I'll openly admit that for me, the worst part about it is that we gained first place on an arguably unfair game. For me, it sucks only for that reason.
mwoods07
offline
offline
Originally posted by roronoa_zoro
Originally posted by mwoods07
Oh yeah...and if anyone wants to see what happens when you know the Strong I is coming and you gameplan for it...I did the "D" for the Toxics, it got ugly pretty fast...not the first time it has happened, but the most recent....
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=379296
?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!? im sorry are u no saying that u new how cheap it was and still used it.
Oh, and the point was, go read the forum now and look for 1 mention of getting stomped by the Strong I. It happens, it sucks, but it happens. Just like the WR Screen happened, unfortunately you have to live with it and hope it isn't used too often.
I know I was done, but just wanted to say...the funny thing is, Cuzco has been in SA for a long while, go back to ALL the games and see if anything like this was EVER done in the past. This isn't the first time Cuzco has played a team who was in first place, yet this WAS the first time a tactic like this was used. Hopefully it would lead a rational person to believe when we say we did it for reason x and not reason y.
Originally posted by mwoods07
Oh yeah...and if anyone wants to see what happens when you know the Strong I is coming and you gameplan for it...I did the "D" for the Toxics, it got ugly pretty fast...not the first time it has happened, but the most recent....
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=379296
?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!? im sorry are u no saying that u new how cheap it was and still used it.
Oh, and the point was, go read the forum now and look for 1 mention of getting stomped by the Strong I. It happens, it sucks, but it happens. Just like the WR Screen happened, unfortunately you have to live with it and hope it isn't used too often.
I know I was done, but just wanted to say...the funny thing is, Cuzco has been in SA for a long while, go back to ALL the games and see if anything like this was EVER done in the past. This isn't the first time Cuzco has played a team who was in first place, yet this WAS the first time a tactic like this was used. Hopefully it would lead a rational person to believe when we say we did it for reason x and not reason y.
CarawayDotCom
offline
offline
Originally posted by roronoa_zoro
Originally posted by roronoa_zoro
ZETA>ALPHA>cuzco
^_^
Correction
ZETA>ALPHA>cuzco>dog poo>mwoods07
Lol sorry i just couldnt resist.
Edit: i know its childish but im being called childish enough so ima just go with it ^_^.
Keyboard Commando.... give it up man... this thread is failing bad enough. Should of taken my advice in the first place and GTFO!
Aside from everything else, you guys are bitching because you lost..I get that..if you would've won we wouldnt have heard shit about our plays..but whatever. Fuck it. You want a "normal" game played vs. us? Fine! I sent a scrimmage to you. Other than that you guys can shut your mouths about this shit because it gets tiring reading a bunch of hogwash.
Woods..I think thats about all we need to say in here man.
Originally posted by roronoa_zoro
ZETA>ALPHA>cuzco
^_^
Correction
ZETA>ALPHA>cuzco>dog poo>mwoods07
Lol sorry i just couldnt resist.
Edit: i know its childish but im being called childish enough so ima just go with it ^_^.
Keyboard Commando.... give it up man... this thread is failing bad enough. Should of taken my advice in the first place and GTFO!
Aside from everything else, you guys are bitching because you lost..I get that..if you would've won we wouldnt have heard shit about our plays..but whatever. Fuck it. You want a "normal" game played vs. us? Fine! I sent a scrimmage to you. Other than that you guys can shut your mouths about this shit because it gets tiring reading a bunch of hogwash.
Woods..I think thats about all we need to say in here man.
alladinsane
offline
offline
2-3 seasons ago I remember people saying the elusive backs were too awesome
Last season the passing games were too strong.
This season (and probably a good bit last one as well) the powerbacks are strong.
