User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Add a MINUMUM cap for each league will solve all!
Page:
 
reddogrw
HOOD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Staz
Originally posted by reddogrw

So basically all this does is that when you decide to gut and start over, you cannot fill your team with new players but instead crappy CPU players and the team still gets killed.

Solves nothing.


So you expect to be able to compete mid-season when you gut? If you were to be able to sign a team, they'd be shitty players. If you want to "start over", wait until the offseason so you can be moved down to an appropriate league.


the OP's whole premise is to avoid blowouts

if a team chooses to start over, they will just sell their players off and have to back fill with CPU players instead of signing actual players

doesn't solve anything and creates a TON of other problems

unfortunately, most that are in favor of this believe it to be a panacea for addressing the issue brought forward and won't listen to anyone who points out flaws in the suggestion

the only way to show people what a disaster this would be would be to implement it and watch things implode

it also eliminates having some lower level guys just for special teams, which many teams do

the problems this would create are endless; sorry you cannot see that

and for the record, none of this would affect me, but I am not short sighted enough to just look at my personal situation but GLB as a whole
 
joesox
offline
Link
 
sounds good but there a lack of teams with lvl 13 cap so that needs to be improve or need to expand d-league to lvl 8 or somethin
 
The Avenger
Hulk Smash
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by reddogrw
Originally posted by Staz

Originally posted by reddogrw


So basically all this does is that when you decide to gut and start over, you cannot fill your team with new players but instead crappy CPU players and the team still gets killed.

Solves nothing.


So you expect to be able to compete mid-season when you gut? If you were to be able to sign a team, they'd be shitty players. If you want to "start over", wait until the offseason so you can be moved down to an appropriate league.


the OP's whole premise is to avoid blowouts

if a team chooses to start over, they will just sell their players off and have to back fill with CPU players instead of signing actual players

doesn't solve anything and creates a TON of other problems

unfortunately, most that are in favor of this believe it to be a panacea for addressing the issue brought forward and won't listen to anyone who points out flaws in the suggestion

the only way to show people what a disaster this would be would be to implement it and watch things implode

it also eliminates having some lower level guys just for special teams, which many teams do

the problems this would create are endless; sorry you cannot see that

and for the record, none of this would affect me, but I am not short sighted enough to just look at my personal situation but GLB as a whole


Um lower level guys can still fill special teams hence the gap between max level and low level cap!

Also riddle me this Batman - if this is some sort of disaster of an idea or imploding things that you accuse of (without any reason except to be anti-everything) then WHY do we have max caps???

Why? why have max caps at all? Please enlighten me because all a max cap does is nothing. I have level 26's vs level 1 sloww builds all over the place in our league and god knows how many other leagues so if a team full of level 20's in a non-max cap league is supposed to be different i don't see it at all!!

Last edited May 13, 2009 17:55:42
 
reddogrw
HOOD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The Avenger
Originally posted by reddogrw

Originally posted by Staz


Originally posted by reddogrw



So basically all this does is that when you decide to gut and start over, you cannot fill your team with new players but instead crappy CPU players and the team still gets killed.

Solves nothing.


So you expect to be able to compete mid-season when you gut? If you were to be able to sign a team, they'd be shitty players. If you want to "start over", wait until the offseason so you can be moved down to an appropriate league.


the OP's whole premise is to avoid blowouts

if a team chooses to start over, they will just sell their players off and have to back fill with CPU players instead of signing actual players

doesn't solve anything and creates a TON of other problems

unfortunately, most that are in favor of this believe it to be a panacea for addressing the issue brought forward and won't listen to anyone who points out flaws in the suggestion

the only way to show people what a disaster this would be would be to implement it and watch things implode

it also eliminates having some lower level guys just for special teams, which many teams do

the problems this would create are endless; sorry you cannot see that

and for the record, none of this would affect me, but I am not short sighted enough to just look at my personal situation but GLB as a whole


Um lower level guys can still fill special teams hence the gap between max level and low level cap!

Also riddle me this Batman - if this is some sort of disaster of an idea or imploding things that you accuse of (without any reason except to be anti-everything) then WHY do we have max caps???

