That being said, I don't think I would be against it just becoming a CPU team for the rest of the season either. However, I think it would be better for the new owner to be able to try to do something with it in the mean time.
Forum > Suggestions > Moving Sold Teams to the Bottom Tier
Painmaker
offline
offline
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Occam's Razor is our best bet here, all things being equal, lets use the simplest workable solution.
This. The idea of moving teams around to provide some artificial sense of "fairness" causes more problems than it solves. Patience with promotion/relegation is the answer imo.
I also think things like starting a 2-week timer where roster moves can't be made prior to a change of ownership (so you'd have to extend ownership if you're in the last two weeks that have been paid for if you want to make a roster move, and any time GMs make a roster move then owner inactivity is reset for purposes of determining when to take away the team), and automatically resetting all contracts to day 40 of current season would better address many of the ownership transition concerns.
Occam's Razor is our best bet here, all things being equal, lets use the simplest workable solution.
This. The idea of moving teams around to provide some artificial sense of "fairness" causes more problems than it solves. Patience with promotion/relegation is the answer imo.
I also think things like starting a 2-week timer where roster moves can't be made prior to a change of ownership (so you'd have to extend ownership if you're in the last two weeks that have been paid for if you want to make a roster move, and any time GMs make a roster move then owner inactivity is reset for purposes of determining when to take away the team), and automatically resetting all contracts to day 40 of current season would better address many of the ownership transition concerns.
awesome
offline
offline
Originally posted by Painmaker
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Occam's Razor is our best bet here, all things being equal, lets use the simplest workable solution.
This. The idea of moving teams around to provide some artificial sense of "fairness" causes more problems than it solves. Patience with promotion/relegation is the answer imo.
I also think things like starting a 2-week timer where roster moves can't be made prior to a change of ownership (so you'd have to extend ownership if you're in the last two weeks that have been paid for if you want to make a roster move, and any time GMs make a roster move then owner inactivity is reset for purposes of determining when to take away the team), and automatically resetting all contracts to day 40 of current season would better address many of the ownership transition concerns.
And with that, GLB flex point revenues -> 0.
There are several problems with this idea.
1. The current promotion/relegation system is too slow. It would take 4 seasons (6 real months) before a gutted pro team gets relegated to the bottom tier where it belongs. By that time, you guessed it, no one will want it. Everyone that gets it will get pissed and try to get rid of it.
2. Extending an owner's grace period for inactivity is a terrible idea. The waiting list has what, 1000+ people on it? Some teams have at least 10 GMs. These teams would never get new owners under this idea.
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Occam's Razor is our best bet here, all things being equal, lets use the simplest workable solution.
This. The idea of moving teams around to provide some artificial sense of "fairness" causes more problems than it solves. Patience with promotion/relegation is the answer imo.
I also think things like starting a 2-week timer where roster moves can't be made prior to a change of ownership (so you'd have to extend ownership if you're in the last two weeks that have been paid for if you want to make a roster move, and any time GMs make a roster move then owner inactivity is reset for purposes of determining when to take away the team), and automatically resetting all contracts to day 40 of current season would better address many of the ownership transition concerns.
And with that, GLB flex point revenues -> 0.
There are several problems with this idea.
1. The current promotion/relegation system is too slow. It would take 4 seasons (6 real months) before a gutted pro team gets relegated to the bottom tier where it belongs. By that time, you guessed it, no one will want it. Everyone that gets it will get pissed and try to get rid of it.
2. Extending an owner's grace period for inactivity is a terrible idea. The waiting list has what, 1000+ people on it? Some teams have at least 10 GMs. These teams would never get new owners under this idea.
Painmaker
offline
offline
The lion's share of flex points comes from players, not teams. The money signified by the standing waiting list is only realized in any significant amount when they expand into new leagues, and eventually that waiting list will hover around some equilibrium value anyway. Slowing down the ownership transition process for the handful of teams that vacate midseason isn't particularly significant to the revenue stream (my opinion).
