User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Coaches - Item Crafting
Page:
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AngryDragon
I think it would be cool if all coaches could craft items but the ones who specialize in crafting should make the best items. That way all coaches would have something fun to do. They may also decide to change directions or career paths if that is even possible.

I guess I cannot see the big picture yet so there may be other fun things for the coaches to do that I am not aware of.


The one problem if all coaches can craft items is you end up with too many crafted items then.

Just have to find other fun things for coaches who don't craft....
 
Gary.
offline
Link
 
What if each player had another slot? A coach could then fill the slot.

Edit for proper punctuation.
Edited by Gary_Hughes on Sep 4, 2009 20:56:47
 
Gary.
offline
Link
 
Could you give us a description of what you have for coaches already? Or is there already a thread for that?
 
trentw
offline
Link
 
I also have to say I have a fear that this is just another way to appease season 1 players / teams that are now facing the decline. Lets face it where are all the coaches going to go? To the season one teams they are already on. I would like to see coaches have to start in the Uncapped Minors or lower then every season after that be allowed to move up.

So:
First Season - Uncapped Minors or lower
Second Season - AA or lower
Third Season - AAA or lower
Fourth Season Pro or lower
Fifth Season World League or lower

 
DAWG
GROWL
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by trentw
I also have to say I have a fear that this is just another way to appease season 1 players / teams that are now facing the decline. Lets face it where are all the coaches going to go? To the season one teams they are already on. I would like to see coaches have to start in the Uncapped Minors or lower then every season after that be allowed to move up.

So:
First Season - Uncapped Minors or lower
Second Season - AA or lower
Third Season - AAA or lower
Fourth Season Pro or lower
Fifth Season World League or lower

One of the founding members of GLB Addicts organization/family


Are you talking about Moral boosts now?
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by trentw
I also have to say I have a fear that this is just another way to appease season 1 players / teams that are now facing the decline.


It was always conceived as a way to make decline less painful. And what, specifically, is wrong with that?

Decline is necessary so that every generation of players gets its chance to be among the best; but giving players the option of something to do after decline keeps the character from just being totally removed from use. It's the win-win solution.
 
trentw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by trentw

I also have to say I have a fear that this is just another way to appease season 1 players / teams that are now facing the decline.


It was always conceived as a way to make decline less painful. And what, specifically, is wrong with that?

Decline is necessary so that every generation of players gets its chance to be among the best; but giving players the option of something to do after decline keeps the character from just being totally removed from use. It's the win-win solution.


Yeah so why not make coaches work their way up just as players have to do?
 
trentw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DAWG
Originally posted by trentw

I also have to say I have a fear that this is just another way to appease season 1 players / teams that are now facing the decline. Lets face it where are all the coaches going to go? To the season one teams they are already on. I would like to see coaches have to start in the Uncapped Minors or lower then every season after that be allowed to move up.

So:
First Season - Uncapped Minors or lower
Second Season - AA or lower
Third Season - AAA or lower
Fourth Season Pro or lower
Fifth Season World League or lower

One of the founding members of GLB Addicts organization/family


Are you talking about Moral boosts now?


No just saying it would be a nice shake up to the game if all the retiring season 1 players were not able to go to the team they were already on to offset the decline. 5 seasons from now if your team is still in the World League then you can join them.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by trentw
Yeah so why not make coaches work their way up just as players have to do?


Because the top levels of the game should always have the best of everything.

WL teams should have entire coaching staffs before minor league teams have coaches.

Wouldn't it be silly to have more coaches on minor league teams than on the top ones?
 
trentw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by trentw

Yeah so why not make coaches work their way up just as players have to do?


Because the top levels of the game should always have the best of everything.

WL teams should have entire coaching staffs before minor league teams have coaches.

Wouldn't it be silly to have more coaches on minor league teams than on the top ones?


No not really, you have tons of season 2 players and later who have been grinding away for over a year now with the promise that decline would eventually come and even the playing field only to have new stuff constantly implemented to keep the the season ones on top.
 
Saris
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Ah, that's an interesting take. You can only teach the SA's you learned? It would probably make the +% bonuses more popular.


The danger in that is that it kind of pigeonholes some positions as crafters. I'd assume there wouldn't be enough coaches for every player to get a crafted item, in all likelyhood teams will be forced to be pretty selective. But we can be sure that primary threats will be at the top of the list, every team will give one to their HB's at least.

I could see halfback coaches being forced to become crafters since their SA selection is so strong, likewise almost every team would want a HB crafter.
Edited by Saris on Sep 4, 2009 21:35:56
 
pottsman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Saris
Originally posted by Bort

Ah, that's an interesting take. You can only teach the SA's you learned? It would probably make the +% bonuses more popular.


The danger in that is that it kind of pigeonholes some positions as crafters. I'd assume there wouldn't be enough coaches for every player to get a crafted item, in all likelyhood teams will be forced to be pretty selective. But we can be sure that primary threats will be at the top of the list, every team will give one to their HB's at least.

I could see halfback coaches being forced to become crafters since their SA selection is so strong, likewise almost every team would want a HB crafter.


And almost no former linebackers will be crafters.
 
ijg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
They will be able to do it in one step if they are over 440. However, they will have to be a FA, and then be signed by the team in a coach spot. Otherwise it would not know which spot to put them in, or if the team wanted them, etc.


What do you think of eliminating chem hit for either all players who make it to day 440 or specifically for players who become coaches? It doesn't really seem to make sense that a popular player retiring to become a coach should be bad for team chemistry.

Maybe if you hire a coach who last played for that team you get a +1 to chem to offset the -1 when he was released? Coaches hired by teams they didn't play for wouldn't impact chem.
 
DAWG
GROWL
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ijg
Originally posted by Bort

They will be able to do it in one step if they are over 440. However, they will have to be a FA, and then be signed by the team in a coach spot. Otherwise it would not know which spot to put them in, or if the team wanted them, etc.


What do you think of eliminating chem hit for either all players who make it to day 440 or specifically for players who become coaches? It doesn't really seem to make sense that a popular player retiring to become a coach should be bad for team chemistry.

Maybe if you hire a coach who last played for that team you get a +1 to chem to offset the -1 when he was released? Coaches hired by teams they didn't play for wouldn't impact chem.


Personally I feel teams shouldn't have to take a chemistry hit for basically a mandatory retirement.That should be addressed before it becomes a problem.
 
EagleOtto
offline
Link
 
Crafting idea is a good idea at heart, but if only select players on a team will benefit this, it really screws over players that aren't best buds with the coach, or has an in with the owner.....

Also we will start to see FAs demand having a crafted piece to sign somewhere.
I just hope if this is done its done in a way that a good majority of players could benefit from it...

Or it will just become another way for the best players to become even better (just like endorsements)

I'm very eager to see how this all turns out, i just hope that 'fairness' for all players is taken into consideration.

Edited by EagleOtto on Sep 4, 2009 22:07:09
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.