User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > i personnely think the new sims are screwed up
Page:
 
karma99
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cruzi
6.
Missed tackles - expected result of tackling changes; the less speed you approach the ball carrier, the more tackling and strength you'll need. And yes, power backs should break a lot of tackles - that's what they are supposed to do!
Something to work out by building the players in a different way.


So this is as intended?
40+ tackling, wrap up and tackle assisting SA's should result in over 50% missed tackles against a similarly leveled RB?
RB's should be able to break tackles on almost the entire D (I've seen 8+ breaks multiple times today) and run for a TD 5 or 6 times every single game?

I agree with making the power back more effective, but a) this is too much, b) there needs to be some compensation to D linemen who are already on the backfoot trying to go stat for stat vs O linemen who just push Strength and Blocking up the ying yang, while D linemen need Strength, Agility and now Tackling all at the high levels to even come close to stopping a lvl20+ power back?

We need to get some balance in the game, so all styles of offence can be effective if used correctly. Last season WR with 80 speed won games, this season power backs will win games (if the current missed tackling frequency is correct), next season.. guess the win button??
 
Sao
offline
Link
 

First play from scrimmage for us? Pass to the HB. Umm, not what the doc ordered.

30 MT's on a team with < 60 in 20 games last season?

Weirdest box score for ASRW ever. Too much to even quantify lol. Very worried.
 
lawdog
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rbetesta
I do remember somewhere he was talking about making wrap-up tackling less effective. Seems like alot of people didn't take that seriously.


So is there even a reason to select wrap-up tackling? If wrap-up tackling sucks this bad, why not select power tackling instead?
 
lawdog
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
Why harsh?? It's true. You've got changes being made that haven't been fully tested.

OK, so it's pre-season. But with so many changes seemingly having been made, how are owners or coaches supposed to know just what the hell works and what doesn't in the vastly complicated AIs??

So are we going to have it all ironed out before the season starts??? Or are we going to have another season where, at some random point, players will miss more tackles in one game than they did all year?? Players will break more tackles in one game than they've done in their entire career?? QBs will throw more INTs in one game than the rest of the league has thrown between them all season??

The nature of ANY sort of test is that it's done in isolation, so that problems can be ironed out. When you make multiple changes at the same time, and then give players multiple options with so many vaiables, there's no way that you can know for certain what changes are having what effect. That's NOT just this game, that's the basis for ANY scientific approach to testing!

We're in season 4 and money is being spent is large amounts. All I'm simply saying is that we should be at a point now where the game is being fine tuned, not having wholesale changes made to it that completely screw up the results and make it into a bit of a joke...........


IT IS A FREAKING BETA VERSION. THE LAST 3 SEASONS HAVE BEEN A TEST!!! YOU ARE TESTING THE PRODUCT AS WE SPEAK!!!
Last edited Jul 29, 2008 13:23:58
 
lancequagmire
offline
Link
 
Tackle rating 51. missed 5 of 8 tackles (all rushes).

The rest of the team had better success tackling, many of which had low tackle ratings.

Maybe a random anomaly.
 
Virtue76
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 1VBChaos



IT IS A FREAKING BETA VERSION. THE LAST 3 SEASONS HAVE BEEN A TEST!!! YOU ARE TESTING THE PRODUCT AS WE SPEAK!!!


That is starting to get a bit tiring now. This was obviously not tested enough before being implemented.
Last edited Jul 29, 2008 13:29:30
 
lawdog
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Cruzi


http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=80255&pbp_id=10637

My NT may protest this play.


Pancake.


Looks like clipping to me.
 
Lazer Noble
offline
Link
 
What about the sub in/out?

we never touched it from last year...we had very balanced rotations and our CBs had 78 and 71 plays while b/u's under 30?

was this a glitch also or do we need to rethink our sub setting?
 
TreMetal
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Lazer Noble
What about the sub in/out?

we never touched it from last year...we had very balanced rotations and our CBs had 78 and 71 plays while b/u's under 30?

was this a glitch also or do we need to rethink our sub setting?


You setup your CB1, CB2, etc. incorrectly. Not a bug.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Virtue76
Reading through all of these posts, obviously the AI hasn't been tested thoroughly. I thought that was what the post season was for, testing.

If this continues into the next round of games I think AI should be disabled, like last season and re-introduced for season 5.


No way should the AI be disabled. No more 4th and inches punts, forced FB runs, forced goal line offense (which was leading to a million 21 yard FG's), etc..

There are other bugs that seem to be legitimate bugs (such as with WR's), but I'd bet most of the AI bugs are things like people not setting downs properly for all their inputs.

The only plays that should be on top of the punt and FG inputs should be plays that are specifically set to go for it on 4th down, and any quarter-specific settings not meant for 4th down, make sure you didn't leave the downs blank, and set them for only the downs you wanted.

And on the missed tackles, I don't know if they were tuned too high; but some teams should be giving up a LOT of them because people didn't put points into tackling as it wasn't really necessary. It's like all the fumbles last season: People had ignored Carrying. Well, now people who pretty much ignored Tackling will find that they might have to boost 3 times and put all 15 points into it.

Tackling really ought to have to be the highest stat for a LB.
 
Lazer Noble
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TreMetal
Originally posted by Lazer Noble

What about the sub in/out?

we never touched it from last year...we had very balanced rotations and our CBs had 78 and 71 plays while b/u's under 30?

was this a glitch also or do we need to rethink our sub setting?


You setup your CB1, CB2, etc. incorrectly. Not a bug.


okay, may you fill me in or direct me to a thread that explains what happened please

thanks in advance...
 
TreMetal
offline
Link
 
You have one guy assigned to CB1, one guy assigned to CB2.

Any time there is only two CBs on the field both of them will play. You need to set other CBs to CB1 and CB2 if you want them to sub out. Or just leave CB1, CB2, CB3 blank and use the "CB" depth chart.
 
Lazer Noble
offline
Link
 
super ..thanks a lot TreMetal appreciate it
 
Arles
offline
Link
 
Just some additional data points, we had 18 missed tackles - most by the DTs and DBs. What's odd is our DEs (with worse tackling/str) had 10 tackles and 0 missed. Meanwhile, our DTs had 4 tackles with 8 missed. And, one of our DTs that missed tackles had a 71 str and 51! tackling. I wonder if there's something in the sim that sets a penalty for DTs making tackles. Just a thought.
 
Arles
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TreMetal
You have one guy assigned to CB1, one guy assigned to CB2.

Any time there is only two CBs on the field both of them will play. You need to set other CBs to CB1 and CB2 if you want them to sub out. Or just leave CB1, CB2, CB3 blank and use the "CB" depth chart.

Problem with this is I can't set a sub rate on CB right now. Try this:

1. Click Tactics and advanced energy tab
2. Set the "CB - Cornerback" to 70 min, 82 return.
3. Click Update on the bottom.
4. Click Tactics and advanced energy tab again and they will be blank.

If we can go back to the old "non CB1, CB2, .." way, we need to be able to set the energy levels for subbing.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.