yall dont want to spend time and effort in a sim that is completely realistic. you dont want your level 60 QB in prison or your all star LB suspended for violating the drug testing. You dont want to spend hours everyday running practices so you get timing down.

I think most people who play want to be the star. You cant do that with 4 OTs 4 G 3 C. You can with 5 starting linemen and 1 or 2 backups to cover the O-line.
 
Kcirdor
offline
Link
 
I think suspensions are a good idea....

but anyway, other interactive stuff to do b/w games and in the postseason/offseason, will suppliment any loss of fun(PT) you are having. Stuff like signing in daily to click "show up for practice" on your player profile. The more people on your team that "show up for practice" the better your chemistry bonus ist or your whole team gets a bonus to training dependant the percent of players that "show up for practice"
Last edited Apr 18, 2008 02:35:04
 
hud
offline
Link
 
lol, you are all out realism! I know if I had one good player and he got busted and out half a season for some real world reason, I would stop playing.
 
Kcirdor
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by hud
lol, you are all out realism! I know if I had one good player and he got busted and out half a season for some real world reason, I would stop playing.


/sarcasm..
 
tpaterniti
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by hud
#1 it was the alpha players who were telling everyone to pump skill points into stamina. We learned in the first season that stamina was by FAR the MOST important stat. Sounds like a real fun way to build, huh? We had no idea, no special insight, that it was gonna work like this.


This was exactly the problem. The only people who knew anything about the game kept telling us newcomers that stamina was SO IMPORTANT so we did what one would logically do in that situation. We pumped stamina and signed depth. Then at the end of the season we see that it was the people telling us stamina was SO IMPORTANT who disregarded it, signed minimal teams, and dominated their leagues. This seems a little shady to me.

Originally posted by hud
Let me ask it this way? If there were enough teams and good owners that we could have teams with 32 active players per team that got more PT and leveled up faster, wouldn't that be more fun that finding 52 players so you could have some sit the bench and hope to get 25% of the plays so he could level 25% as fast as the starters? Wouldnt be more ideal for all players to have 70-90 plays, than some having 60 while other hope to get 20 a game?


My answer to all of this is NO, it wouldn't be more fun. Maybe to you, but the huge outcry against these types of teams underscores the fact that most people would rather have the realism. And a note on realism, basically your argument against it centers on off-the-field issues and injuries, whereas most of our complaints are about on-the-field issues. You can have a realistic simulation of the actual football game and the tactics involved without injuries and off-the-field stuff. To say that because of one small aspect of the football experience, injuries and things that happen off-the-field, we should give up all hope of a realistic on-the-field simulation just doesn't compute.

Here is the best solution I have come up with, which involves combining several good ideas proposed by myself and others.

I think the best suggestions are to combine the following:

1.) Decrease the max plays for XP from 90 to 40-50. NFL games are typically 55-65 plays so 90 is WAY too many. If there were no XP incentive to playing your guys more than 40-50 plays, there would be more depth.

2.) Change the in-game energy-to-effectiveness ratio. it doesn't have to be 1 to 1, but some ratio. It could be a parabolic curve where you lose little at the top and as you drop you lose more and more.

3.) Change the post-game energy situation. You should be able to lose more than 30 energy in a game. It shouldn't be 1 to 1, but again like a parabolic curve where the lower your in-game energy goes the more it affects how much or little you will have after the game.

4.) Add complexity to the offensive and defensive depth charts and game plan to allow for player specialization. Having 3rd down backs, Goalline backs, nickle and dime DBs, pash rush specialists, etc. actually gives owners a reason to have depth that is strategic and meaningful rather than just so it seems more realistic or fair.

Originally posted by hud
Filling up a roster, worring about more inactives, balancing PT isn't fun to me.


What are you saying? If you hate these things don't be an owner or get a GM to do it for you, because that is what the game is. That would be like saying, "I want to have lots of players, but I hate managing them and their training and their skill points. That just isn't fun to me." It doesn't make any sense. As I have written elsewhere this is a Mass Multiplayer Online game, not a Mass Singleplayer Online game. Dealing with other people, and lots of them (cf. "Mass" in Mass Multiplayer...) is kind of part of the deal. If you hate that, then no one is twisting your arm and making you be an owner. I get tired of all this stuff too. So I went out and got talented GMs to help me.

