User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Opponent Scouting Page - need ideas
Page:
 
yello1
Preacher
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by driftinggrifter
Wanting way to much information spoon fed to you. There should be no way you should be able to see or know the exact or approx. amount of VA's/SA's if the build is closed. Same with any other of their attributes.


Spoon Fed???????????????????????????????????????

TOOOOO much information??????????????????????????????????????

LOL

Seriously L O L

This would be dedicating an entire player character, who after a day or two of saving up Scouting Points would only have a chance to know if ONE opposing players speed is over 50 or 75 or something vague like that. SAs and VAs I do not have worked out but they would be equally vague and costly.

You do realize that in the real world a scout can look at a player with a stop watch and tell you EXACTLY how fast he is in about ten seconds, right?

This "too much information" nonsense really cracks me up. Its a game about numbers. Not knowing what the numbers are makes it Pin the Tail on the Donkey stupid. Some way to garner some hint of the numbers would be a boon to the game. Not a detraction.
 
Saris
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
mainly to give a page where you can tag players on their roster for use your AI input options.


If I'm understanding this correctly then I'm kind of torn on the idea. On the one hand it sounds like a neat concept and might add more strategy to the game. But on the other it might just destroy a lot of diverse builds and remove a lot of strategy by making several positions cookie cutter.

First of all I think we could pretty much kiss every rushing QB in the game goodbye. I'm not in any way associated with a team that has a rushing QB, but I would assume that they'd have had to sacrifice a lot of their passing ability to become a viable runner. So if a player is really only viable for one situation and then only if he can catch his opponent off guard. If the opposing team were given the ability to adjust to that player, the situation is no longer viable and neither is the player.

To a degree the same would also apply to blocking TE's, most receiving TE's are already pretty decent blockers. Meanwhile pro calibre blocking TE's would suddenly have to come up with 2nd capped Catching and 1st capped Carrying right out of the blue. If they're not at least semi-viable receivers they'll just be forecasting a run play the vast majority of the time that they're in the game.

The idea sounds cool, and I'm sure most people will be in favor of it now. But when it's actually introduced, I think the negatives will outweigh the positives.
 
butler312
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Saris
If I'm understanding this correctly then I'm kind of torn on the idea. On the one hand it sounds like a neat concept and might add more strategy to the game. But on the other it might just destroy a lot of diverse builds and remove a lot of strategy by making several positions cookie cutter.

First of all I think we could pretty much kiss every rushing QB in the game goodbye. I'm not in any way associated with a team that has a rushing QB, but I would assume that they'd have had to sacrifice a lot of their passing ability to become a viable runner. So if a player is really only viable for one situation and then only if he can catch his opponent off guard. If the opposing team were given the ability to adjust to that player, the situation is no longer viable and neither is the player.

To a degree the same would also apply to blocking TE's, most receiving TE's are already pretty decent blockers. Meanwhile pro calibre blocking TE's would suddenly have to come up with 2nd capped Catching and 1st capped Carrying right out of the blue. If they're not at least semi-viable receivers they'll just be forecasting a run play the vast majority of the time that they're in the game.

The idea sounds cool, and I'm sure most people will be in favor of it now. But when it's actually introduced, I think the negatives will outweigh the positives.


But isn't this what we want? I HATE the specialized builds and how it is better to have 2 opposing specialized players that 1 or 2 balanced players. There is a reason very, very few teams have any success with a rushing QB who can't throw the ball very well. And those that do are at lower levels. Right now in GLB the offense has a huge advantage because the defense can't recognize personnel. Fixing this will go a long way to neutralizing this.
 
odg62
offline
Link
 
Maybe something like how often a particular WR/TE/HB is targeted in clear passing situations where a significant amount of yardage is needed to get a first down.
 
Saris
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by butler312


But isn't this what we want? I HATE the specialized builds and how it is better to have 2 opposing specialized players that 1 or 2 balanced players. There is a reason very, very few teams have any success with a rushing QB who can't throw the ball very well. And those that do are at lower levels. Right now in GLB the offense has a huge advantage because the defense can't recognize personnel. Fixing this will go a long way to neutralizing this.


