User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Southeast Asia A Leagues > Southeast Asia A #7 > |_| Season 8 Power Rankings |_|
Page:
 
jdkrick
offline
Link
 
How did we drop below Ack when we just beat them last week?
 
sckbleh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdkrick
How did we drop below Ack when we just beat them last week?


computerized rankings... we've had better results against our other common opponents. In the sense that winning 175-0 is 'better' than 100-0.

The game was pretty damn close and I think our teams are very evenly matched, but I think any human would give you guys the #1 spot in the power rankings because you got the W.
 
gcmont
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sckbleh
Originally posted by jdkrick

How did we drop below Ack when we just beat them last week?


computerized rankings... we've had better results against our other common opponents. In the sense that winning 175-0 is 'better' than 100-0.

The game was pretty damn close and I think our teams are very evenly matched, but I think any human would give you guys the #1 spot in the power rankings because you got the W.



That's still weird though, we were #2 and you were #3 factoring in every game before the head-to-head. Then we won 34-30 and moved down behind Ack to #3. So I don't think it's about common opponents because those were already factored when we were #2 & Ack was #3; it wasn't until after the 34-30 game that we moved down behind Ack, so I guess the computer "expected" us to score more points or allow fewer points. Or something like that...I don't think I fully understand the formula Garrett uses but I thought it was based on expected outputs in Points Allowed/Points Scored.
Last edited Mar 22, 2009 08:47:35
 
brendlefly69
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by gcmont
Originally posted by sckbleh

Originally posted by jdkrick


How did we drop below Ack when we just beat them last week?


computerized rankings... we've had better results against our other common opponents. In the sense that winning 175-0 is 'better' than 100-0.

The game was pretty damn close and I think our teams are very evenly matched, but I think any human would give you guys the #1 spot in the power rankings because you got the W.



That's still weird though, we were #2 and you were #3 factoring in every game before the head-to-head. Then we won 34-30 and moved down behind Ack to #3. So I don't think it's about common opponents because those were already factored when we were #2 & Ack was #3; it wasn't until after the 34-30 game that we moved down behind Ack, so I guess the computer "expected" us to score more points or allow fewer points. Or something like that...I don't think I fully understand the formula Garrett uses but I thought it was based on expected outputs in Points Allowed/Points Scored.


Strength of schedule might be a factor also.
 
gcmont
offline
Link
 
SOS does matter...but again, before we played each other Mongolia was ahead of Ack. That accounted for our schedule before the game. We beat the #3 team, they lost to the #2 team, the only way I could understand them moving up would be if we didn't win by enough to keep the computer happy. The only thing that happened in between: Mongolia: 2; Ack: 3 was the 34-30 game and after that it became Ack: 2; Mongolia: 3. Games 1-11 were factored into the previous rankings, so the fact that they beat Bangkok Authority 175-0 and we won 133-0 was already considered when we were ahead.
 
travo66
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by gcmont
SOS does matter...but again, before we played each other Mongolia was ahead of Ack. That accounted for our schedule before the game. We beat the #3 team, they lost to the #2 team, the only way I could understand them moving up would be if we didn't win by enough to keep the computer happy. The only thing that happened in between: Mongolia: 2; Ack: 3 was the 34-30 game and after that it became Ack: 2; Mongolia: 3. Games 1-11 were factored into the previous rankings, so the fact that they beat Bangkok Authority 175-0 and we won 133-0 was already considered when we were ahead.


Only other possible reason I can think of is if you look at both of your teams' schedules, Ack Attack has played 3 common teams you haven't played yet. Of those 3 teams, 2, Cardinals and Akuma's, had pretty convincing wins over their opponents. The 3rd team lost to the Cardinals in that convincing loss.

Now, your team, Mongolia, had also played (at time of last week's ranking) 3 teams Ack hadn't. If you look at their profiles, that week all 3 teams suffered pretty bad losses. This, combined with the close win/loss (depending on which team's perspective you're looking from), must've been just enough to push the Ack Attack above you in the rankings.

So in summary, I think it is strength of schedule that did you in. I don't know the formula Garrett uses either, but I do think he posted it in one of the forums.

