User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Passing needs to be fixed in this game, very long post with a ton of research, don't discard as another whine post
Page:
 
Ilok
offline
Link
 
Bort I think that would be a great improvement. Also having Pass interference called would be good too, cause corners seem to be all over WR as it is.
 
GenoBong
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ilok
not every game was unbalanced in our league, but an outstanding performance passing is barely over 200 yards 2 TD and completing 60% of passes. Yes I understand somethings are due to imbalances, but I'm trying to focus on the average not the outrageous.

My QB is level 14 which is way above normal for this league, throwing to WR level 9-7-7, which are normal, yet our passing game is very normal in this league, which means its worthless.


For what it's worth, I looked at the play-by-play of your first game where you went 3 for 13. Your QB started 1 for 5 in the first half, for .5 yards, with 3 drops. Of your 10 incompetions for the game, 5 were drops.

Your first deflection was on a little dump pass to your halfback, over a DE. The DE deflected the pass. That seems fairly realistic. Do you have points in dump pass? Perhaps if your halfback had better jumping/carrying/strength he may have been able to outwork the DE for the ball.

The second deflection you were throwing to a level 3 receiver who was being covered by a level 9 cornerback. Broken?

The third deflection you threw to a level 7 WR covered by a level 7 CB. That's pretty much just a lost dice roll. It happens.

On the fourth deflection, you threw to Harry Adcock (who up until this point has now had 5 drops in the game and is likely suffering from some serious morale issues) and the ball was deflected. I wouldn't be surprised if he would have dropped it even if it wasn't deflected.

Instead of saying the game is broken in some way, I'd first wonder what your qb's confidence is, your wr's catching/confidence is, and the defense's intimidation factors are. With low confidence, it's rare that a player who starts out poorly comes back to have a decent game.

This first game looks like it played out pretty realistically and within the spirit of the game design.


In your second scrim, you went 6 for 12 with 1 drop on your attempts. You had 2 deflected passes, both attempts went to your tight end; none other than Harry Adcock. Stop throwing to that guy. Oh, and you'll never guess who was responsible for the drop. Without your looks to the TE, your quarterback might be having a decent preseason.

Listen, I can understand your frustration (I have a level 16 QB who is making the right reads but his receviers aren't making plays). You mentioned high school level of play. I'd expect Levels 12-16 to be around high school level of talent, 16-20 college, and 20+ pros. Give your player(s) some time to grow before you make a final judgement.
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I think I just found something that's really holding the passing game back - QB's really have no finesse. They just fire it in there at top velocity all the time. I'm testing an update where the QB recalculates a slower velocity throw for those short passes that frequently get fired right through a HB's hands or over the head of a receiver.

Maybe "throwing style" should be a new setting for QB's too? "Bullet" or "lofty?"


Why wouldn't a QB fluctuate between the two depending on circumstances? I'd hate to choose Bullet and then miss all the short passes.. and I'd hate to choose lofty and throw interceptions every time I wanted to pass beyond 10yds.

EDIT, switch that but whatever.
Last edited Aug 1, 2008 16:05:02
 
GenoBong
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I think I just found something that's really holding the passing game back - QB's really have no finesse. They just fire it in there at top velocity all the time. I'm testing an update where the QB recalculates a slower velocity throw for those short passes that frequently get fired right through a HB's hands or over the head of a receiver.

Maybe "throwing style" should be a new setting for QB's too? "Bullet" or "lofty?"


It should be situational, and the speed of the pass should depend on the route, and some formula that considers the QB's vision/throwing/confidence/breath/morale/whether he's hurried or under pressure to determine whether the QB makes the right kind of pass for the route against the defense.

For example, a good QB will throw bullets in between zones or in man coverage on slants, hooks, and outs. A bad QB might try to loft passes in those situations. A good QB will loft deep passes to a speedy or high jumping WR, or to a soft spot in a zone where a receiver's route is taking him, and like was stated earlier to dump passes.

If there would be any sort of QB preference changes, I'd like to see something like [Sidearm/Normal] and [Quick Release/Slow Release] with bonuses to each. For example, Sidearm would get a + to bullet but a - to lofty. Quick release would get a + to accuracy while hurried, a + to pump fake, whereas a slow release would get a + to bullet/loft but would get sacked more often when hurried.

