User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Repetitive plays: More it's run, more likely the defensive is to stop it.
Page:
 
Link
 
I love the idea of stopping plays that a run and run, and run again, it is terrible for the game, and to tell you the truth, my team has the #1 Offense in our league, and WE HAVE NEVER USED AN EXPLOIT!

If it is broke take it out, and those who are cheating once again, will suffer for the playoffs!
 
simmjer
offline
Link
 
Perfect example of play being ran over and over..

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=426980

Check out Racoon City's plays..

This is retarded..
Last edited Mar 27, 2009 09:50:31
 
blump
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Best way to go about this imo is...give defenses bonuses to their rolls.

More likely to break their block, more likely to make tackles, more likely to get a PD or Int, less likely to fail vision checks, less likely to get faked...all that good stuff.

It seems like it would actually get the job done, and it would be more realistic than say, 5% bonus to all attributes or something.

The % modifiers would be dependent on several factors. Obviously, the more that a team runs a play, the higher it will be. I think it should also increase at a rate relative to vision. Higher vision = higher % modifiers per consecutive play, lower vision = lower % modifiers.


This should happen pronto.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by blump
Originally posted by Deathblade

Best way to go about this imo is...give defenses bonuses to their rolls.

More likely to break their block, more likely to make tackles, more likely to get a PD or Int, less likely to fail vision checks, less likely to get faked...all that good stuff.

It seems like it would actually get the job done, and it would be more realistic than say, 5% bonus to all attributes or something.

The % modifiers would be dependent on several factors. Obviously, the more that a team runs a play, the higher it will be. I think it should also increase at a rate relative to vision. Higher vision = higher % modifiers per consecutive play, lower vision = lower % modifiers.


This should happen pronto.


Think Bort said he preferred the attribute bonuses didn't he?
 
Staz
offline
Link
 
I don't see why. Attribute bonuses are a step in the right direction, but the defensive rolls would be a greater "reality", IMO. If an offense runs a play frequently, the defenders are more likely to shed their blocks, break on the play, deflect a pass, pick it off, get into the backfield, etc.
 
Zumbo
offline
Link
 
+1
 
reneg2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Staz
I don't see why. Attribute bonuses are a step in the right direction, but the defensive rolls would be a greater "reality", IMO. If an offense runs a play frequently, the defenders are more likely to shed their blocks, break on the play, deflect a pass, pick it off, get into the backfield, etc.


+1.

We actually cheesed it up ourselves sadly in order to secure a number 2 seed in our game this week.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=398294

Time of Possession: Passion Fruits 45:59 Kobenhaven 14:01

Going against a much higher level team in an A league, we resorted to some poor tactics for ball control. We ran the same run play pretty much every play of the game aside from being inside the 5 and going to a goal line formation. Our starting offense is 33.8 on average and their starting defense is like 45.2 on average and we were able to beat them with this tactic. It's definitely not right. There needs to be a boost of some sort to at least reactionary type attributes like vision once plays are ran so many times they start hitting tiers. I was thinking like vision/confidence boost perhaps if a play was ran % based by tiers according to how many times a team runs a specific play. For example the play we ran to death was SI Slam. Maybe after the 10th time the play is ran increase the vision/confidence of the opposing defense by 10%. Once they hit 15 times increase it to 20%, etc etc. Some may think this is a bit over the top, but I mean honestly those percentages may even be generous. In real football you would not be able to run the same play over and over again and be remotely successful.

For those that think 'what does this garbage A league game prove in regards to that actually being a factor for Pro level teams'?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=376712

It was used here by the Brazilian Waxers to end an 8X game winning streak by the Santiago Benitos.

Time of Possession: Brazilian Waxers 47:52 Santiago Benitos 12:08
 
IIAMLEGEND
offline
Link
 
THIS IS SOME BULL SHIT, I MADE THIS EXACT SAME THREAD A FEW MONTHS AGO AND IT GOT LOCKED BECAUSE SOME MOD THOUGHT IT WAS A DUMB IDEA, YOU MODS ARE BIASED JERKS
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by IIAMLEGEND
THIS IS SOME BULL SHIT, I MADE THIS EXACT SAME THREAD A FEW MONTHS AGO AND IT GOT LOCKED BECAUSE SOME MOD THOUGHT IT WAS A DUMB IDEA, YOU MODS ARE BIASED JERKS


Probably.
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
This sucks. Knocked out of the playoffs because a team ran the same play every single time for 2-4 yards a crack. They passed it once.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=460851
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Staz
I don't see why. Attribute bonuses are a step in the right direction, but the defensive rolls would be a greater "reality", IMO. If an offense runs a play frequently, the defenders are more likely to shed their blocks, break on the play, deflect a pass, pick it off, get into the backfield, etc.


I don't know if that is exactly the case. Yeah, I like the general idea being proposed here, but I'm not positive that it should relate to attribute bonuses or a higher chance of breaking a block, getting a pd, etc. The biggest thing I think that would be increased is my vision and the likelihood to pass my vision check.

For example-if a team continues to run the same running play, then the defenders are going to know basically what hole the back is trying to hit. So a linebacker will know where he should go to stop the run better, but if a lineman or fullback gets a block on him he wouldn't necessarily be able to break from that block easier.

In passing situations the corner or safety would know what route the receiver is running, and therefore could cover him better and position himself better in regards to the pass, but if the receiver gets open or is better at fighting for the ball, he wouldn't necessarily have a greater chance at pass deflections.

So, to me, I think all things related to vision should be bumped the more a play is ran, but not necessarily other attributes. This is just trying to be realistic, though, and as a sim it could be modified to do whatever it wants.
 
magpie
offline
Link
 
this is an awesome suggestion but would be good if We get more plays to choose from. lol.
 
CoachB05
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kretchfoop
This sucks. Knocked out of the playoffs because a team ran the same play every single time for 2-4 yards a crack. They passed it once.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=460851


If your DC knew how to gameplan to stop the run, or if you had a better defense, or even if you did the EXACT SAME THING, then you MIGHT not have lost. The biggest problem is that we don't have enough plays in the playbook, and at that some of them are unusuable, so other plays are better. Besides, you would only lose in the 2nd round anyway!
 
methomps
offline
Link
 
This should be an obvious add in light of the fact that other cheese plays will eventually rise up to replace the strong I slam. Instead of reacting to each new one by nerfing it later (thus potentially screwing a season up, like this one), get out in front of the problem.
 
cptafw163
offline
Link
 
I blame the Waxer/benito game for this fiasco. that game made it socially acceptable to run the same play over and over again.

Increase the fumbles and player decline throughout the course of the game..that way a HB cannot run the ball more than 30-35 times without severe consequences, or at least zero change of getting broken tackles or diving for yards.

BTW, my team lost because of 4 fumbles and 2 of them were returned for a TD, not the strong I. And they played good defense on third and mid/long. But the fumbles on the kick/punt return fumbles, and a reception fumble hurt the morale more than anything.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.