Originally posted by hud
I play Madden and I adjust the staminas importance so I can play the stars. I want to see T.O. on the field, not Patric Crayton.


You sound like a very casual football fan who just likes to watch the stars and who cares very little about the rest. People like you don't realize that without the Patrick Craytons of the world, the TOs of the world wouldn't be that exciting. Also there are many, many people who are pretty dedicated football fans who follow teams and rosters and watch games for more than just seeing one or two stars play. I assure you there are lots of Cowboys fans, and even I, who am not a Cowboys fan, enjoy watching guys like Patrick Crayton and Sam Hurd and Tony Fasano and other guys who are not top 5 in their position. There is nothing wrong with your mindset oer se, but as I said, it would be a mistake to assume that everyone is as casual a fan as you make yourself seem.


Originally posted by hud
New casual players want to see their guy in and growing, not sitting and building comrodary[sic].


I simply couldn't disagree with you more. I own six teams and deal with tons and tons of players every day and the biggest three concerns they have are whether they will get playing time (not necessarily starting), will they be on a winning team, and will the team be a fun group of players they can intract with. I have never once heard a player say, "You know, I don't care about winning or being with cool people, or contributing to my team. I just want to see that little number by his name go up." I am sure there are people like this, but I would say they are less than 10% of the people I interact with, which is a substantial number. You have to realize that the number is just a number. If it doesn't somehow translate to more fun for you, who cares whether your DE is level 18 or 88? I think you assume (as many people do) that others think the same way as you and have the same values, when in reality this is rarely the case.

Edit: See the poster below me. He certainly doesn't seem to be the type of person who only wantsOriginally posted by hud
to see their guy in and growing, not sitting and building comrodary[sic].
The more people who post, the more it will become evident just how cynical and atypical your approach is.
Last edited Apr 18, 2008 04:23:59
 
mapmaker
offline
Link
 
I'm reading the forums constantly to try and keep abreast of what's what and why .. it only makes "realworld" sense that if a player doesn't have good stamina physical activity will wear him down quicker and he'll firstly become less effective over time then eventually he needs to be replaced by a less talented sub because the less talented fresh guy will kick his ass all over the place ... that's the way it works in real life .. what I read here is last years "power user alpha testers' definately had an edge because they had swayed Borts thinking and some things weren't as real life simmed as others ... and the teams that tried building and subbing for a more realistic approach actually got jobbed by the system. Looks like this is going to be fixed for the coming year and everyone should be playing on a more level playing field ... lesson learned.

Great game and a ton of fun, meeting and working with teammates from everywhere and at a whole variety of Levels toward a common goal .. winning games but having fun doing it together!
 
FBG Bonzai
offline
Link
 
No wonder we got rolled by a team with no depth in the playoffs.

Baffling.



Hopefully this gets addressed before the start of next season. From what I read, it seems like Bort knows whats up as usual. My only real contribution here is that I hope we don't get some lukewarm commitment to depth and stamina just because of the complaints here. I'd like to think that depth and stamina become the integral parts of the game that they should.

 
tsherr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tpaterniti

This was exactly the problem. The only people who knew anything about the game kept telling us newcomers that stamina was SO IMPORTANT so we did what one would logically do in that situation. We pumped stamina and signed depth. Then at the end of the season we see that it was the people telling us stamina was SO IMPORTANT who disregarded it, signed minimal teams, and dominated their leagues. This seems a little shady to me.


Well, after reading this (and I really appreciate the work done bringing this out) I'm pretty angry. Effectively, I've not only wasted points on stamina (and time on training) I have also unknowingly misled the players on my team by telling them to pump stamina. So basically, I've been a chump. We've all been misled - yes,, it's a beta, yes, there is no detailed manual, but we were told by stickies on the forums how to build players and one of the things was - "get the stamina up." Heck, there is even a chart telling us how high to get stamina. Now it appears that stamina is largely unimportant, and the first person on the "how to build a player" thread who mentions stamina is running a team that takes advantage of the fact that stamina is meaningless (so the real question is: when did he know this? before or after he told the rest of us to focus on stamina?)

