User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Corners are too fast
Page:
 
Link
 
Here's the key to this: The speed attribute works in a really dumb way in GLB.

In real football, you have even some high school WRs with a 40 time of 4.5. I'm a 6-foot pasty white guy and I ran a 4.9 in high school in my senior year of football. I wasn't even a terribly dedicated athlete, and I was second-string.

WRs and CBs come out of college all the time with a 4.4 to 4.6 speed. There's a VERY narrow range of speed between a NFL speed guy and um... me. Or the old me. Half a second over 40 yards? While that's a noticeable difference in a side-by-side foot race, the equivalent in GLB wouldn't be huge, right? Weird.

The other way it's weird, is that a football player's speed doesn't increase much during their playing career, and it often drops once they get to the Pros and get some wear and tear. Conditioning/training doesn't increase speed much in real life. Dropping weight has a *much* larger impact on speed.

So here we have GLB with a funky system where you can train your speed from a 10 to 125. That's a ridiculous range and doesn't simulate football in any way. It also creates a ton of problems when people try to "train speed" and expect to just be faster than everyone else.

A better simulation of speed would be for each position to have its own speed rating but for it to be largely unchangeable, kind of like weight. That way, coverage/open-ness would be more determined by a range of build features more than just running past the CB.
 
cornerbackX24
offline
Link
 
If you ever played CB in RL youŽd know why a CB doesnt need to be the fastest player on the field. I think if theres one thing in this game that is very well balanced its how CBs play coverage.
Hint: streaks are the easiest route to cover
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Also something to look at, the KR/WR for WWR looks significantly slower now without his 9000+ vision. Could vision play a small role in just flat out speed?

Or maybe it is confidence that effects your top speed, regardless of morale.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by lolMurp
diving tackle, so how's that CB's jumping?


My CB has 64.62 jumping....
 
griffin8r
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by chronoaug

I dunno about the running WRs down thing, but especially when watching Ins, unders and short routes like that, there seems to be a bit of a speed/agility cap on both the WR/TE and the defensive player covering them. It's weird and sometimes they look like robots with the WR just mimicking the WR/TE at a set distance. Creative route running i've seen makes that a bit different and break the route with agility moves but hard to tell exactly


Yep and it seems like there's a cap on their speed on streak routes as well.


Cap = 100

I TOLD YOU PEOPLE MANY TIMES that the sim doesn't acknowledge >100 on any attribute.

I don't give a shit what Bort said. You have your proof right here.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Here's the key to this: The speed attribute works in a really dumb way in GLB.

In real football, you have even some high school WRs with a 40 time of 4.5. I'm a 6-foot pasty white guy and I ran a 4.9 in high school in my senior year of football. I wasn't even a terribly dedicated athlete, and I was second-string.

WRs and CBs come out of college all the time with a 4.4 to 4.6 speed. There's a VERY narrow range of speed between a NFL speed guy and um... me. Or the old me. Half a second over 40 yards? While that's a noticeable difference in a side-by-side foot race, the equivalent in GLB wouldn't be huge, right? Weird..


Yeah, this imo, is a problem with the game.

20 speed = 4 minute 40
120 speed = 3 second 40

It should range from 4 to 5 seconds, or even 4 to 6 seconds tops...not 4 to 240 seconds.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by griffin8r
Cap = 100

I TOLD YOU PEOPLE MANY TIMES that the sim doesn't acknowledge >100 on any attribute.

I don't give a shit what Bort said. You have your proof right here.


p sure that WWR proved that incorrect
 
PierreThomas
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cornerbackX24
If you ever played CB in RL youŽd know why a CB doesnt need to be the fastest player on the field. I think if theres one thing in this game that is very well balanced its how CBs play coverage.
Hint: streaks are the easiest route to cover


Well thanks, that explains it. If Champ Bailey was chasing Chris Johnson he would catch him even though he isn't as fast. The difference that we've all been neglecting is Champ Bailey is listed as a CB and Chris Johnson is listed as a RB. I can't believe I overlooked it, that makes complete sense.
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Also something to look at, the KR/WR for WWR looks significantly slower now without his 9000+ vision. Could vision play a small role in just flat out speed?