I guess everyone enjoys different aspects of the game. Personally I'd like to see more specialized builds. I'd like to see half a dozen viable WR builds (such as possession and ellusive), rather than just Speed+FS and Power WR's. If everyone is a balanced build the game just comes down to who can use their SP's most efficiently and the game looses all of its flavor.

 
yello1
Preacher
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Saris
If I'm understanding this correctly then I'm kind of torn on the idea. On the one hand it sounds like a neat concept and might add more strategy to the game. But on the other it might just destroy a lot of diverse builds and remove a lot of strategy by making several positions cookie cutter.

First of all I think we could pretty much kiss every rushing QB in the game goodbye. I'm not in any way associated with a team that has a rushing QB, but I would assume that they'd have had to sacrifice a lot of their passing ability to become a viable runner. So if a player is really only viable for one situation and then only if he can catch his opponent off guard. If the opposing team were given the ability to adjust to that player, the situation is no longer viable and neither is the player.

To a degree the same would also apply to blocking TE's, most receiving TE's are already pretty decent blockers. Meanwhile pro calibre blocking TE's would suddenly have to come up with 2nd capped Catching and 1st capped Carrying right out of the blue. If they're not at least semi-viable receivers they'll just be forecasting a run play the vast majority of the time that they're in the game.

The idea sounds cool, and I'm sure most people will be in favor of it now. But when it's actually introduced, I think the negatives will outweigh the positives.


Per a recent post of mine suggesting letting the AI adjust to players, its a good thing.

Why?

Because its realistic.

We ARE trying to sim football here right?

Well in football when you line up your 300 pound lineman at Half back and every time you do that, he dives for a yard, opposing defenses are going to cue to his being there.

Same way that if you have a star receiver, opposing Defenses are going to put their best defender on him, regardless of where he lines up.

Its real.

Putting it into GLB avoids gaming the game.

If people built builds around gaming the game, then the retirement button or a rethink on their AI settings would be in order. Thats too bad, but its not a reason we should consider the exploit to be sacrosanct.

 
Link
 
Originally posted by yello1
Originally posted by driftinggrifter

Wanting way to much information spoon fed to you. There should be no way you should be able to see or know the exact or approx. amount of VA's/SA's if the build is closed. Same with any other of their attributes.


Spoon Fed???????????????????????????????????????

TOOOOO much information??????????????????????????????????????

LOL

Seriously L O L

This would be dedicating an entire player character, who after a day or two of saving up Scouting Points would only have a chance to know if ONE opposing players speed is over 50 or 75 or something vague like that. SAs and VAs I do not have worked out but they would be equally vague and costly.

You do realize that in the real world a scout can look at a player with a stop watch and tell you EXACTLY how fast he is in about ten seconds, right?

This "too much information" nonsense really cracks me up. Its a game about numbers. Not knowing what the numbers are makes it Pin the Tail on the Donkey stupid. Some way to garner some hint of the numbers would be a boon to the game. Not a detraction.


Sorry fella, but this is wanting to much information now. You do realize that real world doesn't apply to GLB right? Two different breeds of animals tbh. Peoples builds should stay off limits if they are closed. If you want a rough guess at it, then watch the game tape.
 
butler312
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Saris
I guess everyone enjoys different aspects of the game. Personally I'd like to see more specialized builds. I'd like to see half a dozen viable WR builds (such as possession and ellusive), rather than just Speed+FS and Power WR's. If everyone is a balanced build the game just comes down to who can use their SP's most efficiently and the game looses all of its flavor.



I'm not saying there can't be different builds. In fact, you could argue that there is more builds and more strategy if this happens. Because you can't just become a TE that completely ignores catching or a TE that completely ignores blocking. You have to be capable of doing both. But just like in real life you can become a TE that is a much better blocker or a TE that is more of a down field threat. You have to find a suitable balance of the 2.
 
butler312
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by driftinggrifter
Sorry fella, but this is wanting to much information now. You do realize that real world doesn't apply to GLB right? Two different breeds of animals tbh. Peoples builds should stay off limits if they are closed. If you want a rough guess at it, then watch the game tape.