Why? why have max caps at all? Please enlighten me because all a max cap does is nothing. I have level 26's vs level 1 sloww builds all over the place in our league and god knows how many other leagues so if a team full of level 20's in a non-max cap league is supposed to be different i don't see it at all!!



that is why Bort has begun to re-shuffle things - if he continues to do so around a team's median player range he will get the leagues more competitive without implementing the multitude of suggestions people keep making to try to over regulate every team

he has begun this process; let it play out for another season or 2
 
puubescent
offline
Link
 
You have to go even further than that because everyone wants 'realistic' right? Have no regions just league levels. Add a BB league and when your player(s) go from level 16 to 17 they are forced to play in BBB until they are level 25 like this.

PeeWee or D-league - level 1-8 only
BB - level 9-16 only <--------- these would have to be tweaked because you can sign with
BBB - level 17-24 only <----- BB at 16 and be able to skip BBB after leveling and boosting
A - level 25-32 only
AA - level 33- 40 only
AAA - level 41-48 only
Pro - level 48+
Players must be in that range at the beginning of that season.

Teams couldn't stay together for as long as they do now, but they could stay together somewhat. Teams go CPU or decide to re-build, they would move back down to BB and winners could move up if they choose in the next season. Players on a CPU team has to ride the storm until next season. You better pick a good team. CPU teams will be replaced with the waiting list, but must go to BB automatically or a GM can take over the team if he pays to be on the waiting list. Being in Pro should be earned. This would also stop teams from slow building for multiple seasons. With the roster limit players would have to play and with the exp they wouldn't be able to stay together for more than 3 seasons.

Now find my holes for my idea.


Edit: Yes, that means 1 year contracts for everyone until you are Pro.
Last edited May 14, 2009 10:03:57
 
reddogrw
HOOD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by puubescent
You have to go even further than that because everyone wants 'realistic' right? Have no regions just league levels. Add a BB league and when your player(s) go from level 16 to 17 they are forced to play in BBB until they are level 25 like this.

PeeWee or D-league - level 1-8 only
BB - level 9-16 only <--------- these would have to be tweaked because you can sign with
BBB - level 17-24 only <----- BB at 16 and be able to skip BBB after leveling and boosting
A - level 25-32 only
AA - level 33- 40 only
AAA - level 41-48 only
Pro - level 48+
Players must be in that range at the beginning of that season.

Teams couldn't stay together for as long as they do now, but they could stay together somewhat. Teams go CPU or decide to re-build, they would move back down to BB and winners could move up if they choose in the next season. Teams players that are on CPU cannot move. You better pick a good team. CPU teams will be replaced with the waiting list, but must go to BB automatically. Being in Pro should be earned. This would also stop teams from slow building for multiple seasons. With the roster limit players would have to play and with the exp they wouldn't be able to stay together for more than 3 seasons.

Now find my holes for my idea.


Edit: Yes, that means 1 year contracts for everyone until you are Pro.


The bolded part is why this is a HORRIBLE idea.
 
Steelrain72
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by puubescent
You have to go even further than that because everyone wants 'realistic' right? Have no regions just league levels. Add a BB league and when your player(s) go from level 16 to 17 they are forced to play in BBB until they are level 25 like this.

PeeWee or D-league - level 1-8 only
BB - level 9-16 only <--------- these would have to be tweaked because you can sign with
BBB - level 17-24 only <----- BB at 16 and be able to skip BBB after leveling and boosting
A - level 25-32 only
AA - level 33- 40 only
AAA - level 41-48 only
Pro - level 48+
Players must be in that range at the beginning of that season.

Teams couldn't stay together for as long as they do now, but they could stay together somewhat. Teams go CPU or decide to re-build, they would move back down to BB and winners could move up if they choose in the next season. Teams players that are on CPU cannot move. You better pick a good team. CPU teams will be replaced with the waiting list, but must go to BB automatically. Being in Pro should be earned. This would also stop teams from slow building for multiple seasons. With the roster limit players would have to play and with the exp they wouldn't be able to stay together for more than 3 seasons.

Now find my holes for my idea.


Edit: Yes, that means 1 year contracts for everyone until you are Pro.



Great idea, did I miss somewhere on how EQ was handled?
 
puubescent
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by reddogrw
Originally posted by puubescent

You have to go even further than that because everyone wants 'realistic' right? Have no regions just league levels. Add a BB league and when your player(s) go from level 16 to 17 they are forced to play in BBB until they are level 25 like this.

