Really? Poopoomcgoop? That's a horrible suggestion Darkus
Jed
offline
offline
Darkus, you want to put them no double-secret probation?
But seriously, that would be saying "behave upfront, then you can go nuts later!" The message needs to be "this is a responsibility, you need to always behave."
As for the names mentioned.....
EViL is kinda iffy (hell, Darkus, you just suspended him for racism a week ago!)
Johnny has always been a troll at heart
I'm going to assume poopoom was a joke. It's that bad of a suggestion.
I don't know socrforce.
But seriously, that would be saying "behave upfront, then you can go nuts later!" The message needs to be "this is a responsibility, you need to always behave."
As for the names mentioned.....
EViL is kinda iffy (hell, Darkus, you just suspended him for racism a week ago!)
Johnny has always been a troll at heart
I'm going to assume poopoom was a joke. It's that bad of a suggestion.
I don't know socrforce.
Yeah, sorry. I wasn't being 100% serious. I just thought it would give you all a splutter moment when you reached poop.
They are users that may possibly have the ability to reign it in. The reason for the probation is to see how they react to becoming a moderator and to curb the mistakes early on. Once they are in the habit of thinking before they post then you would likely see a downturn in the issues and problems.
As for the ban for racist comment on Evil2cue, the post was made in jest but we have a 0 tolerance rule. I don't think he is all that bad and I had a pretty poor ban history when I had no responsibility.
They are users that may possibly have the ability to reign it in. The reason for the probation is to see how they react to becoming a moderator and to curb the mistakes early on. Once they are in the habit of thinking before they post then you would likely see a downturn in the issues and problems.
As for the ban for racist comment on Evil2cue, the post was made in jest but we have a 0 tolerance rule. I don't think he is all that bad and I had a pretty poor ban history when I had no responsibility.
Jed
offline
offline
If FFA mods are being chosen with the idea of "I think they'll clean up well," that's the first mistake. If I had a nickle for every time someone PM'd me promising they'd be good as soon as they're made a mod, I'd be able to own GLB right now.
You're supposed to be good, then be made a mod.
You're supposed to be good, then be made a mod.
I am not suggesting anyone that has asked for it though. Based on my suspension history, I would not have made me a moderator. People react differently when put into positions of responsibility. Most get power crazy and think it makes them better than others, some take the responsibility of the job on board and get on with it.
There isn't a single user on this board, including the current moderators, that I would suggest would make a good moderator based on their posts and actions as everyone adds something personal to it.
There isn't a single user on this board, including the current moderators, that I would suggest would make a good moderator based on their posts and actions as everyone adds something personal to it.
Vanilla Thunder
offline
offline
Originally posted by Pallow
Originally posted by Deathblade
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2464493
tj is making threads to complain about mods now?
...*sigh*...back to the drawing board. I will deal with this in the AM. Whotookmybow tie made a bad judgment call on a joke thread, but tjking has been talked to about this in the past. Start throwing out replacement names, but these two incidents make me think twice about how we have been select FFA mods.
This gets me hard tbh.
Originally posted by Deathblade
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2464493
tj is making threads to complain about mods now?

...*sigh*...back to the drawing board. I will deal with this in the AM. Whotookmybow tie made a bad judgment call on a joke thread, but tjking has been talked to about this in the past. Start throwing out replacement names, but these two incidents make me think twice about how we have been select FFA mods.
This gets me hard tbh.
Vanilla Thunder
offline
offline
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Pallow
Right. No need to throw in the towel over a couple bad seeds. We have gotten two reliable mods out of the FFA. I think we need to come up with a more reliable way of filtering out the time-bomb mods.
try hitting them?
I mean scientifically speaking has not hitting them been producing the desired result?
In all seriousness, what do we want here? If we want FFA under control, then they system we're using to "reign it in" isn't working and likely won't.
Let's look at this another way. If you want CPL to keeps it's culture, such as it is, and stay in their own yard (for the most part), you let me go in and keep things under wraps. If you want to change CPL and get it to comply to the strict letter of the law, you get someone as different from me as possible.
The same applies to FFA, if you want it under control, you get someone from FFA. If you want it to follow the rules, you bring in someone outside. They won't like them, but if the above is the goal, they aren't there to be liked.
Originally posted by Pallow
Right. No need to throw in the towel over a couple bad seeds. We have gotten two reliable mods out of the FFA. I think we need to come up with a more reliable way of filtering out the time-bomb mods.
try hitting them?
I mean scientifically speaking has not hitting them been producing the desired result?
In all seriousness, what do we want here? If we want FFA under control, then they system we're using to "reign it in" isn't working and likely won't.
Let's look at this another way. If you want CPL to keeps it's culture, such as it is, and stay in their own yard (for the most part), you let me go in and keep things under wraps. If you want to change CPL and get it to comply to the strict letter of the law, you get someone as different from me as possible.
The same applies to FFA, if you want it under control, you get someone from FFA. If you want it to follow the rules, you bring in someone outside. They won't like them, but if the above is the goal, they aren't there to be liked.
Deathblade
offline
offline
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
The same applies to FFA, if you want it under control, you get someone from FFA. If you want it to follow the rules, you bring in someone outside. They won't like them, but if the above is the goal, they aren't there to be liked.
The problem is, the mods not following the rules, outside of FFA. I mean, I completely understand what you are saying here, if you want to retain a culture, pull mods from that culture...but it would be like you posting "SI is a fag" all over GLB and Suggestions, you just can't do that.
The same applies to FFA, if you want it under control, you get someone from FFA. If you want it to follow the rules, you bring in someone outside. They won't like them, but if the above is the goal, they aren't there to be liked.
