Hmmmm...we are all aware 750 new teams are being added in roughly five days, correct? That's 18,000 new starting spots. If we have a knee-jerk reaction to the unexpected boom of GLB's popularity that has (temporarily) resulted in a shortage of spots and an excess of players, and make team-building backup dependent, there will be a lot of suffering next season.
Forum > Suggestions > What sense is it that the best teams only have 1 person on the depth chart.
CONN CHRIS
offline
offline
Originally posted by Asheme
Hmmmm...we are all aware 750 new teams are being added in roughly five days, correct? That's 18,000 new starting spots. If we have a knee-jerk reaction to the unexpected boom of GLB's popularity that has (temporarily) resulted in a shortage of spots and an excess of players, and make team-building backup dependent, there will be a lot of suffering next season.
There are currently over 84,000 created players though not all active. I can't imagine that there will be any trouble finding bodies eager to fill out depth charts. Maybe the number of inactive players is far higher than I would imagine but if that is because they became dissinterested and left, well that's the point of griping about these one-deep teams.
Hmmmm...we are all aware 750 new teams are being added in roughly five days, correct? That's 18,000 new starting spots. If we have a knee-jerk reaction to the unexpected boom of GLB's popularity that has (temporarily) resulted in a shortage of spots and an excess of players, and make team-building backup dependent, there will be a lot of suffering next season.
There are currently over 84,000 created players though not all active. I can't imagine that there will be any trouble finding bodies eager to fill out depth charts. Maybe the number of inactive players is far higher than I would imagine but if that is because they became dissinterested and left, well that's the point of griping about these one-deep teams.
Asheme
offline
offline
Originally posted by CONN CHRIS
There are currently over 84,000 created players though not all active. I can't imagine that there will be any trouble finding bodies eager to fill out depth charts. Maybe the number of inactive players is far higher than I would imagine but if that is because they became dissinterested and left, well that's the point of griping about these one-deep teams.
True, 41k of which are Free Agents. 24k of those are level 1 FAs. One has to figure a large portion of those numbers are inactive. We'll have a better idea once Bort clears out the true inactives, but I think people are overlooking the impact 750 new teams will have, thus making a total reassembly of game design premature at this point. It's good to discuss things as they are, but we must remember the landscape will change drastically.
There are currently over 84,000 created players though not all active. I can't imagine that there will be any trouble finding bodies eager to fill out depth charts. Maybe the number of inactive players is far higher than I would imagine but if that is because they became dissinterested and left, well that's the point of griping about these one-deep teams.
True, 41k of which are Free Agents. 24k of those are level 1 FAs. One has to figure a large portion of those numbers are inactive. We'll have a better idea once Bort clears out the true inactives, but I think people are overlooking the impact 750 new teams will have, thus making a total reassembly of game design premature at this point. It's good to discuss things as they are, but we must remember the landscape will change drastically.
I think Jed has made a lot of good points. It is funny that you list his team because I think the team I am on the Gators are just about the only USA Pro playoff team with anything resembling a realistic roster. But the simple fact is they played the game the way it was made. Pump up the stamina, take some lumps early, then level up like crazy. Probably the only thing stopping others from doing it was that they didn't think about it until too late. Roster minimums have been a part of every football game in recent memory and it is hard to imagine why they were not part of this game. Would they have made a difference late? No. But early on when your stamina was in the 20s even if you took all the CPUs off the depth chart they still would have taken playing time from your starters and slowed their levelling speed. Slower levelling means less stamina or worse players. It is a cycle. If minimum roster sizes were in effect from day 1 all the USA Pro guys would probably be 1 or 2 levels lower.
The problem is ultimately the XP issue. Of course 90 plays is WAY too many. All you have to do is check out some NFL Box scores and you will see the average # of plays in an entire game is 55-65 TOTAL. I could probably count on 1 hand the number of games in the last 20 years that even went to 90 plays on offense or defense. Maybe in double OT or something like that. So clearly that is the problem. I think they have the ratios by position right. For example QBs can play every play while D-linemen get tired.
