User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Koncorde is still trolling this thread? Sad. I reported him to Pallow, but as I said at the time, I never expected a mod to be held accountable.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde
If a WR on the weak side runs directly from the snap 90 degrees to his left towards the sideline, where is the correct position for him to take up?


shadow him, running parallel with him. coming up to the WR would leaving the CB burned if the WR turns up field.
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Exactly. First and foremost DO NOT LET THE WR GET BEHIND YOU.

Ask any CB which he'd rather give up...a 2 or 3 yd reception or a TD. The answer is pretty obvious.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde
Parallel? What advantage is that?

If they are 3 yards away at the snap, and you're set to 0 yard coverage...how close do you get?


If you are that anal about 0 yard coverage been 0 yards away, why the hell would you line up 3 yards away, why not just line up right next to him?

Parallel is the way to cover in that situation. I suppose you've never played CB before, have you?
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde
It would depend on the instructions I was given by the coach. In short - there is no "right" answer other than to not be beaten. If I was instructed to be 0 yards away from the WR I would move to 0 yards. If I am 3 yards away then then I will move closer.


Why not just line up 0 yards away? If you line up 3 yards away, you are already not "listening" to your coach anyway.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo

There is no coach in the world that is going to instruct his CB to move toward the WR at the start of the play for non-press coverage.


^This, even in press coverage, you don't move toward the WR at the start of the play, you just line up closer.
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo
There is no coach in the world that is going to instruct his CB to move toward the WR at the start of the play for non-press coverage.


And yet you instruct a CB in GLB to be 0 yards away despite the fact jamming, press coverage and funnelling don't exist and the knowledge that they may fail a vision check and make a really stupid first move?

The fact people are arguing NFL vs GLB really is going nowhere, the CB isn't reacting to the same stimuli, nor does he have the same capacity to learn and react. He has only 2 or 3 inputs for his behaviour, and everything has to be then accounted from that.

There are limitations, and there are side effects of the number of variables you can include or rule out. I've attempted to point out on numerous occasions where the logic lies in what a CB does, but apparently that's trolling.

As stated before; I need more examples to identify the origin of the movement. Formation, build, instructions, SA's etc.

The "fix" may be as simple as making the minimum distance between a WR and CB 0.5yds, as I'm not sure from where on a Dot a player is measured (for instance are Dots measured bullseye to bullseye, or circumference to circumference for the purpose of working out distance between each other?).
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by datongw
If you are that anal about 0 yard coverage been 0 yards away, why the hell would you line up 3 yards away, why not just line up right next to him?


Originally posted by datongw
Why not just line up 0 yards away? If you line up 3 yards away, you are already not "listening" to your coach anyway.


As raised by Trev, moving up closer to the LOS based on your coverage distance is a fair suggestion.

Though that doesn't change the potential for an auto-fake, or the potential to still step forward if there are underlying issues.

Originally posted by datongw
Parallel is the way to cover in that situation. I suppose you've never played CB before, have you?


I've never understood the "played CB before" logic. My point highlighted the conflict between GLB and the NFL logic and the fact that there is no advantage in GLB by being further away from the player (i.e. running parallel).
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde
a really stupid first move


To call it a really stupid first move is a huge understatement. It's an inexplicable move. One that we should not have to worry about even if we set our CBs to cover as tightly as possible.

Originally posted by Koncorde
The fact people are arguing NFL vs GLB really is going nowhere


Who said anything about the NFL?

Originally posted by Koncorde
There are limitations
As I previously responded to this: Originally posted by TrevJo
I don't think it's appropriate to tell us that GLB cannot do it. There are a lot of things in a sim like this that don't happen naturally, they require special attention. This is one of those things.


Originally posted by Koncorde
As stated before; I need more examples to identify the origin of the movement. Formation, build, instructions, SA's etc.


I suggest the test server.


We all agree that we don't know for sure what it is that the CB is reacting to. All of us except for you agree that there is no possible stimulus for which this is a reasonable reaction. I appreciate that you are trying to do your due diligence here, but it seems as though you are stubbornly refusing to look at this as a problem, rather than as an unvaoidable consequence of programming. I know that in my experience, I tend to fail to get problems solved when I refuse to accept that there is a problem.
Edited by TrevJo on Aug 31, 2009 19:43:50
Edited by TrevJo on Aug 31, 2009 19:41:24
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde
As raised by Trev, moving up closer to the LOS based on your coverage distance is a fair suggestion.

Though that doesn't change the potential for an auto-fake, or the potential to still step forward if there are underlying issues.


I agree with the bolded part. If the WR is lined up off the line, I'm not sure if it would be possible for the CB to line up close enough to avoid this problem. While I think a CB positioning fix is in order, it probably wouldn't be enough.

Originally posted by Koncorde
the fact that there is no advantage in GLB by being further away from the player (i.e. running parallel).


You're completely on your own on that one. There certainly is an advantage to running parallel, rather than moving toward the line of scrimmage, it is common sense. The many replays of CBs getting stepping forward and getting torched demonstrate why it is disadvantageous to move toward the line of scrimmage.
Edited by TrevJo on Aug 31, 2009 18:55:02
Edited by TrevJo on Aug 31, 2009 18:54:46
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sik Wit It

The advantage is you don't let the WR get behind you and take yourself out of the play just in case it's a wheel route or something like that.

The problem I have with this whole thing is first and foremost, a priority of a CB is to stay in front of the WR. Giving up a 2 or 3 yd reception (biting on a fake and stepping forward I guess), should NOT happen as much as it does.


 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
And the only guy who says you're trolling is jdbolick who is not the most mature poster. Nobody else said that...just ignore his personal attacks.

While I don't think you're trolling, I don't think you're being very productive when you keep saying basically it's a side-effect of other factors in the game, and basically it would be too complicated to fix. Is that the kind of spirit we have around here now? To just let bugs go because they're too difficult to find a fix for?
 
Signalsgt
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
And the only guy who says you're trolling is jdbolick who is not the most mature poster. Nobody else said that...just ignore his personal attacks.

While I don't think you're trolling, I don't think you're being very productive when you keep saying basically it's a side-effect of other factors in the game, and basically it would be too complicated to fix. Is that the kind of spirit we have around here now? To just let bugs go because they're too difficult to find a fix for?


Umm...the track record for fixing the easy bugs isn't exactly better then a D- effort at best, what makes you think a "hard" bug can be tracked down?
 
Shusta
offline
Link
 
Owned by Drk
Edited by DrkSandman on Aug 31, 2009 21:32:19
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde
I've attempted to point out on numerous occasions where the logic lies in what a CB does, but apparently that's trolling.

No, you're the one and only person arguing that this isn't a problem / bug / whatever. Do you notice that? You're the only person on your side, while everyone else says that you're wrong. And you're not dumb enough to be disagreeing legitimately. You don't believe the bullshit you're spewing, you're just saying it to be antagonistic. So yes, that's trolling. You're making up excuses to frustrate and antagonize people reporting a legitimate bug.

There is no logic in the CB stepping forward at the snap. None. All your excuses have been complete bullshit and every single person who posts in this thread has told you that you're wrong.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.