User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Bort, just come out and confirm or deny the X-Factor.
Page:
 
F8n4tune
offline
Link
 
D League(not that great but I don't have a team to test with) fuel for the fire , exact same height/weight , sp's distributed exactly , training done the same , onlu human HB's on the team , 8 days old.


http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1566163 - 1 Breakthrough Training
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1566179 - 2 Breakthrough Trainings

First game played today. We'll see what happens.
Edited by F8n4tune on Jul 16, 2009 11:51:04
 
Gart888
things!
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Why are we still discussing h/w?


because some people are trying to deny that h/w have an effect on top speed. (i think)
 
InRomoWeTrust
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
All I know is that a lot of RBs success as a result of their o-line, FB, TE, WRs as blockers, etc. Not to forget the control the OC has.

If that's mistaken as an x-factor, then idk what to say.

<<<Not a believer in an x-factor.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by Deathblade

Best way to make the best players, as I said last night, roll 10-20 players that are nearly exactly the same. Put them all on D-League teams. See which one is the fastest, then retire the rest.

Interesting idea, but only if we're confident that X-factor is constant throughout a player's lifespan.


Originally posted by Gart888

All you're proving is that lighter players are better, not that height/weight don't play a role.

He didn't say they don't play any role, just that they aren't the explanation some people are trying to make them out to be. If height/weight were that powerful, heavier power backs would generally be better. They obviously have some effect, just not a huge one.


Exactly and the argument that lighter players are the best doesn't work either because I could find quite a few heavier players that are dominant as well...like this guy:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=75206
(Gart should know him)

 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sbuck143
My X-factor theory:

First - no-one but me ever remembers this, but Bort gave us a clue way back when he acknowledged on the new training system rollout that "some players you'll discover just naturally will get more "training breakthroughs" compared to others while intense training". that right there screams there is something static, hidden, and not randomly generated that controls how "lucky" they are to get that. Not that hard of a stretch to ascertain that element that controls how 'lucky' you are on your training breakthroughs could be coded all throughout the game and in different interactions.

Don't believe me? The clutch VA acknowledges there is 'multiplier' on the end of your rolls. I believe Clutch is a natural ability, the VA only boosts your clutchness. So you also have (if you follow my logic) a VA that boosts a players X-factor-ness. This would also go a long way in explaining why some players swear by clutch and others cant ever tell its doing anything. Especially with the recent revelation that Clutch helps your SA's fire more often, I can almost guarantee the hidden attribute is a players natural 'clutch' level.


Good stuff, but do you happen to have a link to exactly what Bort said about training breakthroughs?
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mat McBriar
All I know is that a lot of RBs success as a result of their o-line, FB, TE, WRs as blockers, etc. Not to forget the control the OC has.

If that's mistaken as an x-factor, then idk what to say.

<<<Not a believer in an x-factor.


Except X Factors aren't only in RBs...they are everywhere like WRs, DEs, DTs, etc.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gart888
Originally posted by Deathblade

Why are we still discussing h/w?


because some people are trying to deny that h/w have an effect on top speed. (i think)


p sure nobody denied it

But when a heavier, shorter WR with lower speed is faster (and by a lot) than a lighter, taller WR with more speed...something is factoring in besides weight.
 
InRomoWeTrust
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gart888
Originally posted by Deathblade

Why are we still discussing h/w?


because some people are trying to deny that h/w have an effect on top speed. (i think)


ib4 Bort stalker

Benefits/Drawbacks of Height/Weight

Originally posted by Bort

There is NO max speed limiter for routes or certain positions running routes, etc. I even just went and looked to make sure, because there are other times when speed is limited (such as qb handoffs). Speed and acceleration work on a linear progression towards a value calculated by speed, agility, weight, and other factors (speed and weight being by far most important for max speed). SA's, VA's, etc. of course factor in.

However, WR's often have to slow down catch the ball when it is underthrown, or when doing moves on creative route running, or when changing direction, or when doing comebacks.

Also, you CAN lose speed in the middle of a play by getting tired. Energy and morale are a constantly updating factor; they do not just get applied at the beginning of the play. Otherwise, skills like snarl wouldn't affect the other player, etc.

Originally posted by Bort
Yeah heavy dudes have always gotten a higher score on breaking tackles, breaking blocks, blocking, and tackling than lighter dudes.

Originally posted by Player
How about my question...does weight only affect acceleration or top end speed too?
Originally posted by Bort
both
 
Gart888
things!
offline
Link
 
And i'd bet a large sum of money that JO isn't as fast as Dooley.
 
Joe Buck
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by sbuck143

My X-factor theory:

First - no-one but me ever remembers this, but Bort gave us a clue way back when he acknowledged on the new training system rollout that "some players you'll discover just naturally will get more "training breakthroughs" compared to others while intense training". that right there screams there is something static, hidden, and not randomly generated that controls how "lucky" they are to get that. Not that hard of a stretch to ascertain that element that controls how 'lucky' you are on your training breakthroughs could be coded all throughout the game and in different interactions.