I also think that some of the things I suggested a while ago, 3rd down pass rush specialist D-linemen, goalline run stuffers, special teams demons, 3rd down HBs, nickle backs, dime backs, big blocking backup TEs like Kyle Brady, receiving backup TEs like Ben Utecht, etc etc etc. There are so many ways to add depth to the game in a strategic and meaningful way without injuring players to do it.
So it's 3rd down. You are going to want a back like Kevin Faulk with catch in the 30s. Basically as a developer you force players to specialize just like in real life. Sure a regular HB with catch in the low 20s can catch a screen pass, but he would not be able to run a route or catch a downfild pass with any consistency- maybe 1 in 10. So if its 3rd down and it makes a big difference having him on the field vs your starting HB, then owners will start signing 3rd down backs.
Again, it's 3rd down. Having a DE who only rushes the passer (high speed, agility, pass rush tree with very low stamina and very low strengths comparatively) gives you an advantage. These are not every down DEs. They would get shredded by a good running game, but on 3rd and in a definite passing situation, they could make a huge difference.
Rewarding specialization and basically cutting the XP effect in half has so many advantages:
1.) It allows for people who can't boost to carve out a niche for themselves where they can be useful.
2.) It makes it pointless from a game standpoint to play people more than 40 plays a game except at certain positions like QB
3.) It makes it strategically beneficial to have backups. Rather than force people to get depth just for its own sake, we make the game inherently reward depth in the same way that real football does. Then owners will get depth without us having to force them to do it because it will actually be in their best interest.
NFL football is the greatest and most complex game in the world. If you don't think so you just need to learn more about it. All the answers to these types of things lie in the game itself. Just make this game more like the real game in every imaginable aspect and it will only get better and better. Also thinking a little outside the box helps.
The problem is ultimately the XP issue. Of course 90 plays is WAY too many. All you have to do is check out some NFL Box scores and you will see the average # of plays in an entire game is 55-65 TOTAL. I could probably count on 1 hand the number of games in the last 20 years that even went to 90 plays on offense or defense. Maybe in double OT or something like that. So clearly that is the problem. I think they have the ratios by position right. For example QBs can play every play while D-linemen get tired.
I also think that some of the things I suggested a while ago, 3rd down pass rush specialist D-linemen, goalline run stuffers, special teams demons, 3rd down HBs, nickle backs, dime backs, big blocking backup TEs like Kyle Brady, receiving backup TEs like Ben Utecht, etc etc etc. There are so many ways to add depth to the game in a strategic and meaningful way without injuring players to do it.
So it's 3rd down. You are going to want a back like Kevin Faulk with catch in the 30s. Basically as a developer you force players to specialize just like in real life. Sure a regular HB with catch in the low 20s can catch a screen pass, but he would not be able to run a route or catch a downfild pass with any consistency- maybe 1 in 10. So if its 3rd down and it makes a big difference having him on the field vs your starting HB, then owners will start signing 3rd down backs.
Again, it's 3rd down. Having a DE who only rushes the passer (high speed, agility, pass rush tree with very low stamina and very low strengths comparatively) gives you an advantage. These are not every down DEs. They would get shredded by a good running game, but on 3rd and in a definite passing situation, they could make a huge difference.
Rewarding specialization and basically cutting the XP effect in half has so many advantages:
1.) It allows for people who can't boost to carve out a niche for themselves where they can be useful.
2.) It makes it pointless from a game standpoint to play people more than 40 plays a game except at certain positions like QB
3.) It makes it strategically beneficial to have backups. Rather than force people to get depth just for its own sake, we make the game inherently reward depth in the same way that real football does. Then owners will get depth without us having to force them to do it because it will actually be in their best interest.
