User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Fundamental sim illogic is fundamentally illogical.
Page:
 
bobdakota
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tsherr
Originally posted by Joebarber

Agreed on all accounts. Sorry you spent the time writing it because Bort will ignore it.


In the old days, Bort would be in a thread like this, and post regularly. Not any longer. Perhaps he's losing interest at the same rate as the players?

T


I think he is too busy making the baseball MMORPG

Bort made the game while he was working another job. That is why I don't understand why the game is not better almost 2 years later. Bort got a lot more done when he had another job. This is his job now and he can't fix the broken shit. I mean really, what does he do all season.

I remember thinking "the game is fun, and if I don't boost, than I will be behind when the game gets relly good." I too like many others have not bought flex in a year. I would like to have a few more players and boost them all, but I am still holding off until the game gets better



 
Osmlol
offline
Link
 
How hard can it really be to change level up bonuses for certain position? ESP OT's... Tackling for an O player is stupid. Make you wonder how much bort knew about football at the time he starter making the sim...

"Offensive Tackles.. they must need tackling!"
 
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Why isn't "fixing broken league structure" on the changelog list of projects?


 
PP
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sleepingazure
I don't know griffin8r, but if anyone wants to troll this post, why not challenge the points made in the OP? You tell any of us why blocking works the way it's supposed to now or that there's a fundamental benefit to having attributes scaled the way they are or that those sliders make sense and are the best option conceivable.


I don't know griff either, but I think his OP is pretty nuts on (though I believe that the lvl up bonuses (point 1) and attrib system (point 6) deserve to be p far down the list of priorities...issues, but not as bad as some not on the list). In my mind, the day users can't post legit concerns is the day this game no longer has any chance of success, and I think one would be hard pressed to argue that griff's OP isn't comprised of legit concerns.

That said, I think Bort gets more of a bad rap than he deserves (I know he has from me at times in the past and most likely will again in the future). Having some programming exp myself, I can see how fixing the blocking issues is nearly like chasing down the Holy Grail. Programming intelligence and the ability to correctly react into dots is got to be a major MFer of a task.

As far as Bort only wanting "yes men" (couple of earlier posts), I believed that myself to a certain extent (even at my most frustrated, Hazy, Pain, Bones, DB (like him or hate him, he isn't a yes man) and a few others argued against that in my mind...Some other testers argue p strong the other way too though). That was blown to shit for me today when he offered me a tester slot. From the thread in the testers' forum about potential testers, it's painfully clear from the remarks that I'm not viewed as a "yes man," and I have no intentions of changing because of it (and it appears Bort would be disappointed if I did...from the posts, it appears that was a major part of why I was invited in).

I can tell you, from reading the threads, it certainly does appear that Bort truly wants to make this game better. I even read posts where he encourages testers to review the bugs forum for things to work on. Add it all up together, though I doubt I'll ever agree with everything and suspect this will often be rather frustrating, I can tell you that I believe he is trying to improve his product. I know there is currently more threads on blocking than any other topic. Take all of that for what little it's worth.

 
odt
offline
Link
 
griff is a good agent. I'm in a couple of private forums with him and have read a few of his posts in here and he's usually got some great insight onto things.
 
griffin8r
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PP
I can tell you, from reading the threads, it certainly does appear that Bort truly wants to make this game better. I even read posts where he encourages testers to review the bugs forum for things to work on. Add it all up together, though I doubt I'll ever agree with everything and suspect this will often be rather frustrating, I can tell you that I believe he is trying to improve his product. I know there is currently more threads on blocking than any other topic. Take all of that for what little it's worth.



My sarcastic sense of humor aside, I really do believe this, which is why I made sure my OP was comprised predominantly of issues, not personal feelings. My frustration with the sim is my own problem, and shouldn't poison the well when I'm trying to delineate problems that I see.
 
griffin8r
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by odt
griff is a good agent. I'm in a couple of private forums with him and have read a few of his posts in here and he's usually got some great insight onto things.


