User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Demotion Ideas for the WPL
Page:
 
El_Windex
Baby Executive
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wombat killer
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by kwankwan


The relegation of teams is a VERY big deal... The WL will make GLB a "one league game" .... so it is a big deal.. so to distribute demoted teams randomly, could go against Bort's wishes.


It would actually probably be best for the overall health of pro league competition, tbh, to demote the teams to wherever they are needed, but it is not an easy pill for quite a few owners to swallow.


You know it is best for the long term. Just do it.


I'd agree with this, but the froth-mouthed gutjob future doesn't sound too appealing.
Edited by El_Windex on Jul 27, 2009 18:41:07
 
Knightman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JHight
Just demote the non-playoff teams to their respective regions and the conference champions from the Pros are promoted up. This ensures at least 2 teams per region in the WPL, while still giving more powerful leagues the opportunity to have multiple spots in the WPL over time.

This also gives a better shot at providing balance across the leagues while still making sure that current rivalries and friendships stay intact for the near future.


This is so simple and makes so much sense that I don't know why it can't be implemented.

Originally posted by Gott
What if all four OPL teams make the playoffs? Then no OPL teams get promoted?


If I understand it correctly, then all 4 of those teams that started in OPL would still stay in the WL. 2 more OPL teams (the Conference Champions) would then be promoted to the WL making OPL have 6 representatives. If all 4 OPL teams made the playoffs, then another Pro league is disproportionately NOT represented in the WL Playoffs, and would lose some teams in the WL. However, since the Conference Champions from each Pro League ALWAYS get promoted to WL, then each region will ALWAYS have at least 2 teams (one in each conference) in the WL.

The only thing I'd probably add is a mechanism to allow WL playoff teams that are going to gut to get demoted during regular demotion/relegation. Say one of those OPL team owners has the core of his team about to retire and decides to gut. He would need to let Bort know so that his team would be demoted out of the WL. You could make it so that teams that voluntarily ask for a demotion get replaced by a team from their original region in order to preserve some regional representation. It would suck if a WL playoff team stays in the WL after the promotion/relegation process and then guts so that we have a WL team with an average player level of 3. There would also need to be a SERIOUS penalty for violation of this rule imho--maybe even loss of ALL players, teams, AND FP. We're talking about the showcase league for all of GLB. Just like the NFL jealously protects the "Super Bowl" name, so should GLB protect the integrity of the World League.

 
FairForever
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ICRockets
Originally posted by Bort

Added to OP.

Caveats:

- Special treatment cannot be given to a certain region or regions, just because some people think that region is better. Biases should be determined by stats, wins, losses alone.
- Think long term. Encouraging the regions to even out as far as talent is a GOOD thing.
- Team owners would prefer to go back to the region they came from. If we can make that happen, it is best.


My idea accomodates all of that.

2 demoted teams go to each region every year. There's no "We need to push an extra team down a rung to fill it out right". The BEST demoted teams are likely to get their LAST choice of region, thus ensuring that the most competitive teams are going to the most competitive leagues unless other teams specifically request to do so. AND I have a safeguard against frequent demotees going to the same league over and over and dominating outclassed competition.


That's a horrible system. The best demoted teams should have first choice.

Your system ensures that there will always be imbalances in the Pro League.
 
vrshah
offline
Link
 
Main thing you have to think about is access--

Most Pro and even AAA teams will complain that WPL is not accessible enough so you don't want to limit it.

You also don't want to open it up to whomever because it diminishes the credibility of WPL and it becomes a hassle to deal with.

My solution gives the top 96 teams in the game an access to WPL at the end of any given season.

If your team can't make it to top 4 of your conference and into the bracket for WPL placement, you can't really complain.
 
the man of doom
Miracles happen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jamz
Originally posted by FairForever

Random is the dumbest idea ever... I can see teams complaining next season already, and Bort having to deal with those issues.


Easy fix, rename all the regions Generic Pro League.



Pro league A > Pro league C tbh
 
jamz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by the man of doom
Originally posted by jamz

Originally posted by FairForever


Random is the dumbest idea ever... I can see teams complaining next season already, and Bort having to deal with those issues.


Easy fix, rename all the regions Generic Pro League.



Pro league A > Pro league C tbh


No letters, they're all just called Generic Pro League.
 
FairForever
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Galkuris


Originally posted by FairForever

Originally posted by Bort


Added to OP.

Caveats:

- Special treatment cannot be given to a certain region or regions, just because some people think that region is better. Biases should be determined by stats, wins, losses alone.
- Think long term. Encouraging the regions to even out as far as talent is a GOOD thing.
- Team owners would prefer to go back to the region they came from. If we can make that happen, it is best.


My solution fits all of them to be honest.


What if the top two teams both make it to the WL conference championship? Why should they be punished? Drygerian/Marblehead could very easily pull that off and it would not be fair to demote one of them. This is one part of the solution I would absolutely not agree on.


That's why we included the play-in game after. So if Marblehead beat Dryden in the WPL Conference Championship Game, Dryden would face off against CPL East's champion. If Dryden was good enough to make WPL Conference Finals, they should have no problem dispatching the CPL team and staying in WPL.
Edited by FairForever on Jul 27, 2009 18:43:08
 
the man of doom
Miracles happen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jamz
Originally posted by the man of doom

Originally posted by jamz


Originally posted by FairForever



Random is the dumbest idea ever... I can see teams complaining next season already, and Bort having to deal with those issues.


