User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Gameplan doesnt run in playoff game WTF?
Page:
 
LordEvil
offline
Link
 
Ive been saying this for many seasons since the Ai's first came out. It does its own thing from time to time. Its mostly ONLY in playoff games. Its always offense as defense runs pretty consistant of what you asked it to.
IN our championhsip we ran the ball on 4th and long and passed on 4th and very short yet its the other way around in my Ai. The drives stalled because of it but luckily it didn't cost us the game. Also it didn't kick the FG like I had it programmed to either.
Something else I think happens is when a team who is stronger across the board plays a team not so much, the stronger team runs a pitch play and the defensive player just stands there as the HB runs right by them? I think the replays just play out what the sim decided on which team should win right at the start of the game.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by LordEvil
Ive been saying this for many seasons since the Ai's first came out. It does its own thing from time to time. Its mostly ONLY in playoff games. Its always offense as defense runs pretty consistant of what you asked it to.
IN our championhsip we ran the ball on 4th and long and passed on 4th and very short yet its the other way around in my Ai. The drives stalled because of it but luckily it didn't cost us the game. Also it didn't kick the FG like I had it programmed to either.
Something else I think happens is when a team who is stronger across the board plays a team not so much, the stronger team runs a pitch play and the defensive player just stands there as the HB runs right by them? I think the replays just play out what the sim decided on which team should win right at the start of the game.


I hope my sim decides I should win.

Team based "X factors?" Perhaps some teams are just destined to win more.

 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BP
Taut said exactly what I was thinking. It appears to be basic AI.

Means one of these things (assuming your AI tester states confirms that it's not an input error on your end)

1) Someone didn't check the Enable AI button
2) AutoAdjust was at 100 and you ran one play that worked and the AI just decided to do what it wanted to do that was similiar to that play
3) Your playbook was jacked up


I'd look at #3 real hard, I'm not familiar with the script you are using here

http://img194.imageshack.us/img194/7942/picture1chy.png

but why does the sweep strong indicate pass? te quick hit indicate run pitch?

If I had to guess, I'd say this isn't a case of the sim just doing what it wants to do. I'd say either your input/outputs are screwed up (What you call them vs. what's actually in there) or your Playbook is messed up...wrong playbook...not enabled...whatever.

When you something gets selected...like 10% HB sweep strong and if you input/output/playbook match doesn't make any sense...the AI just picks something to run. I'll bet that's what happened here for sure.


Enable AI button was checked.
Auto-adjust off.

The play is labeled wrong because that's how they're set in the outputs, but the Select Play thing says it overrides the settings.

For example the TE Quick hit output was set to a pitch, but the select play was used, and TE quick hit was selected. I think the PItch was just set from one of the earlier games, and bhall just changed the select play part.

I was thinking it had something to do with the Select Play feature not overriding the settings like it should. Could be a possibility. That wouldn't explain why we kicked those long FGs and why we had the wrong personnel in on certain plays though.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BP
Taut said exactly what I was thinking. It appears to be basic AI.

Means one of these things (assuming your AI tester states confirms that it's not an input error on your end)

1) Someone didn't check the Enable AI button
2) AutoAdjust was at 100 and you ran one play that worked and the AI just decided to do what it wanted to do that was similiar to that play
3) Your playbook/inputs/outputs were jacked up


I'd look at #3 real hard, I'm not familiar with the script you are using here

http://img194.imageshack.us/img194/7942/picture1chy.png

but why does the sweep strong indicate pass? te quick hit indicate run pitch?

If I had to guess, I'd say this isn't a case of the sim just doing what it wants to do. I'd say either your input/outputs are screwed up (What you call them vs. what's actually in there) or your Playbook is messed up...wrong playbook...not enabled...whatever.

When you something gets selected...like 10% HB sweep strong and if you input/output/playbook match doesn't make any sense...the AI just picks something to run. I'll bet that's what happened here for sure.


This happened to me 3 seasons ago, but I caught it before the game played. 90% of my outputs had changed in the offense...the names were the same, but the actual outputs had all "shifted" down the list by 1 or 2 slots.

The changes were so dramatic that I decided it could not possibly be sabotage...I believe it occurred when I updated the AI right around rollover time.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
Originally posted by BP

Taut said exactly what I was thinking. It appears to be basic AI.

Means one of these things (assuming your AI tester states confirms that it's not an input error on your end)

1) Someone didn't check the Enable AI button
2) AutoAdjust was at 100 and you ran one play that worked and the AI just decided to do what it wanted to do that was similiar to that play
3) Your playbook was jacked up


I'd look at #3 real hard, I'm not familiar with the script you are using here

http://img194.imageshack.us/img194/7942/picture1chy.png

but why does the sweep strong indicate pass? te quick hit indicate run pitch?

