User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Playable Cheerleaders Compiled Suggestion
Page:
 
morgan3
offline
Link
 
Lets allow people to pay to create fans to and you can build them to how they cheer on their team. If they leave in a blowout or stay and cheer. Everyone would love to build fans too. I mean the game could even make it so that your attendance is based on how many people make fans and make them a fan of ur team. That would be a money maker right?

This idea sucks!
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by Laggo

Originally posted by aeakers



In the NFL, cheerleaders sole existence is for the fans. They do not affect the game. Unless Chad Johnson is doing a celebration.


Cheerleaders affect the fans, who in turn affect the game.

Do you think the fans do not affect the game?


Again, you are talking "Home Field Advantage", not "cheerleaders". The Developers will NEVER go for "building" cheerleaders. This crappy idea needs to be shot down ASAP.


I could see, however, them going for adding cheerleaders as a stadium upgrade.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Tiny Ball of Muscle
Cheerleaders matter to football in the same way spots matter to a cow. They're there but they're generally useless. The crowd effects the game 10 times more than a bunch of sluts in skirts.


Exactly.
 
Laggo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by aeakers
OK, here is a compelling reason not to have playable cheerleaders:

#1. It would be very time consuming to program, esp. for minimal gain. I mean, not that many teams will hire cheerleaders, let alone a full squad. And...if by some unGodly coincidence, lets say a lot of teams had full cheerleader squads. What tangible result can be had? How do we separate a good cheerleader build from a bad? How do we gauge performance? How could they possibly be programmed to affect the game when even home field advantage has no benefit?

Now....let me throw in a 'what if'. What if cheerleaders do not boost morale? What if instead they are PR queens, as in real life. Send them to a mall, have them sign autographs, all the while selling Tshirts and coffee mugs. Raising fan support.


But.....even then, not something I would support. So much to work on to improve the game and you want them to add a fictional mechanism such as cheerleaders affecting the game. Cheerleaders do not get fans pumped. Go to a game. The ones getting the fans pumped up ARE THE FANS. The Bengal Darth Vader, the Broncos' Naked Guy in a Barrel, The Raiders fans with the spiked shoulderpads.

Sorry for hating but guys, this is just a bad idea.


Ok let me break this down.

"It would be very time consuming to program" - Wrong. If you pseudocode it efficiently and have others help you plan it out (Like I am offering to) it can be finished in an afternoon. I assume you don't program at all or you would see this.

"Not that many teams would hire cheerleaders, especially a full squad" - Wrong. If there was something in the game I could hire that would boost my team's morale and make them play better I would hire them. I'm sure owners would do the same.

"How do we seperate a good cheerleader build from a bad" - How do we seperate a good player build from a bad? We guess, analyze, and do the best we can.


"How do we gauge perfomance" - Fan reactions in the sim by text. Same as how we gauge the performance of morale itself - by guesses based on what occured. Nobody knows how often Snarrl works.

"How could they possibly be programmed to affect the game when even home field advantage has no benefit?" - They would in essence represent home field advantage in some cases, as they would cheer slightly more often etc. when playing at home - leading to a bigger morale boost for your team when playing at home (TA DA HOME FIELD ADVANTAGE).

"What if cheerleaders do not boost morale?" - Won't happen if you program correctly.

"you want them to add a fictional mechanism such as cheerleaders affecting the game." - Cheerleaders exist in real life. Not fictional.

"The ones getting the fans pumped up ARE THE FANS. The Bengal Darth Vader, the Broncos' Naked Guy in a Barrel, The Raiders fans with the spiked shoulderpads." - So would you complain as much if I made the same exact suggestion except replaced the word Cheerleader with Fan, and had you build a fan the same way and assign them to teams? It's the same thing in essence.


 
Rudiger
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Laggo

"The ones getting the fans pumped up ARE THE FANS. The Bengal Darth Vader, the Broncos' Naked Guy in a Barrel, The Raiders fans with the spiked shoulderpads." - So would you complain as much if I made the same exact suggestion except replaced the word Cheerleader with Fan, and had you build a fan the same way and assign them to teams? It's the same thing in essence.




