User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > This is clearly an exploit and should be addressed ASAP
Page:
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi



Nor do I believe that allowing the Defense to dictate matchups necessarily leads to better game balance...



But that's the way the REAL game of football is played. When Marvin Harrison breaks the huddle, IF Denver wants Champ Bailey to cover him, Champ Bailey is going to find Harrison and attempt to cover him regardless of where the Colts direct Harrison to lineup.


GLB != NFL

EDIT - and if you read my posts:
1) I don't mind the idea of allowing specific matchups.. but that would be a SUGGESTION which doesn't belong in the bugs forum, and this thread is premised upon the current mechanics being an exploit. If the OP wants to put it into the Suggestion forum, cool - as I've said a dozen times.

2) Even if such a mechanic was created, who is to say that it would be any better? Right before the game, OC puts #1 WR into TE slot and then your defenders see that #1 WR is on the field and make a rush to cover him.. hey look - a WR is open because the CB is off chasing a TE. Then you guys would be calling this an exploit.

3) Even assuming that it creates stronger offenses and weaker defenses to allow the Offense to create mismatches through DC manipulation.. BOTH teams get to use the same manipulations and therefore there is no issue of balance. ALL CBs would face the same mismatch potentials, ALL WRs would face the same mismatch opportunities, and ALL teams would have a mix of each.

4) If you are so worried about Balance, then you should be arguing against Boosting... Boosting is exactly the same thing as offering an IPOD for sale to two kids - one of them gets an allowance because their parents are rich, the other doesn't because their parents are poor.... One of them will be able to get the IPOD - the other wont, and it won't have anything to do with merits of the kids.. it's all about which one has more money from parents. That's the same relationship between Players (who are the kids, if you needed the analogy explained) and players (the people on the computers, who are the parents). Real life isn't fair, which is one of the big reasons why people strive for fairness within the games.
Last edited Aug 7, 2008 17:42:49
 
RIP Al Davis
offline
Link
 
I tried this and it didn't work. Apparently it's been fixed.

/thread
 
RIP Al Davis
offline
Link
 
To be more specific, I left the first 2 WRs blank and it just made the backups the starters.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi


GLB != NFL




This isn't personal, and its not directed at you--just wanted full disclosure for what follows.

But that argument is annoying as anything that repeatedly shows up in these discussions. We all know that somewhere upward of 90 percent of the folks who play here model their players and their strategies after what they know about the game of football as its played either in the NFL or Division 1 NCAA. As such, its more than a little silly to pretend that (legalities aside) buried underneath all of the disclaimers isn't the overwhelming desire to build a football sim that "plays" like the Pro/NCAA Division 1 game plays.

Sorry to vent--again, nothing personal.
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader

This isn't personal, and its not directed at you--just wanted full disclosure for what follows.

But that argument is annoying as anything that repeatedly shows up in these discussions. We all know that somewhere upward of 90 percent of the folks who play here model their players and their strategies after what they know about the game of football as its played either in the NFL or Division 1 NCAA. As such, its more than a little silly to pretend that (legalities aside) buried underneath all of the disclaimers isn't the overwhelming desire to build a football sim that "plays" like the Pro/NCAA Division 1 game plays.

Sorry to vent--again, nothing personal.


No problem.. 90% eh? How did you come to this number?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader


This isn't personal, and its not directed at you--just wanted full disclosure for what follows.

But that argument is annoying as anything that repeatedly shows up in these discussions. We all know that somewhere upward of 90 percent of the folks who play here model their players and their strategies after what they know about the game of football as its played either in the NFL or Division 1 NCAA. As such, its more than a little silly to pretend that (legalities aside) buried underneath all of the disclaimers isn't the overwhelming desire to build a football sim that "plays" like the Pro/NCAA Division 1 game plays.

Sorry to vent--again, nothing personal.


No problem.. 90% eh? How did you come to this number?



*laughs* Personally, I wanted to say 100%! But then I remembered that one player here was proudly sporting HIS OWN current picture of himself in his current high school football uniform as his avatar! *laughs again* So I decided I had better give myself some leeway with my guesstimate!
Last edited Aug 7, 2008 17:57:02
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
There's a few more problems with CB - WR matchups:

1.
Lets say, offense got 3 WRs, defense 5 CBs.

How do you want to split up the playtime for your CBs?
- energy settings override matchups? (... whine! the stupid AI put in my backup CB just when I needed to stop this TD-drive! This MUST be changed!!!)
- or matchups override energy settings? (... whine! how do I get my backups playtime? Something needs to be done)

... and to make it worse:

#1 WR I really want to cover only by CB #1 and #3 WR only by CB#4, but anyone else I'd like to sub in and out based on breath.

2.
What happens, if a set WR plays at TE or RB while a TE or RB plays WR?

3.
What happens, if formations and/or orders do not match...

- CB#1 and CB#2 playing in a regular formation, offense in a 3 WR shotgun?
- defense plays a quarter defense vs. a 3 WR set, unforunately all 4 CBs are set to cover only 2 WR #1 and #2

4.
What happens, if a WR is signed and/or dropped right before the game?


best regards
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
yes it has been fixed

/lock
 
kinglehr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

Originally posted by Bort


It really just sounds like a job for CB -> WR matchup priorities. Of course that wouldn't apply to zone defenses -- only man-to-man -- but it would probably help.

The new DC 1/2/3 positions were supposed to help in this regard but I think they have caused more problems than they have solved really, which is too bad.

I don't know if it would be very easy to just lock the offense part of the DC earlier than the defense, since they are on the same page and part of the same form submission. It would take some doing, and it doesn't really address the problem completely. More of a band-aid than anything.