Screwing around with 15 other teams in a conference every time ownership changes hands for 1 team just multiplies the number of people being affected by at least 15 (when you consider that the outgoing team owner probably doesn't care so much, this ratio goes higher). Moving teams up from the conferences below (which will require a daisy chain all the way from the bottom tier leagues) adds to the number of teams getting jerked around. Customer satisfaction poses a much more significant impact to revenue than delaying ownership transition for existing teams. Of course that's just my view of the business model.
Screwing around with 15 other teams in a conference every time ownership changes hands for 1 team just multiplies the number of people being affected by at least 15 (when you consider that the outgoing team owner probably doesn't care so much, this ratio goes higher). Moving teams up from the conferences below (which will require a daisy chain all the way from the bottom tier leagues) adds to the number of teams getting jerked around. Customer satisfaction poses a much more significant impact to revenue than delaying ownership transition for existing teams. Of course that's just my view of the business model.
Last edited Jun 30, 2008 21:03:31
Vanilla Thunder
offline
offline
Originally posted by awesome
Originally posted by Painmaker
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Occam's Razor is our best bet here, all things being equal, lets use the simplest workable solution.
This. The idea of moving teams around to provide some artificial sense of "fairness" causes more problems than it solves. Patience with promotion/relegation is the answer imo.
I also think things like starting a 2-week timer where roster moves can't be made prior to a change of ownership (so you'd have to extend ownership if you're in the last two weeks that have been paid for if you want to make a roster move, and any time GMs make a roster move then owner inactivity is reset for purposes of determining when to take away the team), and automatically resetting all contracts to day 40 of current season would better address many of the ownership transition concerns.
And with that, GLB flex point revenues -> 0.
There are several problems with this idea.
1. The current promotion/relegation system is too slow. It would take 4 seasons (6 real months) before a gutted pro team gets relegated to the bottom tier where it belongs. By that time, you guessed it, no one will want it. Everyone that gets it will get pissed and try to get rid of it.
2. Extending an owner's grace period for inactivity is a terrible idea. The waiting list has what, 1000+ people on it? Some teams have at least 10 GMs. These teams would never get new owners under this idea.
1) No it's not. This isn't a one year game, it's a "life-time" game. If a player is really going to quit over 1 year of being relegated (and your 4 seasons assumes they can't sign any new players) then they're going to quit the first year they own a team and finish 6-10.
2) Pain is on the right track here, things that limit gutting in small doses are better then broad sweeping changes that harm more then the help.
Also, GLB will be fine. Getting the game mechanics fixed is much more important then these changes, especially when much easier and more effective changes exist.
Originally posted by Painmaker
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Occam's Razor is our best bet here, all things being equal, lets use the simplest workable solution.
This. The idea of moving teams around to provide some artificial sense of "fairness" causes more problems than it solves. Patience with promotion/relegation is the answer imo.
I also think things like starting a 2-week timer where roster moves can't be made prior to a change of ownership (so you'd have to extend ownership if you're in the last two weeks that have been paid for if you want to make a roster move, and any time GMs make a roster move then owner inactivity is reset for purposes of determining when to take away the team), and automatically resetting all contracts to day 40 of current season would better address many of the ownership transition concerns.
And with that, GLB flex point revenues -> 0.
There are several problems with this idea.
1. The current promotion/relegation system is too slow. It would take 4 seasons (6 real months) before a gutted pro team gets relegated to the bottom tier where it belongs. By that time, you guessed it, no one will want it. Everyone that gets it will get pissed and try to get rid of it.
2. Extending an owner's grace period for inactivity is a terrible idea. The waiting list has what, 1000+ people on it? Some teams have at least 10 GMs. These teams would never get new owners under this idea.
1) No it's not. This isn't a one year game, it's a "life-time" game. If a player is really going to quit over 1 year of being relegated (and your 4 seasons assumes they can't sign any new players) then they're going to quit the first year they own a team and finish 6-10.
2) Pain is on the right track here, things that limit gutting in small doses are better then broad sweeping changes that harm more then the help.
