Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Nor do I believe that allowing the Defense to dictate matchups necessarily leads to better game balance...
But that's the way the REAL game of football is played. When Marvin Harrison breaks the huddle, IF Denver wants Champ Bailey to cover him, Champ Bailey is going to find Harrison and attempt to cover him regardless of where the Colts direct Harrison to lineup.
GLB != NFL
EDIT - and if you read my posts:
1) I don't mind the idea of allowing specific matchups.. but that would be a SUGGESTION which doesn't belong in the bugs forum, and this thread is premised upon the current mechanics being an exploit. If the OP wants to put it into the Suggestion forum, cool - as I've said a dozen times.
2) Even if such a mechanic was created, who is to say that it would be any better? Right before the game, OC puts #1 WR into TE slot and then your defenders see that #1 WR is on the field and make a rush to cover him.. hey look - a WR is open because the CB is off chasing a TE. Then you guys would be calling this an exploit.
3) Even assuming that it creates stronger offenses and weaker defenses to allow the Offense to create mismatches through DC manipulation.. BOTH teams get to use the same manipulations and therefore there is no issue of balance. ALL CBs would face the same mismatch potentials, ALL WRs would face the same mismatch opportunities, and ALL teams would have a mix of each.
4) If you are so worried about Balance, then you should be arguing against Boosting... Boosting is exactly the same thing as offering an IPOD for sale to two kids - one of them gets an allowance because their parents are rich, the other doesn't because their parents are poor.... One of them will be able to get the IPOD - the other wont, and it won't have anything to do with merits of the kids.. it's all about which one has more money from parents. That's the same relationship between Players (who are the kids, if you needed the analogy explained) and players (the people on the computers, who are the parents). Real life isn't fair, which is one of the big reasons why people strive for fairness within the games.
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Nor do I believe that allowing the Defense to dictate matchups necessarily leads to better game balance...
But that's the way the REAL game of football is played. When Marvin Harrison breaks the huddle, IF Denver wants Champ Bailey to cover him, Champ Bailey is going to find Harrison and attempt to cover him regardless of where the Colts direct Harrison to lineup.
GLB != NFL
EDIT - and if you read my posts:
1) I don't mind the idea of allowing specific matchups.. but that would be a SUGGESTION which doesn't belong in the bugs forum, and this thread is premised upon the current mechanics being an exploit. If the OP wants to put it into the Suggestion forum, cool - as I've said a dozen times.
2) Even if such a mechanic was created, who is to say that it would be any better? Right before the game, OC puts #1 WR into TE slot and then your defenders see that #1 WR is on the field and make a rush to cover him.. hey look - a WR is open because the CB is off chasing a TE. Then you guys would be calling this an exploit.
3) Even assuming that it creates stronger offenses and weaker defenses to allow the Offense to create mismatches through DC manipulation.. BOTH teams get to use the same manipulations and therefore there is no issue of balance. ALL CBs would face the same mismatch potentials, ALL WRs would face the same mismatch opportunities, and ALL teams would have a mix of each.
4) If you are so worried about Balance, then you should be arguing against Boosting... Boosting is exactly the same thing as offering an IPOD for sale to two kids - one of them gets an allowance because their parents are rich, the other doesn't because their parents are poor.... One of them will be able to get the IPOD - the other wont, and it won't have anything to do with merits of the kids.. it's all about which one has more money from parents. That's the same relationship between Players (who are the kids, if you needed the analogy explained) and players (the people on the computers, who are the parents). Real life isn't fair, which is one of the big reasons why people strive for fairness within the games.
Last edited Aug 7, 2008 17:42:49






























