Originally posted by stromstarhammer
Non-trophy teams can make the playoffs in their first season after promoting, but it's rare to see it without cheating.
After Puvirnituq's promotion to AA1 we made playoffs in an 8 vs 1 upset of the Nova Scotia Bluenosers:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=200451
We went 8-8 and got 9th in our first season of AAA1, though 
The Yaksmen went 15-1 after being promoted to A, went 12-4 after being promoted to AA, and last season went 10-6 in their first season in AAA. And if we were cheaters, we would have gotten trophies in those 3 seasons and would be sitting better than 0-2 right now, lol! My point is that stormstarhammer is right.