User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Tagging players is ready
Page:
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tjplainclothesmod82
I think DB recognizes that it will work now, but he just laments all the time it would take to set up a proper DAI with tagging. He'd rather Bort remove some of the realism in favor of a simpler AI.


I'm pretty sure you are trolling with this realism schpeal, so I'm done.
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by tjplainclothesmod82

I think DB recognizes that it will work now, but he just laments all the time it would take to set up a proper DAI with tagging. He'd rather Bort remove some of the realism in favor of a simpler AI.


I'm pretty sure you are trolling with this realism schpeal, so I'm done.


Not really. I think alot of people come here for something that is as logically similar to football as possible. Putting random penalties on things reminds me of the DE nerf. If you make the sim and the gameplanning as realistic as possible, the right result will be reached naturally. Otherwise we can completely fuck over the metagame and just randomly buff and nerf things until they look like football, but don't really interact like football.
Edited by tjplainclothesmod82 on Sep 21, 2009 23:01:05
 
Kirghiz
offline
Link
 
As an owner of four rushing QB's I am glad that Bort is getting this ready for next season. The teams that don't try to stop the rushing QB's now still won't next season, and the teams that already do well against them will continue to do so. At least now though the bad DC's will have to stop using the custom TE slots as a crutch for their inability to stop rushing QB's.

If for some reason the rushing QB becomes a dinosaur in normal leagues because of this though, I am sure that the rushing QB's will either start putting points in passing attributes or move them to lolcasual and we will start seeing the closest thing to an option offense as we will ever get in GLB.
 
tragula
title
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
But no, I'll reply to this with what I think should be the case.

Custom Slots should have some sort of penalty incurred, whether that be energy, a hit to attributes, or not 100% "uptime". Or hell, give a vision boost to the defense.

Keep the custom slots. But make it so that if a team forces TE2 to be in the game, he isn't nearly as effective as if he was just the normal TE.


Nerfing is not a good solution. (even though killing custom slot may work)

The best options imo:
1) Improve the scouting tool to save up the time
2) Make changes to the DAI to allow packages, and let the offense custom slots be scanned from the package. So you have
normal I 1st and 10:
package A
package B

package A :
-powerback
-elusive back
- reciving TE + elsuive back
...
package B:
- blitz (doesn't care about offense custom slot)
Will make the DAI smaller and easier

3) Improve the AA tools. Let the DC/OC use more generic gameplans and relay on the AA to pick the better plays.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Kirghiz
As an owner of four rushing QB's I am glad that Bort is getting this ready for next season. The teams that don't try to stop the rushing QB's now still won't next season, and the teams that already do well against them will continue to do so. At least now though the bad DC's will have to stop using the custom TE slots as a crutch for their inability to stop rushing QB's.

If for some reason the rushing QB becomes a dinosaur in normal leagues because of this though, I am sure that the rushing QB's will either start putting points in passing attributes or move them to lolcasual and we will start seeing the closest thing to an option offense as we will ever get in GLB.


The problem with rushing QBs (the ones that dont throw), is that extreme builds tend to break the sim. And then nerfs/rebalancing/buffing of defense happens.

 
RobertRJS
offline
Link
 
bort listened to me (and others). hoorah
 
Argonut
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kirghiz
As an owner of four rushing QB's I am glad that Bort is getting this ready for next season. The teams that don't try to stop the rushing QB's now still won't next season, and the teams that already do well against them will continue to do so. At least now though the bad DC's will have to stop using the custom TE slots as a crutch for their inability to stop rushing QB's.

If for some reason the rushing QB becomes a dinosaur in normal leagues because of this though, I am sure that the rushing QB's will either start putting points in passing attributes or move them to lolcasual and we will start seeing the closest thing to an option offense as we will ever get in GLB.


What a rushing QB will need is the option to either keep running or pass on the run.
 
RobertRJS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Originally posted by Kirghiz

As an owner of four rushing QB's I am glad that Bort is getting this ready for next season. The teams that don't try to stop the rushing QB's now still won't next season, and the teams that already do well against them will continue to do so. At least now though the bad DC's will have to stop using the custom TE slots as a crutch for their inability to stop rushing QB's.