Just my 2 cents.
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
If we wanted a new QB tactical setting - then I'd go with something that demonstrated a QB's preference between sacks and interceptions. Something that tells how long a QB will keep looking for a good passing target.

I don't know if that would help the overall Yards per pass average - but it'd be good to have.
 
emdude
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I think I just found something that's really holding the passing game back - QB's really have no finesse. They just fire it in there at top velocity all the time. I'm testing an update where the QB recalculates a slower velocity throw for those short passes that frequently get fired right through a HB's hands or over the head of a receiver.

Maybe "throwing style" should be a new setting for QB's too? "Bullet" or "lofty?"

Except sometimes you want to throw a bullet and sometimes you want to lob it, so IDK if 'bullet ot lofty' is the answer, but it's true that QBs need some 'touch' and need to know when to throw it harder or softer.
Last edited Aug 1, 2008 15:58:33
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I think I just found something that's really holding the passing game back - QB's really have no finesse. They just fire it in there at top velocity all the time. I'm testing an update where the QB recalculates a slower velocity throw for those short passes that frequently get fired right through a HB's hands or over the head of a receiver.

Maybe "throwing style" should be a new setting for QB's too? "Bullet" or "lofty?"


Wouldn't the correct throwing style be determined by the length of the pass? No QB can really throw a 20 yard bullet.

Also, it wouldn't fix the problem that pass defenders are just too hard to beat. They'll knock lofty passes away even more easily. I realize you might want exactly that tradeoff, but the thing is that if you at least make the right tradeoff, passes should work better than they have been.

I mean, if lofty passes were dropped less but knocked away the same as now, bullet passes dropped as now but knocked away less, and the middle position doing a little of both, then that might work. But still, well, I suppose longer passes could have the degree of loft (they'd all need some) affected by that.
 
GenoBong
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by Bort

I think I just found something that's really holding the passing game back - QB's really have no finesse. They just fire it in there at top velocity all the time. I'm testing an update where the QB recalculates a slower velocity throw for those short passes that frequently get fired right through a HB's hands or over the head of a receiver.

Maybe "throwing style" should be a new setting for QB's too? "Bullet" or "lofty?"


Wouldn't the correct throwing style be determined by the length of the pass? No QB can really throw a 20 yard bullet.

Also, it wouldn't fix the problem that pass defenders are just too hard to beat. They'll knock lofty passes away even more easily. I realize you might want exactly that tradeoff, but the thing is that if you at least make the right tradeoff, passes should work better than they have been.

I mean, if lofty passes were dropped less but knocked away the same as now, bullet passes dropped as now but knocked away less, and the middle position doing a little of both, then that might work. But still, well, I suppose longer passes could have the degree of loft (they'd all need some) affected by that.


Definitely agree here on the 20 yard bullet comment. Longer passes should be slower relative to the QB's arm strength and the length of the pass. These 30 yard lazers downfield look ridiculous.


As far as the idea in general, bullets would require a higher level of catching by the wr to catch, but in theory should be more difficult to deflect/intercept unless the bullet pass goes over a player who jumps up and deflects/intercepts it. E.g. a zoning linebacker. They should also be easier to be swatted at the line of scrimmage.

Whereas a slower moving "lofty" pass with arc should in theory be easier to catch (if it's on target), should be far more difficult to deflect if the WR's jumping is higher than the CB's, and nearly unswattable at the line unless the defender is right in the qb's face.


 
arcadecowboy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I think I just found something that's really holding the passing game back - QB's really have no finesse. They just fire it in there at top velocity all the time. I'm testing an update where the QB recalculates a slower velocity throw for those short passes that frequently get fired right through a HB's hands or over the head of a receiver.

Maybe "throwing style" should be a new setting for QB's too? "Bullet" or "lofty?"


All due respect, I don't like this. I don't like this at all. Why does my QB have to be an idiot and always do it one way or the other? This seems something that should have been addressed with an ability (an SA, perhaps) before it started, or now that we're a few seasons in, tied into an extant ability (or more than one, if needed). Whether to throw a bullet or a soft toss is a call a smart quarterback makes based on what's needed, and what he's physically capable.

I do think slower velocity throws would be great when needed, but as of right now, I can't see why I'd ever put it on Bullet or Lofty.
 