NFL football is the greatest and most complex game in the world. If you don't think so you just need to learn more about it. All the answers to these types of things lie in the game itself. Just make this game more like the real game in every imaginable aspect and it will only get better and better. Also thinking a little outside the box helps.
Last edited Apr 16, 2008 21:09:28
lizrdgizrd
offline
offline
I'll go ahead throw my two cents in too.
1) Forcing depth by position is overbearing and unnecessary.
2) Making energy drain affect players significantly will organically cause increased backup recruiting.
3) Tying energy drain to number of plays is inelegant, but simple and easily grasped.
4) Energy drain would be better impacted based on player stamina, play intensity, and (to a lesser degree) confidence. My suggestion would be something like this:
100/stamina * intensity modifier + (100-confidence)/1000
I worked it with intensities of .1 for relaxed, .2 for normal, and .3 for hard. A player with 15 stamina and 10 confidence with normal intensity would be able to play 28 plays before he lost 40 energy. A player with 30 stamina and 15 confidence on normal intensity would be able to play 52 plays before loosing 40 energy. A player with 100 stamina and 100 confidence on normal intensity would be able to play 200 plays before loosing 40 energy.
I think the intensity modifier could be tweaked but overall it's fairly reasonable.
1) Forcing depth by position is overbearing and unnecessary.
2) Making energy drain affect players significantly will organically cause increased backup recruiting.
3) Tying energy drain to number of plays is inelegant, but simple and easily grasped.
4) Energy drain would be better impacted based on player stamina, play intensity, and (to a lesser degree) confidence. My suggestion would be something like this:
100/stamina * intensity modifier + (100-confidence)/1000
I worked it with intensities of .1 for relaxed, .2 for normal, and .3 for hard. A player with 15 stamina and 10 confidence with normal intensity would be able to play 28 plays before he lost 40 energy. A player with 30 stamina and 15 confidence on normal intensity would be able to play 52 plays before loosing 40 energy. A player with 100 stamina and 100 confidence on normal intensity would be able to play 200 plays before loosing 40 energy.
I think the intensity modifier could be tweaked but overall it's fairly reasonable.
Rage Kinard
offline
offline
Originally posted by Asheme
Originally posted by CONN CHRIS
There are currently over 84,000 created players though not all active. I can't imagine that there will be any trouble finding bodies eager to fill out depth charts. Maybe the number of inactive players is far higher than I would imagine but if that is because they became dissinterested and left, well that's the point of griping about these one-deep teams.
True, 41k of which are Free Agents. 24k of those are level 1 FAs. One has to figure a large portion of those numbers are inactive. We'll have a better idea once Bort clears out the true inactives, but I think people are overlooking the impact 750 new teams will have, thus making a total reassembly of game design premature at this point. It's good to discuss things as they are, but we must remember the landscape will change drastically.
Lets say 20K of those free agents are true inactives. That leaves 21,000 who still want to be on a team. 750 X 28 = 21,000. So even if almost 1/2 of the free agents are inactives, then every team could get starters and a few backups with the players that already exist in free agency. Plus this doesn't account for all the new players that will be created by the new team owners. If they create only 2 each, you are up to the 30 free agents per team. What about new people joining the game? What about current non team owners that are going to be creating more players.
Originally posted by CONN CHRIS
There are currently over 84,000 created players though not all active. I can't imagine that there will be any trouble finding bodies eager to fill out depth charts. Maybe the number of inactive players is far higher than I would imagine but if that is because they became dissinterested and left, well that's the point of griping about these one-deep teams.
True, 41k of which are Free Agents. 24k of those are level 1 FAs. One has to figure a large portion of those numbers are inactive. We'll have a better idea once Bort clears out the true inactives, but I think people are overlooking the impact 750 new teams will have, thus making a total reassembly of game design premature at this point. It's good to discuss things as they are, but we must remember the landscape will change drastically.
