User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Coaches - ideas for them to spend money on (and other ideas)
Page:
 
pottsman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Saris
I kind of liked the idea of being able to let each coach hire staff members who could provide different options or bonuses to the team.


Definitely a key thing. If a team can have 5 coaches, there should be at least 7, 10 roles that coaches can have, which means you need to chose between having a "this" coach and a "that" coach. Kinda like if teams weren't able to sign linebackers if they wanted to have fullbacks.
 
AngryDragon
offline
Link
 
I can see the training chains being exploited over time. It would probably take some time to figure it out but eventually they would be exploited and then nerfed.

So there would be whining X2.
 
Iron Maiden
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AngryDragon
I can see the training chains being exploited over time. It would probably take some time to figure it out but eventually they would be exploited and then nerfed.

So there would be whining X2.


I agree. Coach abilities should relate to how a player can be built. I can see it affecting how they perform, though.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Iron Maiden
I agree. Coach abilities should relate to how a player can be built. I can see it affecting how they perform, though.


I think you meant "shouldn't", right?
 
Saris
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by christianhall
Also, the additional skill level of the 'Seamstress' could increase the odds of getting the half of the advanced EQ that you would like


That's an interesting idea. Give the option to hire a famous staff member for a day at an extreme cost to the coach. So in the case of a seamstress if a coach wanted to blow half his seasonal salary on a famous seamstress, one could be available for a day that might even allow players on the team to pick the attributes they wanted from an AE when recycling.

This would actually add an interesting element to the game if every coach's salary was equal and fixed. If there were enough staff and equipment options, providing differing bonuses for different periods of time; there could be a lot of strategy going into what a coach spent their limited pool of funds on and when during the season they spent it.
Edited by Saris on Sep 3, 2009 21:50:24
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
The one thing I do know, is whatever roles coaches play, they should not have the option, to in anyway boost speed/agil/or str, for any play, or any situation. Regardless of what happens, you need to make sure speed/agi/str cannot be affected by coaches. Go in any direction but leave these att's out of he equation.
 
jearly
offline
Link
 
Let the coach build a training center - the coach could then gradually upgrade it with different equipment/rooms/tracks to help players train better.
-Though this may be better for an Owner to have (hint. hint)
 
AngryDragon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by David Stern
The one thing I do know, is whatever roles coaches play, they should not have the option, to in anyway boost speed/agil/or str, for any play, or any situation. Regardless of what happens, you need to make sure speed/agi/str cannot be affected by coaches. Go in any direction but leave these att's out of he equation.


I think we have already learned this lesson with attribute VAs.
 
jearly
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by David Stern
The one thing I do know, is whatever roles coaches play, they should not have the option, to in anyway boost speed/agil/or str, for any play, or any situation. Regardless of what happens, you need to make sure speed/agi/str cannot be affected by coaches. Go in any direction but leave these att's out of he equation.


agreed for in-game boosts, I think they could affect how well a player trains.

I think vision/confidence/stamina etc. could be in-game boosts.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Saris
That's an interesting idea. Give the option to hire a famous staff member for a day at an extreme cost to the coach. So in the case of a seamstress if a coach wanted to blow half his seasonal salary on a famous seamstress, one could be available for a day that might even allow players on the team to pick the attributes they wanted from an AE when recycling.

This would actually add an interesting element to the game if every coach's salary was equal and fixed. If there were enough staff and equipment options, providing differing bonuses for different periods of time; there could be a lot of strategy going into what a coach spent their limited pool of funds on and when during the season they spent it.


Hm, I hadn't thought about a fixed coach salary idea. It would add a strategic element. Could accomplish the same thing by having fixed amount of "coaching points" or some other name, etc.
 
Saris
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Hm, I hadn't thought about a fixed coach salary idea. It would add a strategic element. Could accomplish the same thing by having fixed amount of "coaching points" or some other name, etc.


Exactly, although you'd have to decide if you wanted unspent cash to carry over to subsequent seasons. Or if the coach's fund was considered to be more of a bar(similar to morale or energy) that refills each season.
Edited by Saris on Sep 3, 2009 22:04:19
Edited by Saris on Sep 3, 2009 21:59:57
Edited by Saris on Sep 3, 2009 21:59:16
 
NiborRis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
So, perhaps some of these ideas are good, but should just be skills for the coach to buy with his skill points, and then he can do them X number of times per day/week/etc.

Or perhaps every ability described here should require skills to be built up along side the cash requirements.

There is definitely a per-team limit on coaches. There's only so many slots.


Yes, the cash component is just dangerous, imo. It's currently too easy to farm cash from a team and that's difficult to change; this means cash as a limiter is not only not effective, but it encourages more farming of teams for cash.

I think training options is fine - as a coaching skill - it unlocks some other build styles for player types without being particularly overpowering. I don't follow all the build models for all positions, but I don't think there are any points where a positional build just completely falls flat on itself. It's more that someone will be able to efficiently build a Blocking > Str OT, for example, without sacrificing training value down the road, or leave stamina low and train confidence up higher, etc. I doubt we'll see any position that requires a build from a coached training option (and by position I mean "WR" and not "Slant route WR")

Coaching abilities that affect building does have to be done VERY carefully, There won't be nearly enough coaches available for all the lower level players, which means coaches will be in SUPER high demand if they're important to making a maxed out character for the pros. Most of them will be available only to people they currently work with, which would be discouraging to newer players who don't have the networking in place for that. I think that would be more damaging then fun.
 
whitewolf
offline
Link
 
I have to agree that coaches should in no way affect the builds of players in a permanent way. That will definitely lead to farm teams and serious inequities. Right now every build has the same exact potential, we all create and build players on an even playing field. Doing something to reduce that parity is a terrible idea.

Coaches affecting the sim itself, via morale-boosting skills, energy-restoring skills, play-effectiveness skills, etc are a potential fun thing I think. Coaches need to have level restrictions just like players though in terms of the leagues they are able to be in.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by whitewolf
I have to agree that coaches should in no way affect the builds of players in a permanent way. That will definitely lead to farm teams and serious inequities. Right now every build has the same exact potential, we all create and build players on an even playing field. Doing something to reduce that parity is a terrible idea.



Well said.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by whitewolf
I have to agree that coaches should in no way affect the builds of players in a permanent way. That will definitely lead to farm teams and serious inequities. Right now every build has the same exact potential, we all create and build players on an even playing field. Doing something to reduce that parity is a terrible idea.

Coaches affecting the sim itself, via morale-boosting skills, energy-restoring skills, play-effectiveness skills, etc are a potential fun thing I think. Coaches need to have level restrictions just like players though in terms of the leagues they are able to be in.


What if you could have "temporary training sessions" with a coach? Like, he gives you training gains as a bonus that lasts until the next game, or the end of the season, or something like that? Could be cool.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.