GenoBong
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by arcadecowboy
Originally posted by Bort

I think I just found something that's really holding the passing game back - QB's really have no finesse. They just fire it in there at top velocity all the time. I'm testing an update where the QB recalculates a slower velocity throw for those short passes that frequently get fired right through a HB's hands or over the head of a receiver.

Maybe "throwing style" should be a new setting for QB's too? "Bullet" or "lofty?"


All due respect, I don't like this. I don't like this at all. Why does my QB have to be an idiot and always do it one way or the other? This seems something that should have been addressed with an ability (an SA, perhaps) before it started, or now that we're a few seasons in, tied into an extant ability (or more than one, if needed). Whether to throw a bullet or a soft toss is a call a smart quarterback makes based on what's needed, and what he's physically capable.

I do think slower velocity throws would be great when needed, but as of right now, I can't see why I'd ever put it on Bullet or Lofty.


Well, first of all, there'd have to be "lofty" passes in the game. There really isn't right now. There's no "touch" to throws, they're just lazered all around.

I could get behind something like this if the above issue is addressed. And a lofty/bullet preference setting I could get behind depending on what it affects. I mean, if you set it to lofty and every single one of your passes is high and slow, regardless of the route, that would indeed be lame. But if you had a preference for bullet/lofty where one setting would give pluses/minuses to certain routes (e.g. bullet throwers would get a benefit from medium range throws but a minus for long throws or throws out of the backfield. whereas a lofty preference qb might get bonuses for deep passes and passes to backs, but a minus to medium length routes, or short routes to wrs)I could get behind that.
 
arcadecowboy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GenoBong
Originally posted by arcadecowboy

Originally posted by Bort


I think I just found something that's really holding the passing game back - QB's really have no finesse. They just fire it in there at top velocity all the time. I'm testing an update where the QB recalculates a slower velocity throw for those short passes that frequently get fired right through a HB's hands or over the head of a receiver.

Maybe "throwing style" should be a new setting for QB's too? "Bullet" or "lofty?"


All due respect, I don't like this. I don't like this at all. Why does my QB have to be an idiot and always do it one way or the other? This seems something that should have been addressed with an ability (an SA, perhaps) before it started, or now that we're a few seasons in, tied into an extant ability (or more than one, if needed). Whether to throw a bullet or a soft toss is a call a smart quarterback makes based on what's needed, and what he's physically capable.

I do think slower velocity throws would be great when needed, but as of right now, I can't see why I'd ever put it on Bullet or Lofty.


Well, first of all, there'd have to be "lofty" passes in the game. There really isn't right now. There's no "touch" to throws, they're just lazered all around.

I could get behind something like this if the above issue is addressed. And a lofty/bullet preference setting I could get behind depending on what it affects. I mean, if you set it to lofty and every single one of your passes is high and slow, regardless of the route, that would indeed be lame. But if you had a preference for bullet/lofty where one setting would give pluses/minuses to certain routes (e.g. bullet throwers would get a benefit from medium range throws but a minus for long throws or throws out of the backfield. whereas a lofty preference qb might get bonuses for deep passes and passes to backs, but a minus to medium length routes, or short routes to wrs)I could get behind that.


I second that emotion.

EDIT: I think I'd prefer finesse be tied into extant skills (I can see how Throwing, Strength and Vision--maybe even Confidence--could affect it), but in lieu of that, I could also get behind a bonus one direction or the other like the one described above.
Last edited Aug 1, 2008 16:49:00
 
The_Kirk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I think I just found something that's really holding the passing game back - QB's really have no finesse. They just fire it in there at top velocity all the time. I'm testing an update where the QB recalculates a slower velocity throw for those short passes that frequently get fired right through a HB's hands or over the head of a receiver.

Maybe "throwing style" should be a new setting for QB's too? "Bullet" or "lofty?"


Yes, but no. We need help. Right now the tie goes to the defense. But to have an either or won't work either. Because then you have no choice as to changing for a long pass or a short pass. Or a red zone pass. In a real game, that is a play by play decision the QB makes. One play he guns it in. The next he adds touch. But to have only one for the whole game won't work either.
 
Ilok
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GenoBong
Originally posted by Ilok

not every game was unbalanced in our league, but an outstanding performance passing is barely over 200 yards 2 TD and completing 60% of passes. Yes I understand somethings are due to imbalances, but I'm trying to focus on the average not the outrageous.