Much obliged. I think the smartest thing I've done recently was open BTF. It has been a great place to expend effort on analysis without fear of flame wars.
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
Nice job Griffin...spot on with everything. One point is that I think that the blocking interaction IS better this season. What has blown up is blocker decision making, which is so bad that it makes the blocking interaction improvement entirely lost.



 
griffin8r
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OttawaShane
Nice job Griffin...spot on with everything. One point is that I think that the blocking interaction IS better this season. What has blown up is blocker decision making, which is so bad that it makes the blocking interaction improvement entirely lost.


If you look at the changelog, he didn't change the blocking interaction, he just "leaned" it more in favor of the defense, which put a spotlight on how utterly broken it all is.

 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by griffin8r
If you look at the changelog, he didn't change the blocking interaction, he just "leaned" it more in favor of the defense, which put a spotlight on how utterly broken it all is.



This is from the October 5 changelog update:

- Pass blocking dynamics updated a bit; same formulas, but interaction is not quite so bouncy

He later tweaked things because there weren't many sacks during preseason or testing or whatever.

I don't disagree with your fundamental point though that things are pretty much broken and need serious fixing. We've seen similar smart dissections of the problems here accompanied by pleas for Bort to update the basic sim rather than continuing to put bandaids on top of bandaids.

I really hope that Bort is working on a fundamental reworking of the game, but doubt it will ever happen.
 
griffin8r
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OttawaShane
This is from the October 5 changelog update:

- Pass blocking dynamics updated a bit; same formulas, but interaction is not quite so bouncy

He later tweaked things because there weren't many sacks during preseason or testing or whatever.

I don't disagree with your fundamental point though that things are pretty much broken and need serious fixing. We've seen similar smart dissections of the problems here accompanied by pleas for Bort to update the basic sim rather than continuing to put bandaids on top of bandaids.

I really hope that Bort is working on a fundamental reworking of the game, but doubt it will ever happen.


I missed that one. Should be paying better attention to the changelog. O_O
 
Link
 
Great Post and valid points, can't say that I don't like the new additions to the game over the last 2 months, honestly, the most forward progress the game has had since I have started. Are there things broke, for damn sure, but one thing that I feel has still been unaddressed.....

Why at LV.28 do players go to auto - pilot?

What I mean by this is, once you hit the LV.28 wall, you go to 100 XP for games, and 25 for training. In turn, alot of agents with only high level players end up quitting the game, there has to be a way to fix the XP per LV. after LV.28.

Why do Capped League's stop at LV.38 or so?

If you have a LV.39 player, or let's say a LV.49, you are phucked, and have to back up because you are on a No Cap team that has LV.70's or even LV.55+'s. We need to have caps the embrace the waves of players that have been created. Bort and comp. have nailed the caps to a tee all the way to LV.38, and to be honest, many LV.55 - 58+ players are better then the LV.70 players that are out there, but there are alot, and I mean ALOT of lost players that are in that LV.39 - LV.50 or so Gray Zone.

 
kentrol72
offline
Link
 
Spot on by the OP, every point!

Originally posted by F8n4tune

Agree with it all but especially the bold. In a game where EVERY player should be viable regardless of level as in real life we have teams full of like built and level players.

NO NFL team has a 52 man roster of the exact playing/skill level of players no matter what age. It's kind of crazy for a football game imo.


You know, I remember right after the change was made on how to fund players for EQ (the creation of the EQ Fund) and Owners were complaining about not having enough money to equip their teams at the higher levels, Bort chimed in an made a mention that by Season 10 or so, teams would have to be made up of different skill levels, like every real team sport, to make up for the players reaching the end, downward spiral of their career.

But the creation of these LVL Cap leagues seems to have killed that from ever happening.

Sorry but I will be laughing about this for weeks
Originally posted by tsherr
I may be the only person who knows this, but when the offense huddles up, the QB actually tells the players what sort of play they are going to run. So when it's a passing play, the o-linemen are prepared for that and block according, and the same on a running play. The idea that the o-linemen should have one setting for an entire game is ridiculous.
T
 
griffin8r
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kentrol72
But the creation of these LVL Cap leagues seems to have killed that from ever happening.


All to placate the people who want their teams to be competitive throughout one group of dots' careers.

 
odt
offline
Link
 
Most of these issues will be very hard to fix because changing the fundamental coding is going to be hard even if they are partitioned into different functions. Since bort is the only coder and also has to do daily maintenance things this just might never happen.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.