User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > The solution!! For retiring players, teams playing 100+ plays per player/penalizing depth, and rewarding team with good defenses/quick scoring offenses
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by jearly
A lot of complaints have been given up surrounding the following issues:

Capping Player development at season 10 with a steady decline afterwards.
Teams with no depth (1 starter at each position) levelling up faster than teams that sign and develop depth.
Good offenses that score too quickly to gain decent xp and defenses that have too many 3 and outs to gain decent xp.

Here's my idea for the solution to all 3.
1st - cap the xp gain at 60 plays vs 90 so there's no incentive to play your starters a ridiculous amount of plays per game.
2nd - instead of capping player development at level 10, cap it a set number of plays before a player stops improving and starts declining. (say 600 plays = 10 seasons at 60 plays per game).

That way if team wants to run the crap out of their starters they have the option to do so - for a short term victory, but a lower long term careerr for the players.

The players that choose to be backups aren't penalized as they can become just as good as the other players, but would do it over a longer period of time, before they start to decline.

Teams that sign and play depth would eventually catch up with the superstarters, but could do so while building a team concept and having fun along the way - it would just take a little while longer...

Also - this has "real world applicability" as player's careers will decline after a period of "wear and tear" on their bodies vs. a set number of years. (you could still implement a max set of years to compensate for age, say 15 years?).

A future enhancement would be to allow players to train "durability" which would allow them to extend careers beyond the set number of plays/year limit (but they would obviously lose the extra skill points along the way, so the trick would be to figure out the right balance). In addition, if players play too much, injuries could shorten thier set number of plays/year limit...

I'm sure some will see some problems with the above, but to me this seems like a great way to allow people to play the game the way they want to (e.g superstarters vs. superdepth) AND allow a competitive game all around...


this is retarded. to cap it at lvl 10 would be rediculous. you can get to lvl 10 mid way in your second season. it would make owning a player less fun. if he can onl develop for about 45 days.

and a cap on plays is redicoulus.it is like it would be punishin our plaers for being at the top of the depth chart. (Also 600 plays dosnt equal 60 plays per game for 10 seasons. that would be if you played 1 game per season)
 
tpaterniti
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
I understand that but I think you will still have a contingent of people who will create a player with the intention of never having them play a single play until their 6th year. Along with boosting and daily XP gains, this will put them in the level 17-19 range by my calculations. Adding an element where they are still getting some wear and tear (20 plays per game regardless) you mitigate that tactic a little bit. It's still a valid tactic but not as unbalancing as it potentially could be.


So people make a player, pay for their boosts and don't play them for 6 seasons (8-9 months) just so they can bring them in at level 18 and play them for 9 more seasons? Meanwhile the people who created their player at the same time and actually played them has their guy at something like level 70. Does this make as little sense to anyone else as it does to me? Considering that there will be level capped leagues, what is the point of this or how is it an exploit?
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tpaterniti
Originally posted by drifter

I understand that but I think you will still have a contingent of people who will create a player with the intention of never having them play a single play until their 6th year. Along with boosting and daily XP gains, this will put them in the level 17-19 range by my calculations. Adding an element where they are still getting some wear and tear (20 plays per game regardless) you mitigate that tactic a little bit. It's still a valid tactic but not as unbalancing as it potentially could be.


So people make a player, pay for their boosts and don't play them for 6 seasons (8-9 months) just so they can bring them in at level 18 and play them for 9 more seasons? Meanwhile the people who created their player at the same time and actually played them has their guy at something like level 70. Does this make as little sense to anyone else as it does to me? Considering that there will be level capped leagues, what is the point of this or how is it an exploit?


If I have 10 guys, yes I have no problem doing this with 3 of them. I plan on playing this game a long time. Why wouldn't I shelve a small number of the players so that some time down the road they can be 12 levels better than everyone else in the game?
 
kristof65
offline
Link
 
Uh, Florida - you didn't read the original post very well, or the rest of the thread, did you?

First off, it isn't capped at level 10 - he's referring to the 10 season limit on players that is already in effect. Secondly, the math error was already addressed.
Last edited Apr 16, 2008 13:34:28
 
leaglebv
offline
Link
 
I love this idea, but I think there should be random exceptions to the "wear and tear" limit - ie Brett Favre or Jim Kelly...

I think at random certain players will not lose productivity until much later in their careers, or until they hit a certain age limit. Brett Favre had one of his best seasons in this past NFL year, and is now retiring (maybe?).
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tpaterniti


So people make a player, pay for their boosts and don't play them for 6 seasons (8-9 months) just so they can bring them in at level 18 and play them for 9 more seasons? Meanwhile the people who created their player at the same time and actually played them has their guy at something like level 70. Does this make as little sense to anyone else as it does to me? Considering that there will be level capped leagues, what is the point of this or how is it an exploit?