I agree with the "band-aid over a chest wound" thing, but wouldn't having CBs match up to the "Best" WR (and the god awful levels of describing "best" in such a way the AI can understand and apply it) be murder.

I mean, maybe a simple match-up by name would work (assuming it didn't go off the other team's DC because people would just leave it blank for a while so the Def. couldn't plan) but I have no idea the amount of work required.


Yeah, I'm talking about matchups that the team owner enters.

Like he can edit his list of CB's and use some pulldowns to select the name of the WR he wants to to be the #1 priority for each CB. If that WR's in the game, the CB covers him. If not it just falls back to the same logic as now.

There's probably some conflict stuff that might get hairy, like if you choose the same matchup on more than one player, but you get the idea.


I was thinking maybe a player tactic... like how QBs have favorite receivers... CBs can have WR coverage responsibilities as well.

Of course, DCs will probably complain about the lack of control.
 
Blitz_Inc.
offline
Link
 
Correct me if I'm wrong but couldn't you do the same thing with your CBs to address this mismatch. Ergo, corrects your problem.
 
Sigmaforce
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Blitz_Inc.
Correct me if I'm wrong but couldn't you do the same thing with your CBs to address this mismatch. Ergo, corrects your problem.


Then it comes down to who changes their DC last. The administration has took a stance against any sort of feature that allows guys who can be on close to game time an advantage. Some people sim in the morning, middle of the night, or when at work so they are unable to monitor the DC every minute up until the chart lock. Wouldn't be fair that way.

Some sort of matchup preferences would be great, but I think it should be Defensive Coord. controlled, not as an individual setting. DC puts the opposing WRs into their own matchup chart, and their top CB on the field according to their DC will be matched up with the top WR on the field according to the matchup chart.
Last edited Aug 8, 2008 08:39:21
 
pumph
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader


This isn't personal, and its not directed at you--just wanted full disclosure for what follows.

But that argument is annoying as anything that repeatedly shows up in these discussions. We all know that somewhere upward of 90 percent of the folks who play here model their players and their strategies after what they know about the game of football as its played either in the NFL or Division 1 NCAA. As such, its more than a little silly to pretend that (legalities aside) buried underneath all of the disclaimers isn't the overwhelming desire to build a football sim that "plays" like the Pro/NCAA Division 1 game plays.

Sorry to vent--again, nothing personal.


No problem.. 90% eh? How did you come to this number?



57.3% of all statistics are made up.

 
RunningMn9
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sigmaforce
Some sort of matchup preferences would be great, but I think it should be Defensive Coord. controlled, not as an individual setting. DC puts the opposing WRs into their own matchup chart, and their top CB on the field according to their DC will be matched up with the top WR on the field according to the matchup chart.


I was thinking about suggesting this too, but the problem is that the balance then flips the other way to the defense and it's impossible to create mismatches with the secondary. As an OC, I need control over formation and play selection (both of which are currently selected at random by the AI according to some broad parameters that I can control). You would also need the ability to put a WR in motion to try and get him a free release at the snap.

These are all things that NFL offenses can do to counteract NFL defenses. You've got to deal with all of the issues, not just DCs whining that they can't take away mismatches.
 
Domer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AgentTBC
Originally posted by Bort

Like he can edit his list of CB's and use some pulldowns to select the name of the WR he wants to to be the #1 priority for each CB. If that WR's in the game, the CB covers him. If not it just falls back to the same logic as now.


I've been saying this is the way you're going to have to end up going for some time now. Last time was 2 days ago in the flames receiver thread. There really is no getting around it. Otherwise offense will always have an incredible advantage in finding mismatches.

It also, as I point out in the flames receiver thread, helps solve the problem with builds like Plotz with 96 speed and nothing else. Right now that breaks things because the defense can't just make all their CBs have 90 speed to cover him as the other WRs will eat them alive. And if the defense has one CB with 90 speed there is simply no way to get him to cover Plotz as the offense can switch him around on the depth chart to find a mismatch.

I have no idea how much work it will be to allow the defensive coordinator to assign matchups by name for CB/WR, but the truth is you'll have to do it eventually so you might as well think about it now.



You can use player names in the interface, but player #'s in the background. So if you choose to have your CB -Joe Cover, line up against a certain WR, Mike Run, then the SIM would recognize that as Player 1234 covers player 5432. That way you avoid teams changing the names of their players to exploit the system further.

I really like your idea and think it deserves a lot of thought.

Domer
 
evilmonkey
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TreMetal
Doing it that way sucks, because if Jack Schmack is not on the field.. then Joe Schmack has to cover him..

So your list would be like this:

CB1
----
WR: Joe Blah
WR: Jon Foo
WR: Ike Spikes

CB2
----
WR: Joe Blah
WR: Jon Foo
WR: Ike Spikes

CB3
----
WR: Joe Blah
WR: Jon Foo
WR: Ike Spikes

You really just want
My team:
CB1
CB2
CB3

Their team:
WR1
WR2
WR3

Your highest guy on the field guards their highest guy on the field on the list.

It might be suggested that you can have 4 lists: their speedsters, your speedsters, their posession, your lockdown. (Or however you want to label them).


ehh... my way accomplished the same thing and has the advantage of being the most flexible between your "solution" and mine... maybe do a combo where you set up speedsters / possession / shutdown, and then overrides for certain players ... I'm not thinking very much on this, so I'm sure there are holes...

But thanks for saying my way sucks outright... I appreciate your crudeness.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.