If I had to guess, I'd say this isn't a case of the sim just doing what it wants to do. I'd say either your input/outputs are screwed up (What you call them vs. what's actually in there) or your Playbook is messed up...wrong playbook...not enabled...whatever.

When you something gets selected...like 10% HB sweep strong and if you input/output/playbook match doesn't make any sense...the AI just picks something to run. I'll bet that's what happened here for sure.


Enable AI button was checked.
Auto-adjust off.

The play is labeled wrong because that's how they're set in the outputs, but the Select Play thing says it overrides the settings.

For example the TE Quick hit output was set to a pitch, but the select play was used, and TE quick hit was selected. I think the PItch was just set from one of the earlier games, and bhall just changed the select play part.

I was thinking it had something to do with the Select Play feature not overriding the settings like it should. Could be a possibility. That wouldn't explain why we kicked those long FGs and why we had the wrong personnel in on certain plays though.


There is no way in hell that I would have a custom play selected, *and* a traditional playcall selection in the same output...that's begging for trouble.


Also- If the AI errors out for some reason, it seems to default to your basic AI section. I discovered this on defense some time back with illegal blitz calls.
Edited by tautology on Jul 30, 2009 19:35:38
 
BP
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
Originally posted by BP

Taut said exactly what I was thinking. It appears to be basic AI.

Means one of these things (assuming your AI tester states confirms that it's not an input error on your end)

1) Someone didn't check the Enable AI button
2) AutoAdjust was at 100 and you ran one play that worked and the AI just decided to do what it wanted to do that was similiar to that play
3) Your playbook was jacked up


I'd look at #3 real hard, I'm not familiar with the script you are using here

http://img194.imageshack.us/img194/7942/picture1chy.png

but why does the sweep strong indicate pass? te quick hit indicate run pitch?

If I had to guess, I'd say this isn't a case of the sim just doing what it wants to do. I'd say either your input/outputs are screwed up (What you call them vs. what's actually in there) or your Playbook is messed up...wrong playbook...not enabled...whatever.

When you something gets selected...like 10% HB sweep strong and if you input/output/playbook match doesn't make any sense...the AI just picks something to run. I'll bet that's what happened here for sure.


Enable AI button was checked.
Auto-adjust off.

The play is labeled wrong because that's how they're set in the outputs, but the Select Play thing says it overrides the settings.

For example the TE Quick hit output was set to a pitch, but the select play was used, and TE quick hit was selected. I think the PItch was just set from one of the earlier games, and bhall just changed the select play part.

I was thinking it had something to do with the Select Play feature not overriding the settings like it should. Could be a possibility. That wouldn't explain why we kicked those long FGs and why we had the wrong personnel in on certain plays though.


Yeah, to be honest...I don't use the select play feature cuz it says OR and it kinda scares me...like it's kind of random what it's gonna do, you know?

Because you guys thought that the select play thing worked properly, you probably didn't pay any attention to the inputs below and maybe they didn't match up to the playbook (if you create a new one every game) or they weren't set up properly (wrong custom slots, wrong ball carrier, wrong target...ect)

I'll bet you that's the problem Sik.
Edited by BP on Jul 30, 2009 19:35:14
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by Sik Wit It

Originally posted by BP


Taut said exactly what I was thinking. It appears to be basic AI.

Means one of these things (assuming your AI tester states confirms that it's not an input error on your end)

1) Someone didn't check the Enable AI button
2) AutoAdjust was at 100 and you ran one play that worked and the AI just decided to do what it wanted to do that was similiar to that play
3) Your playbook was jacked up


I'd look at #3 real hard, I'm not familiar with the script you are using here

http://img194.imageshack.us/img194/7942/picture1chy.png

but why does the sweep strong indicate pass? te quick hit indicate run pitch?

If I had to guess, I'd say this isn't a case of the sim just doing what it wants to do. I'd say either your input/outputs are screwed up (What you call them vs. what's actually in there) or your Playbook is messed up...wrong playbook...not enabled...whatever.

When you something gets selected...like 10% HB sweep strong and if you input/output/playbook match doesn't make any sense...the AI just picks something to run. I'll bet that's what happened here for sure.


Enable AI button was checked.
Auto-adjust off.

The play is labeled wrong because that's how they're set in the outputs, but the Select Play thing says it overrides the settings.

For example the TE Quick hit output was set to a pitch, but the select play was used, and TE quick hit was selected. I think the PItch was just set from one of the earlier games, and bhall just changed the select play part.

I was thinking it had something to do with the Select Play feature not overriding the settings like it should. Could be a possibility. That wouldn't explain why we kicked those long FGs and why we had the wrong personnel in on certain plays though.


There is no way in hell that I would have a custom play selected, *and* a traditional playcall selection in the same output...that's begging for trouble. o_O


Haha neither would I...gotta talk to bhall about that one.

