User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Plankton
OPL4Lyfe
offline
Link
 
Adding a league type and removing a league type is basically a wash. You could just as easily change the promotion rules of the existing leagues to match your list.

The problem with this system is that it does not allow for the fluctuation of # of teams/players per season. Since you have fixed numbers of leagues at the top but the number of teams coming out of the minors changes every season, a fixed promotion plan will not work. There needs to be some way to handle the fluctuation in the number of teams not in the minors, which the current system has.

With that said, I do like your idea of increasing the number of automatic demotions from the Pros.
 
Adderfist
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Plankton
Adding a league type and removing a league type is basically a wash. You could just as easily change the promotion rules of the existing leagues to match your list.

The problem with this system is that it does not allow for the fluctuation of # of teams/players per season. Since you have fixed numbers of leagues at the top but the number of teams coming out of the minors changes every season, a fixed promotion plan will not work. There needs to be some way to handle the fluctuation in the number of teams not in the minors, which the current system has.

With that said, I do like your idea of increasing the number of automatic demotions from the Pros.


No, the reason his semi-pro league works is there is a MUCH higher promotion/demotion level.

Ironically, I've been asking for a much higher level of movement for nearly 10 seasons.
 
Plankton
OPL4Lyfe
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Adderfist
No, the reason his semi-pro league works is there is a MUCH higher promotion/demotion level.

Ironically, I've been asking for a much higher level of movement for nearly 10 seasons.


Regardless of the promotion/demotion rate (and I agree that increasing the rate would be better), you can not have a fixed number leagues at the top and a fluctuating number of leagues at the bottom AND have a fixed promotion policy (i.e. all playoff teams promote). That is how the old pyramid system worked and you have to have the bottom tier be larger than the maximum number of teams which leads to CPU teams and blowouts.
Edited by Plankton on Aug 30, 2010 10:34:22
 
jmarter
offline
Link
 
I changed the numbers a bit to better reflect what I was trying to accomplish. That being, a structure for a fixed number of teams - in this scenario, 1056. The biggest change to the current structure are specific (& more extensive) promotion/demotion rules to make leagues more competitive quicker.

WL (1 league, 32 teams) - no change here
Promotion: none
Demotion: 16 (non-playoff qualifiers)

Pro (8 leagues, 256 teams) - only is to up the demotions from 4 to 6 per league
Promotion: 16 (championship finalist in each league)
Demotion: 64 (bottom 8 from each league)

Semi-Pro (4 leagues, 128 teams) - new league (+4 leagues), training grounds for the PROs, complete turnover every season
Promotion: 64 (playoff teams)
Demotion: 64 (non-playoff teams)

AAA (8 leagues, 256 teams) - change to all 1st round playoff winners promote, -3 fewer leagues than currently
Promotion: 64 (all 1st round playoff winners)
Demotion: 48 (bottom 6 from each league)

AA (12 leagues, 384 teams) - change to conference finalists promote, +6 more leagues than currently
Promotion: 48 (all 2nd round playoff winners)
Demotion: 48 (bottom 4 from each league)

A (TBA) - need 48 teams per season to promote, # of leagues & promotion requirements dependent on # of teams eligible to move out of the minors

This can be accomplished quickly. Adds just one league to the current structure and would be stable long term.

 
jmarter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Plankton
Regardless of the promotion/demotion rate (and I agree that increasing the rate would be better), you can not have a fixed number leagues at the top and a fluctuating number of leagues at the bottom AND have a fixed promotion policy (i.e. all playoff teams promote). That is how the old pyramid system worked and you have to have the bottom tier be larger than the maximum number of teams which leads to CPU teams and blowouts.


But I think you can do this. In effect we do currently, with a fixed number of WL and Pro leagues. I am just suggesting moving this fixed number of teams down through AA and a better way to ensure that the best teams reach the Pro level. From A and below, the # of leagues and can fluid.
Edited by jmarter on Aug 30, 2010 12:36:21
 
Plankton
OPL4Lyfe
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jmarter
But I think you can do this. In effect we do currently, with a fixed number of WL and Pro leagues. I am just suggesting moving this fixed number of teams down through AA and a better way to ensure that the best teams reach the Pro level. From A and below, the # of leagues and can fluid.