Easy fix, rename all the regions Generic Pro League.



Pro league A > Pro league C tbh


No letters, they're all just called Generic Pro League.


Gereric Pro League that this team is in > Generic Pro League that ths one is in
 
turnit643
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Galkuris
Originally posted by FairForever
Originally posted by Bort


Added to OP.

Caveats:

- Special treatment cannot be given to a certain region or regions, just because some people think that region is better. Biases should be determined by stats, wins, losses alone.
- Think long term. Encouraging the regions to even out as far as talent is a GOOD thing.
- Team owners would prefer to go back to the region they came from. If we can make that happen, it is best.


My solution fits all of them to be honest.


What if the top two teams both make it to the WL conference championship? Why should they be punished? Drygerian/Marblehead could very easily pull that off and it would not be fair to demote one of them. This is one part of the solution I would absolutely not agree on.


Agreed. This is the problem with all regional quote demotion ideas, even if all WL teams from one region succeed while in the WL, they can't all stay. Have four teams there and all finish int he final four? Too bad, two are getting the boot. Makes no sense in what is supposed to be the best league in the game.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by kwankwan


The relegation of teams is a VERY big deal... The WL will make GLB a "one league game" .... so it is a big deal.. so to distribute demoted teams randomly, could go against Bort's wishes.


It would actually probably be best for the overall health of pro league competition, tbh, to demote the teams to wherever they are needed, but it is not an easy pill for quite a few owners to swallow.


Not all Pro Leagues are equal.


At the moment, no, they are not. They would be eventually after world league teams from other regions demoted to them, however.
 
AngryDragon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by kwankwan

The relegation of teams is a VERY big deal... The WL will make GLB a "one league game" .... so it is a big deal.. so to distribute demoted teams randomly, could go against Bort's wishes.


It would actually probably be best for the overall health of pro league competition, tbh, to demote the teams to wherever they are needed, but it is not an easy pill for quite a few owners to swallow.


This could backfire. Consider that you could end up with 12 USA pro teams in a few seasons if they are demoted to other regions and then get back to the WPL on another regions ticket.
Edited by AngryDragon on Jul 27, 2009 18:44:06
 
the man of doom
Miracles happen
offline
Link
 
lol soccer idea is teh best imo
 
FairForever
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by turnit643
Originally posted by Galkuris

Originally posted by FairForever

Originally posted by Bort



Added to OP.

Caveats:

- Special treatment cannot be given to a certain region or regions, just because some people think that region is better. Biases should be determined by stats, wins, losses alone.
- Think long term. Encouraging the regions to even out as far as talent is a GOOD thing.
- Team owners would prefer to go back to the region they came from. If we can make that happen, it is best.


My solution fits all of them to be honest.


What if the top two teams both make it to the WL conference championship? Why should they be punished? Drygerian/Marblehead could very easily pull that off and it would not be fair to demote one of them. This is one part of the solution I would absolutely not agree on.


Agreed. This is the problem with all regional quote demotion ideas, even if all WL teams from one region succeed while in the WL, they can't all stay. Have four teams there and all finish int he final four? Too bad, two are getting the boot. Makes no sense in what is supposed to be the best league in the game.


In the long run this would mean better teams going to OPL, EEPL and APL (to try and get easier entrance into WPL), making the Pro Leagues more equal.
 
ICRockets
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by FairForever
Originally posted by ICRockets

Originally posted by Bort


Added to OP.

Caveats:

- Special treatment cannot be given to a certain region or regions, just because some people think that region is better. Biases should be determined by stats, wins, losses alone.
- Think long term. Encouraging the regions to even out as far as talent is a GOOD thing.
- Team owners would prefer to go back to the region they came from. If we can make that happen, it is best.


My idea accomodates all of that.

2 demoted teams go to each region every year. There's no "We need to push an extra team down a rung to fill it out right". The BEST demoted teams are likely to get their LAST choice of region, thus ensuring that the most competitive teams are going to the most competitive leagues unless other teams specifically request to do so. AND I have a safeguard against frequent demotees going to the same league over and over and dominating outclassed competition.


That's a horrible system. The best demoted teams should have first choice.

Your system ensures that there will always be imbalances in the Pro League.


So what happens if the best demoted team decides he wants to go to OPL? Say we're talking about Bonn Dynamo. They rocked WEPL, did well in Worlds, but fell just short of the playoffs. But they were close, and feel that if they get back to the World League, they can make it happen this time. All they have to do is get back. So naturally they're going to choose the WEAKEST league possible to be demoted into, so they have the easiest road back to the World Pro League where they feel they belong.

You really think the best option is to FACILIATE THAT?!
 
smallbugger
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Added to OP.

Caveats:

- Special treatment cannot be given to a certain region or regions, just because some people think that region is better. Biases should be determined by stats, wins, losses alone.
- Think long term. Encouraging the regions to even out as far as talent is a GOOD thing.
- Team owners would prefer to go back to the region they came from. If we can make that happen, it is best.


I still like my idea... allows even representation of each region and even conference.

Originally posted by smallbugger
1. you have 2 teams in from each region in each WPL conference.

2. Whoever of those 2 that finishes lower is replaced by their regions pro conference championship

3. the demoted team returns to their region's Pro team

This keeps a type of regional pride in the 4 teams overall representing your region and helps spur on the "What region is best argument idea" over loosing that from teams getting shuffed all over different regions.

This also means you have half of the WPL being changed every season, which is what is really needed in a top tournament.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.