User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Stop the trophies for LOL GM's
Page:
 
Link
 
+1 to the OP.

I offer GM titles to players who've contributed to the season = as a co-ord i'm not going anywhere if my agents don't apply tactics properly.

I think there should be a seperate trophy for players though, that would lessen the need for GM titles of any description - I think there are enough titles/positions in the game currently to cover any genuine help that has been offered to a team.

Its funny reading people defending their worthless 'loltrophies' - guys who did nothing other than accept an invite to a teams GM list when it became clear they were going to make noise in the post-season.

I had one such email - I basically ignored it.

I would laugh at anyone who had trophies gained in similar circumstances in real-life (my friends football team won their Championship game and they gave me a medal too!!).

I'd suggest getting rid of GM trophies altogether and replace them with player trophies that easy to differentiate.
 
Phantom_Opera
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Empire_Strikes_Back
+1 to the OP.

I offer GM titles to players who've contributed to the season = as a co-ord i'm not going anywhere if my agents don't apply tactics properly.

I think there should be a seperate trophy for players though, that would lessen the need for GM titles of any description - I think there are enough titles/positions in the game currently to cover any genuine help that has been offered to a team.

Its funny reading people defending their worthless 'loltrophies' - guys who did nothing other than accept an invite to a teams GM list when it became clear they were going to make noise in the post-season.

I had one such email - I basically ignored it.

I would laugh at anyone who had trophies gained in similar circumstances in real-life (my friends football team won their Championship game and they gave me a medal too!!).

I'd suggest getting rid of GM trophies altogether and replace them with player trophies that easy to differentiate.


We give the parents a medal when the team I am an assistant couch of won their Conference. (6-8 year olds pee wee) last year. The Kids and the coaches got trophies. All the coaches. 5 in all. just sayin.
 
Nuldaan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Phantom_Opera

We give the parents a medal when the team I am an assistant couch of won their Conference. (6-8 year olds pee wee) last year. The Kids and the coaches got trophies. All the coaches. 5 in all. just sayin.


But did you have random people off the street asking to be a "coach" when it became clear that you had a shot at winning the conference?
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Landrys Legacy
nothing fun about trophies that aren't earned


Objectively, of course.

 
hatchman
Goat Father
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nuldaan
But did you have random people off the street asking to be a "coach" when it became clear that you had a shot at winning the conference?


this is eactly what burns me up about the LOL GM's. I don't mind people that are associated with the team over the course of the season getting a trophy. If they have been listed as a GM the entire season or atleast half the season then hey they should have actually been a part of the team in some way. so they get a trophy that is great. I just think stopping the trophy whores who PM a ton of teams just to try to ride their coattails is pathetic. those guys can defend their actions all they want and they can try to devalue the trophies for the teams or whatever. But at the end of the day there are alot of us that enjoy the game and take pride in winning and earning our trophies. thank you to all of you guys that are backing this and hopefully it will go epic and get some sort of resolve.
 
BrumNasty
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dub J
I show no respect for generic GM trophies. If "GM of ..." is under the trophy all I see is "loltrophy".


Someone want to make me LOLOC?
 
hatchman
Goat Father
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BrumNasty
Someone want to make me LOLOC?


Not funny but it is something that will be done to get around any changes that is made to LOL GMs getting trophies and that would be a even worse mistake for teams then.
 
Link
 
Its pretty obvious to me, that those who are spam collecting these GM titles are doing so for a reason.

That reason is: its gives their home page 'prestige' - sure everyone knows the difference between a co-ord trophy and a GM one - but not many will look deep enough to differentiate between a lolGM and a genuine trophy earned by a player on a Championship team.

If it was one or two people doing this, you could pass it off as a couple of guys fooling around - right now its a pretty well co-ordinated (theres some irony for you) effort to fill their pages with undeserved hardware.
 
pamitch
offline
Link
 
I agree LoLGM trophies are stupid. But I know this idiot on here who gave 1 of his agents the DC position for the day the trophies were handed out just so he could have a DC trophy and he didnt do crap to get it all season. Then they go into the forums and brag about they have more trophies then the other person. It is pretty lame it should be for OC DC ETC and you have to be in the position for more then 1/4 of the season
Edited by pamitch on May 9, 2010 15:34:55
 
hatchman
Goat Father
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Empire_Strikes_Back
Its pretty obvious to me, that those who are spam collecting these GM titles are doing so for a reason.

That reason is: its gives their home page 'prestige' - sure everyone knows the difference between a co-ord trophy and a GM one - but not many will look deep enough to differentiate between a lolGM and a genuine trophy earned by a player on a Championship team.

If it was one or two people doing this, you could pass it off as a couple of guys fooling around - right now its a pretty well co-ordinated (theres some irony for you) effort to fill their pages with undeserved hardware.


I fully agree and alot of the newby owners don't look very close they just see that a agent has a bunch of trophies and assumes that the agent has won these and thinks that they are lucky that they are getting help from such a player. then they figure out after it is to late that a LOL GM has screwed their team and very possibly screwed their whole season.
 
Link
 
I have earned my trophies, so go away
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by hatchman
I fully agree and alot of the newby owners don't look very close they just see that a agent has a bunch of trophies and assumes that the agent has won these and thinks that they are lucky that they are getting help from such a player. then they figure out after it is to late that a LOL GM has screwed their team and very possibly screwed their whole season.


I don't really have an opinion either here because tbh I don't care about other people's trophies when looking at their team either to sign there or just scouting. However, if an agent is signing his guy based off of how many trophies my profile has, I'm not so sure I want his guy.

If the agent has a bunch of trophies on the other hand, I'll take that into consideration as to how heavy I recruit them and I'll assign my own value to their trophies.

 
hatchman
Goat Father
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by brady2moss2endzone
I have earned my trophies, so go away



If you earned them then good for you. just looking at your trophies I see 1 with a actual job title which was a recruiter one. but that doesn't mean you didn't earn them. I do see it though as you took offense when no one spoke of you so there may be something you feel you need to try to defend?
 
hatchman
Goat Father
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by VolBrian
Originally posted by hatchman

I fully agree and alot of the newby owners don't look very close they just see that a agent has a bunch of trophies and assumes that the agent has won these and thinks that they are lucky that they are getting help from such a player. then they figure out after it is to late that a LOL GM has screwed their team and very possibly screwed their whole season.


I don't really have an opinion either here because tbh I don't care about other people's trophies when looking at their team either to sign there or just scouting. However, if an agent is signing his guy based off of how many trophies my profile has, I'm not so sure I want his guy.

If the agent has a bunch of trophies on the other hand, I'll take that into consideration as to how heavy I recruit them and I'll assign my own value to their trophies.


I am not speaking about players on the dotball field. I am talking about owners trying to recruit OC's, DC's or any other coordinator job. alot of new owners will see a agent with a bunch of trophies and think that the agent is very good at the game. and then later on the owner finds out that the LOL GM didn't know anything and eventually screwed the teams chances for a season and basically wasted the players time and money.
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Ahhh, I should've read more than the last page.

I still don't have an opinion here because I have two trophies that I got just for being on the team, and the rest I "earned". I am, however, likely to end up with some loltrophies this season but I'm fine with that.

I do see your point about hiring an OC/DC, etc. but again, I would never do that off of trophies. I would have to have interacted/known the agent for at least a season. I end up OCing myself anyway.

To this point, I remember back in like season two when the Scotch Cocks did this, and I had to fire a guy off my buddy's team because he came in saying he had DC'd the Cocks when I knew the DC and knew this guy had just gone fishing for a trophy.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.