You can read all of this in the bug forums...its always something and I guess thats why we are still in Beta (expensive beta nonetheless)
In order to justify that someone was planning to be ‘dishonorable’ you would have to build a case that they were planning this 5-7 seasons ago when they began building what was at the time ‘just a powerback’. The sliding scale that we try to use online of what is ‘honorable’ seems a bit subjective at least and an excuse at worst. I used to play BRE (barren realms elite)on bulletin boards back before the net was really widespread and sooner or later during every reset there would erupt a flamewar over a ‘dishonorable’ attack or conduct etc. Nothing has changed and the ‘honor’ of online gaming that people lament as ‘gone’ probably never existed in the first place, at least to the degree that selective memory conjures.
Being an ‘older’ member of this community, I think back and remember the Oklahoma, Texas, and Nebraska teams (among others) who ran the powerT and Wishbone formations in the 70’s of my youth. You could hate those teams, especially when they held that darn ball for 8min a quarter(never passing!) and just whipped the crap out of people with them big ol farm boys clearing the way. Eventually those plays no longer worked and teams like UCLA, Florida, and Tennessee started dominating with their wide open offenses. In no case did any of those coaches break any moral commitments (recruiting aside) by implementing those offenses any more than Buddy Ryan cheated by using the 46 defense during the bears super-run. Judging or measuring their morality using the ‘flavor of the month’ is a zero sum game with no winners imo.
This is already too long, sorry. We have been running a powerback for 2+ seasons, from back when elusives were too strong and last season when the passing game was too strong. I run my back often, though out of many formations and try to mix it up because we did get stopped last season by Bogata. It can be done, its difficult (or maybe I stink as an OC). When it gets nerfed, we will adjust and all of you will too. Calling each other names though...what has it accomplished. I hope nobody leaves this league because of it though, despite this being our first season here, we have grown to know quite a few characters that would be sorely missed.
Be well
Last season the passing games were too strong.
This season (and probably a good bit last one as well) the powerbacks are strong.
You can read all of this in the bug forums...its always something and I guess thats why we are still in Beta (expensive beta nonetheless)
In order to justify that someone was planning to be ‘dishonorable’ you would have to build a case that they were planning this 5-7 seasons ago when they began building what was at the time ‘just a powerback’. The sliding scale that we try to use online of what is ‘honorable’ seems a bit subjective at least and an excuse at worst. I used to play BRE (barren realms elite)on bulletin boards back before the net was really widespread and sooner or later during every reset there would erupt a flamewar over a ‘dishonorable’ attack or conduct etc. Nothing has changed and the ‘honor’ of online gaming that people lament as ‘gone’ probably never existed in the first place, at least to the degree that selective memory conjures.
Being an ‘older’ member of this community, I think back and remember the Oklahoma, Texas, and Nebraska teams (among others) who ran the powerT and Wishbone formations in the 70’s of my youth. You could hate those teams, especially when they held that darn ball for 8min a quarter(never passing!) and just whipped the crap out of people with them big ol farm boys clearing the way. Eventually those plays no longer worked and teams like UCLA, Florida, and Tennessee started dominating with their wide open offenses. In no case did any of those coaches break any moral commitments (recruiting aside) by implementing those offenses any more than Buddy Ryan cheated by using the 46 defense during the bears super-run. Judging or measuring their morality using the ‘flavor of the month’ is a zero sum game with no winners imo.
This is already too long, sorry. We have been running a powerback for 2+ seasons, from back when elusives were too strong and last season when the passing game was too strong. I run my back often, though out of many formations and try to mix it up because we did get stopped last season by Bogata. It can be done, its difficult (or maybe I stink as an OC). When it gets nerfed, we will adjust and all of you will too. Calling each other names though...what has it accomplished. I hope nobody leaves this league because of it though, despite this being our first season here, we have grown to know quite a few characters that would be sorely missed.
Be well
geturembedder
offline
offline
Not bitching about power backs. Bitching about a blatant exploit that any team can use with any back.
alladinsane
offline
offline
I get that and I hope it does get fixed.