If you look around, you can find people who own one (or more) teams and already have over 30 players. Yes they would shelve a few. And it wouldn't be level 18, it would be level 25 with 5 full years of intense training.
 
bmedders
offline
Link
 
To fix the shelving player, you could institute something where players have to play a minimum of xxx plays in a season, or xxx number is deducted. That number can increase with more seasons into the game, as players legitimately on the bench shouldn't be penalized. Something like:

Season 1 - 100 plays
Season 2 - 200 plays
Season 3 - 350 plays
Season 4 - 500 plays
Season 5 - 500 plays

If a player goes over the minimum number of plays, then the actual number is used instead of the minimum. But if they don't reach that number, then the minimum number is charge to their total (For the sake of argument let say it is 10000 plays for the career). If a player sits out five seasons, they will come in with an advantage, yes, but he only has 8350 plays left for his career.

Obviously the numbers I came up with are completely arbitrary, and just to show the framework of how something could be done.
Last edited Apr 16, 2008 14:41:01
 
AF_Medic30
offline
Link
 
You could also institute a policy that an owner can only have say 2 or 3 players of his on any 1 team that he owns. He can have as many players as he wants to pay to have, but he can't "stack" his own team.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AF_Medic30
You could also institute a policy that an owner can only have say 2 or 3 players of his on any 1 team that he owns. He can have as many players as he wants to pay to have, but he can't "stack" his own team.


Wouldn't work. Lots of people on here are buddies. You don't to own a team to have someone shelve a player for you

 
Paladin58
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Originally posted by jearly


i think there would have to be an "age limit" as well as a "wear and tear" limit that would work in conjunction together - i.e. the actual limit is a a variable based on a players wear and tear in conjunction with his age...


Even better is if players and owners don't know what the formula is. It could vary slightly by position. When player reached that point, there would be a red dot show up on their profile.




Your time has come. Renew. RENEW!
 
AF_Medic30
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by AF_Medic30

You could also institute a policy that an owner can only have say 2 or 3 players of his on any 1 team that he owns. He can have as many players as he wants to pay to have, but he can't "stack" his own team.


Wouldn't work. Lots of people on here are buddies. You don't to own a team to have someone shelve a player for you



Very true, but again there will always be ass mongers who will bend and break any rules, but at least the ass monger would have to develop some friends
 
wine
offline
Link
 
I like the OPs proposal and support it fully.

I think it resolves some of the weaker constructs of the game.
 
Saris
offline
Link
 
I agree that experience yielding plays need to be capped at 60. The rest though is just gaming socialism, and pretty lame.
 
kristof65
offline
Link
 
Ok, I actually ran some numbers. Now, this is assuming I have the XP progression correct - these all assume that you get 100xp per day at 1st level, 96xp/day at 2 lvl, 92xp/day at 3rd, and so on.

For a player sitting on the bench for 5 seasons, earning only daily XP, not playing, and without boosting - he will have just barely made 15th level by the 40th day of season 5.

For a player sitting on the bench for 5 seasons, earning only daily XP, not playing, but boosting three levels at the end of each season - he will have just barely made level 23 on the last day, but the boost will bring him to level 26.

Now, I have no idea what the actual XP for playing is, but it looks to me like a guy actually playing all that time will be no more than 2-3 levels behind the guy who sits out, at most - from what I've seen, they'll probably be pretty even. Yes, the guy who just starts will get an extra 4-5 seasons of play, but how much would he really advance beyond that point? My guess is that over all, he'd have maybe a 4-5 level advantage at most, and at what cost? A whole lot of training money that will probably never be made up.

Unless this guy is sitting on someones team as deadweight, it's really not worth it as a player, and any team that pays them as deadweight is wasting resources.

It might be worth it for a season or two at most.

Last edited Apr 16, 2008 15:41:34
 
tpaterniti
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
But there will be level caps to leagues, so it doesn't matter if you enter the league at level 20, you will be in a league with other people of similar level. The only difference is it will have taken you 6 season (8 months) to get to level 20 and them only 2 seasons to get there. One way or another your player retires after 15 seasons, so if you waste 6 of them on the bench, that makes no sense. Either way you are playing in a league with other players of your level or close. I must be missing something.

BTW I am assuming a 15 season max based on when you make the player not his first game, which would make no sense. The way it has been described is:

Wear and tear per play
15 season max from the time he is created.

It's not like a modern day running back could start playing at 40, no matter how "fresh" he was.
Last edited Apr 16, 2008 15:45:10
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.