User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > ATTN: Tying Flex Points to Contracts as an Incentive or Condition
Page:
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme
Originally posted by oldskool

I don't disdain the rule, I disdain how many loopholes I've already been able to pull out of it.


I hope you feel accomplished in that; making my fellow mods sprout gray hairs prematurely

I understand what you're after, and I appreciate the diligence, but you're getting rather caught up in the "letter of the law" rather than the "spirit of the law", so to speak.

Every case will be examined and decided upon, and after a few such cases pass before the admins, etc., precedent will be set up and we'll have a clearer idea on how to move forward. Currently, as it stands, the rule is basically this: do not use Flex Points as incentive to sign or re-sign a player, nuances to follow.


That's been the point all along. Suspensions and bannings are with "No warnings, no debates, no questions", but there are already conceded nuances in the rule that have not been examined, let alone defined. I can't be the first one to bring up these situations when the moderators & admins discussed it.

The smart thing to do would've been to completely outlaw any form of FP or cash transaction. Same outcome, no "Well sometimes it's ok if it's not related to this as determined by us when we go through whatever facts we can find" ambiguity.

And I've already put in the support request for a full inquisition into my account, but if a moderator would like to push it to the front of the line I'd appreciate it
 
Asheme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
The smart thing to do would've been to completely outlaw any form of FP or cash transaction.


I have a feeling that's where we'll end up (not sure why we aren't there already, as FP transactions definitely are not carried out, at least to my knowledge since they require admin approval, though we can do nothing, clearly, about PayPal or other cash transfers).

And, sorry, I won't green light your inquisition, the admins have enough to do as is
 
Taha19
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by LJ
Originally posted by Taha19

Originally posted by Jed


Originally posted by TuNice



Its BS really. No matter what way you want to look at it, the people with money are always going to be ahead of those without it. So now you not only disallow players without money to succeed in the future but you dont allow a regulated way to transfer flex points between friends now you dont even allow it AT ALL. The argument is it will ruin the player market but in reality, if the owner really wanted too, he could use the FPs to make his own damn player and boost him. Which would be advantageous to him. Instead both people win. What players choose to do with THEIR OWN MONEY should be their own business. This rule is more un-ethical than that of the suspected owners.


"...as a condition of signing a contract with a team..."

Did you miss that part? You seem to be arguing that this hurts your ability to transfer FP between friends. This rule is aimed at people basically offering/asking for FP to play for a team.


but why is this illegal???? if an owner want to give a player FP to play for him it should be his and the players business only........ and allowed... I see nothing wrong with it even though I have never taken part is such thing...... I mean its the owers money... I think he should be allowed to recruit playes the way he sees fit!!! after all he bought a team so he can win games!!


read the thread....

"To balance the recruiting incentives."

so 1 teams wont have advantage over another cause they offer FP.


if you want it that fair then eliminate boosting.. because it gives ann "unfair" advantage to the team with people who have money" but I do see your point.... it sucks never the less!!!
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Taha19
Originally posted by LJ

Originally posted by Taha19


Originally posted by Jed



Originally posted by TuNice




Its BS really. No matter what way you want to look at it, the people with money are always going to be ahead of those without it. So now you not only disallow players without money to succeed in the future but you dont allow a regulated way to transfer flex points between friends now you dont even allow it AT ALL. The argument is it will ruin the player market but in reality, if the owner really wanted too, he could use the FPs to make his own damn player and boost him. Which would be advantageous to him. Instead both people win. What players choose to do with THEIR OWN MONEY should be their own business. This rule is more un-ethical than that of the suspected owners.


"...as a condition of signing a contract with a team..."

Did you miss that part? You seem to be arguing that this hurts your ability to transfer FP between friends. This rule is aimed at people basically offering/asking for FP to play for a team.


but why is this illegal???? if an owner want to give a player FP to play for him it should be his and the players business only........ and allowed... I see nothing wrong with it even though I have never taken part is such thing...... I mean its the owers money... I think he should be allowed to recruit playes the way he sees fit!!! after all he bought a team so he can win games!!


read the thread....

"To balance the recruiting incentives."

so 1 teams wont have advantage over another cause they offer FP.


if you want it that fair then eliminate boosting.. because it gives ann "unfair" advantage to the team with people who have money" but I do see your point.... it sucks never the less!!!


Taha because this game is not about the richest person wins...it's supposed to let people with all types of money situations play but how can a guy who can't afford to give out Flex Points get FAs when everyone else if offering 1000-2000 FPs to sign...it isn't rocket science...YOU CAN TRANSFER FPS TO A FRIEND IF YOU ARE NOT BRIBING HIM TO SIGN WITH YOU. AN OWNER CAN GIVE A PLAYER FPS ON HIS TEAM IF IT IS NOT A BRIBE TO RESIGN. Try reading the thread before posting...they are trying to stop owners who bribe Free Agents to sign.
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by LJ
The only reason to dislike this rule is if you offered or recieved a offer including FP in the past and wanna do it again.



Wow. That is just horrible. So if anyone is of the opinion that they don't like this rule you think the only reason is because they have done this?
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by norsemanvike
Originally posted by oldskool

Ahahah. Great, real classy. "If you don't like this rule you must be a cheater!". I'm impressed, really, moderators have the power to directly talk to admins but why bother when you can throw out an accusation?