Though I still expect (or hope) that powerbacks can break some tackles, that elusives can dodge some tackles, that RDE's (another big exploit complaint) can get some sacks, that WR's can still get open using pure speed, that blitz packages can stop certain runs and passes and that screen plays can burn those blitzes etc.
We are playing an imperfect simulation of (I can't believe I am saying this: ) an imperfect game.
I may need an intervention after that.
If any team can use it, why doesn't every team use it and we can just call it even. I understand that it might make the game boring though, just as the passing exploit of last season made the game exciting (sorta like arena ball lol!). The best builds are going to be a factor throughout the life of GLB I think, otherwise there wouldn't be so many teams losing their butts for 3-4 seasons just to 'slow-build' what they think is a winning program. Every advantage can be termed an exploit of some sort or other can't it? I am still learning here so I defer to those of you with greater experience in all of this, I am just confused by the whole labelling of other people as lacking integrity or morality or honor or whatever. I don't see where that gets us.
You know....revenge is a dish best served cold
edit: formatting
Though I still expect (or hope) that powerbacks can break some tackles, that elusives can dodge some tackles, that RDE's (another big exploit complaint) can get some sacks, that WR's can still get open using pure speed, that blitz packages can stop certain runs and passes and that screen plays can burn those blitzes etc.
We are playing an imperfect simulation of (I can't believe I am saying this: ) an imperfect game.
I may need an intervention after that.
If any team can use it, why doesn't every team use it and we can just call it even. I understand that it might make the game boring though, just as the passing exploit of last season made the game exciting (sorta like arena ball lol!). The best builds are going to be a factor throughout the life of GLB I think, otherwise there wouldn't be so many teams losing their butts for 3-4 seasons just to 'slow-build' what they think is a winning program. Every advantage can be termed an exploit of some sort or other can't it? I am still learning here so I defer to those of you with greater experience in all of this, I am just confused by the whole labelling of other people as lacking integrity or morality or honor or whatever. I don't see where that gets us.
You know....revenge is a dish best served cold
edit: formatting
Last edited Mar 19, 2009 18:34:41
valakar
offline
offline
Originally posted by CarawayDotCom
Originally posted by roronoa_zoro
Originally posted by roronoa_zoro
ZETA>ALPHA>cuzco
^_^
Correction
ZETA>ALPHA>cuzco>dog poo>mwoods07
Lol sorry i just couldnt resist.
Edit: i know its childish but im being called childish enough so ima just go with it ^_^.
Keyboard Commando.... give it up man... this thread is failing bad enough. Should of taken my advice in the first place and GTFO!
Aside from everything else, you guys are bitching because you lost..I get that..if you would've won we wouldnt have heard shit about our plays..but whatever. Fuck it. You want a "normal" game played vs. us? Fine! I sent a scrimmage to you. Other than that you guys can shut your mouths about this shit because it gets tiring reading a bunch of hogwash.
Woods..I think thats about all we need to say in here man.
I promise you even had we won I would have commented on that bogus AI bullshit. Believe me on that. The only difference would have been I would have been able to say that you tried to win using underhanded tactics and failed.
Originally posted by roronoa_zoro
Originally posted by roronoa_zoro
ZETA>ALPHA>cuzco
^_^
Correction
ZETA>ALPHA>cuzco>dog poo>mwoods07
Lol sorry i just couldnt resist.
Edit: i know its childish but im being called childish enough so ima just go with it ^_^.
Keyboard Commando.... give it up man... this thread is failing bad enough. Should of taken my advice in the first place and GTFO!
Aside from everything else, you guys are bitching because you lost..I get that..if you would've won we wouldnt have heard shit about our plays..but whatever. Fuck it. You want a "normal" game played vs. us? Fine! I sent a scrimmage to you. Other than that you guys can shut your mouths about this shit because it gets tiring reading a bunch of hogwash.
Woods..I think thats about all we need to say in here man.
