User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Ok, from what I can tell from the server logs, there were a few POSTs (updates) made to that page (team_energy_tactics.pl?team_id=216) today:

It was viewed a bunch of times too (GETS) though I'm not sure if any of them would have been updates. I'm pretty sure all the forms on that page are POSTs, but I might be mistaken.

(these are game time, MST)
11:45am
12:26pm
12:52.19pm
12:52.20pm
12:53pm
Last edited Jul 15, 2008 17:10:34
 
crzyblue
offline
Link
 
so by that log we can narrow it down to 1 of 4 people.....
Maximus Power, BobJoeJim, dkgojackets, Vanilla Thunder
giveyourcash hasn't logged in since yesterday.
I'm going to put my money on bobjoejim..... just cause of the name.
Last edited Jul 15, 2008 17:13:11
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Unfortunately, I don't have any way to look up who updated the tactics. I just looked at one of the web log files, and they aren't exactly helpful in this situation either, because the IP information in them isn't reliable due to the way I have the load balancer configured. All I can see is when updates were made, but that's not exacly helpful.

What I can do is look at adding tactics update logging in the future to help figure out what happened in future events. or at the very least whose account was used.


Ugh. Thanks for the effort, and a public thanks to Asheme for the help.

I suppose its soliloquy time, but I just don’t have it in me. I’m so disappointed by today’s events that there’s little a long-winded rant could do.

My team was cheated, either by the sim, an outside user, or by one of our own. It doesn’t seem to matter which one as there are no means available to test any of the three possible cases. This calls into question other issues in the game like “how are we catching multiple accounters if we have to IP tracking capability?”. More importantly, with all the delegation possible in this game, why is there no method for accountability?

It feels awful to have invested both time and money into a game only to find out that, in all likelihood, you are not even guaranteed a fair attempt at the game. Worse yet, should an error occur (either human or CPU) there are not only no measures in place to reverse the damage, or even assess what caused the damage in the first place.

For those that don’t trust me, there’s little I can do to sway your minds, but for those that know and trust me, I’ll ask for your trust on this matter. I DID NOT change the ENG settings to levels that would intentionally cripple our team, nor did any of my GMs. Take that for whatever it is worth to you.

I’ve been here for 3 seasons now, and there are many of you, Admins, Mods, and Users that know my name and have been affected in some way by my time here, as I’ve been affected by you. I can say that today, with consideration for all days past in GLB, I have never been more disappointed in the game then I am right now. I don’t want flex, I don’t even want a re-sim anymore (even though I feel like my players deserve it), all I want is some accountability, and it appears that it’s impossible for me to even expect that.

To anyone affected by this, I’m sorry. GLB at large shouldn’t have had to deal with the delays because of this, and there are plenty of people that shouldn’t have been drug in.

Good luck everyone, I hope you fare better then we did, and I hope you continue having fun with the game.

What do you know, I did have it in me.
 
Commander
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by crzyblue
so by that log we can narrow it down to 1 of 4 people.....
Maximus Power, BobJoeJim, dkgojackets, Vanilla Thunder
giveyourcash hasn't logged in since yesterday.
I'm going to put my money on bobjoejim..... just cause of the name.


fwiw we're 99.99% sure none of those guys did it intentionally.
 
dkgojackets
offline
Link
 
alright at 12:46 VT posted in our forum that he went to check the settings and saw it had all been changed. I guess that was the 12:26?

Why would it have been updated twice in two seconds?

Also, was it changed at all after the game? Thats when VT noticed they were all switched back.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by SL__72
Originally posted by Bort

All I can see is when updates were made, but that's not exacly helpful.


I think this could be useful. It would at least point to something being fishy if they were updated right before the game simmed and then changed again right afterwords. As a member of the Trout I'd at least like any that is available...


Our game was simmed late today, at around 2:30 EST, if that matters. I check everything prior to that and it was in working order.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by dkgojackets
alright at 12:46 VT posted in our forum that he went to check the settings and saw it had all been changed. I guess that was the 12:26?

Why would it have been updated twice in two seconds?

Also, was it changed at all after the game? Thats when VT noticed they were all switched back.


Yes the settings had returned to normal after the game, I checked at 2:58 EST.
 
crzyblue
offline
Link
 
dkgojackets... because 2 people editing at the sametime
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by SL__72
Originally posted by Bort
All I can see is when updates were made, but that's not exacly helpful.

I think this could be useful. It would at least point to something being fishy if they were updated right before the game simmed and then changed again right afterwords. As a member of the Trout I'd at least like any that is available...

Our game was simmed late today, at around 2:30 EST, if that matters. I check everything prior to that and it was in working order.