Also, GLB will be fine. Getting the game mechanics fixed is much more important then these changes, especially when much easier and more effective changes exist.
awesome
offline
offline
Originally posted by Painmaker
Flex points come from players, not teams (seriously, do the math). The money signified by the standing waiting list is only realized in any significant amount when they expand into new leagues, and eventually that waiting list will hover around some equilibrium value anyway. Slowing down the ownership transition process for the handful of teams that vacate midseason isn't particularly significant to the revenue stream (my opinion).
Screwing around with 15 other teams in a conference every time ownership changes hands for 1 team just multiplies the number of people being affected by at least 15 (when you consider that the outgoing team owner probably doesn't care so much, this ratio goes higher). Moving teams up from the conferences below (which will require a daisy chain all the way from the bottom tier leagues) adds to the number of teams getting jerked around. Customer satisfaction poses a much more significant impact to revenue than delaying ownership transition for existing teams. Of course that's just my view of the business model.
So your solution is to just keep adding thousands of teams? That doesn't solve anything as the new teams will be added at the bottom and the gutted teams will remain at the top. The only difference is that now instead of 4 seasons for the gutted team to reach the bottom, it will be 6 or 8 or 10 or whatever. That only compounds the problem and isn't worth discussing further.
Why do you think that the top teams from lower conferences would complain about being promoted? Isn't that the whole point of being the top team in a lower conference, to be promoted to the next level? All this does is speeds it up. I would have to disagree with you 100% as, instead of customer satisfaction decreasing, it will increase because more people will get to experience promotion at a faster rate.
Flex points come from players, not teams (seriously, do the math). The money signified by the standing waiting list is only realized in any significant amount when they expand into new leagues, and eventually that waiting list will hover around some equilibrium value anyway. Slowing down the ownership transition process for the handful of teams that vacate midseason isn't particularly significant to the revenue stream (my opinion).
Screwing around with 15 other teams in a conference every time ownership changes hands for 1 team just multiplies the number of people being affected by at least 15 (when you consider that the outgoing team owner probably doesn't care so much, this ratio goes higher). Moving teams up from the conferences below (which will require a daisy chain all the way from the bottom tier leagues) adds to the number of teams getting jerked around. Customer satisfaction poses a much more significant impact to revenue than delaying ownership transition for existing teams. Of course that's just my view of the business model.
So your solution is to just keep adding thousands of teams? That doesn't solve anything as the new teams will be added at the bottom and the gutted teams will remain at the top. The only difference is that now instead of 4 seasons for the gutted team to reach the bottom, it will be 6 or 8 or 10 or whatever. That only compounds the problem and isn't worth discussing further.
Why do you think that the top teams from lower conferences would complain about being promoted? Isn't that the whole point of being the top team in a lower conference, to be promoted to the next level? All this does is speeds it up. I would have to disagree with you 100% as, instead of customer satisfaction decreasing, it will increase because more people will get to experience promotion at a faster rate.
awesome
offline
offline
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by awesome
Originally posted by Painmaker
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Occam's Razor is our best bet here, all things being equal, lets use the simplest workable solution.
This. The idea of moving teams around to provide some artificial sense of "fairness" causes more problems than it solves. Patience with promotion/relegation is the answer imo.
I also think things like starting a 2-week timer where roster moves can't be made prior to a change of ownership (so you'd have to extend ownership if you're in the last two weeks that have been paid for if you want to make a roster move, and any time GMs make a roster move then owner inactivity is reset for purposes of determining when to take away the team), and automatically resetting all contracts to day 40 of current season would better address many of the ownership transition concerns.
And with that, GLB flex point revenues -> 0.
There are several problems with this idea.
1. The current promotion/relegation system is too slow. It would take 4 seasons (6 real months) before a gutted pro team gets relegated to the bottom tier where it belongs. By that time, you guessed it, no one will want it. Everyone that gets it will get pissed and try to get rid of it.
2. Extending an owner's grace period for inactivity is a terrible idea. The waiting list has what, 1000+ people on it? Some teams have at least 10 GMs. These teams would never get new owners under this idea.
1) No it's not. This isn't a one year game, it's a "life-time" game. If a player is really going to quit over 1 year of being relegated (and your 4 seasons assumes they can't sign any new players) then they're going to quit the first year they own a team and finish 6-10.
