User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Owner Sold Playoff team without telling anyone. New Owner inactive, no GMs......
Page:
 
Sabiancym
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bamaman82
Originally posted by Sabiancym

Originally posted by bamaman82


I was on a team last season that had this very thing happen. Owner went inactive and left no powers to any of the GM's (i was one of them). So i know how you guys feel. Hell at least we could set game plans. But i don't think 3 days is enough to have the Admins step in. In my situation they waited 10 days and gave me trading ability then at day 14 i got the team. They give it to whichever GM is most active. Go ahead and send a PM to the Admins but don't expect anything to be done until at least another week. Actually i would go ahead and PM them becuase it might take 3-4 days to get a response and that would be a week by then.


But you had GMs, so your situation was quite a bit better than ours.


Just a little. By the time the 14 day period was over 70% of the team was inactive. talk about a f-d up situation. Id didn't matter if i gameplanned or not. The fact is you just have to wait.



I'd say the ability to set the gameplan is more than "just a little".
 
rutraven76
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by McGruffHawk
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

Originally posted by


If he sets the gameplan, fine. If he doesn't it's bullshit.

This game is about players, not owners, players. In a real situation, the players simply wouldn't show up to the game. The owner would lose millions and he'd be ruined.

The only thing this is hurting is the players.


But it's "his" team. He may be an awful player, but it's still his team.

That's the point in all this. You guys are (probably, since we don't know for sure) on a team with a shitty owner (or like someone said, he may just be on vacation and be a great guy/owner). If that makes you not want to resign, good that's what you should do. Moreover, you guys should be firmly in the "Let owners pass on teams" camp now, as you see what problems it would avoid.

Other then that, it's not smart to allow people to assume control like this. What if one of your guys wants off the team? Do we allow GMs control to cut/sign players? I can see this getting out of control fast.


Again, slipper slope arguments fail.

No, we don't allow teams to make any changes to the roster. In fact, we don't need to make any rules about this whatsoever. This is an isolated and seldom repeated event. But that doesn't mean it shouldn't be addressed, it merely means it is a gray area where admins can and should act with discretion and common sense.

Common sense would suggest the simplest solution is to assign a GM until the owner returns to assert their ownership rights.



I wish you were an admin
 
Tito716
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by McGruffHawk
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

Originally posted by


If he sets the gameplan, fine. If he doesn't it's bullshit.

This game is about players, not owners, players. In a real situation, the players simply wouldn't show up to the game. The owner would lose millions and he'd be ruined.

The only thing this is hurting is the players.


But it's "his" team. He may be an awful player, but it's still his team.

That's the point in all this. You guys are (probably, since we don't know for sure) on a team with a shitty owner (or like someone said, he may just be on vacation and be a great guy/owner). If that makes you not want to resign, good that's what you should do. Moreover, you guys should be firmly in the "Let owners pass on teams" camp now, as you see what problems it would avoid.

Other then that, it's not smart to allow people to assume control like this. What if one of your guys wants off the team? Do we allow GMs control to cut/sign players? I can see this getting out of control fast.


Again, slipper slope arguments fail.

No, we don't allow teams to make any changes to the roster. In fact, we don't need to make any rules about this whatsoever. This is an isolated and seldom repeated event. But that doesn't mean it shouldn't be addressed, it merely means it is a gray area where admins can and should act with discretion and common sense.

Common sense would suggest the simplest solution is to assign a GM until the owner returns to assert their ownership rights.


Sets a GM to do what? Tactics? Depth Chart? Renegotiate? Sign players? Finances?
 
rutraven76
offline
Link
 
tactics and gameplan. thats it.
 
Sabiancym
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tito716
Originally posted by McGruffHawk

Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder


Originally posted by



If he sets the gameplan, fine. If he doesn't it's bullshit.

This game is about players, not owners, players. In a real situation, the players simply wouldn't show up to the game. The owner would lose millions and he'd be ruined.

The only thing this is hurting is the players.


But it's "his" team. He may be an awful player, but it's still his team.

That's the point in all this. You guys are (probably, since we don't know for sure) on a team with a shitty owner (or like someone said, he may just be on vacation and be a great guy/owner). If that makes you not want to resign, good that's what you should do. Moreover, you guys should be firmly in the "Let owners pass on teams" camp now, as you see what problems it would avoid.

Other then that, it's not smart to allow people to assume control like this. What if one of your guys wants off the team? Do we allow GMs control to cut/sign players? I can see this getting out of control fast.


Again, slipper slope arguments fail.

No, we don't allow teams to make any changes to the roster. In fact, we don't need to make any rules about this whatsoever. This is an isolated and seldom repeated event. But that doesn't mean it shouldn't be addressed, it merely means it is a gray area where admins can and should act with discretion and common sense.

Common sense would suggest the simplest solution is to assign a GM until the owner returns to assert their ownership rights.


Sets a GM to do what? Tactics? Depth Chart? Renegotiate? Sign players? Finances?


We want to gameplan. That is it.