If the game was supposed to be simmed at 2 EST and went through ~2:30, then that's 12 + ~12:30 MST (obviously), meaning that only the first or second time slots were actually options as far as "whodunit". The other times would have been after the sim.
 
dkgojackets
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by crzyblue
dkgojackets... because 2 people editing at the sametime


and they updated one second from each other?
 
Maximus Power
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by crzyblue
so by that log we can narrow it down to 1 of 4 people.....
Maximus Power, BobJoeJim, dkgojackets, Vanilla Thunder
giveyourcash hasn't logged in since yesterday.


I'm not sure if there's any way you can track when a person logs in. I logged in last night (well really this morning) from about 4 AM to 4:40 AM ET. I didn't log in again until about 3:40 PM ET.

If any of those POSTs were from my account, then my account got hacked. I guess you'd have to take my word for that, but hopefully Bort would be able to tell someone logged into my account from a different IP.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Ok, from what I can tell from the server logs, there were a few POSTs (updates) made to that page (team_energy_tactics.pl?team_id=216) today:

It was viewed a bunch of times too (GETS) though I'm not sure if any of them would have been updates. I'm pretty sure all the forms on that page are POSTs, but I might be mistaken.

(these are game time, MST)
11:45am
12:26pm
12:52.19pm
12:52.20pm
12:53pm


Wait, is this saying that there were no changes post game? Because if there weren't our seettings now could NOT have produced those that existed during the game.
 
crzyblue
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Ok, from what I can tell from the server logs, there were a few POSTs (updates) made to that page (team_energy_tactics.pl?team_id=216) today:

It was viewed a bunch of times too (GETS) though I'm not sure if any of them would have been updates. I'm pretty sure all the forms on that page are POSTs, but I might be mistaken.

(these are game time, MST)
11:45am
12:26pm
12:52.19pm
12:52.20pm

12:53pm


the bolded part is probably where 2 people were editing at once. the second save over took the first now from the log which I've stated
Originally posted by crzyblue

so by that log we can narrow it down to 1 of 4 people.....
Maximus Power, BobJoeJim, dkgojackets, Vanilla Thunder
giveyourcash hasn't logged in since yesterday.
I'm going to put my money on bobjoejim..... just cause of the name.


It had to be 2 people editing.... which 2 I couldn't tell you myself but that would explain the bolded part up top.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by Bort

Unfortunately, I don't have any way to look up who updated the tactics. I just looked at one of the web log files, and they aren't exactly helpful in this situation either, because the IP information in them isn't reliable due to the way I have the load balancer configured. All I can see is when updates were made, but that's not exacly helpful.

What I can do is look at adding tactics update logging in the future to help figure out what happened in future events. or at the very least whose account was used.


Ugh. Thanks for the effort, and a public thanks to Asheme for the help.

I suppose its soliloquy time, but I just don’t have it in me. I’m so disappointed by today’s events that there’s little a long-winded rant could do.

My team was cheated, either by the sim, an outside user, or by one of our own. It doesn’t seem to matter which one as there are no means available to test any of the three possible cases. This calls into question other issues in the game like “how are we catching multiple accounters if we have to IP tracking capability?”. More importantly, with all the delegation possible in this game, why is there no method for accountability?

It feels awful to have invested both time and money into a game only to find out that, in all likelihood, you are not even guaranteed a fair attempt at the game. Worse yet, should an error occur (either human or CPU) there are not only no measures in place to reverse the damage, or even assess what caused the damage in the first place.

For those that don’t trust me, there’s little I can do to sway your minds, but for those that know and trust me, I’ll ask for your trust on this matter. I DID NOT change the ENG settings to levels that would intentionally cripple our team, nor did any of my GMs. Take that for whatever it is worth to you.

I’ve been here for 3 seasons now, and there are many of you, Admins, Mods, and Users that know my name and have been affected in some way by my time here, as I’ve been affected by you. I can say that today, with consideration for all days past in GLB, I have never been more disappointed in the game then I am right now. I don’t want flex, I don’t even want a re-sim anymore (even though I feel like my players deserve it), all I want is some accountability, and it appears that it’s impossible for me to even expect that.

To anyone affected by this, I’m sorry. GLB at large shouldn’t have had to deal with the delays because of this, and there are plenty of people that shouldn’t have been drug in.

Good luck everyone, I hope you fare better then we did, and I hope you continue having fun with the game.

What do you know, I did have it in me.


Hindsight is 20/20 - I didn't have the logs set up in a way that would let me track IP->page load data, though I thought that I did actually. I'll update the configs to help out in future cases, but I can't pull data out of thin air once the opportunity past. Sorry.
 
Commander
offline
Link
 
so we have the times.

is there any way bort can find out when people have logged in, and from what IP? this info would be so clutch.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.