The solution is pretty simple, in my mind. Two changes fix this:
1)Make the energy drop off logarithmic - energy and effectiveness would look something like this:
Energy Effectiveness
100 100%
90 89%
80 78%
70 67%
60 56%
50 45%
40 34%
30 23%
20 12%
10 5%
0 Cannot play
2)Make the maximum energy go down over the season (so if you finish a game at 70%, your maximum energy would drop to, say 90% (100-70)/3. The next game, you might finish at 50%, so your maximum energy would drop to 83% (100-50)/3. If your owner sat you out a game, then you'd be able to gain 10 maximum energy per game sat (which would allow players to sit out a game to come back tougher at the end of the year.) This would guarantee playing time by backups, and would make team planning more fun.

Stamina would keep your energy from dropping so quickly (so maybe a person with a stamina of 10 would lose one energy point per play, but a person with a stamina of 20 would lose only .8 per play, and a person with 30 would lose only .6 per play (this should also be logarithmic, but there should always be energy loss - even if you have 100 stamina.)

(All the numbers I use above are guesstimates, of course. I'm sure Bort would come up with more functional numbers.

T
 
S3M1N0L3
offline
Link
 
Have stamina drops increase ineffectiveness at each position, have it affect some positions more than others. Put an "effectiveness" percentage on the sub settings for each position so owners can take out a tired and ineffective player at a particular position when needed.

This will have a few effects..

Depth will be needed but not as important at all positions.
Sub settings will be more accurate and allow a GM/Owner to manage their rosters better.
Substitutions will be based on effectiveness and not just stamina.
It will allow stamina to be more important for some positions over others.
It will allow backup players to see the field more and will more accurately penalize a guy with one WR and one CB playing the entire game on both sides of the ball.

So this way a player can be subbed out for low stamina or for low effectiveness.
Players that don't have stamina now will not be able to play a whole game. Players with super high stamina MIGHT be able to play every snap from a stamina point of view but can't do it in an effective manner at all. GMs and Owners would balance this between positions and couldn't just set this kind of player's effectiveness to 0% as they would start dropping passes, fumbling, missing tackles, getting pancaked or throwing INTs more.

Seems that the issue stems from Stamina / number of plays and how effective the players are. Players need to drop more effectiveness in relation to stamina and sub settings need to be more intuitive for owners and GMs.

As it stands now, you have to build an entire roster to cater to the stamina settings for the whole team and you end up with crappy substitutions in key situations. Not to mention that when you figure out something like the 60/0 setting and no depth, you have to rearrange your entire roster, cut players, etc to gain the "edge".

I just don't see how this is going to work with a bunch of human players looking for roster spots if GMs and owners are looking to cut players instead of add them.

Find a balance with stamina and effectiveness and please add more features to manage the rosters and substitutions so GMs can build depth as needed at each position.

This will make the GMs try to figure out stamina and effectiveness per position and figure out where depth is needed.
This should provide enough factors so that no team would have an advantage going into next season and would require EVERYONE from players to GMs and Owners to figure out the balance and level the playing field all around.


 
Defeugo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by buffalobills_tw

Originally posted by Bort


Hey, I have no problem with making energy affect you more, for next season. It used to be, but people got me second guessing myself. I should probably go with my gut more often than letting the internets sway me.


Bort, can we now assume stamina will play a bigger role in season 2 so teams can plan ahead?



Yeah, I'll make some adjustments. Maybe I should increase the effect slowly over the course of the first week or so of the new season, to give people time to adjust? I'll probably do various adjustments over the course of the season, too, just to make sure it gets balanced out properly.

"Power gamers" will bitch and moan about this I assure you, but I guess they bitch and moan about everything anyway.


You say "Power gamers" I say "Min/Maxers"

For all those that said that the starters play most or all of the snaps in a game, you do realize there were only 7 players that played in 100% of their units snaps this last NFL season.

My issue with stamina the way in its current form is that it penalizes depth to the point that each team should have as few players as possible. Depth should be a good thing as long as the depth has decent talent. I would think you also want to reward teams that take on more players and not penalize them. So many players are having hard times finding teams that they can participate in. To a point this will always be the case as long as teams are only going to be 1 player deep.
 
cpwhite
offline
Link
 
Thanks Bort. Tying Energy directly to Performance would seem like a no brainer and the people telling you otherwise have obviously never played a down of competetive football.

It took us a few games to figure out why the best teams playing were only 1 deep at every position. But if there are no injuries or penalties for fatigue it does make sense even though it's contrary to RL.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.