User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > General Discussion > Alcoholism and obestiy
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by 5thyearcock
You looked at this completely the wrong way. I wasn't defining addiction as dependency, I was defining dependency as addiction. Dependency comes from being addicted to something. You know words have multiple definitions right? When I say people in Denver are way up high, I don't mean they've all smoked a bunch of pot.

Dependence is also not "doing something as a crutch." There is a very specific list of criteria you must meet a certain number of to be "dependent" on a substance, as laid out by the DSM - IV. There is also criteria for abuse of a substance. You can abuse something and not be dependent or addicted.


Are you the same judgmental guy who doesn't judge? Cause you're just getting worse and worse. I mean, at what point did you think pulling abuse off the shelf, dusting it off, and slapping it into your post was a good idea?
 
5thyearcock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by whotookmybowtie
Originally posted by 5thyearcock

You looked at this completely the wrong way. I wasn't defining addiction as dependency, I was defining dependency as addiction. Dependency comes from being addicted to something. You know words have multiple definitions right? When I say people in Denver are way up high, I don't mean they've all smoked a bunch of pot.

Dependence is also not "doing something as a crutch." There is a very specific list of criteria you must meet a certain number of to be "dependent" on a substance, as laid out by the DSM - IV. There is also criteria for abuse of a substance. You can abuse something and not be dependent or addicted.


Are you the same judgmental guy who doesn't judge? Cause you're just getting worse and worse. I mean, at what point did you think pulling abuse off the shelf, dusting it off, and slapping it into your post was a good idea?


That hard for you to go back and check the posters names? Not the same guy. I pulled "abuse" off the shelf because it goes hand in hand with dependence when you are administering an psychiatric interview (we use the MINI where I work.) We first ask about abuse, then go deeper into current or past dependence.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 5thyearcock
You looked at this completely the wrong way. I wasn't defining addiction as dependency, I was defining dependency as addiction. Dependency comes from being addicted to something.

false. you got that backwards -- addiction comes from dependency, not the other way around.

Originally posted by 5thyearcock
You know words have multiple definitions right? When I say people in Denver are way up high, I don't mean they've all smoked a bunch of pot.

uh, technical denotations are rigid for a reason. it's a little tough to do business otherwise.

Originally posted by 5thyearcock
Dependence is also not "doing something as a crutch."

i was obviously oversimplifying for a reason.

Originally posted by 5thyearcock
Especially if we want to be super medical-technical here. There is a very specific list of criteria you must meet a certain number of to be "dependent" on a substance, as laid out by the DSM - IV.

so? and note that you only have to hit some of that list to be deemed dependent by the APA, which speaks to the fact that (as i said before) this is a continuum.

Originally posted by 5thyearcock
There is also criteria for abuse of a substance. You can abuse something and not be dependent or addicted.

so? you can also cycle out of addiction down to dependency and still abuse alcohol. what of it? why are you suddenly talking about abuse?
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 5thyearcock
That hard for you to go back and check the posters names? Not the same guy.

yet you replied to r87, but quoted me.

Originally posted by 5thyearcock
I pulled "abuse" off the shelf because it goes hand in hand with dependence when you are administering an psychiatric interview (we use the MINI where I work.) We first ask about abuse, then go deeper into current or past dependence.

but as you already said, abuse isn't an exclusively sufficient determining factor here. it's obviously part of the picture, but it's not even necessary, let alone sufficient. (and i'm using 'necessary' and 'sufficient' in a clinical sense here as well.)

also, i'm not sure why we're suddenly hyper-focusing on psychiatry.
 
5thyearcock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16

Originally posted by 5thyearcock

You know words have multiple definitions right? When I say people in Denver are way up high, I don't mean they've all smoked a bunch of pot.

uh, technical denotations are rigid for a reason. it's a little tough to do business otherwise.

Originally posted by 5thyearcock

Dependence is also not "doing something as a crutch."

i was obviously oversimplifying for a reason.



So you want me to be rigid, but you get to oversimplify. ???

I explained my reasoning for adding abuse into the convo in my last post. You brought up habituation, why?