Or maybe it is confidence that effects your top speed, regardless of morale.


He still looks just as fast to me. It's just his pathing isn't lolwtfcrazy.
 
PierreThomas
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cornerbackX24
If you ever played CB in RL youŽd know why a CB doesnt need to be the fastest player on the field. I think if theres one thing in this game that is very well balanced its how CBs play coverage.
Hint: streaks are the easiest route to cover


What if the CB was in a wheel chair but has great instincts?

edit: The field is flat.
Edited by PierreThomas on Jul 9, 2009 18:15:21
 
Link
 
Originally posted by cornerbackX24
If you ever played CB in RL youŽd know why a CB doesnt need to be the fastest player on the field. I think if theres one thing in this game that is very well balanced its how CBs play coverage.
Hint: streaks are the easiest route to cover


I played CB in high school and in a tackle (with full eq) intramural football league with the Air Force. I would say this is definitely true. I routinely covered WRs that I'm certain were faster than me. It has to do with being able to quickly diagnose the play and the route the WR was running, and be in a position to pounce in case the ball was coming our way.

Most WRs I played against tended to give the play away by where they were looking. Once you know what's going on, you can use your cushion and some bumping to stay on the WR the entire route. Having good footwork and hip motion is crucial to coverage as well, which meant we practiced backpedaling and transitioning for hours on end.

As far as the deep route goes, once you know that's what's going on, a CB can use the cushion and field positioning to cover it very well despite a speed differential.
Edited by fallingmercury on Jul 9, 2009 18:19:45
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
He still looks just as fast to me. It's just his pathing isn't lolwtfcrazy.


True...using my script, his speed is exactly the same.

There goes that theory, though morale could definitely be playing a part.
 
PierreThomas
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Sik Wit It

He still looks just as fast to me. It's just his pathing isn't lolwtfcrazy.


True...using my script, his speed is exactly the same.

There goes that theory, though morale could definitely be playing a part.


If morale is a factor then how much better could the morale be if a RB starts with 100 (per Bort) and on the first play of the game he breaks a long run?
 
tsherr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Originally posted by cornerbackX24

If you ever played CB in RL youŽd know why a CB doesnt need to be the fastest player on the field. I think if theres one thing in this game that is very well balanced its how CBs play coverage.
Hint: streaks are the easiest route to cover


I played CB in high school and in a tackle intramural football league with the Air Force. I would say this is definitely true. I routinely covered WRs that I'm certain were faster than me. It has to do with being able to quickly diagnose the play and the route the WR was running, and be in a position to pounce in case the ball was coming our way.

Most WRs I played against tended to give the play away by where they were looking. Once you know what's going on, you can use your cushion and some bumping to stay on the WR the entire route. Having good footwork and hip motion is crucial to coverage as well, which meant we practiced backpedaling and transitioning for hours on end.

As far as the deep route goes, once you know that's what's going on, a CB can use the cushion and field positioning to cover it very well despite a speed differential.


Is there bumping in GLB?

T
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by fallingmercury

Here's the key to this: The speed attribute works in a really dumb way in GLB.

In real football, you have even some high school WRs with a 40 time of 4.5. I'm a 6-foot pasty white guy and I ran a 4.9 in high school in my senior year of football. I wasn't even a terribly dedicated athlete, and I was second-string.

WRs and CBs come out of college all the time with a 4.4 to 4.6 speed. There's a VERY narrow range of speed between a NFL speed guy and um... me. Or the old me. Half a second over 40 yards? While that's a noticeable difference in a side-by-side foot race, the equivalent in GLB wouldn't be huge, right? Weird..


Yeah, this imo, is a problem with the game.

20 speed = 4 minute 40
120 speed = 3 second 40

It should range from 4 to 5 seconds, or even 4 to 6 seconds tops...not 4 to 240 seconds.


Bort really needs to read this.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.