2) Pain is on the right track here, things that limit gutting in small doses are better then broad sweeping changes that harm more then the help.
Also, GLB will be fine. Getting the game mechanics fixed is much more important then these changes, especially when much easier and more effective changes exist.
1) That is the whole damn point: they won't be able to sign good enough players to keep from being relegated year after year after year. Instead of forcing paying customers to go through this pointless, frustrating process, just put them in the bottom from the start and let them rebuild against competition that they can compete against.
2) Your opinion that it harms more than it helps is irrelevant, just as mine that it helps (period). Without some support here, this is just a statement of opinion and cannot be responded to further.
Originally posted by awesome
Originally posted by Painmaker
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Occam's Razor is our best bet here, all things being equal, lets use the simplest workable solution.
This. The idea of moving teams around to provide some artificial sense of "fairness" causes more problems than it solves. Patience with promotion/relegation is the answer imo.
I also think things like starting a 2-week timer where roster moves can't be made prior to a change of ownership (so you'd have to extend ownership if you're in the last two weeks that have been paid for if you want to make a roster move, and any time GMs make a roster move then owner inactivity is reset for purposes of determining when to take away the team), and automatically resetting all contracts to day 40 of current season would better address many of the ownership transition concerns.
And with that, GLB flex point revenues -> 0.
There are several problems with this idea.
1. The current promotion/relegation system is too slow. It would take 4 seasons (6 real months) before a gutted pro team gets relegated to the bottom tier where it belongs. By that time, you guessed it, no one will want it. Everyone that gets it will get pissed and try to get rid of it.
2. Extending an owner's grace period for inactivity is a terrible idea. The waiting list has what, 1000+ people on it? Some teams have at least 10 GMs. These teams would never get new owners under this idea.
1) No it's not. This isn't a one year game, it's a "life-time" game. If a player is really going to quit over 1 year of being relegated (and your 4 seasons assumes they can't sign any new players) then they're going to quit the first year they own a team and finish 6-10.
2) Pain is on the right track here, things that limit gutting in small doses are better then broad sweeping changes that harm more then the help.
Also, GLB will be fine. Getting the game mechanics fixed is much more important then these changes, especially when much easier and more effective changes exist.
1) That is the whole damn point: they won't be able to sign good enough players to keep from being relegated year after year after year. Instead of forcing paying customers to go through this pointless, frustrating process, just put them in the bottom from the start and let them rebuild against competition that they can compete against.
2) Your opinion that it harms more than it helps is irrelevant, just as mine that it helps (period). Without some support here, this is just a statement of opinion and cannot be responded to further.
sois
offline
offline
Originally posted by sois
Maybe instead of pyramid shaped leagues, we should strictly have vertical leagues, from Pro to B. That will fix the issue and make it easier to program.
How many leagues are there now? We could possibly do 50 leagues and use State names. Texas Pro, Texas AAA, Texas AA.. all the way down to Texas B. Each league will only have one feeder.
awesome, I'm starting to buy into your theory. That would require the least amount of coding for Bort. Just tinker with team starting money. Bingo. I would also like to add "No loans until owner had held the team for one season". That will keep him from taking a loan out just to sign ringers at the beginning.
I do want to bump my short idea. I think it would work well. It might be more initial work, it will definitely help solve promotion/relegation coding.
Maybe instead of pyramid shaped leagues, we should strictly have vertical leagues, from Pro to B. That will fix the issue and make it easier to program.
How many leagues are there now? We could possibly do 50 leagues and use State names. Texas Pro, Texas AAA, Texas AA.. all the way down to Texas B. Each league will only have one feeder.
awesome, I'm starting to buy into your theory. That would require the least amount of coding for Bort. Just tinker with team starting money. Bingo. I would also like to add "No loans until owner had held the team for one season". That will keep him from taking a loan out just to sign ringers at the beginning.
I do want to bump my short idea. I think it would work well. It might be more initial work, it will definitely help solve promotion/relegation coding.