I promise you even had we won I would have commented on that bogus AI bullshit. Believe me on that. The only difference would have been I would have been able to say that you tried to win using underhanded tactics and failed.
CarawayDotCom
offline
offline
Originally posted by alladinsane
If any team can use it, why doesn't every team use it and we can just call it even.
Nice way to look at it from my perspective..
If any team can use it, why doesn't every team use it and we can just call it even.
Nice way to look at it from my perspective..
geturembedder
offline
offline
Originally posted by alladinsane
I get that and I hope it does get fixed.
Though I still expect (or hope) that powerbacks can break some tackles, that elusives can dodge some tackles, that RDE's (another big exploit complaint) can get some sacks, that WR's can still get open using pure speed, that blitz packages can stop certain runs and passes and that screen plays can burn those blitzes etc.
We are playing an imperfect simulation of (I can't believe I am saying this: ) an imperfect game.
I may need an intervention after that.
If any team can use it, why doesn't every team use it and we can just call it even. I understand that it might make the game boring though, just as the passing exploit of last season made the game exciting (sorta like arena ball lol!). The best builds are going to be a factor throughout the life of GLB I think, otherwise there wouldn't be so many teams losing their butts for 3-4 seasons just to 'slow-build' what they think is a winning program. Every advantage can be termed an exploit of some sort or other can't it? I am still learning here so I defer to those of you with greater experience in all of this, I am just confused by the whole labelling of other people as lacking integrity or morality or honor or whatever. I don't see where that gets us.
You know....revenge is a dish best served cold
edit: formatting
Again though. it's the formation blocking that is the exploit. Elusive backs set on a power slide actually run it a little bit better. Don't break he tackles but get upfield quicker. Teams have been bitching about it all season, as there are teams who run it 100% for four downs.
What that causes is morale to drop which affects the other offense, UNLESS they are set to run STR I 100% of the time too. And there are a few leagues that have come to that. Read the forums. 10 yard fight is the name of the game. If it was a build issue then that is something you can work towards or buy new equip to compensate. You can't do anything about the power I.
And yes the WR screen was an exploit that finally got fixed. Teams were using that 100% of the time as well and was no less BS then what happened today.
If you really want to think about it, all of us are stupid for not employing that play. And then it comes down to which back fumbles less. There are many games that happen this way, and it is unfortunate that Cuzco wants to play that way.
But most of us here know that is BS so we don't do it. Until today.
I get that and I hope it does get fixed.
Though I still expect (or hope) that powerbacks can break some tackles, that elusives can dodge some tackles, that RDE's (another big exploit complaint) can get some sacks, that WR's can still get open using pure speed, that blitz packages can stop certain runs and passes and that screen plays can burn those blitzes etc.
We are playing an imperfect simulation of (I can't believe I am saying this: ) an imperfect game.
I may need an intervention after that.
If any team can use it, why doesn't every team use it and we can just call it even. I understand that it might make the game boring though, just as the passing exploit of last season made the game exciting (sorta like arena ball lol!). The best builds are going to be a factor throughout the life of GLB I think, otherwise there wouldn't be so many teams losing their butts for 3-4 seasons just to 'slow-build' what they think is a winning program. Every advantage can be termed an exploit of some sort or other can't it? I am still learning here so I defer to those of you with greater experience in all of this, I am just confused by the whole labelling of other people as lacking integrity or morality or honor or whatever. I don't see where that gets us.
You know....revenge is a dish best served cold
edit: formatting
Again though. it's the formation blocking that is the exploit. Elusive backs set on a power slide actually run it a little bit better. Don't break he tackles but get upfield quicker. Teams have been bitching about it all season, as there are teams who run it 100% for four downs.
What that causes is morale to drop which affects the other offense, UNLESS they are set to run STR I 100% of the time too. And there are a few leagues that have come to that. Read the forums. 10 yard fight is the name of the game. If it was a build issue then that is something you can work towards or buy new equip to compensate. You can't do anything about the power I.
