User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
j10er
offline
Link
 
First off, to all the doubters,

Secondly, these changes sound amazing - thank you Bort! This will make the passing game much, much more realistic, imo. Well-build CBs/WRs should perform to their abilities and mismatches will actually result in opportunities.

Beautiful.
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Cheers Bort. Knew there was more to it than "your builds must be teh suckz", and I wasn't far wrong :humb:
 
Revel8
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Just wanted to post letting everybody know I haven't been around posting much today because I've been running tons of tests and modifying stuff to try and address this. I did a dump of the whole live database, so I'm able to test with any currently live teams (well, at least as they existed a day ago).

I've found a few things so far:

Fast CB's back up too fast compared to slow WR's on streak routes, due to the fact their their acceleration is a constant. I've made them match acceleration in this case and it seems to work so far. I've put a 20 speed 20 agility guy against a 70 speed 50 agility CB and the CB is all over him in general.

Agile WR's don't have a way to fake out equally agile CB's and get open. I'm increasing the effect of the head fake and juke SA's, and adding some reduced reaction time for defenders based on vision and agility and coverage distance. The result is that on some plays the CB will stay with the WR and on others he will not make the turn with the receiver until a split second too late.

CB's were basically getting an immediate jump on the ball when thrown. I'm adding a delay on the jump based on vision agility and coverage distance. The result is that sometimes the CB gets a great jump on the ball and knocks it down while other times he waits a split second too long and doesn't get there in time. Combined with the above = botched coverage, basically.

Fast CB's with poor agility playing on close vs Fast WR's often dash forward at the snap to get within the "close" cushion and are then unable to turn around quick enough to keep up with the speedy WR. I've made them back up a little at the snap instead and wait for the WR to make his move.

QB's with decent vision hardly ever miss an open man on a checkdown, which means they will ALWAYS take advantage of the situation. I'm making them slightly more likely to miss the open guy unless they have really high vision.

Risk calculations did not take the catching ability of the receiver into account as a very big part of the calculation. Being open is the major part. I'm tweaking that a little to be willing to pass to a guy if he's just way better than his defender, even if he's not wide open.

Anyway, just an update because I know people are waiting on this and I wanted to let everybody know I'm working on it. I want to make sure it's right before pushing it out there, though!


Thanks for the info.
 
Juan Fiddy
offline
Link
 
Wow, this seems to deal with just about every possible problem on both sides of the fence and I can't see how anyone won't be pleased with this.

Thanks B-Dawg!
 
Revel8
offline
Link
 
Bort, will all head fake and juke abilities be affected by these changes or just WRs?

 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Revelation
Bort, will all head fake and juke abilities be affected by these changes or just WRs?



They're the same skill for HB's and WR's - do you think HB's should be excluded from using them unless in a WR spot?
 
Zable
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Revelation

Bort, will all head fake and juke abilities be affected by these changes or just WRs?



They're the same skill for HB's and WR's - do you think HB's should be excluded from using them unless in a WR spot?


Hope you didnt make them where they will become like the slow WR vs Fast CB's were before these changes

 
j10er
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Juan Fiddy
Wow, this seems to deal with just about every possible problem on both sides of the fence and I can't see how anyone won't be pleased with this.

Thanks B-Dawg!


Haha - people will find something to complain about. Especially all the turtle WRs that were ripping up the leagues.

On a serious note...

1) Will Head Fake and Juke's effectiveness be increase both without the ball AND with the ball? And is it only for WRs, as Revelation mentioned?

2) Will QBs with high vision still dump it off way too often? And what exactly is considered "high vision"?

3) What's the basic delay on the various coverage distances? I would imagine you have a better chance of jumping the route/pass on medium coverage, but I could also see the argument that close coverage should get the most bonus, since the CB is closer to the play.

4) So if a lesser WR is slightly open and a better WR is covered, who gets the pass thrown their way? Will this swing too far the other way, where crappy WRs, even if they're wide open, never get a pass?

I'm sure you're on top of everything, but these were just questions that popped into my head. Thanks once again Bort - looking forward to seeing what the new changes produce!
 
Zable
offline
Link
 
More importantly... Will these changes be in before tomorrows Simmed games?
 
arteryman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Revelation

Bort, will all head fake and juke abilities be affected by these changes or just WRs?



They're the same skill for HB's and WR's - do you think HB's should be excluded from using them unless in a WR spot?


We did have that problem with crazy HB's and their shield with head fake, so I think so.
 
dead_poet
offline
Link
 
Has the WR1 problem been addressed?
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by j10er

1) Will Head Fake and Juke's effectiveness be increase both without the ball AND with the ball? And is it only for WRs, as Revelation mentioned?


I'm just uppping the likelihood during route running. Basically, when you change direction, you have a chance to fake out the CB. That obviously doesn't happen much on a streak route, which makes sense, but it should make it easier to get open on posts and flags, etc.


Originally posted by j10er

2) Will QBs with high vision still dump it off way too often? And what exactly is considered "high vision"?


Depends on your QB's dump off setting. I'm talking about vision +50 or so basically meaning you see the whole field very well. You can still make mistakes, but not nearly as many as somebody with 10 or 20.

Originally posted by j10er

3) What's the basic delay on the various coverage distances? I would imagine you have a better chance of jumping the route/pass on medium coverage, but I could also see the argument that close coverage should get the most bonus, since the CB is closer to the play.


A split second is really all you need to get open. The amount of time he's delayed all depends on your CB's stats like vision and agility. Close coverage is more likely to screw up than medium. Long basically has no penalty other than the fact that you're 5-6 yards away.

Originally posted by j10er

4) So if a lesser WR is slightly open and a better WR is covered, who gets the pass thrown their way? Will this swing too far the other way, where crappy WRs, even if they're wide open, never get a pass?


That's why I'm still testing to find a balance. It depends on how covered the better receiver is and how much better he is than the crappy guy. Everybody gets a bonus to their risk value based on catching ability, so if the WR is 5 times better at catching he's got a better chance of being thrown to unless his defender is pretty good at swatting down passes, which would negate his bonus.

Originally posted by j10er

I'm sure you're on top of everything, but these were just questions that popped into my head. Thanks once again Bort - looking forward to seeing what the new changes produce!


I hope they help out. These have been problems since day 1 of the game, and I think we just managed to bring them out through a combinations of things this season.
 
Revel8
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Revelation

Bort, will all head fake and juke abilities be affected by these changes or just WRs?



They're the same skill for HB's and WR's - do you think HB's should be excluded from using them unless in a WR spot?


If both abilities are tied to all positions equally then there wouldn't be any good reason for the exclusion. I was not sure how they were programmed into the game, thanks.
 
Drewg81
offline
Link
 
Thanks, Bort. My CB had been toasted quite a bit by this in today's game, so I'm glad a fix is already in the works. As always, your hard work is appreciated.
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Bort, a concern I have is that if you allow all these speedster SA's to help super-fast WR's get open, yet give no way for defenses to matchup their faster CBs to the faster WRs on the field, there's going to be severe problems.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.