MAXIMUS LEGIONS
offline
offline
use the baseball minor league system and work your way up to pro level
hall of fame lg lvl
champions lg lvl
pro= top lvl
aaa= next lvl
aa = next lvl
a+ = a level champs class lg
a= lowest lvl
hall of fame lg lvl
champions lg lvl
pro= top lvl
aaa= next lvl
aa = next lvl
a+ = a level champs class lg
a= lowest lvl
Last edited Jun 30, 2008 23:07:56
Nazrat
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by AcidBee
3. If team sales are allowed mid-season, the team would become all-CPU for the rest of the season and basically be a cupcake team for all purposes.
I'm not going to say this is a good idea, but I don't see a good alternative. An all CPU team would only happen if you released all the human players right away. Perhaps a better solution would be to cut the human player's contract down to the end of the season and, in the meantime, have the contracts function like D-League contracts (i.e. bound to the contract unless a human team own sends a contract offer the the player)
I kinda like this idea...Basically, though, the players are gutting themselves off the team if they wanted. I guess it would allow the owner a way out without having to deal with releases/trades, etc, and the headache that goes with it.
On a related note (not addressed to AcidBee):
I think the thing that some people are missing is that if the team has no owner, no GM's, and a bunch of players left on it, those players are going to come and complain about having to stuck on a CPU team, ALL THE TIME.
It sounds all well and good to say "your contract will run out at the end of the season" but what if my owner sells on day 1 or 2 of the season? I'm stuck on a CPU-owned team until day 40? People who have signed on human teams want to play on human-controlled teams with people they know, not in the D-League. We need to let them go if they want.
My recommendation is that all contracts on teams where the owner quits expire within 48 hours. This leaves everyone on the team until the new owner can be added. It gives the new owner 48 hours to establish credibility with the existing players and attempt to retain them. It also guarantees that the players will only miss one game in that 48 hours if the change over doesn't go well.
By changing the end date of the contracts to 48 hours after ownership change, it might also prevent the gutting that occurs by the old owner on his way out of the door. The old owner won't feel guilty about leaving "his" players on someone else's team.
This small change may do wonders to resolve the rest of the issues that you raised.
Thanks for reading this.
Originally posted by AcidBee
3. If team sales are allowed mid-season, the team would become all-CPU for the rest of the season and basically be a cupcake team for all purposes.
I'm not going to say this is a good idea, but I don't see a good alternative. An all CPU team would only happen if you released all the human players right away. Perhaps a better solution would be to cut the human player's contract down to the end of the season and, in the meantime, have the contracts function like D-League contracts (i.e. bound to the contract unless a human team own sends a contract offer the the player)
I kinda like this idea...Basically, though, the players are gutting themselves off the team if they wanted. I guess it would allow the owner a way out without having to deal with releases/trades, etc, and the headache that goes with it.
On a related note (not addressed to AcidBee):
I think the thing that some people are missing is that if the team has no owner, no GM's, and a bunch of players left on it, those players are going to come and complain about having to stuck on a CPU team, ALL THE TIME.
It sounds all well and good to say "your contract will run out at the end of the season" but what if my owner sells on day 1 or 2 of the season? I'm stuck on a CPU-owned team until day 40? People who have signed on human teams want to play on human-controlled teams with people they know, not in the D-League. We need to let them go if they want.
My recommendation is that all contracts on teams where the owner quits expire within 48 hours. This leaves everyone on the team until the new owner can be added. It gives the new owner 48 hours to establish credibility with the existing players and attempt to retain them. It also guarantees that the players will only miss one game in that 48 hours if the change over doesn't go well.
By changing the end date of the contracts to 48 hours after ownership change, it might also prevent the gutting that occurs by the old owner on his way out of the door. The old owner won't feel guilty about leaving "his" players on someone else's team.
This small change may do wonders to resolve the rest of the issues that you raised.
Thanks for reading this.