No it's not. Fans don't need "beauty" as a stat
 
Laggo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by morgan3
Lets allow people to pay to create fans to and you can build them to how they cheer on their team. If they leave in a blowout or stay and cheer. Everyone would love to build fans too. I mean the game could even make it so that your attendance is based on how many people make fans and make them a fan of ur team. That would be a money maker right?

This idea sucks!


Flesh it out, give the pro's, tell me exactly how it would work from both a general aspect and a programming aspect and we will talk.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by atm490
Originally posted by Checkmate187

I think if made available, every damn one of you nay-sayers will have at least one cheerleader the next day.... as will all the people who love this idea. That means mo' money, mo' money, MO' MONEY!!


You're entitled to your opinion. Here's mine: I think if this were made part of the game, large numbers of people would leave, and the income would drop. Current players would leave because adding this part of the game would tell the players that the site operators have a very skewed list of priorities when it comes to making this game the best it can be.

This idea appeals to a very, VERY limited number of current players that actually buy flex points. Those players would be very jaded if cheerleaders were added instead of tactics beyond even the next set of advanced tactics that would make this a better football simulation.




Exactly. I don't pay to level up 3 times each season just so a pack of hormonal KIDS can get their jollies "building" cheerleaders.
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
""Not that many teams would hire cheerleaders, especially a full squad" - Wrong. If there was something in the game I could hire that would boost my team's morale and make them play better I would hire them. I'm sure owners would do the same."

Hasty generalization. Assuming the majority would act as you would is fallacious.

The fact is, if you make site users pay for this, some WILL use it. This will put those that don't want to in a position where they will either have to follow suit in order to stay "competitive" or leave. I would wager that more people will just leave than have to spend extra cash on this nonsense.
 
Laggo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rudiger
Originally posted by Laggo


"The ones getting the fans pumped up ARE THE FANS. The Bengal Darth Vader, the Broncos' Naked Guy in a Barrel, The Raiders fans with the spiked shoulderpads." - So would you complain as much if I made the same exact suggestion except replaced the word Cheerleader with Fan, and had you build a fan the same way and assign them to teams? It's the same thing in essence.




No it's not. Fans don't need "beauty" as a stat


Dolphin's girl pic? I won't post it here as it's NSFW but you can google it.

She's relatively famous now.
 
Checkmate187
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rudiger
Originally posted by Laggo


"The ones getting the fans pumped up ARE THE FANS. The Bengal Darth Vader, the Broncos' Naked Guy in a Barrel, The Raiders fans with the spiked shoulderpads." - So would you complain as much if I made the same exact suggestion except replaced the word Cheerleader with Fan, and had you build a fan the same way and assign them to teams? It's the same thing in essence.




No it's not. Fans don't need "beauty" as a stat


So make it 'Spirit'. There, all better now.
 
atm490
offline
Link
 
Laggo - Why have you avoided the several people that have mentioned that cheerleaders in reality do not have the effect that you claim they do, which is the foundation of this very idea?

Several of us have said that cheerleaders do NOT effect fans, do NOT effect morale, and are NOT a part of football.

Comments?
 
Rudiger
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Laggo
Originally posted by Rudiger

Originally posted by Laggo



"The ones getting the fans pumped up ARE THE FANS. The Bengal Darth Vader, the Broncos' Naked Guy in a Barrel, The Raiders fans with the spiked shoulderpads." - So would you complain as much if I made the same exact suggestion except replaced the word Cheerleader with Fan, and had you build a fan the same way and assign them to teams? It's the same thing in essence.




No it's not. Fans don't need "beauty" as a stat


Dolphin's girl pic? I won't post it here as it's NSFW but you can google it.

She's relatively famous now.


Yes because one fan would justify a stat. You're an idiot.
 
the_flutist
offline
Link
 
Edited for the non-existant children on here.
Last edited Jun 23, 2008 14:49:04
 
CONN CHRIS
offline
Link
 
The day that an owner has to beg me to buy bling or dump flex points into cheerleaders so we can keep our team moral up to par with the rest of the league is the day this gets uninteresting to me. It's a short slide from there to no longer here spending money.

But that's just me.
 
defdrago
offline
Link
 
Gayest thread ever.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.