User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Oceania AAA Leagues > Oceania AAA #1 > Oceania AAA - Season 2 - MVP Candidates
Page:
 
steelerblitz
offline
Link
 
MVP???

Id rather have a Championship!

Its just a game. Who cares. Let the season play out and the numbers will speak for themselves. The owners will vote, then end of story.

Carry on
 
nhazelett
offline
Link
 
My point was supposed to be that it's harder to make a good defensive lineman than a CB. I've tried it and it's hard, so that's why my vote is going for that DE, sorry I didn't make that clear. For your argument about him covering a #2 receiver, it would be like saying that the right offensive tackle isn't has good as the left offensive tackle because he's not defending a QBs blind spot. It's a moot point.

I keep my build open just because people ask for help building a CB, I don't mind them looking. If they can change their build to help against my guy in 2 days, more power to them. It's not a big deal to me.

But I will take back the douche bag statement, after your last post actually had good points. Your first one was kind of like a "Hey, you suck, here's reasoning with no backing behind it." When Jamal Lewis broke the rushing records against the Browns, it didn't matter that the browns run defense sucked horribly, he still had the record (till last year.) I just thought that you were one of those people who pop their head in, put in your two cents, and leave without thinking, so sorry.
 
DaSaintFan
offline
Link
 
Rudger, you're not helping your cause with the foul language... however:

Originally posted by Rudger
C] Yah MVPs only come from playoff teams, us low lifes on unsuccessful teams dont count. Way to sound like a douche. Also have someone explain the concept of Most Valuable Player to you sometime, it might be enlightening.


Uhm... here's the point... How do you define value. is it someone that turns a "zero" team into a playoff team, or is the most valuable player on any team?

I'm of the opinion that you have to go for a league MVP.. is someone that carried their team to victory more often than not throughout the season.

Can you argue that McNeely was a key part of why the bulls are 4-10 rather than 0-14 at the moment? And is that enough to say that McNelly made them a "near contender" in their losses?

If the Bulls were say 6-8 rather than 4-10, I'd say you'd have an argument for McNeely, but at the moment... Eh... He'd be on the outside looking in on my ballot.(Same thing with the TE for the SSR.. .I had him as my early MVP choice, even though they weren't the greatest team at that point.. but now that they're in a playoff hunt, he's fallen off the 'MVP' numbers he had early on.)
 
Link
 
I can't believe Gordon James is being left out of this conversation...IMHO its no question that he is the Defensive MVP. The SQC weren't even a playoff team last year and now we are 2nd in our conference and James had a lot to do with making us one of the best defenses in the entire league so I think all of this arguing about CBs is a moot point

Edit: oh and I forgot to mention that he by himself has more sacks then all but 3 teams in this entire league.
Last edited May 23, 2008 13:16:14
 
HaplosDog
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by footbalfever21
I can't believe Gordon James is being left out of this conversation...IMHO its no question that he is the Defensive MVP. The SQC weren't even a playoff team last year and now we are 2nd in our conference and James had a lot to do with making us one of the best defenses in the entire league so I think all of this arguing about CBs is a moot point


I agree. James is a beast. If I had a vote, it would be him. Maybe even for League MVP, but for sure at least for Defensive MVP.


-- edited to add:

Tank Taylor and Bryan Locke are also worthy of consideration.
Last edited May 23, 2008 13:15:04
 
lukin83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by footbalfever21
I can't believe Gordon James is being left out of this conversation...IMHO its no question that he is the Defensive MVP. The SQC weren't even a playoff team last year and now we are 2nd in our conference and James had a lot to do with making us one of the best defenses in the entire league so I think all of this arguing about CBs is a moot point


I think most people will tend to agree with you. Who do you think the DE some have mentioned is? I am guessing James because nobody out there can compare to those numbers on the defensive side of the ball.
 
Carpy
offline
Link
 
I think there's no doubt that James is a better defensive MVP candidate than most people mentioned in this thread.

I am waiting for the official ballot to be set before lobbying for him. He has 21 sacks in 14 games. The next best DE has 8.

Best cash trade for a 'back-up' I ever made!!!
 
lukin83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Carpy
I think there's no doubt that James is a better defensive MVP candidate than most people mentioned in this thread.

I am waiting for the official ballot to be set before lobbying for him. He has 21 sacks in 14 games. The next best DE has 8.

Best cash trade for a 'back-up' I ever made!!!


We have a DE with three picks and 2 TDs, but he can't compete with those sack numbers.
 
Carpy
offline
Link
 
James also has 3 INTs (no TDs). And 3 pancakes!!
 
lukin83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Carpy
James also has 3 INTs (no TDs). And 3 pancakes!!


I know he had three picks. I have noticed what he has done.
 
Rudger
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DaSaintFan
Rudger, you're not helping your cause with the foul language... however:


Agreed, and I apologize for that if it offended anyone. Ill try to keep it clean, and stick to the issues. I just cant help being pissed at some of the people on here.

Originally posted by DaSaintFan

Can you argue that McNeely was a key part of why the bulls are 4-10 rather than 0-14 at the moment? And is that enough to say that McNelly made them a "near contender" in their losses?

Yes to both questions. We have never got completely blown out of the water except in the brantford match. Only reason we arent more of a contender this season is we have had activity issues and people not wanting to play for us. Im not saying we would have been 14-0, but atleast mid level. Through all the strife on our team, we have had some very devoted players who want to try to make it work. Mcneeley is one of those players. Hence my defensive stance on here... Granted I wish I would have just left it at my first post of "Mcneeley gets my vote".

Last edited May 23, 2008 22:38:30
 
nhazelett
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rudger
Granted I wish I would have just left it at my first post of "Mcneeley gets my vote".



lol yeah same here.
 
Staden
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Carpy
I think there's no doubt that James is a better defensive MVP candidate than most people mentioned in this thread.

I am waiting for the official ballot to be set before lobbying for him. He has 21 sacks in 14 games. The next best DE has 8.

Best cash trade for a 'back-up' I ever made!!!


that 21 sacks is also more than all but three teams have. only mustangs and cajun have more. with sydney sharks having the same amount.
 
slyraje
offline
Link
 
James Doom. Ridiculous.
 
Jukin Jive
offline
Link
 
Gotta be Vin Numbers. I'd be willing to bet he has more broken tackles than some teams have rushing yards lol. Oh, and he splits carries on a balanced team.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.