Originally posted by aeakers
OK, here is a compelling reason not to have playable cheerleaders:
#1. It would be very time consuming to program, esp. for minimal gain. I mean, not that many teams will hire cheerleaders, let alone a full squad. And...if by some unGodly coincidence, lets say a lot of teams had full cheerleader squads. What tangible result can be had? How do we separate a good cheerleader build from a bad? How do we gauge performance? How could they possibly be programmed to affect the game when even home field advantage has no benefit?
Now....let me throw in a 'what if'. What if cheerleaders do not boost morale? What if instead they are PR queens, as in real life. Send them to a mall, have them sign autographs, all the while selling Tshirts and coffee mugs. Raising fan support.
But.....even then, not something I would support. So much to work on to improve the game and you want them to add a fictional mechanism such as cheerleaders affecting the game. Cheerleaders do not get fans pumped. Go to a game. The ones getting the fans pumped up ARE THE FANS. The Bengal Darth Vader, the Broncos' Naked Guy in a Barrel, The Raiders fans with the spiked shoulderpads.
Sorry for hating but guys, this is just a bad idea.
Ok let me break this down.
"It would be very time consuming to program" - Wrong. If you pseudocode it efficiently and have others help you plan it out (Like I am offering to) it can be finished in an afternoon. I assume you don't program at all or you would see this.
"Not that many teams would hire cheerleaders, especially a full squad" - Wrong. If there was something in the game I could hire that would boost my team's morale and make them play better I would hire them. I'm sure owners would do the same.
"How do we seperate a good cheerleader build from a bad" - How do we seperate a good player build from a bad? We guess, analyze, and do the best we can.
"How do we gauge perfomance" - Fan reactions in the sim by text. Same as how we gauge the performance of morale itself - by guesses based on what occured. Nobody knows how often Snarrl works.
"How could they possibly be programmed to affect the game when even home field advantage has no benefit?" - They would in essence represent home field advantage in some cases, as they would cheer slightly more often etc. when playing at home - leading to a bigger morale boost for your team when playing at home (TA DA HOME FIELD ADVANTAGE).
"What if cheerleaders do not boost morale?" - Won't happen if you program correctly.
"you want them to add a fictional mechanism such as cheerleaders affecting the game." - Cheerleaders exist in real life. Not fictional.
"The ones getting the fans pumped up ARE THE FANS. The Bengal Darth Vader, the Broncos' Naked Guy in a Barrel, The Raiders fans with the spiked shoulderpads." - So would you complain as much if I made the same exact suggestion except replaced the word Cheerleader with Fan, and had you build a fan the same way and assign them to teams? It's the same thing in essence.