And yes the WR screen was an exploit that finally got fixed. Teams were using that 100% of the time as well and was no less BS then what happened today.
If you really want to think about it, all of us are stupid for not employing that play. And then it comes down to which back fumbles less. There are many games that happen this way, and it is unfortunate that Cuzco wants to play that way.
But most of us here know that is BS so we don't do it. Until today.
alladinsane
offline
offline
I am finding out that I didn't really know exactly what the 'exploit' was and was probably feeling a bit defensive that we use our powerback like a battering ram. I didn't realize that it was strictly a strong I thing (though we have used that too, just not exclusively) and thought it was about powerbacks in general. When we beat Bogata, plax said (in a joking way I think) that we had used the powerback exploit and I was worried that I had, even if inadvertently, cheated (by some peoples opinion) and didn't want anything like that staining my teams reputation because we (the SHARKS) are not about that.
I apologize for this to everyone whom I may have misled or misunderstood.
I still wonder if there is a possible 'gentlemens agreement' that can be tendered. I guess its up to the community.
Be well
I apologize for this to everyone whom I may have misled or misunderstood.
I still wonder if there is a possible 'gentlemens agreement' that can be tendered. I guess its up to the community.
Be well
aceor
offline
offline
Miss a few hours, miss a lot.
I think alladinsane made some great points. And probably did a lot to calm things down. Thanks for that. I don't want to fan the flames again, and certainly am not interested in bad mouthing anyone. But I need to make 1 last comment ....
As I said yesterday geturembedder ... I have a lot of respect for you, and what you've accomplished with your team. You too Valakar, for what you've done with the Addicts organization. But I do think there is too much morality being thrown around here. I won't take the time to look, but do you both think we won't find any "exploits" used by all those teams your involved with? Valakar, I swear you are on 1/2 the teams in GLB! And none of them ever used a WR screen when it was OP? And get ... you've never run a strong I OT run that got you 6 yards before? Your point will be that it was the overuse that is the problem. But that's where I come back to morality. Once, many times ... what's the diff?
I think alladinsane made some great points. And probably did a lot to calm things down. Thanks for that. I don't want to fan the flames again, and certainly am not interested in bad mouthing anyone. But I need to make 1 last comment ....
As I said yesterday geturembedder ... I have a lot of respect for you, and what you've accomplished with your team. You too Valakar, for what you've done with the Addicts organization. But I do think there is too much morality being thrown around here. I won't take the time to look, but do you both think we won't find any "exploits" used by all those teams your involved with? Valakar, I swear you are on 1/2 the teams in GLB! And none of them ever used a WR screen when it was OP? And get ... you've never run a strong I OT run that got you 6 yards before? Your point will be that it was the overuse that is the problem. But that's where I come back to morality. Once, many times ... what's the diff?
mwoods07
offline
offline
Just a couple of things for you alladinsane...
It is strictly from the strong I.
It is strictly for powerbacks, as if they don't break tackles they are only getting 2-3 ypc.
And Cuzco does not (man, I keep repeating this) want to use this exclusively.
It is strictly from the strong I.
It is strictly for powerbacks, as if they don't break tackles they are only getting 2-3 ypc.
And Cuzco does not (man, I keep repeating this) want to use this exclusively.
geturembedder
offline
offline
Originally posted by aceor
Miss a few hours, miss a lot.
I think alladinsane made some great points. And probably did a lot to calm things down. Thanks for that. I don't want to fan the flames again, and certainly am not interested in bad mouthing anyone. But I need to make 1 last comment ....
As I said yesterday geturembedder ... I have a lot of respect for you, and what you've accomplished with your team. You too Valakar, for what you've done with the Addicts organization. But I do think there is too much morality being thrown around here. I won't take the time to look, but do you both think we won't find any "exploits" used by all those teams your involved with? Valakar, I swear you are on 1/2 the teams in GLB! And none of them ever used a WR screen when it was OP? And get ... you've never run a strong I OT run that got you 6 yards before? Your point will be that it was the overuse that is the problem. But that's where I come back to morality. Once, many times ... what's the diff?