PeeWee or D-league - level 1-8 only
BB - level 9-16 only <--------- these would have to be tweaked because you can sign with
BBB - level 17-24 only <----- BB at 16 and be able to skip BBB after leveling and boosting
A - level 25-32 only
AA - level 33- 40 only
AAA - level 41-48 only
Pro - level 48+
Players must be in that range at the beginning of that season.

Teams couldn't stay together for as long as they do now, but they could stay together somewhat. Teams go CPU or decide to re-build, they would move back down to BB and winners could move up if they choose in the next season. Teams players that are on CPU cannot move. You better pick a good team. CPU teams will be replaced with the waiting list, but must go to BB automatically. Being in Pro should be earned. This would also stop teams from slow building for multiple seasons. With the roster limit players would have to play and with the exp they wouldn't be able to stay together for more than 3 seasons.

Now find my holes for my idea.


Edit: Yes, that means 1 year contracts for everyone until you are Pro.


The bolded part is why this is a HORRIBLE idea.


everyone wants 'realistic' right?

no NFL team has the same roster or even close to the same roster for 5 years
 
puubescent
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Steelrain72
Originally posted by puubescent

You have to go even further than that because everyone wants 'realistic' right? Have no regions just league levels. Add a BB league and when your player(s) go from level 16 to 17 they are forced to play in BBB until they are level 25 like this.

PeeWee or D-league - level 1-8 only
BB - level 9-16 only <--------- these would have to be tweaked because you can sign with
BBB - level 17-24 only <----- BB at 16 and be able to skip BBB after leveling and boosting
A - level 25-32 only
AA - level 33- 40 only
AAA - level 41-48 only
Pro - level 48+
Players must be in that range at the beginning of that season.

Teams couldn't stay together for as long as they do now, but they could stay together somewhat. Teams go CPU or decide to re-build, they would move back down to BB and winners could move up if they choose in the next season. Teams players that are on CPU cannot move. You better pick a good team. CPU teams will be replaced with the waiting list, but must go to BB automatically. Being in Pro should be earned. This would also stop teams from slow building for multiple seasons. With the roster limit players would have to play and with the exp they wouldn't be able to stay together for more than 3 seasons.

Now find my holes for my idea.


Edit: Yes, that means 1 year contracts for everyone until you are Pro.



Great idea, did I miss somewhere on how EQ was handled?


same as now, the teams that move up starting with A will or should have a good base of a stadium and funding for equipment shouldn't be a problem if you want your team to be better, up to the owner. pro is the only league where you would have to pay for more than 1 level (edit for clarity: 1 equip upgrade level you know 8,16,24,32,40,48,56) of equip unless you get players that had a bum owner.
Last edited May 14, 2009 10:13:29
 
reddogrw
HOOD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by puubescent
Originally posted by reddogrw

Originally posted by puubescent


You have to go even further than that because everyone wants 'realistic' right? Have no regions just league levels. Add a BB league and when your player(s) go from level 16 to 17 they are forced to play in BBB until they are level 25 like this.

PeeWee or D-league - level 1-8 only
BB - level 9-16 only <--------- these would have to be tweaked because you can sign with
BBB - level 17-24 only <----- BB at 16 and be able to skip BBB after leveling and boosting
A - level 25-32 only
AA - level 33- 40 only
AAA - level 41-48 only
Pro - level 48+
Players must be in that range at the beginning of that season.

Teams couldn't stay together for as long as they do now, but they could stay together somewhat. Teams go CPU or decide to re-build, they would move back down to BB and winners could move up if they choose in the next season. Teams players that are on CPU cannot move. You better pick a good team. CPU teams will be replaced with the waiting list, but must go to BB automatically. Being in Pro should be earned. This would also stop teams from slow building for multiple seasons. With the roster limit players would have to play and with the exp they wouldn't be able to stay together for more than 3 seasons.

Now find my holes for my idea.


Edit: Yes, that means 1 year contracts for everyone until you are Pro.