If for some reason the rushing QB becomes a dinosaur in normal leagues because of this though, I am sure that the rushing QB's will either start putting points in passing attributes or move them to lolcasual and we will start seeing the closest thing to an option offense as we will ever get in GLB.


The problem with rushing QBs (the ones that dont throw), is that extreme builds tend to break the sim. And then nerfs/rebalancing/buffing of defense happens.



pure extreme rushing QBs will die, as they should.

Now QBs will be built to rush but be adequate enough to somewhat be a threat to throw. As they should.
 
RobertRJS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Argonut
Originally posted by Kirghiz

As an owner of four rushing QB's I am glad that Bort is getting this ready for next season. The teams that don't try to stop the rushing QB's now still won't next season, and the teams that already do well against them will continue to do so. At least now though the bad DC's will have to stop using the custom TE slots as a crutch for their inability to stop rushing QB's.

If for some reason the rushing QB becomes a dinosaur in normal leagues because of this though, I am sure that the rushing QB's will either start putting points in passing attributes or move them to lolcasual and we will start seeing the closest thing to an option offense as we will ever get in GLB.


What a rushing QB will need is the option to either keep running or pass on the run.


this, there does need to be a roll out pass play.
 
Primate
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by tjplainclothesmod82

Your point is well-taken, but the fact is that such athletes DO exist in football, and the only reason they don't succeed and reach the highest levels is that defensive coordinators can minimize their one-dimensional skills by doing precisely what tagging players allows DCs to do.

So basically you could take the cheap and easy route and prevent specialized builds at all, or you could take the realistic route and allow them, but give DCs the tools to make them ineffective. I applaud Bort for taking the realistic way.


The only thing missing is that "real life" DC's get paid for putting in 8 hours a day.


This is the biggest issue, imo. That basket case of an ai interface really adds to the problem. This will make it nearly unusable.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Yeah, as much as I hate to say it, casual teams are looking more and more enticing.

I was against them to begin with, but coordinating just seems more and more like a waste of time...from being jaded, from getting even more time-consuming, and from being a game of rock paper scissors (which is a good balancing mechanic, but a terrible gameplay mechanic).


No kidding. Teams I'm on are shedding coordinators like crazy. The burnout factor is incredible.

And with every layer of complexity that gets piled on, yet another layer is required to compensate.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by RobertRJS
pure extreme rushing QBs will die, as they should.


Why do you say that? Defenses will still react ridiculously slow to them, even with tagging. Most of the time defenses don't even react until the QB is at the line of scrimmage.
 
Kirghiz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RobertRJS
pure extreme rushing QBs will die, as they should.


Supposing you're right, what should happen to the people that built them and now are forced to retire them? Should they be penalized 30% of their flex because Bort was negligent to let it go on for four or five seasons before putting an end to it? It was a viable build for four or five seasons after all. Longer than Flames54's extreme speed builds were at any rate.
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Argonut
Originally posted by Kirghiz

As an owner of four rushing QB's I am glad that Bort is getting this ready for next season. The teams that don't try to stop the rushing QB's now still won't next season, and the teams that already do well against them will continue to do so. At least now though the bad DC's will have to stop using the custom TE slots as a crutch for their inability to stop rushing QB's.

If for some reason the rushing QB becomes a dinosaur in normal leagues because of this though, I am sure that the rushing QB's will either start putting points in passing attributes or move them to lolcasual and we will start seeing the closest thing to an option offense as we will ever get in GLB.


What a rushing QB will need is the option to either keep running or pass on the run.


times a million
 
Primate
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kirghiz
Originally posted by RobertRJS

pure extreme rushing QBs will die, as they should.


Supposing you're right, what should happen to the people that built them and now are forced to retire them? Should they be penalized 30% of their flex because Bort was negligent to let it go on for four or five seasons before putting an end to it? It was a viable build for four or five seasons after all. Longer than Flames54's extreme speed builds were at any rate.


Tell that to the hundreds?... thousands? of DE's that got screwed in the same way a few seasons ago.
Edited by Primate on Sep 21, 2009 23:55:17
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.