I'm gonna have to go make a giant sign with that on it aren't I?

 
Laggo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by McGruffHawk


Again, slipper slope arguments fail.

No, we don't allow teams to make any changes to the roster. In fact, we don't need to make any rules about this whatsoever. This is an isolated and seldom repeated event. But that doesn't mean it shouldn't be addressed, it merely means it is a gray area where admins can and should act with discretion and common sense.

Common sense would suggest the simplest solution is to assign a GM until the owner returns to assert their ownership rights.


That "simplest solution" is merely as Malachorn said a band-aid that sets a terrible precedent for future situations of this kind.

It's simple, a rule was created to deal with this situation and you have to now live with it and follow that rule.

You cannot make a rule just for your own situation, despite how angry you may be.
 
McGruffHawk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Laggo
But you are suggesting you make a new rule/precedent that if an owner goes afk for 3 days someone from the team can be assigned to GM to change depth chart / etc. which is blatantly trying to go around the 14 day rule.


Precedent perhaps, but if so, so be it. GM's should be able to maintain tactical control of a newly purchased team until the new owner becomes active.
 
Sabiancym
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Laggo
Originally posted by McGruffHawk



Again, slipper slope arguments fail.

No, we don't allow teams to make any changes to the roster. In fact, we don't need to make any rules about this whatsoever. This is an isolated and seldom repeated event. But that doesn't mean it shouldn't be addressed, it merely means it is a gray area where admins can and should act with discretion and common sense.

Common sense would suggest the simplest solution is to assign a GM until the owner returns to assert their ownership rights.


That "simplest solution" is merely as Malachorn said a band-aid that sets a terrible precedent for future situations of this kind.

It's simple, a rule was created to deal with this situation and you have to now live with it and follow that rule.

You cannot make a rule just for your own situation, despite how angry you may be.



You can when the rule is flawed. That's how progress is made.
 
Laggo
offline
Link
 
It's a TERRIBLE precedent to set, which is why we are "trolling" trying to get you guys to give up trying to make your own rules.
 
Laggo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sabiancym


You can when the rule is flawed. That's how progress is made.


So make a fucking suggestion.

Please, please do not arbitrarily make your own rules because of that.
 
Tito716
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by McGruffHawk
Originally posted by Laggo

But you are suggesting you make a new rule/precedent that if an owner goes afk for 3 days someone from the team can be assigned to GM to change depth chart / etc. which is blatantly trying to go around the 14 day rule.


Precedent perhaps, but if so, so be it. GM's should be able to maintain tactical control of a newly purchased team until the new owner becomes active.


Inactive players aren't supposed to be assigned teams. This and the example I posted are exceptions that "slipped through the cracks."
 
McGruffHawk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tito716
Originally posted by McGruffHawk

Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder


Originally posted by



If he sets the gameplan, fine. If he doesn't it's bullshit.

This game is about players, not owners, players. In a real situation, the players simply wouldn't show up to the game. The owner would lose millions and he'd be ruined.

The only thing this is hurting is the players.


But it's "his" team. He may be an awful player, but it's still his team.

That's the point in all this. You guys are (probably, since we don't know for sure) on a team with a shitty owner (or like someone said, he may just be on vacation and be a great guy/owner). If that makes you not want to resign, good that's what you should do. Moreover, you guys should be firmly in the "Let owners pass on teams" camp now, as you see what problems it would avoid.

Other then that, it's not smart to allow people to assume control like this. What if one of your guys wants off the team? Do we allow GMs control to cut/sign players? I can see this getting out of control fast.


Again, slipper slope arguments fail.

No, we don't allow teams to make any changes to the roster. In fact, we don't need to make any rules about this whatsoever. This is an isolated and seldom repeated event. But that doesn't mean it shouldn't be addressed, it merely means it is a gray area where admins can and should act with discretion and common sense.

Common sense would suggest the simplest solution is to assign a GM until the owner returns to assert their ownership rights.


Sets a GM to do what? Tactics? Depth Chart? Renegotiate? Sign players? Finances?


Read first, post later. Tactics and depth chart. That's it. Daily operations.
 
McGruffHawk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Laggo
Originally posted by Sabiancym



You can when the rule is flawed. That's how progress is made.


So make a fucking suggestion.

Please, please do not arbitrarily make your own rules because of that.


I just made one. Existing GM's maintain tactical abilities whenever a team is purchased by a new owner until that owner merely becomes active.
 
Sabiancym
offline
Link
 
Ignore Laggo and the other guy. They are obviously 40 somethings bored at work and mad at life so they need an argument.


Back on topic.
 
Laggo
offline
Link
 
So make a suggestion that GM's of a team when the owner goes inactive for ~3 days should be allowed to become GM's to set tactics and depth chart issues so the team can be managed from day-to-day until the owner removes them.

This way, if accepted, it becomes a rule and something standardized rather than a one-time thing for your team that the next team goes WELL 3 DAYS IS TOO LONG WE COULD LOSE A GAME THEN MAKE IT 24 HOURS and the next team gets even worse.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.