There's a difference in using it a as part of your gameplan and using it exlusively to take advantage of the known bug that teams are in an uproar about. We all used the screen, and we all use the str I. But you knew what you were doing, and you all said as much. Really I have more respect when you guys say, "yeah we did it and what" then when you try to sugar coat it.
You all know I have never "whined" about a loss. This is much more than that.
Now we are faced with a "moral" dillema. Because you guys are right in that, hey if it's there, use it. Don't hate the player, hate the game. I get that. Really to win we should use that exclusively. But that sucks and is really not something I want to play, much less pay for.
However, seeing as we have never had to deal with that crap that plagues the other leagues, it made this enjoyable for all our teams. You can't run that play four times in a row with the I formation lead and have the same results no matter how good your line is or power back. You can still do it, but not like with str I. Like i said, set an elusive to 50 power rush or even 0 rush and he runs through there better than a power back because he shoots up the gap so fast. So this is not about power backs. One of my other GM's got mad at me because he uses one of my backs relentlessly, and asked what the difference is. I have given him a little shit about it in the past even though it's my back, but what he does is still play a complete game, and not the same thing. He does abuse the exploit and I have said so, but not like this.
The moral dilemma is, do we continue to gameplan balanced offense or do we just slam power i 4 times in a row all game. I can tell you what I am gonna do, you can't stop it. All you can do is match it.
Miss a few hours, miss a lot.
I think alladinsane made some great points. And probably did a lot to calm things down. Thanks for that. I don't want to fan the flames again, and certainly am not interested in bad mouthing anyone. But I need to make 1 last comment ....
As I said yesterday geturembedder ... I have a lot of respect for you, and what you've accomplished with your team. You too Valakar, for what you've done with the Addicts organization. But I do think there is too much morality being thrown around here. I won't take the time to look, but do you both think we won't find any "exploits" used by all those teams your involved with? Valakar, I swear you are on 1/2 the teams in GLB! And none of them ever used a WR screen when it was OP? And get ... you've never run a strong I OT run that got you 6 yards before? Your point will be that it was the overuse that is the problem. But that's where I come back to morality. Once, many times ... what's the diff?
There's a difference in using it a as part of your gameplan and using it exlusively to take advantage of the known bug that teams are in an uproar about. We all used the screen, and we all use the str I. But you knew what you were doing, and you all said as much. Really I have more respect when you guys say, "yeah we did it and what" then when you try to sugar coat it.
You all know I have never "whined" about a loss. This is much more than that.
Now we are faced with a "moral" dillema. Because you guys are right in that, hey if it's there, use it. Don't hate the player, hate the game. I get that. Really to win we should use that exclusively. But that sucks and is really not something I want to play, much less pay for.
However, seeing as we have never had to deal with that crap that plagues the other leagues, it made this enjoyable for all our teams. You can't run that play four times in a row with the I formation lead and have the same results no matter how good your line is or power back. You can still do it, but not like with str I. Like i said, set an elusive to 50 power rush or even 0 rush and he runs through there better than a power back because he shoots up the gap so fast. So this is not about power backs. One of my other GM's got mad at me because he uses one of my backs relentlessly, and asked what the difference is. I have given him a little shit about it in the past even though it's my back, but what he does is still play a complete game, and not the same thing. He does abuse the exploit and I have said so, but not like this.
The moral dilemma is, do we continue to gameplan balanced offense or do we just slam power i 4 times in a row all game. I can tell you what I am gonna do, you can't stop it. All you can do is match it.
RandomBeast
offline
offline
Wow. Sad to see the game turn out like that. I know some of the guys on Cuzco and have more than one player on teams they own and GM. I'll just say I am very disappointed in how that went down.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