Lets say 20K of those free agents are true inactives. That leaves 21,000 who still want to be on a team. 750 X 28 = 21,000. So even if almost 1/2 of the free agents are inactives, then every team could get starters and a few backups with the players that already exist in free agency. Plus this doesn't account for all the new players that will be created by the new team owners. If they create only 2 each, you are up to the 30 free agents per team. What about new people joining the game? What about current non team owners that are going to be creating more players.
CONN CHRIS
offline
offline
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Lets say 20K of those free agents are true inactives. That leaves 21,000 who still want to be on a team. 750 X 28 = 21,000. So even if almost 1/2 of the free agents are inactives, then every team could get starters and a few backups with the players that already exist in free agency. Plus this doesn't account for all the new players that will be created by the new team owners. If they create only 2 each, you are up to the 30 free agents per team. What about new people joining the game? What about current non team owners that are going to be creating more players.
The need to find a way to discourage the one-deep teams from continuing the scheme is quite large.
Lets say 20K of those free agents are true inactives. That leaves 21,000 who still want to be on a team. 750 X 28 = 21,000. So even if almost 1/2 of the free agents are inactives, then every team could get starters and a few backups with the players that already exist in free agency. Plus this doesn't account for all the new players that will be created by the new team owners. If they create only 2 each, you are up to the 30 free agents per team. What about new people joining the game? What about current non team owners that are going to be creating more players.
The need to find a way to discourage the one-deep teams from continuing the scheme is quite large.
holloway4263
offline
offline
I have been upset about this for awhile. I think it is funny how I have read on these forums if you find a BUG and don't report it you risk losing your team. I think by all means this is a BUG issue. It has been stated on this tread time and again that it is not cheating. I agree all Owners could do it. I own a US PRO team and I seen what was going on. I didn't do it.
The only true way to fix the problem is with Injuries. You can't have a one man D.C. if you have the fear of injuries.
I understand a QB can play the whole game in the NFL as can the Oline. But I have not seen a RB avg. 37 carries in a game over the course of the season. It just doesn't happen.
The people fighting this idea are the ones using it. I am sorry Jed the don't hate the player hate the game statement is wrong. If you seen there was a way for you to gain an advantage over the rest of the field you should have reported it as a BUG. The game is Beta that is why we are playing the game. Not to gain a headstart. Fix the issue and make the game better.
I am sure there are going to be people out there riping me or asking how this is a bug. I will tell you right now that if a player can play 90 plus plays a game running the ball and there is no effect on his energy. He doesn't slow down. What do you call it?
I think I want what we all want THE BEST GAME.
The only true way to fix the problem is with Injuries. You can't have a one man D.C. if you have the fear of injuries.
I understand a QB can play the whole game in the NFL as can the Oline. But I have not seen a RB avg. 37 carries in a game over the course of the season. It just doesn't happen.
The people fighting this idea are the ones using it. I am sorry Jed the don't hate the player hate the game statement is wrong. If you seen there was a way for you to gain an advantage over the rest of the field you should have reported it as a BUG. The game is Beta that is why we are playing the game. Not to gain a headstart. Fix the issue and make the game better.
I am sure there are going to be people out there riping me or asking how this is a bug. I will tell you right now that if a player can play 90 plus plays a game running the ball and there is no effect on his energy. He doesn't slow down. What do you call it?
I think I want what we all want THE BEST GAME.
Malachorn
offline
offline
Originally posted by holloway4263
I agree all Owners could do it. I own a US PRO team and I seen what was going on. I didn't do it.
Record: 5-11-0 (13th place)
You, sir, are a terrible owner.
I agree all Owners could do it. I own a US PRO team and I seen what was going on. I didn't do it.
Record: 5-11-0 (13th place)
You, sir, are a terrible owner.
CONN CHRIS
offline
offline
Originally posted by tpaterniti
Rather than force people to get depth just for its own sake, we make the game inherently reward depth in the same way that real football does. Then owners will get depth without us having to force them to do it because it will actually be in their best interest.
