User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > XP bonus for playing at or above your level
Page:
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
So let's do that.

1000 FP to me for the suggestion.
 
Saris
offline
Link
 
I may be totally wrong, but level based modifiers to experience could create more problems than they would solve.

A possibly safer solution would be to apply a league wide level based modfier to team income. Maybe exponential(?), with say a league that has a mean level of 15 bringing in at least twice as much cash as a league with a mean value of 10. The net result would be pro leagues would make considerably more than they do currently while lower leagues would make less than they currently do.

Once people start to hit their next equipment upgrades ($50k per), greatly increased training costs, and minimum salaries for high-level players, they'd start to be forced into more competitive leagues.
Last edited Jun 6, 2008 19:00:55
 
TheSeanTeam
offline
Link
 
I don't think there should be a bonus of any kind. We should not promote mediocrity. A bonus of any kind will lead people to try to exploit this.

The basis for a rule like this is to prevent higher level guys from playing in lower level leagues.

There should just be no XP for people who are above the average for the league (in addition to hard cap for those significantly higher). If people want to bring ringers or if they want to play with their friends, they should be able to, but there will be consequences for such. The higher level they bring in will have their development slowed to the point where while they may pile up the wins, they will allow people around them to catch up.

Another suggestion would be a performance modifier. If a level 30 wants to play in let's say the level 10-20 bracket, he will perform like he's level 20. Have the computer ignore the skill points he put in for the last 10 levels, in addition to ignoring any equipment not suitable for a level 20 player.

 
TxSteve
Not A Mod
offline
Link
 
holes -

- teams tell players not to boost so they can max experience - this could hurt your revenues - as from a business stand point - you'd rather have that flex point money at the beginning of a season - instead of 40 days later

- after a certain point; you can't control the level of your team vs other teams in your conference - so that team that has an inactive owner or all cpu players is actually hurting me now...instead of just those few players he signed

- it could hurt team unity - 'if we didn't have that level 19; we'd have gotten better exp (standard mmorpg fare)

- you'll have players screaming 'i can't get on a team because i'm too high of a level'


other ideas-
- tie exp bonus into team chemistry to further promote keeping teams together - "oh - your chemistry is in the 70's - here's 70% of the exp you would have gotten"

- exp bonus for beating or keeping a game close to a team that is better than you
- exp bonus for demolishing a team that is worse than you
- exp bonus for beating a team similar to you in level
ie - bonuses based on accomplishments - you'd have to devise a formula based on overall team scouting report i suppose (though that can currently be jimmied with)

make it performance based instead of just - you showed up to get your ass kicked - here's an exp bonus

I think this could be cool. - that team was way better than us; 3 avg lvls per position; but through tactics and good play; we kept it within 3 - we lost; but at least we got the extra exp

 
KillaCheetah
offline
Link
 
Just for my own reasonings, what level are we aiming to be at when our player retires?

100? 75? What's the deal?

At current pace, and the way you're dropping in exp per game, you might get 4 levels next season if you're a season 3 player. 3 with boosting puts it at 7 total.

If we're looking at players capping at level 100, you need to extend the XP as it is. If you're looking to have it around 70, it'll wind up being that way.
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by KillaCheetah
Just for my own reasonings, what level are we aiming to be at when our player retires?

100? 75? What's the deal?

At current pace, and the way you're dropping in exp per game, you might get 4 levels next season if you're a season 3 player. 3 with boosting puts it at 7 total.

If we're looking at players capping at level 100, you need to extend the XP as it is. If you're looking to have it around 70, it'll wind up being that way.


It would be pretty amazing to see someone reach level 70 the way things are now.
 
ZachG650
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Serenity
I'd almost prefer just a small boost of XP for players playing against players who are higher level and no penalty otherwise

agreed
 
Renomitsu
offline
Link
 
How about high-level players that are stuck on long contracts in the low leagues? Would they just sit there, watching the level ones gain levels six or seven times faster than they do? Are we looking for these 8-season veterans to have the same level as the ones who have been here for three seasons, but have played in USA Pro and thusly play against higher levels? I could imagine some guy having his player in for one play and getting XP when his opponents are 30 levels higher.
 