I agree. I wouldn't be opposed to getting scouting reports on players, such as "speed receiver" vs "possession receiver" or "scrambling QB" vs "pocket QB." But any numbers at all need to stay out of it.
 
pottsman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Saris

I guess everyone enjoys different aspects of the game. Personally I'd like to see more specialized builds. I'd like to see half a dozen viable WR builds (such as possession and ellusive), rather than just Speed+FS and Power WR's. If everyone is a balanced build the game just comes down to who can use their SP's most efficiently and the game looses all of its flavor.



So you feel that right now, a highly specialized QB who is only capable of running the ball is a build that should be encouraged, despite the fact that a defender can't recognize the obvious play call?

Specialized builds will still work fine. Just they will need to be competent enough to keep the defenses honest. It turns the game into a chess match. You know TE A is a great receiver and a sub par blocker, so you go nickle when he's in the game. But then the team starts running the ball behind him, and he completely takes the CB out and moves on to the SS. Do that, and teams will play you "honest", putting a linebacker on your TE more often, which lets the TE burn them deep. This won't kill the game, it will make it more involved on both sides of the ball.

Right now, picking TE1 and TE2 is obvious. No thought is needed on which one to use on a play. Do you really want any depth chart decision to be that obvious?
 
Saris
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by yello1

Because its realistic.

We ARE trying to sim football here right?


Well using the realism argument, there are some ridiculously exploitive defensive formations. Such as where the middle of the field is wide open and my grandmother could get 6 yards rushing up the middle on her walker, so in the name of realism shouldn't the offense be able to call audibles? Anyway, I'm pretty sure most people have their minds made up on this, so I'll probably leave the conversation at this. The situation reminds me so much of the push for realism following season 6 that everyone was in favor of, which instead set the sim back several seasons. Season 10 was one of the better sims, but it's much closer to the season 6 sim than that of seasons 7 or 8 which were pretty bad.
 
pottsman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Saris

Well using the realism argument, there are some ridiculously exploitive defensive formations. Such as where the middle of the field is wide open and my grandmother could get 6 yards rushing up the middle on her walker, so in the name of realism shouldn't the offense be able to call audibles?

Yes.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Saris
Originally posted by yello1


Because its realistic.

We ARE trying to sim football here right?


Well using the realism argument, there are some ridiculously exploitive defensive formations. Such as where the middle of the field is wide open and my grandmother could get 6 yards rushing up the middle on her walker, so in the name of realism shouldn't the offense be able to call audibles? Anyway, I'm pretty sure most people have their minds made up on this, so I'll probably leave the conversation at this. The situation reminds me so much of the push for realism following season 6 that everyone was in favor of, which instead set the sim back several seasons. Season 10 was one of the better sims, but it's much closer to the season 6 sim than that of seasons 7 or 8 which were pretty bad.


Realism is a two sided sword in GLB. Every one uses it for a reason when they want their idea implemented but then they say that realism isn't good if it negativly affects one of their players/teams or is a idea they don't like.
 
Seth4444
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by driftinggrifter
Realism is a two sided sword in GLB. Every one uses it for a reason when they want their idea implemented but then they say that realism isn't good if it negativly affects one of their players/teams or is a idea they don't like.


Truer words never spoken
 
Saris
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by driftinggrifter

Realism is a two sided sword in GLB. Every one uses it for a reason when they want their idea implemented but then they say that realism isn't good if it negativly affects one of their players/teams or is a idea they don't like.


I agree but that's also why I prefaced my original comment by stating that I'm in no way associated with a team that uses a rushing QB.

The audible example was just a way of demonstrating that a push for too much realism could open pandoras box. Defense reacts to offensive formation > offense reacts to defense > defense reacts > ad infinitum > game crashes!
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.