Either way, we got a game coming up with Mongolia, which I'm really looking forward to! Good luck and may the better team win!
 
sckbleh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by gcmont
SOS does matter...but again, before we played each other Mongolia was ahead of Ack. That accounted for our schedule before the game. We beat the #3 team, they lost to the #2 team, the only way I could understand them moving up would be if we didn't win by enough to keep the computer happy. The only thing that happened in between: Mongolia: 2; Ack: 3 was the 34-30 game and after that it became Ack: 2; Mongolia: 3. Games 1-11 were factored into the previous rankings, so the fact that they beat Bangkok Authority 175-0 and we won 133-0 was already considered when we were ahead.


You're reading the rankings wrong. The 'Week 10' rankings have us at #3 and you at #2. That's after the week 10 games -- right before we played each other.

The 'Week 11' rankings, after your 34-30 win, have you at #2 and us at #3. So you did move up.

The 'Week 12' rankings, afer we beat East Timor 173-0 and you beat Kung Pow 155-0, have us ahead of you again.

If you look at the rankings components, we have almost identical strength of schedule components. The difference is the 'quality of play' component.

Here are the scores of our common opponents this season, ack attack first, mongolian horde second.
Bangkok Blues: 68-3, 77-0
Crystal Bay: 176-0, 92-3
Ballers: 183-0, 146-0
Oakland: 58-13, 44-30
Bangkok Authority: 175-0, 132-0
Edo City: 97-17, 54-0
East Timor: 173-0, 108-0

Our margin of victory is significantly higher in most games, with Bangkog Blues being the one exception where you fared better than we did. Note in particular the large difference in score against East Timor, which is the team we played this past week.

I'm not defending this method of ranking teams, just pointing out two things:

1) You actually passed us immediately after beating us, we didn't pass you back in these rankings until after the week 12 games.
2) We're probably ahead of you in the rankings because we're blowing out inferior teams by much wider margins.


 
gcmont
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sckbleh
Originally posted by gcmont

SOS does matter...but again, before we played each other Mongolia was ahead of Ack. That accounted for our schedule before the game. We beat the #3 team, they lost to the #2 team, the only way I could understand them moving up would be if we didn't win by enough to keep the computer happy. The only thing that happened in between: Mongolia: 2; Ack: 3 was the 34-30 game and after that it became Ack: 2; Mongolia: 3. Games 1-11 were factored into the previous rankings, so the fact that they beat Bangkok Authority 175-0 and we won 133-0 was already considered when we were ahead.


You're reading the rankings wrong. The 'Week 10' rankings have us at #3 and you at #2. That's after the week 10 games -- right before we played each other.

The 'Week 11' rankings, after your 34-30 win, have you at #2 and us at #3. So you did move up.

The 'Week 12' rankings, afer we beat East Timor 173-0 and you beat Kung Pow 155-0, have us ahead of you again.

If you look at the rankings components, we have almost identical strength of schedule components. The difference is the 'quality of play' component.

Here are the scores of our common opponents this season, ack attack first, mongolian horde second.
Bangkok Blues: 68-3, 77-0
Crystal Bay: 176-0, 92-3
Ballers: 183-0, 146-0
Oakland: 58-13, 44-30
Bangkok Authority: 175-0, 132-0
Edo City: 97-17, 54-0
East Timor: 173-0, 108-0

Our margin of victory is significantly higher in most games, with Bangkog Blues being the one exception where you fared better than we did. Note in particular the large difference in score against East Timor, which is the team we played this past week.

I'm not defending this method of ranking teams, just pointing out two things:

1) You actually passed us immediately after beating us, we didn't pass you back in these rankings until after the week 12 games.
2) We're probably ahead of you in the rankings because we're blowing out inferior teams by much wider margins.




Shit my bad. Thanks for clearing that up. I understand that the rankings are based on a formula and aren't necessarily perfect...but (and I apologize to Kung Pow) I had it in my head that our schedule was Ack then Macau. Thanks for clearing that up and g/l down the stretch. Sorry a/b that.
 