TurboBoxer
offline
Link
 
I like the idea, because it would mean backups would get more XP, and there would less complaining from them from not getting enough playing time.

I agree with Serenity in that there shouldn't be a penalty for higher levels. All teams should have a few stars so the game isn't a coin flip. If the team has a lot of stars, then they will probably win and move to the next level. If they throw a game to stay in the league, then im sure someone will make a thread and complain anyways and can be dealt with.
EDIT:Maybe make it if your team average is way above the league average, the team gets some sort of penalty instead of individual players...either XP or a cocky/overconfident (whatever) designation to the team and gives them a -10% in performance, or a daily fine. This way the owners have to think about which positions they want higher players in and make sure they dont go overboard.

i saw that someone suggested this earlier; but moving more teams up and down between seasons would help even the teams out.
Last edited Jun 6, 2008 20:19:48
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort


Levels could be based on:
1) The average level of the other team, weighted toward starters. A "better" team would be one that was, say, 3 levels higher than you on average. And worse, would be say, 3 levels lower (could be 4/5, dunno).
2) Or, the average level of the league, weighted towards the top. You get a bonus for being below the avg.

Shoot holes in it! What are the exploits?


1) weighted toward the starters is a bad idea since teams if they have say a level 18 and 16 LB that they rotate in platoon at a 99/0 sub pattern, they'll put the lower player as the starter to make their average level as low as possible.

2) isn't bad at all, but then you can sign a bunch of lowbies and never play them to bring down your team average.

What I would suggest is using the average level of players played in the game and compare those two. The only exploit here is if one team doesn't play their starters to get their scrubs more experience, but is it that much of an exploit since their starters won't get any experience and they'll likely lose the game.

Here is pseudo-code on however you are handling things...
RunPlay() - foreach player in play { game.totalTeamLevels += player.level }
EndGame() - game.avgPlayerLevel = game.totalTeamLevels / 12 / game.totalplays

Simply compare the average level of the teams that played and modify EXP based on that. It's fairly simple and shouldn't add much computationally to the game run time. I'm a fan of giving more of an EXP bonus, then a penalty. Simply because a team can't help who they play. My team shouldn't be penalized if we play a team that was gutted mid way through the season. Half the league would get normal EXP and we would get a penalty. Not cool. In addition, if a league started collecting crap teams, the top of the league that would get promoted would be getting less EXP than those teams in the league above making their transition harder.
 
InRomoWeTrust
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
I'd say just slant the leagues for an exp bonus based on rank. Basically, D would have say a 15% increase, BBB would have 10, A would have 7, AA would have 5, and AAA would have 3

Pro League would recieve 0 bonus to exp. Those percentage are probably too high even. The trouble is that a player who has played longer doesn't want to see himself passed up by some new blood. It really isn't nice to see someone make a player and catch you in level in a matter of 2 seasons.
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
NOTE: Any EXP bonus should be based PER PLAYER, not per TEAM. So you couldn't toss a few level 20's in with a few level 5's and see the level 20's make out with a ton of experience.

Perhaps code it so anyone on the lower team only gets the bonus if their level is below the average level of the opponent?
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mat McBriar
I'd say just slant the leagues for an exp bonus based on rank. Basically, D would have say a 15% increase, BBB would have 10, A would have 7, AA would have 5, and AAA would have 3

Pro League would recieve 0 bonus to exp. Those percentage are probably too high even. The trouble is that a player who has played longer doesn't want to see himself passed up by some new blood. It really isn't nice to see someone make a player and catch you in level in a matter of 2 seasons.


This is the opposite of what it should be.

This ENCOURAGES players to go to lower leagues.
 
morgan3
offline
Link
 
This wud not be implemented for Season 3 correct if it is approved? Because this totally kills my idea of signing with this Africa AA OWNAGE team. I was expecting to just whoop on people and now I see this suggestion. I just want to know before I sign if this "could" be implemented for Season 3 or and idea for Season 4
 
JBen33
offline
Link
 
i love itd do me good cuz im lvl 5 doin decent against lvl 14 avg teams
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.