User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > More clarification from Bort re: Promotions
Page:
 
Argonut
online
Link
 
double post srry
Edited by Argonut on Jan 20, 2010 15:07:23
 
Jiddy78
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catch22
I just got done talking to Bort to get a more clear cut definition of how things should be taking place:

NOTE - this is ONLY for teams submitting demotion requests. If you do not submit a request, the default process (two levels for playoff teams, one level for non-playoff teams) will take place.

Summary:

If you won your conference or were clearly superior to the teams in your league (for example, you went 18-0 and lost in the CCG), you are going to move up two levels.
If you made the playoffs and every one is below the cap, you are going to move up one level.
If you didn't make the playoffs and every one is below the cap, you can remain at the same level.
Some exceptions will be made - for example if you only made the playoffs because 8 teams in your league were CPU, then we will evaluate that and you could possibly remain at the same level if all of your players are below the cap.

So for the ten or so teams that I told the wrong information too - my apologies. I'm going to go back through and review the tickets I closed and correct.

Hope this clears things up. If you fall under the above and have had Support tell you otherwise, please send me a pm.

Catch


Support ticket submitted.
 
Jagsfan2010
offline
Link
 
thankx
 
Mindor
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Argonut
Originally posted by Mindor

I hate this rule,I have 1 player on my team lvl 30 the rest are all 26-28 and because we went to the championship game this season we have to get bumped up to cap 34?When the reality of it is we should only be cap 30.

Explain to me why you cant have it so that the highest lvl player on the team, come promotion time, determines where you will be?


Is that the Waverly team? If so then you are mistaken. You DO NOT have to go to 34. (2 players level 30 BTW) You go to 30 cap next season unless you request to go to 34 cap yourself.

You won your conference in 22 cap! (22 + 2 caps = 30)



Thanks for pointing that out .

 
bumph
offline
Link
 
wow, this is awesome news and pretty much what most of us http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3684463&page=1 were asking for.


As damage control I would suggest Bort have set of guidelines that Moderators and those replying to Support PM follow so that fuel isn't added to the fire as was in this case.
 
JackBeQuick
offline
Link
 

I am definitely happy with how this is being handled.
 
zroeder
offline
Link
 
So i am a GM of a team in a lvl 42 league we made the playoffs as a 5 seed. So we should go to maybe a AA league, but it is saying that our likely cap next season is lvl 46. So what should i be planning for?
 
WalterManning
offline
Link
 
Makes one think if closed leagues is still a better idea.
 
Catch22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by zroeder
So i am a GM of a team in a lvl 42 league we made the playoffs as a 5 seed. So we should go to maybe a AA league, but it is saying that our likely cap next season is lvl 46. So what should i be planning for?


46
 
reddogrw
HOOD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catch22
Originally posted by zroeder

So i am a GM of a team in a lvl 42 league we made the playoffs as a 5 seed. So we should go to maybe a AA league, but it is saying that our likely cap next season is lvl 46. So what should i be planning for?


46


even if they have players over level 46 on the team?

doesn't that go against the "playoff teams can go up 1 level if they have no players over the cap" rule?
 
bumph
offline
Link
 
red you might try re-reading or looking at his roster.He has no one over 46 and has players from 39-46 on his team. Where did you see anything about players over 46?
 
Catch22
offline
Link
 
like I said, have to get clarification from Bort - he just asked what he should be planning for and since it says likely cap is 46, that is what he should be planning for.
 
SteveMax58
offline
Link
 
C22...can you see about getting an option put in for a Cap-14 team to request demotion (i.e. to only "advance" to Cap-18) if they made the playoffs? Might make more sense to rename it to "Request League Level" instead?

I've read thru about 5 pages here and saw a few references to "request demotion" but you can't actually request this at Cap-14 (for obvious enough reasons I suppose). IDK if it works for a Cap-18 & higher team (i.e. can request Cap-22) but it seems this should have a more automated aspect to it. I've already started down the road of building a Cap-22 team (and let my entire O-line go because we couldnt possibly compete with Cap-22 teams) but wouldn't have if I knew I had the option of Cap-18. Not whining about it...just saying it should be a known option to future Cap-14 owners via the available in-game mechanism.
 
reddogrw
HOOD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bumph
red you might try re-reading or looking at his roster.He has no one over 46 and has players from 39-46 on his team. Where did you see anything about players over 46?


there are teams in his situation with players over level 46

like this one I co-own

http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=5659

the answer was given cart blanche - like it doesn't matter - this team mentioned has players over level 46 and it still shows level 46

fyi - we WANT to be in AA and the owner should have put in a request, but theoretically, we should be going to AA no matter what and not even have the option to be in a level 46-capped league

all season long we have recruited based on the premise we should be in AA based on how the promotion rules are written - now we might only go up 1 cap level even though we made the playoffs and have players over the next level cap
Edited by reddogrw on Jan 20, 2010 16:43:58
 
eqkoser
offline
Link
 
Bleh...I really wish this could be looked at on a case by case basis.

My team started season 13 with all level 1 players. The goal was to slow build, reach level 14 (for a 14 or 18 cap in S14), and start season 14 with everybody ready to go. But, we just so happened to be in an absolutely terrible casual 14cap league. It was horrible.

We made the playoffs, and lucked into a conference championship. It's not that my team is so awesome that we can compete in a 22 or 26 cap league, it's that most of the other teams sucked.

Here's the catch....We haven't even spent all of our skill points yet! We started season 13 as level 1's that didn't even spend skill points until mid-season!!!! But now we start S14 in a 22 cap league with a bunch of level 13's and a couple of level 14's.

If you're going to set limitations on "demotion" then you need to balance the leagues. Some leagues are full of great teams and are competitive almost every game. On the other hand, some have 1 or 2 good teams and a bunch of lame ducks....but you're setting the same promotion standards regardless of the imbalanced talent. Balance the leagues before you restrict demotion...otherwise you're penalizing owners/agents who are the most organized and structured (aka people who buy a crapload of flex points)
Edited by eqkoser on Jan 20, 2010 16:47:15
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.