The problem is, the mods not following the rules, outside of FFA. I mean, I completely understand what you are saying here, if you want to retain a culture, pull mods from that culture...but it would be like you posting "SI is a fag" all over GLB and Suggestions, you just can't do that.
Vanilla Thunder
offline
offline
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
The same applies to FFA, if you want it under control, you get someone from FFA. If you want it to follow the rules, you bring in someone outside. They won't like them, but if the above is the goal, they aren't there to be liked.
The problem is, the mods not following the rules, outside of FFA. I mean, I completely understand what you are saying here, if you want to retain a culture, pull mods from that culture...but it would be like you posting "SI is a fag" all over GLB and Suggestions, you just can't do that.
I see what you're getting at but I don't think that's a worry. As a mod I don't say "SI is a fag" in or out of CPL, it's against the rules (even in CPL) so it's not something I should do. The problem is that we're taking suggestions and promoting people that are after the "power" and "Prestige" (quoted for LOL) of being a mod. For obvious reasons, those are bad choices.
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
The same applies to FFA, if you want it under control, you get someone from FFA. If you want it to follow the rules, you bring in someone outside. They won't like them, but if the above is the goal, they aren't there to be liked.
The problem is, the mods not following the rules, outside of FFA. I mean, I completely understand what you are saying here, if you want to retain a culture, pull mods from that culture...but it would be like you posting "SI is a fag" all over GLB and Suggestions, you just can't do that.
I see what you're getting at but I don't think that's a worry. As a mod I don't say "SI is a fag" in or out of CPL, it's against the rules (even in CPL) so it's not something I should do. The problem is that we're taking suggestions and promoting people that are after the "power" and "Prestige" (quoted for LOL) of being a mod. For obvious reasons, those are bad choices.
Last edited Apr 11, 2009 12:06:25
Deathblade
offline
offline
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
I see what you're getting at but I don't think that's a worry. As a mod I don't say "SI is a fag" in or out of CPL, it's against the rules (even in CPL) so it's not something I should do. The problem is that we're taking suggestions and promoting people that are after the "power" and "Prestige" (quoted for LOL) or being a mod. For obvious reasons, those are bad choices.
Yes, which makes it tough to find FFA mods. The ones craving the power are the ones that somewhat behave, and the ones held on a pedestal by the FFA community are the ones that break rules, excel at inflammatory remarks, and stand up to the mods. So which group do you pick from?
Chessey was from the group wanting power, and he turned out to be pretty good afaik. The ones from the other group are TJ, mwag, and to a lesser extent, whotook. Darkus I don't know about. Picking people who want it has seemed to be the lesser of two evils.
I see what you're getting at but I don't think that's a worry. As a mod I don't say "SI is a fag" in or out of CPL, it's against the rules (even in CPL) so it's not something I should do. The problem is that we're taking suggestions and promoting people that are after the "power" and "Prestige" (quoted for LOL) or being a mod. For obvious reasons, those are bad choices.
Yes, which makes it tough to find FFA mods. The ones craving the power are the ones that somewhat behave, and the ones held on a pedestal by the FFA community are the ones that break rules, excel at inflammatory remarks, and stand up to the mods. So which group do you pick from?
Chessey was from the group wanting power, and he turned out to be pretty good afaik. The ones from the other group are TJ, mwag, and to a lesser extent, whotook. Darkus I don't know about. Picking people who want it has seemed to be the lesser of two evils.
Chessey
offline
offline
Originally posted by Deathblade
Chessey was from the group wanting power, and he turned out to be pretty good afaik.
Don't fall for the trap tbh
Chessey was from the group wanting power, and he turned out to be pretty good afaik.
Don't fall for the trap tbh
Vanilla Thunder
offline
offline
Originally posted by Deathblade
Picking people who want it has seemed to be the lesser of two evils.
Forcing a false choice are bit aren't you?
Picking people who want it has seemed to be the lesser of two evils.
Forcing a false choice are bit aren't you?
Chessey
offline
offline
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by Deathblade
Picking people who want it has seemed to be the lesser of two evils.
Forcing a false choice are bit aren't you?
And that is why I'm for not picking people for the sake of having more
Originally posted by Deathblade
Picking people who want it has seemed to be the lesser of two evils.
Forcing a false choice are bit aren't you?
And that is why I'm for not picking people for the sake of having more
Deathblade
offline
offline
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by Deathblade
Picking people who want it has seemed to be the lesser of two evils.
Forcing a false choice are bit aren't you?
Oh I'd be fine with not hiring more, and I'm aware that nobody falls 100% into either "group", but I'm just calling it how I have seen it. Chessey4mod
Originally posted by Deathblade
Picking people who want it has seemed to be the lesser of two evils.
Forcing a false choice are bit aren't you?
Oh I'd be fine with not hiring more, and I'm aware that nobody falls 100% into either "group", but I'm just calling it how I have seen it. Chessey4mod
Jed
offline
offline
NUKE IT FROM ORBIT!
It had been too long since I said that about FFA (and CPL for that matter). Anyway, if other potentially good, responsible mods can be picked from FFA, fine, give it a shot. If not....then it's time for plan B: choose them from outside of FFA and FFA can deal with it or fuck off.
It had been too long since I said that about FFA (and CPL for that matter). Anyway, if other potentially good, responsible mods can be picked from FFA, fine, give it a shot. If not....then it's time for plan B: choose them from outside of FFA and FFA can deal with it or fuck off.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