Don't believe me? The clutch VA acknowledges there is 'multiplier' on the end of your rolls. I believe Clutch is a natural ability, the VA only boosts your clutchness. So you also have (if you follow my logic) a VA that boosts a players X-factor-ness. This would also go a long way in explaining why some players swear by clutch and others cant ever tell its doing anything. Especially with the recent revelation that Clutch helps your SA's fire more often, I can almost guarantee the hidden attribute is a players natural 'clutch' level.


Good stuff, but do you happen to have a link to exactly what Bort said about training breakthroughs?


I've tried digging through the announcement forums to see if I could find those discussions. This was waaaaaay before the changelog. Havent found it yet.

 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mat McBriar
Originally posted by Gart888

Originally posted by Deathblade


Why are we still discussing h/w?


because some people are trying to deny that h/w have an effect on top speed. (i think)


ib4 Bort stalker

Benefits/Drawbacks of Height/Weight

Originally posted by Bort


There is NO max speed limiter for routes or certain positions running routes, etc. I even just went and looked to make sure, because there are other times when speed is limited (such as qb handoffs). Speed and acceleration work on a linear progression towards a value calculated by speed, agility, weight, and other factors (speed and weight being by far most important for max speed). SA's, VA's, etc. of course factor in.

However, WR's often have to slow down catch the ball when it is underthrown, or when doing moves on creative route running, or when changing direction, or when doing comebacks.

Also, you CAN lose speed in the middle of a play by getting tired. Energy and morale are a constantly updating factor; they do not just get applied at the beginning of the play. Otherwise, skills like snarl wouldn't affect the other player, etc.

Originally posted by Bort

Yeah heavy dudes have always gotten a higher score on breaking tackles, breaking blocks, blocking, and tackling than lighter dudes.

Originally posted by Player

How about my question...does weight only affect acceleration or top end speed too?
Originally posted by Bort

both


Mat, I know I sound like a conspiracy theorist but why does a 197 pound Larry Csonka break tackles better than anyone in GLB? Or why does a 186 pound Jedi Knight break tackles like crazy especially when he was a power RB?
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mat McBriar
All I know is that a lot of RBs success as a result of their o-line, FB, TE, WRs as blockers, etc. Not to forget the control the OC has. If that's mistaken as an x-factor, then idk what to say. <<<Not a believer in an x-factor.

Lots of people have shown examples of players at the same position on the same team having wildly differing performance despite very similar if not identical builds. Some of them even had very similar if not identical height & weight. Pierre's comparison was particularly vexing because the WR with slightly more speed and lower weight was consistently much slower than his other WR who had been on the same team. X-factor isn't necessarily the answer, but something is definitely strange about that.
 
PierreThomas
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pottsman
Originally posted by jrry32

Originally posted by Gart888


Originally posted by jrry32



Originally posted by Gart888




Originally posted by jrry32






I don't think height and weight is really it because GLB's best power RBs are for the most part, light.


logic fail. epic, epic logic fail.


Please tell me how that is a logic fail. So power HBs that break a shitload of tackles should be around 180 pounds? Makes no sense.


All you're proving is that lighter players are better, not that height/weight don't play a role.


But that's not always true...



You're also working with a very small sample size of season 1 players who couldn't reroll and thought weight was meaningless. I'd be willing to bet that players with the proper build for their weight outperform players with the wrong weight for their build.


Every time?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=835503
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=840825
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=656778
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=158382
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=306590
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=609988
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=167909


See if you can put these players in order to how they should perform. I threw a little bit of all weights in there.


If you want to have even more fun, try to put the WRs in order by who runs the fastest using DB's script and then I'll put them in the correct order for you so you can compare the results.
 
pottsman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mat McBriar
Originally posted by Gart888

Originally posted by Deathblade


Why are we still discussing h/w?


because some people are trying to deny that h/w have an effect on top speed. (i think)


ib4 Bort stalker

Benefits/Drawbacks of Height/Weight

Originally posted by Bort


There is NO max speed limiter for routes or certain positions running routes, etc. I even just went and looked to make sure, because there are other times when speed is limited (such as qb handoffs). Speed and acceleration work on a linear progression towards a value calculated by speed, agility, weight, and other factors (speed and weight being by far most important for max speed). SA's, VA's, etc. of course factor in.

However, WR's often have to slow down catch the ball when it is underthrown, or when doing moves on creative route running, or when changing direction, or when doing comebacks.

Also, you CAN lose speed in the middle of a play by getting tired. Energy and morale are a constantly updating factor; they do not just get applied at the beginning of the play. Otherwise, skills like snarl wouldn't affect the other player, etc.

Originally posted by Bort

Yeah heavy dudes have always gotten a higher score on breaking tackles, breaking blocks, blocking, and tackling than lighter dudes.

Originally posted by Player

How about my question...does weight only affect acceleration or top end speed too?
Originally posted by Bort

both


Where do you have this easily searchable index of all that Bort's said? I know of plenty of not-so-easy to search ones, but you seem to pull stuff pretty damn quick.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gart888
And i'd bet a large sum of money that JO isn't as fast as Dooley.


I would too...because JO is combo RB, Dooley is elusive. I'd expect that Dooley has more speed and agility than JO.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.