sois
offline
offline
Originally posted by MAXIMUS LEGIONS
use the baseball minor league system and work your way up to pro level
hall of fame lg lvl
champions lg lvl
pro= top lvl
aaa= next lvl
aa = next lvl
a+ = a level champs class lg
a= lowest lvl
Yeah, you're on the right track. I wouldn't necessarily call the top levels Hall of Fame or Champions just yet because current teams will have to fill those positions, but you definitely understand my thinking.
use the baseball minor league system and work your way up to pro level
hall of fame lg lvl
champions lg lvl
pro= top lvl
aaa= next lvl
aa = next lvl
a+ = a level champs class lg
a= lowest lvl
Yeah, you're on the right track. I wouldn't necessarily call the top levels Hall of Fame or Champions just yet because current teams will have to fill those positions, but you definitely understand my thinking.
Sarg01
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
1. Who moves up? I.E, which team is selected to move up? They'd have to be in the same conference as the team that moves to the bottom.
The obvious answer is the conference championship loser - but that only works if only one team is sold. Would it take a lot of time to code something where a PM goes out to all the .501+ team owners in the eligible conference with a link to a page where they can indicate whether or not they would like to "claim" the spot? The spot goes to the team that got the furthest in the playoffs and/or had the best regular season record that enters a claim.
Originally posted by
2. Some people have suggested not allowing team sales in the middle of the season. I'm worried that this would leave a whole lot of players stranded with an inactive owner who gave up. Ideas/solutions?
Compromise. Short the owner some FP if they sell midseason. It encourages them to stick around without forcing them to. Ultimately, if all the players are going to be released at end of season, it won't be that painful an experience for them - especially if there's no gutting until the auto-gut. Limit the damage to a single season and most folks will be reasonably content.
Originally posted by
3. If team sales are allowed mid-season, the team would become all-CPU for the rest of the season and basically be a cupcake team for all purposes. Good or Bad?
Bad, but no worse than allowing gutting. As in #2 above, I think you should try to cut down on mid-season sales as much as possible.
Originally posted by
4. Many new owners want to be able to get a team where their lv 20+ players can come and play. If all new teams always start at the lowest level, that becomes impossible due to sportsmanship penalties and/or level caps. Solutions/Ideas?
I'm not sure this bothers me too much. I think a team owner should expect to have to recruit people on GLB and not in RL as a sort of rite-of-passage. They can outsource to a GM if they find it personally distasteful, and why do they need to own a team if they aren't interested in dealing with players in regards to contracts, playing time, etc?
However, if you must, you can have some teams fall back to the lowest uncapped league instead of into the brand new leagues. Have two waiting lists, capped and uncapped.
Originally posted by
5. Some owners randomly sell a team who is actually competitive in the league without releasing or trading away the players first, so the new owner can keep on keepin' on. Yes, they could sell it to a GM, but maybe the GM doesn't want it, etc. Disbanding this kind of team just because the owner doesn't have time any more seems like a waste. Ideas/Solutions?
To fix this without human intervention, you need to be willing to devise a system to grade competitiveness. That sounds like a lot of work for a pretty limited situation. I think ownership should be able to be transferred to GMs, then players - under the 1 season tenure caveat.
1. Who moves up? I.E, which team is selected to move up? They'd have to be in the same conference as the team that moves to the bottom.
The obvious answer is the conference championship loser - but that only works if only one team is sold. Would it take a lot of time to code something where a PM goes out to all the .501+ team owners in the eligible conference with a link to a page where they can indicate whether or not they would like to "claim" the spot? The spot goes to the team that got the furthest in the playoffs and/or had the best regular season record that enters a claim.
Originally posted by
2. Some people have suggested not allowing team sales in the middle of the season. I'm worried that this would leave a whole lot of players stranded with an inactive owner who gave up. Ideas/solutions?
Compromise. Short the owner some FP if they sell midseason. It encourages them to stick around without forcing them to. Ultimately, if all the players are going to be released at end of season, it won't be that painful an experience for them - especially if there's no gutting until the auto-gut. Limit the damage to a single season and most folks will be reasonably content.
Originally posted by
3. If team sales are allowed mid-season, the team would become all-CPU for the rest of the season and basically be a cupcake team for all purposes. Good or Bad?
Bad, but no worse than allowing gutting. As in #2 above, I think you should try to cut down on mid-season sales as much as possible.