Either way, there's still a bug about how the Select Play works if that's indeed what happened. I still don't think that was the cause of it. Again, I point to the super long FGs and wrong personnel being in.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
If the AI errors out for some reason, it seems to default to your basic AI section. I discovered this on defense some time back with illegal blitz calls.

I can imagine having both play calls in the same output causing an error-out situation...defaulting to basic AI as a result.
Edited by tautology on Jul 30, 2009 19:37:09
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BP
Originally posted by Sik Wit It

Originally posted by BP


Taut said exactly what I was thinking. It appears to be basic AI.

Means one of these things (assuming your AI tester states confirms that it's not an input error on your end)

1) Someone didn't check the Enable AI button
2) AutoAdjust was at 100 and you ran one play that worked and the AI just decided to do what it wanted to do that was similiar to that play
3) Your playbook was jacked up


I'd look at #3 real hard, I'm not familiar with the script you are using here

http://img194.imageshack.us/img194/7942/picture1chy.png

but why does the sweep strong indicate pass? te quick hit indicate run pitch?

If I had to guess, I'd say this isn't a case of the sim just doing what it wants to do. I'd say either your input/outputs are screwed up (What you call them vs. what's actually in there) or your Playbook is messed up...wrong playbook...not enabled...whatever.

When you something gets selected...like 10% HB sweep strong and if you input/output/playbook match doesn't make any sense...the AI just picks something to run. I'll bet that's what happened here for sure.


Enable AI button was checked.
Auto-adjust off.

The play is labeled wrong because that's how they're set in the outputs, but the Select Play thing says it overrides the settings.

For example the TE Quick hit output was set to a pitch, but the select play was used, and TE quick hit was selected. I think the PItch was just set from one of the earlier games, and bhall just changed the select play part.

I was thinking it had something to do with the Select Play feature not overriding the settings like it should. Could be a possibility. That wouldn't explain why we kicked those long FGs and why we had the wrong personnel in on certain plays though.


Yeah, to be honest...I don't use the select play feature cuz it says OR and it kinda scares me...like it's kind of random what it's gonna do, you know?

Because you guys thought that the select play thing worked properly, you probably didn't pay any attention to the inputs below and maybe they didn't match up to the playbook (if you create a new one every game) or they weren't set up properly (wrong custom slots, wrong ball carrier, wrong target...ect)

I'll bet you that's the problem Sik.


It could be, but again...the long FGs?
 
BP
offline
Link
 
I would bet you 1000% it's the problem. Just by looking at that screen shot you can see that what the play is called in AI and what's being selected to run are different things...

The problem IS probably selecting both a play from the menu and then also having a little custom input you've created below. This is the first time I've read this thread and from an outsiders perspective...it's definately what happened. So it's not a user problem so much as a logic problem in that AI, having both of those underneath one output and how they relate to each other.
 
BP
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
Originally posted by BP

Originally posted by Sik Wit It


Originally posted by BP



Taut said exactly what I was thinking. It appears to be basic AI.

Means one of these things (assuming your AI tester states confirms that it's not an input error on your end)

1) Someone didn't check the Enable AI button
2) AutoAdjust was at 100 and you ran one play that worked and the AI just decided to do what it wanted to do that was similiar to that play
3) Your playbook was jacked up


I'd look at #3 real hard, I'm not familiar with the script you are using here

http://img194.imageshack.us/img194/7942/picture1chy.png

but why does the sweep strong indicate pass? te quick hit indicate run pitch?

If I had to guess, I'd say this isn't a case of the sim just doing what it wants to do. I'd say either your input/outputs are screwed up (What you call them vs. what's actually in there) or your Playbook is messed up...wrong playbook...not enabled...whatever.

When you something gets selected...like 10% HB sweep strong and if you input/output/playbook match doesn't make any sense...the AI just picks something to run. I'll bet that's what happened here for sure.


Enable AI button was checked.
Auto-adjust off.

The play is labeled wrong because that's how they're set in the outputs, but the Select Play thing says it overrides the settings.

For example the TE Quick hit output was set to a pitch, but the select play was used, and TE quick hit was selected. I think the PItch was just set from one of the earlier games, and bhall just changed the select play part.

I was thinking it had something to do with the Select Play feature not overriding the settings like it should. Could be a possibility. That wouldn't explain why we kicked those long FGs and why we had the wrong personnel in on certain plays though.


Yeah, to be honest...I don't use the select play feature cuz it says OR and it kinda scares me...like it's kind of random what it's gonna do, you know?

Because you guys thought that the select play thing worked properly, you probably didn't pay any attention to the inputs below and maybe they didn't match up to the playbook (if you create a new one every game) or they weren't set up properly (wrong custom slots, wrong ball carrier, wrong target...ect)

I'll bet you that's the problem Sik.