I completely agree. The forced depth chart idea (which I have mentioned) is rather ham-handed.
I also agree that this falls under the title of a bug; rewarding players that are artificialy pumped by playing both ways or playing a number of snaps that would leave them on an IV drip in real life should not be part of a sim that attempts to mimmic real life.
The team that most of my players are on is very deep. However, we are up against a one-deep wonder for the first time in our next playoff game. Since the sim currently rewards that, we have decided to bench many of our lower players for this one game. A strategy that cleary is counter to real life. It is a bug when teams can choose to field an un-realistic lineup and are actually rewarded for doing so.
Rather than force people to get depth just for its own sake, we make the game inherently reward depth in the same way that real football does. Then owners will get depth without us having to force them to do it because it will actually be in their best interest.
I completely agree. The forced depth chart idea (which I have mentioned) is rather ham-handed.
I also agree that this falls under the title of a bug; rewarding players that are artificialy pumped by playing both ways or playing a number of snaps that would leave them on an IV drip in real life should not be part of a sim that attempts to mimmic real life.
The team that most of my players are on is very deep. However, we are up against a one-deep wonder for the first time in our next playoff game. Since the sim currently rewards that, we have decided to bench many of our lower players for this one game. A strategy that cleary is counter to real life. It is a bug when teams can choose to field an un-realistic lineup and are actually rewarded for doing so.
Malachorn
offline
offline
Originally posted by CONN CHRIS
...we are up against a one-deep wonder for the first time in our next playoff game. Since the sim currently rewards that, we have decided to bench many of our lower players for this one game.
It's the playoffs. You shouldn't play bad players. That's how it works in the real NFL, too. Of course, the sim actually does reward depth. It just doesn't reward it as much as really high levels.
So, if this guy's levels and builds are so much better than your guys' level and builds then it will more than compensate for the energy issues that his team will have for lack of depth.
...we are up against a one-deep wonder for the first time in our next playoff game. Since the sim currently rewards that, we have decided to bench many of our lower players for this one game.
It's the playoffs. You shouldn't play bad players. That's how it works in the real NFL, too. Of course, the sim actually does reward depth. It just doesn't reward it as much as really high levels.
So, if this guy's levels and builds are so much better than your guys' level and builds then it will more than compensate for the energy issues that his team will have for lack of depth.
CONN CHRIS
offline
offline
There are no apparent energy issues durring a game that arise from having no depth.
You are somehwat missing the whole point of this discussion.
You are somehwat missing the whole point of this discussion.
Joe Gibbs II
offline
offline
Originally posted by ohmybriguy
For a game that is trying to attract people and new players, why is it that it that the teams are better off to not have good depth and rotations during a game. I cam to the conclusion that i had to cut almost 60% of my team, cause all the best teams only have 1 or 2 players at most for positions. It penalizes teams who sign young and new players or players who cannot find teams. Am i wrong in my thinking?
Just cant figure out why it would be better to only have 2 DE's play during a game when in the NFL they are always rotating players to get fresh legs.
For the sake of the game they should force team to put in a minimum number of players per positions ... that's what happens in other games e.g. fantasy basketball, soccer ...
For a game that is trying to attract people and new players, why is it that it that the teams are better off to not have good depth and rotations during a game. I cam to the conclusion that i had to cut almost 60% of my team, cause all the best teams only have 1 or 2 players at most for positions. It penalizes teams who sign young and new players or players who cannot find teams. Am i wrong in my thinking?
Just cant figure out why it would be better to only have 2 DE's play during a game when in the NFL they are always rotating players to get fresh legs.
For the sake of the game they should force team to put in a minimum number of players per positions ... that's what happens in other games e.g. fantasy basketball, soccer ...
HOODjelly
offline
offline
Originally posted by Joe Gibbs II
Originally posted by ohmybriguy
For a game that is trying to attract people and new players, why is it that it that the teams are better off to not have good depth and rotations during a game. I cam to the conclusion that i had to cut almost 60% of my team, cause all the best teams only have 1 or 2 players at most for positions. It penalizes teams who sign young and new players or players who cannot find teams. Am i wrong in my thinking?