Originally posted by
4. Many new owners want to be able to get a team where their lv 20+ players can come and play. If all new teams always start at the lowest level, that becomes impossible due to sportsmanship penalties and/or level caps. Solutions/Ideas?
I'm not sure this bothers me too much. I think a team owner should expect to have to recruit people on GLB and not in RL as a sort of rite-of-passage. They can outsource to a GM if they find it personally distasteful, and why do they need to own a team if they aren't interested in dealing with players in regards to contracts, playing time, etc?
However, if you must, you can have some teams fall back to the lowest uncapped league instead of into the brand new leagues. Have two waiting lists, capped and uncapped.
Originally posted by
5. Some owners randomly sell a team who is actually competitive in the league without releasing or trading away the players first, so the new owner can keep on keepin' on. Yes, they could sell it to a GM, but maybe the GM doesn't want it, etc. Disbanding this kind of team just because the owner doesn't have time any more seems like a waste. Ideas/Solutions?
To fix this without human intervention, you need to be willing to devise a system to grade competitiveness. That sounds like a lot of work for a pretty limited situation. I think ownership should be able to be transferred to GMs, then players - under the 1 season tenure caveat.
SunDevil03
offline
offline
1. Select the team that came closest to moving up last time IMHO.
So the loser of the playoff semi-finals in that conference.2. Is it possible to put a time limit on an owner? If you are the owner of a team, and you go inactive for like 3-4 games (officially inactive), then the players could be able to release themselves? If you are a serious owner of a team, what are you doing going inactive in the first place ya know? lol
3. As far as being a cupcake team I think it would be fine because it seems all of these new teams need at least one rebuilding year anyways. I imagine many of the teams being sold were cupcakes in the first place anyways.
4. I think that new owner will just have to deal with it.
lol go put your lvl 20 player on a better team, and enjoy running your own at a lower level.5. If an owner wants to keep a team rolling, maybe they should have the option to appoint a new owner within the team. That keeps everything pretty within the team, so if they all really want to stay together they can rally around the new owner.
sois
offline
offline
All of you posting ideas for "who gets promoted" are missing key issues. For example, SunDevil03, you suggest loser of the plaoyff semi-finals in the conference. You are missing a major consideration:
There are two AAA leagues for each Pro league. That means four runner-up conference finishers. There is no way to determine a fair way to move one up if they never play each other or play similar competition.
That is why I suggested this:
Originally posted by sois
Maybe instead of pyramid shaped leagues, we should strictly have vertical leagues ranging from Pro to B. That will fix the issue and make it easier to program. Each league will only have one feeder. One AAA will feed into Pro, one A league will feed into AA... etc.
There are two AAA leagues for each Pro league. That means four runner-up conference finishers. There is no way to determine a fair way to move one up if they never play each other or play similar competition.
That is why I suggested this:
Originally posted by sois
Maybe instead of pyramid shaped leagues, we should strictly have vertical leagues ranging from Pro to B. That will fix the issue and make it easier to program. Each league will only have one feeder. One AAA will feed into Pro, one A league will feed into AA... etc.
Last edited Jul 1, 2008 09:49:07
SCACE
offline
offline
Use the championship home field tiebreaker:
1. Top team from each conference NOT in the championship game 16 game record (if tied, move to 2)
2. Conference with more interconference wins (if tied, move to 3)
3. Point differential (for - against) (if tied, move to 4)
4. etc.
You just use that all the way down from top to bottom.
If there are 2 teams, you just send the top ranked team that didn't make the championship game from each conferece. 4, 6, 8, etc. - same way. If it is an odd number, you use the same tiebreak system already in place for championship game homefield.
1. Top team from each conference NOT in the championship game 16 game record (if tied, move to 2)
2. Conference with more interconference wins (if tied, move to 3)
3. Point differential (for - against) (if tied, move to 4)
4. etc.
You just use that all the way down from top to bottom.
If there are 2 teams, you just send the top ranked team that didn't make the championship game from each conferece. 4, 6, 8, etc. - same way. If it is an odd number, you use the same tiebreak system already in place for championship game homefield.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