As for addiction coming from dependency or vice versa, kind of the chicken and the egg. Again, they are essentially the same thing. Addiction is the broad term used, while dependence is the actual clinical measurement of it.
Edited by 5thyearcock on Apr 19, 2010 13:24:15
 
5thyearcock
offline
Link
 

Replied to both of you, IE makes quoting a real bitch. Time saving move on my part, apologies.

 
5thyearcock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16


also, i'm not sure why we're suddenly hyper-focusing on psychiatry.


Because substance abuse/addictions/mental health all relates to psychiatry.

Any and all of these things can be defined by anyone in many ways. If we don't have some standard to fall back on, it'd all just be a mess. The DSM-IV is the standard currently.

 
jxwhee
offline
Link
 
They both stem from the same broken mechanism, "I feel a certain way now, if I do this I will feel this way."

It's the start of all addictions. Sex, video games, shopping, hoarding, drinking, whatever.

It is a disease in the sense that you have to treat it and maintain it your entire life. I go to AA meetings daily and I haven't had a drinking problem in a long time. I will always have a thinking problem though. It's no one but the addicts responsibily though to treat his illness.
 
r87
offline
Link
 
dude i have no idea what you're talking about now. i think you're just running in circles
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 5thyearcock
Because substance abuse/addictions/mental health all relates to psychiatry.

Any and all of these things can be defined by anyone in many ways. If we don't have some standard to fall back on, it'd all just be a mess. The DSM-IV is the standard currently.


okay, but the original context of this thread was why they're considered diseases. obviously the APA definitions apply, but the AMA definitions are much more relevant here.

and again, this is just a continuum. you can find demarcation problems on any continuum, so...
 
Gturtle
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16


and again, this is just a continuum. you can find demarcation problems on any continuum, so...


NOT THE SPACE TIME CONTINUUM!
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
somehow missed this.

Originally posted by 5thyearcock
So you want me to be rigid, but you get to oversimplify. ???

no. the definitions are rigid, i was just oversimplifying to help others understand. if you already understand, then great.

Originally posted by 5thyearcock
I explained my reasoning for adding abuse into the convo in my last post. You brought up habituation, why?

because habituation breeds dependence and dependence breeds addiction. this threefold model is very, very, very common.

Originally posted by 5thyearcock
As for addiction coming from dependency or vice versa, kind of the chicken and the egg. Again, they are essentially the same thing. Addiction is the broad term used, while dependence is the actual clinical measurement of it.

maybe in some parts of psychiatry, but i am flat-out telling you that dependency and addiction are separate categories in medicine. for starters, there's a big deal about the difference between alcohol dependence and alcoholism when it comes to treatment, and your abuse angle is part of that.
 
Link
 
JMO but I don't think either are a disease tbh.
 
wormser1971
no title
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by UsCtRoJaNs1820
JMO but I don't think either are a disease tbh.


Dammm, Now we have to think? I am out!
 
Raid
offline
Link
 
I don't drink, but a friend of mine does, and is rabidly addicted.

the fact of the matter is some people are genetically disposed to relying on drinking, It's been shown time and time again... all because you don't ruin your life with alcohol doesn't mean that people going through the trials of it are just weak willed people.

as for obesity, I don't have much to talk about on that one, it's a life choice for many that's for sure. But for people with thyroid disorder it's not a choice at all.

I myself have a really slow metabolism, and I don't know what causes it. I get out to the Y to exorcise at least 3 times a week, I try to eat as healthy as I can provided my income (which often leaves me not eating at all for weeks) and yet I cannot seem to lose much weight. I'm about 5'9" and 290 lbs, so I'm fairly severely overweight and the doctors just tell me the same thing 'I don't know'

I've had tests for diabetes, among other things, but none came back conclusive of anything. So maybe it's just that I am going to be a heavier person, maybe I just don't do enough exorcise to kick my metabolism up to a normal person's rate... It probably doesn't help that I don't eat much since it actually tells your body to slow down metabolism when you take in less food.

So in short, for some few people these things are a disease, or at least a disorder. But to the vast majority who claim these things it's not true, many people drink solely because they enjoy it, the same with many people who eat too much and lay about. But it's not fair to generalize in such wide spectrums as to say that all obese people and all alcoholics are just weak willed people.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.