It could be, but again...the long FGs?


Dunno, I'd have to look at the AI.....and run the AI tester and see what happens, but did you guys set up a custom input and then also select FG from the picture drop down menu (I don't know if it's in there or not) under the same input/output?

Were the long FG's in situations where you AI dictates you go for it on 4th?

Hard to say without seeing it...

Edited by BP on Jul 30, 2009 19:41:21
 
LordEvil
offline
Link
 
Ive made the mistake before but luckily caught it on my FG AI, I had put my own 35 to opponents goal instead of opponents 35 and opponents goal
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BP
Originally posted by Sik Wit It

Originally posted by BP


Originally posted by Sik Wit It



Originally posted by BP




Taut said exactly what I was thinking. It appears to be basic AI.

Means one of these things (assuming your AI tester states confirms that it's not an input error on your end)

1) Someone didn't check the Enable AI button
2) AutoAdjust was at 100 and you ran one play that worked and the AI just decided to do what it wanted to do that was similiar to that play
3) Your playbook was jacked up


I'd look at #3 real hard, I'm not familiar with the script you are using here

http://img194.imageshack.us/img194/7942/picture1chy.png

but why does the sweep strong indicate pass? te quick hit indicate run pitch?

If I had to guess, I'd say this isn't a case of the sim just doing what it wants to do. I'd say either your input/outputs are screwed up (What you call them vs. what's actually in there) or your Playbook is messed up...wrong playbook...not enabled...whatever.

When you something gets selected...like 10% HB sweep strong and if you input/output/playbook match doesn't make any sense...the AI just picks something to run. I'll bet that's what happened here for sure.


Enable AI button was checked.
Auto-adjust off.

The play is labeled wrong because that's how they're set in the outputs, but the Select Play thing says it overrides the settings.

For example the TE Quick hit output was set to a pitch, but the select play was used, and TE quick hit was selected. I think the PItch was just set from one of the earlier games, and bhall just changed the select play part.

I was thinking it had something to do with the Select Play feature not overriding the settings like it should. Could be a possibility. That wouldn't explain why we kicked those long FGs and why we had the wrong personnel in on certain plays though.


Yeah, to be honest...I don't use the select play feature cuz it says OR and it kinda scares me...like it's kind of random what it's gonna do, you know?

Because you guys thought that the select play thing worked properly, you probably didn't pay any attention to the inputs below and maybe they didn't match up to the playbook (if you create a new one every game) or they weren't set up properly (wrong custom slots, wrong ball carrier, wrong target...ect)

I'll bet you that's the problem Sik.


It could be, but again...the long FGs?


Dunno, I'd have to look at the AI.....and run the AI tester and see what happens, but did you guys set up a custom input and then also select FG from the picture drop down menu (I don't know if it's in there or not) under the same input/output?

Were the long FG's in situations where you AI dictates you go for it on 4th?

Hard to say without seeing it...



Well I'm on the Wolfpack and Lincoln so I didn't have anything to do with the gameplanning on this one. But I seriously doubt they created a whole new 4th & out of FG range output for this game. Why would we do that? Also I tested the exact situation in the AI tester separately (since people said the replay re-write one might not work correctly), and it came out as the punt output on every one of those long FGs we kicked. And no, it's not a select play input. You can't select FG from there; only regular plays. The FG output I am almost 100% sure remained unchanged. I see no reason why any amount of gameplanning would lead us to change anything involving punting or kicking FGs. But like I said, I wasn't involved in the gameplanning on this one so only bhall can say for sure.
 
sunshineduck
offline
Link
 
Have you tried using the actual AI tester? I've found that the script you're using (I've used it too, so I'm not just talking out of my ass) is unreliable at best when it comes to FG issues. A team I OC had FG distance issues as well, and it turns out that using the "Special Circumstances" section of the input itself doesn't work as intended. The tester built into the replay rewrite script picked up my outputs, but the tester that GLB provides didn't. I just use the distance from Opp. goal settings to set my max FG range now.
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sunshineduck
Have you tried using the actual AI tester? I've found that the script you're using (I've used it too, so I'm not just talking out of my ass) is unreliable at best when it comes to FG issues. A team I OC had FG distance issues as well, and it turns out that using the "Special Circumstances" section of the input itself doesn't work as intended. The tester built into the replay rewrite script picked up my outputs, but the tester that GLB provides didn't. I just use the distance from Opp. goal settings to set my max FG range now.


Yeah I used the real AI tester for all of those after some people told me earlier in the thread it may not work correctly.

Everything was set up exactly even down to the exact second.

Also before that game we never kicked a FG longer than 57 yards, and since then we haven't either. Nothing significant was changed.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.