Just cant figure out why it would be better to only have 2 DE's play during a game when in the NFL they are always rotating players to get fresh legs.
For the sake of the game they should force team to put in a minimum number of players per positions ... that's what happens in other games e.g. fantasy basketball, soccer ...
Minimum rosters are already in the works
Originally posted by ohmybriguy
For a game that is trying to attract people and new players, why is it that it that the teams are better off to not have good depth and rotations during a game. I cam to the conclusion that i had to cut almost 60% of my team, cause all the best teams only have 1 or 2 players at most for positions. It penalizes teams who sign young and new players or players who cannot find teams. Am i wrong in my thinking?
Just cant figure out why it would be better to only have 2 DE's play during a game when in the NFL they are always rotating players to get fresh legs.
For the sake of the game they should force team to put in a minimum number of players per positions ... that's what happens in other games e.g. fantasy basketball, soccer ...
Minimum rosters are already in the works
Coach Greedy
offline
offline
Originally posted by holloway4263
I have been upset about this for awhile. I think it is funny how I have read on these forums if you find a BUG and don't report it you risk losing your team. I think by all means this is a BUG issue. It has been stated on this tread time and again that it is not cheating. I agree all Owners could do it. I own a US PRO team and I seen what was going on. I didn't do it.
The only true way to fix the problem is with Injuries. You can't have a one man D.C. if you have the fear of injuries.
I understand a QB can play the whole game in the NFL as can the Oline. But I have not seen a RB avg. 37 carries in a game over the course of the season. It just doesn't happen.
The people fighting this idea are the ones using it. I am sorry Jed the don't hate the player hate the game statement is wrong. If you seen there was a way for you to gain an advantage over the rest of the field you should have reported it as a BUG. The game is Beta that is why we are playing the game. Not to gain a headstart. Fix the issue and make the game better.
I am sure there are going to be people out there riping me or asking how this is a bug. I will tell you right now that if a player can play 90 plus plays a game running the ball and there is no effect on his energy. He doesn't slow down. What do you call it?
I think I want what we all want THE BEST GAME.
I have to totally agree with this post, if nothing is done about this I honestly believe the maturer gamers looking for an as realistic a simulation as possible will walk away. I have already thought about leaving but enjoyed the first season in a relatively fair division so much I thought I would give the developers time to put this ridiculous loophole right.
I have been upset about this for awhile. I think it is funny how I have read on these forums if you find a BUG and don't report it you risk losing your team. I think by all means this is a BUG issue. It has been stated on this tread time and again that it is not cheating. I agree all Owners could do it. I own a US PRO team and I seen what was going on. I didn't do it.
The only true way to fix the problem is with Injuries. You can't have a one man D.C. if you have the fear of injuries.
I understand a QB can play the whole game in the NFL as can the Oline. But I have not seen a RB avg. 37 carries in a game over the course of the season. It just doesn't happen.
The people fighting this idea are the ones using it. I am sorry Jed the don't hate the player hate the game statement is wrong. If you seen there was a way for you to gain an advantage over the rest of the field you should have reported it as a BUG. The game is Beta that is why we are playing the game. Not to gain a headstart. Fix the issue and make the game better.
I am sure there are going to be people out there riping me or asking how this is a bug. I will tell you right now that if a player can play 90 plus plays a game running the ball and there is no effect on his energy. He doesn't slow down. What do you call it?
I think I want what we all want THE BEST GAME.
I have to totally agree with this post, if nothing is done about this I honestly believe the maturer gamers looking for an as realistic a simulation as possible will walk away. I have already thought about leaving but enjoyed the first season in a relatively fair division so much I thought I would give the developers time to put this ridiculous loophole right.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