The bolded part is why this is a HORRIBLE idea.


everyone wants 'realistic' right?

no NFL team has the same roster or even close to the same roster for 5 years


NFL teams don't have to construct their stadiums like us.
NFL teams don't spend more on equipment than salaries.
etc.

This game isn't anything like the NFL. That's fine.

Playing this games with the same groups of friends is what keeps many people active and I doubt Bort would put something in place to destroy that.

Signing people to longer deals so you can keep rolling them over to avoid chemistry hits is important.

Giving level 32 and above equipment to someone who can only be under contract for one year will destroy a team's finances.

Like I mentioned in previous posts, people are only looking at one aspect of this and not the big picture.
 
puubescent
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by reddogrw
Originally posted by puubescent

Originally posted by reddogrw


Originally posted by puubescent



You have to go even further than that because everyone wants 'realistic' right? Have no regions just league levels. Add a BB league and when your player(s) go from level 16 to 17 they are forced to play in BBB until they are level 25 like this.

PeeWee or D-league - level 1-8 only
BB - level 9-16 only <--------- these would have to be tweaked because you can sign with
BBB - level 17-24 only <----- BB at 16 and be able to skip BBB after leveling and boosting
A - level 25-32 only
AA - level 33- 40 only
AAA - level 41-48 only
Pro - level 48+
Players must be in that range at the beginning of that season.

Teams couldn't stay together for as long as they do now, but they could stay together somewhat. Teams go CPU or decide to re-build, they would move back down to BB and winners could move up if they choose in the next season. Teams players that are on CPU cannot move. You better pick a good team. CPU teams will be replaced with the waiting list, but must go to BB automatically. Being in Pro should be earned. This would also stop teams from slow building for multiple seasons. With the roster limit players would have to play and with the exp they wouldn't be able to stay together for more than 3 seasons.

Now find my holes for my idea.


Edit: Yes, that means 1 year contracts for everyone until you are Pro.


The bolded part is why this is a HORRIBLE idea.


everyone wants 'realistic' right?

no NFL team has the same roster or even close to the same roster for 5 years


NFL teams don't have to construct their stadiums like us.
NFL teams don't spend more on equipment than salaries.
etc.

This game isn't anything like the NFL. That's fine.

Playing this games with the same groups of friends is what keeps many people active and I doubt Bort would put something in place to destroy that.

Signing people to longer deals so you can keep rolling them over to avoid chemistry hits is important.

Giving level 32 and above equipment to someone who can only be under contract for one year will destroy a team's finances.

Like I mentioned in previous posts, people are only looking at one aspect of this and not the big picture.



okay, you realize this is a game and is for FUN not reality. i actually like it the way it is. i wouldn't like this idea that i submitted. i was just letting them know what would have to happen if they wanted leagues to be competitive each and every year.
 
reddogrw
HOOD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by puubescent
Originally posted by reddogrw

Originally posted by puubescent


Originally posted by reddogrw



Originally posted by puubescent




You have to go even further than that because everyone wants 'realistic' right? Have no regions just league levels. Add a BB league and when your player(s) go from level 16 to 17 they are forced to play in BBB until they are level 25 like this.

PeeWee or D-league - level 1-8 only
BB - level 9-16 only <--------- these would have to be tweaked because you can sign with
BBB - level 17-24 only <----- BB at 16 and be able to skip BBB after leveling and boosting
A - level 25-32 only
AA - level 33- 40 only
AAA - level 41-48 only
Pro - level 48+
Players must be in that range at the beginning of that season.

Teams couldn't stay together for as long as they do now, but they could stay together somewhat. Teams go CPU or decide to re-build, they would move back down to BB and winners could move up if they choose in the next season. Teams players that are on CPU cannot move. You better pick a good team. CPU teams will be replaced with the waiting list, but must go to BB automatically. Being in Pro should be earned. This would also stop teams from slow building for multiple seasons. With the roster limit players would have to play and with the exp they wouldn't be able to stay together for more than 3 seasons.

Now find my holes for my idea.


Edit: Yes, that means 1 year contracts for everyone until you are Pro.


The bolded part is why this is a HORRIBLE idea.


everyone wants 'realistic' right?

no NFL team has the same roster or even close to the same roster for 5 years


NFL teams don't have to construct their stadiums like us.
NFL teams don't spend more on equipment than salaries.
etc.