TBH, I prefer your system over the current one. Since there needs to be an area that where there are "flexible" promotion rules, I would rather those occur at the bottom of the pyramid than the top.

The issue still remains for this season tho, although I am giving up hope of us having any input for this season anyway. I guess we will take what we get and like it.
Edited by Plankton on Aug 30, 2010 12:58:29
 
jmarter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Plankton
TBH, I prefer your system over the current one. Since there needs to be an area that where there are "flexible" promotion rules, I would rather those occur at the bottom of the pyramid than the top.

The issue still remains for this season tho, although I am giving up hope of us having any input for this season anyway. I guess we will take what we get and like it.


Yeah, would be nice to get this done for this season. It's doable. Basically the SemiPro could be created this offseason and all the others fall in place then. SemiPro would consist of 32 demotions from PRO + 96 promotions from AAA. This would mean that a total of 128 move out of AAA after this season (32 directly to Pro, 96 to this SemiPro). That would mean all 1st round playoff winners (88) plus another 40. I would recommend that this 40 being the next best records across AAA.

With SemiPro cleaning house after each season, I would think we'd quickly get the best teams to the top.

 
Plankton
OPL4Lyfe
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jmarter
Yeah, would be nice to get this done for this season. It's doable. Basically the SemiPro could be created this offseason and all the others fall in place then. SemiPro would consist of 32 demotions from PRO + 96 promotions from AAA. This would mean that a total of 128 move out of AAA after this season (32 directly to Pro, 96 to this SemiPro). That would mean all 1st round playoff winners (88) plus another 40. I would recommend that this 40 being the next best records across AAA.

With SemiPro cleaning house after each season, I would think we'd quickly get the best teams to the top.



In all honestly, promoting from AAA to SemiPro will not feel like a promotion for those teams, since they are still one step away from Pro. It is more like a shuffling.
 
jmarter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Plankton
In all honestly, promoting from AAA to SemiPro will not feel like a promotion for those teams, since they are still one step away from Pro. It is more like a shuffling.


True, but the ones going to this SemiPro would be the ones that missed out on the Pro promotion. Remember, 32 to have to go up there. SemiPro would be that "one step away" league. Make the playoffs and you get your shot in the Pros, miss the playoffs and you have to go back down to AAA to earn your way back up.
 
Plankton
OPL4Lyfe
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jmarter
True, but the ones going to this SemiPro would be the ones that missed out on the Pro promotion. Remember, 32 to have to go up there. SemiPro would be that "one step away" league. Make the playoffs and you get your shot in the Pros, miss the playoffs and you have to go back down to AAA to earn your way back up.


Good point. I like it going forward.
Edited by Plankton on Aug 30, 2010 20:03:52
 
jmarter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Plankton
Good point. I like it going forward.


Looking like this is a two person conversation though.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by jmarter
Originally posted by Plankton

Good point. I like it going forward.


Looking like this is a two person conversation though.


I am readinga ll of this....but it really doesn't matter as long as Bort or Catch do not chime in....
 
jmarter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Beachsand DTD
I am readinga ll of this....but it really doesn't matter as long as Bort or Catch do not chime in....


Yeah, that was my point. Not the RIGHT two people to be having this conversation.
 
Little M
offline
Link
 
It would have been nice to have this settled when they did the league restructuring last off-season. I am co-ordinating for an A team and we can't recruit now because we don't know what league we will be in next season, so we don't know what our cap limit will be.
 
jmarter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Little M
It would have been nice to have this settled when they did the league restructuring last off-season. I am co-ordinating for an A team and we can't recruit now because we don't know what league we will be in next season, so we don't know what our cap limit will be.


Yeah, I think there needs to be some stable alignment so that owners can project exactly where they will be the following season. The new team purchasing thing ought to help it out, if there's a stable framework in place. In the system that I outlined with specific promotion/demotion requirements (regardless of ownership of team) the only thing that would be fluid would be the number of A leagues & teams. This would be dependent on the # of teams that moved out of the cap leagues each season.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.