My QB is level 14 which is way above normal for this league, throwing to WR level 9-7-7, which are normal, yet our passing game is very normal in this league, which means its worthless.


For what it's worth, I looked at the play-by-play of your first game where you went 3 for 13. Your QB started 1 for 5 in the first half, for .5 yards, with 3 drops. Of your 10 incompetions for the game, 5 were drops.

Your first deflection was on a little dump pass to your halfback, over a DE. The DE deflected the pass. That seems fairly realistic. Do you have points in dump pass? Perhaps if your halfback had better jumping/carrying/strength he may have been able to outwork the DE for the ball.

The second deflection you were throwing to a level 3 receiver who was being covered by a level 9 cornerback. Broken?

The third deflection you threw to a level 7 WR covered by a level 7 CB. That's pretty much just a lost dice roll. It happens.

On the fourth deflection, you threw to Harry Adcock (who up until this point has now had 5 drops in the game and is likely suffering from some serious morale issues) and the ball was deflected. I wouldn't be surprised if he would have dropped it even if it wasn't deflected.

Instead of saying the game is broken in some way, I'd first wonder what your qb's confidence is, your wr's catching/confidence is, and the defense's intimidation factors are. With low confidence, it's rare that a player who starts out poorly comes back to have a decent game.

This first game looks like it played out pretty realistically and within the spirit of the game design.


In your second scrim, you went 6 for 12 with 1 drop on your attempts. You had 2 deflected passes, both attempts went to your tight end; none other than Harry Adcock. Stop throwing to that guy. Oh, and you'll never guess who was responsible for the drop. Without your looks to the TE, your quarterback might be having a decent preseason.

Listen, I can understand your frustration (I have a level 16 QB who is making the right reads but his receviers aren't making plays). You mentioned high school level of play. I'd expect Levels 12-16 to be around high school level of talent, 16-20 college, and 20+ pros. Give your player(s) some time to grow before you make a final judgement.


I not surprised out of my QB's performance. The first game was a test with complete basic AI. I don't care what he did. The second game we did some tweaks and we spent more time working back ups than my QB. My build is about as perfect as it could be for the level. We do have problems with WR builds and we know.

The problem I was addressing was not just my team, but basically all teams in the league. There is no incentive to throw a pass, since running is so effective. Throw in the fact that the defensive up grades that have made man coverage supreme (which in real football no team on any level plays complete man all the time) running is that much more imbalanced.

Bort is on the right track that might help passing a little. As it is right now, the QB throws the ball as hard as he can every pass. If he can tweak it where depending on distance and situation the QB uses some touch, it will help out some. I'm not sure what kind of football you are watching, but I've never seen a game where it normal for a QB to complete lower than 50% of their passes. Yes a QB might every once in a while have a bad game and throw 40%, but its rare. As is, stats are going to be completely screwed right now.

oh my qb's build at level 14 is:

Strength: 36.54 Blocking: 8
Speed: 12.6 Tackling: 10
Agility: 12.6 Throwing: 64.2
Jumping: 12.6 Catching: 12.6
Stamina: 16.2 Carrying: 12.6
Vision: 44.2 Kicking: 8
Confidence: 25.64 Punting: 9

and 2 in all pocket passer tree thats with special equipment. It's not my build that's the problem.
Last edited Aug 1, 2008 17:09:24
 
Ilok
offline
Link
 
Also Bort, since you did implement the touch passing tactic, are you going to post test results before the season starts to see what works? I hate to make drastic changes with my QB on a game that counts.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ilok
Also Bort, since you did implement the touch passing tactic, are you going to post test results before the season starts to see what works? I hate to make drastic changes with my QB on a game that counts.


It works pretty well already. It's all situational, based on how far the target is. Obviously the farther a guy is from you, the higher an angle you have to throw the ball at. The setting just makes some adjustments to the angle your guy will use to throw the ball for close receivers like HB's where the angle is variable and you don't have to launch it at 45 degrees to get it there. If you choose "bullet" it will throw right at the player like it does now, if you choose "medium" it will try to keep it at least 10-15 degrees, and lofty is around 20deg. The little floaters are easier for the HB's to catch than the bullet passes.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.