This game isn't anything like the NFL. That's fine.

Playing this games with the same groups of friends is what keeps many people active and I doubt Bort would put something in place to destroy that.

Signing people to longer deals so you can keep rolling them over to avoid chemistry hits is important.

Giving level 32 and above equipment to someone who can only be under contract for one year will destroy a team's finances.

Like I mentioned in previous posts, people are only looking at one aspect of this and not the big picture.



okay, you realize this is a game and is for FUN not reality. i actually like it the way it is. i wouldn't like this idea that i submitted. i was just letting them know what would have to happen if they wanted leagues to be competitive each and every year.


yes - it is more fun when played with people you know

I think the shuffling Bort is doing is the right way to address this - year 1 was a nice start and I hope it continues
 
The Avenger
Hulk Smash
offline
Link
 
But shuffling doesn't fix low level slow build teams playing in 32/24/16 cap leagues! New team owners get their teams and fill them with inapropriate rosters just for the hell of it and not as intended. The happy medium would be at least fill with half the cap minimum. So as for a shuffel, sure all the low avergae level teams go to the bottom but a new team owner joining that league and wanting to compete right away with the "appropriate" max cap will have no fun all year beating on slow builds.......thus the cycle of not renewing ownership, boredom.

Another idea would be to keep the Leagues at just 16 team leagues. There could be a larger diversity of team owners who could plan their future in a level 8 cap league and only play 8 cap teams and another legue where its a 16 cap league with an 8 cap min so those players have somewhere to graduate to and so on..
 
reddogrw
HOOD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The Avenger
But shuffling doesn't fix low level slow build teams playing in 32/24/16 cap leagues! New team owners get their teams and fill them with inapropriate rosters just for the hell of it and not as intended. The happy medium would be at least fill with half the cap minimum. So as for a shuffel, sure all the low avergae level teams go to the bottom but a new team owner joining that league and wanting to compete right away with the "appropriate" max cap will have no fun all year beating on slow builds.......thus the cycle of not renewing ownership, boredom.

Another idea would be to keep the Leagues at just 16 team leagues. There could be a larger diversity of team owners who could plan their future in a level 8 cap league and only play 8 cap teams and another legue where its a 16 cap league with an 8 cap min so those players have somewhere to graduate to and so on..


New team owners would be getting teams at the 13-cap level now - maybe 16

Hardly any new teams at the higher levels now

And since more teams are able to CHOOSE what cap level they play at, slow build teams now have the CHOICE to be shuffled to a lower cap league - look at SA A leagues - one is a level 13 cap - that would have NEVER happened before - the process has begun to address getting similarly leveled teams into the same league and I believe the direction that the game has chosen to under take is the correct one as opposed to this suggestion
 
The Avenger
Hulk Smash
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by reddogrw
Originally posted by The Avenger

But shuffling doesn't fix low level slow build teams playing in 32/24/16 cap leagues! New team owners get their teams and fill them with inapropriate rosters just for the hell of it and not as intended. The happy medium would be at least fill with half the cap minimum. So as for a shuffel, sure all the low avergae level teams go to the bottom but a new team owner joining that league and wanting to compete right away with the "appropriate" max cap will have no fun all year beating on slow builds.......thus the cycle of not renewing ownership, boredom.

Another idea would be to keep the Leagues at just 16 team leagues. There could be a larger diversity of team owners who could plan their future in a level 8 cap league and only play 8 cap teams and another legue where its a 16 cap league with an 8 cap min so those players have somewhere to graduate to and so on..


New team owners would be getting teams at the 13-cap level now - maybe 16

Hardly any new teams at the higher levels now

And since more teams are able to CHOOSE what cap level they play at, slow build teams now have the CHOICE to be shuffled to a lower cap league - look at SA A leagues - one is a level 13 cap - that would have NEVER happened before - the process has begun to address getting similarly leveled teams into the same league and I believe the direction that the game has chosen to under take is the correct one as opposed to this suggestion



Shall i link 6 new threads about un-even games, gutted teams, slow built teams in leagues way too ahead of their teams level?

I'm pretty sure the BIG Bort shuffle caused enough crap to float a GLB Ark, but the problem of "un-competing teams" is still alive and well and frustrates many!



 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.