GarrettFoster
offline
Link
 
Week 13 is up. GG Mongolia

Offense … Defense
3 ..................... 3 .......................... Ack Attack
8 ..................... 6 .......................... Akita Akuma's
22 ..................... 25 .......................... Baby ballers
27 ..................... 22 .......................... Bangkok Authority Figures
30 ..................... 28 .......................... Piscataway Peacocks
16 ..................... 14 .......................... Bangkok Blues
24 ..................... 23 .......................... Cambodian RiverRats
18 ..................... 19 .......................... Crystal Bay Wrecking Balls
19 ..................... 17 .......................... East Timor Hurricanes
14 ..................... 13 .......................... Edo City Shogun
28 ..................... 27 .......................... Hugh Jass Corp
23 ..................... 24 .......................... Jakarta Rhinos
20 ..................... 18 .......................... Koh Tao Triggerfish
26 ..................... 26 .......................... Kung Pow Chickens
4 ..................... 8 .......................... Macau Gamblers
7 ..................... 2 .......................... Mongolian Horde
13 ..................... 10 .......................... Muncie Cardinals
10 ..................... 11 .......................... Nagasaki Bombers
12 ..................... 12 .......................... New England Cowboy
9 ..................... 9 .......................... Oakland Green Machine
21 ..................... 20 .......................... Orlando Tropic Thunder
31 ..................... 31 .......................... Pu Pu Platter
11 ..................... 15 .......................... Saigon Sun Devils
2 ..................... 1 .......................... Shanghai Knights
29 ..................... 32 .......................... Singapore Fighting Falcons
6 ..................... 7 .......................... Star Wars Force
17 ..................... 21 .......................... Super Human Tetris Gods
5 ..................... 5 .......................... Surabaya Tsunami
25 ..................... 29 .......................... The New York Mafia
1 ..................... 4 .......................... To Ken: Love, Bort
15 ..................... 16 .......................... Van Alstyne Venom
32 ..................... 30 .......................... Vietnam Veterans CPU
 
monkeylipps
offline
Link
 
The top game in Garuda could shake things up this week... TKLB vs Surabaya .......I wonder if they'll game plan for them....

either way...it should be fun to watch......
 
jfcvsrxb
offline
Link
 
TKLB never game plans!

Last edited Mar 24, 2009 17:40:51
 
monkeylipps
offline
Link
 
Liar....LOL...good luck guys

Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Originally posted by monkeylipps

Ya'll will be tougher next time.....should be an even better game then...........hope to see ya then....


We will actually game plan then. You did horrible considering how much you out rank us. I would not be proud of that. We will all have lvl 32 EQ come playoff time and you will not be able to token boost.


 
jfcvsrxb
offline
Link
 
Okay, maybe against Shanghai...but NO ONE else gets a game plan from TKLB!!!
 
GarrettFoster
offline
Link
 
Week 14 is up.

Offense … Defense
3 ..................... 3 .......................... Ack Attack
6 ..................... 6 .......................... Akita Akuma's
22 ..................... 25 .......................... Baby ballers
27 ..................... 22 .......................... Bangkok Authority Figures
30 ..................... 28 .......................... Piscataway Peacocks
16 ..................... 14 .......................... Bangkok Blues
23 ..................... 23 .......................... Cambodian RiverRats
17 ..................... 19 .......................... Crystal Bay Wrecking Balls
19 ..................... 17 .......................... East Timor Hurricanes
14 ..................... 13 .......................... Edo City Shogun
28 ..................... 27 .......................... Hugh Jass Corp
24 ..................... 24 .......................... Jakarta Rhinos
20 ..................... 18 .......................... Koh Tao Triggerfish
26 ..................... 26 .......................... Kung Pow Chickens
4 ..................... 8 .......................... Macau Gamblers
7 ..................... 2 .......................... Mongolian Horde
13 ..................... 10 .......................... Muncie Cardinals
11 ..................... 11 .......................... Nagasaki Bombers
12 ..................... 12 .......................... New England Cowboy
10 ..................... 9 .......................... Oakland Green Machine
21 ..................... 20 .......................... Orlando Tropic Thunder
32 ..................... 31 .......................... Pu Pu Platter
9 ..................... 15 .......................... Saigon Sun Devils
2 ..................... 1 .......................... Shanghai Knights
29 ..................... 32 .......................... Singapore Fighting Falcons
8 ..................... 7 .......................... Star Wars Force
18 ..................... 21 .......................... Super Human Tetris Gods
5 ..................... 4 .......................... Surabaya Tsunami
25 ..................... 29 .......................... The New York Mafia
1 ..................... 5 .......................... To Ken: Love, Bort
15 ..................... 16 .......................... Van Alstyne Venom
31 ..................... 30 .......................... Vietnam Veterans CPU
 
brendlefly69
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jfcvsrxb
Okay, maybe against Shanghai...but NO ONE else gets a game plan from TKLB!!!


you guys might want to re think that strategy. good luck in the playoffs though...


http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=413805
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.