You know what, go for it. Apparently the moderators and admins are looking for something to help pass the time this offseason, so I encourage you to investigate me as much as you like.

It's your own fault, and I'm sure you realize this.

You say you'll ban people for offering FP as a contract negotiation bait, and then say you'll allow FP to be given out if it's not related to the contract. I point out that it's nigh-impossible to differentiate between the two without a direct PM or forum post, and therefore it's pretty unfair to say that "it's legal to give someone FP but you MIGHT be banned for it", especially when by your own admissions you don't have the slightest fucking clue what the criteria to determine contract vs. no contract is.

Instead of actually addressing the concern, you stumble around like blind rats contradicting each other as well as what you've already decreed, and then when you're out of weapons you pull the "You must be cheating" card.


First, you've made the assumption that I was accusing you, which is not the case, but only suggesting that your comments and your clear disdain for this rule raises suspicion. I'd be careful from this point forward in contesting the ruling so ardently, you're on the brink of a suspension with your antagonistic stance with the mods.


Sweet. Nazi GLB.
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wombat killer
Originally posted by LJ

The only reason to dislike this rule is if you offered or recieved a offer including FP in the past and wanna do it again.



Wow. That is just horrible. So if anyone is of the opinion that they don't like this rule you think the only reason is because they have done this?


Please name the realistic reason why you would be against stopping this unless you're a part of it.
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
Originally posted by wombat killer

Originally posted by LJ


The only reason to dislike this rule is if you offered or recieved a offer including FP in the past and wanna do it again.



Wow. That is just horrible. So if anyone is of the opinion that they don't like this rule you think the only reason is because they have done this?


Please name the realistic reason why you would be against stopping this unless you're a part of it.


I see nothing wrong with it. There are all kinds of reasons people get an advantage in recruiting. In fact, the type of player that would pick a team based on getting flexpoints is probably one I wouldn't want on my team.
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by LJ
The only reason to dislike this rule is if you offered or recieved a offer including FP in the past and wanna do it again.



The only reason to dislike warrantless searches is if you have something to hide. Yeah, good argument......

not.
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
Originally posted by wombat killer

Originally posted by LJ


The only reason to dislike this rule is if you offered or recieved a offer including FP in the past and wanna do it again.



Wow. That is just horrible. So if anyone is of the opinion that they don't like this rule you think the only reason is because they have done this?


Please name the realistic reason why you would be against stopping this unless you're a part of it.


One does not need to have a personal interest in a rule to be for or against it. One could simply see the inherent flaws in the way that the rule is written and the way that it is proposed to be enforced.
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
My real problem with this rule and every other rule that has been discussed/approved recently is the fact that they are all spread out all over the place. A new user would have to spend hours digging through various forums to find these rules. That is just plain ridiculous.

There should be ONE SINGLE PLACE to go for ALL the rules. ONE. The more threads that have rules and interpretations of rules by admins and mods buried in them, the more confusion about the rules there will be.

The rules need to be consolidated. Now. Especially since you are now threatening suspensions and bannings for people who have spent actual money on this game, there needs to be a single, comprehensive reference guide to avoid any confusion on these matters.
 
Norsemanvike
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by awesome
My real problem with this rule and every other rule that has been discussed/approved recently is the fact that they are all spread out all over the place. A new user would have to spend hours digging through various forums to find these rules. That is just plain ridiculous.

There should be ONE SINGLE PLACE to go for ALL the rules. ONE. The more threads that have rules and interpretations of rules by admins and mods buried in them, the more confusion about the rules there will be.

The rules need to be consolidated. Now. Especially since you are now threatening suspensions and bannings for people who have spent actual money on this game, there needs to be a single, comprehensive reference guide to avoid any confusion on these matters.


A wiki is in the works that should help with this issue.
 
morgan3
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme
Originally posted by oldskool

The smart thing to do would've been to completely outlaw any form of FP or cash transaction.


I have a feeling that's where we'll end up (not sure why we aren't there already, as FP transactions definitely are not carried out, at least to my knowledge since they require admin approval, though we can do nothing, clearly, about PayPal or other cash transfers).


Whats the time frame for buying a player on your team FP then? Because this can easily be exploited by saying well he was on my team for 10 days so I gave him FP. For this to be effective you'd have to outlaw allowing owners to buy any of their players FP.
 
Norsemanvike
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by morgan3
Originally posted by Asheme

Originally posted by oldskool


The smart thing to do would've been to completely outlaw any form of FP or cash transaction.


I have a feeling that's where we'll end up (not sure why we aren't there already, as FP transactions definitely are not carried out, at least to my knowledge since they require admin approval, though we can do nothing, clearly, about PayPal or other cash transfers).


Whats the time frame for buying a player on your team FP then? Because this can easily be exploited by saying well he was on my team for 10 days so I gave him FP. For this to be effective you'd have to outlaw allowing owners to buy any of their players FP.


That will be determined on a case by case basis since it allows owners/players to create their loophole to bypass or get around the spirit of the ruling.
 
morgan3
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by norsemanvike


That will be determined on a case by case basis since it allows owners/players to create their loophole to bypass or get around the spirit of the ruling.


So I can sign a FA and then mid season give him FP because I want him to stay on my team, but can just say its for having a good season so far?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.