User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > ReProgram the Simulation - Redo The Game
Page:
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheInfinity
Originally posted by Ken1


Note only two O-Linemen on that list are 5.0 or faster, plus:

Speed can be scaled however one wants to scale it. One can easily scale a 5 second 40 yard dash to be 25 Speed. Bort messed up on that one IMO, letting different Speeds be far too different in how fast the dot moves.

If you don't value Strength much more than Speed, you don't have 300 pound players playing at a position in real life.

And look at the reps some WR's and a number of CB's can do. Should they have to soft-cap Strength? Look at the vertical leap at, say, HB. Either no one has realized it or Jumping is very much undervalued in RB's.

Back to Strength, Speed, and 300 pounds: In baseball Strength (for power hitting) is more important than Speed at corner infield positions and catcher, and often teams will play slow power hitters at corner outfield positions as well, even knowing they are sacrificing defense to do so.

But you very rarely see 300 pounders playing baseball, because they might hit home runs, but they're extremely slow and can't run the bases, etc., even though again, only CF's, SS's, and 2Bmen truly have to be fast.

You never see in basketball anyone nearly as heavy for their height as in football, because basketball, like soccer, truly is a speed over strength sport (because too much contact in either results in a foul). Some basketball players weigh a lot because they're so tall, as height is a big deal there. But none look like O-linemen.

But in football, it's a sport of hitting other players, and most positions need to be strong as much as fast. WR's and DB's are exceptions, although it's surprising how strong on that same site one can see that a lot of DB's are.

One other note from the site: O-linemen in real life are even much less agile than other positions, more so than I thought. They suck (relatively speaking) at the 3-cone drill, although D-linemen definitely seem to need to be good in that area.


They're definitely the slow pokes of the league and the least athletic (due to their size). But I guess we're yelling about scaling here. To me 25 speed is way to slow and taking it to the first cap 48 is reasonable, only because you can do that with training alone over time. I also don't want the difference between 25 speed and 35 speed to be greater than the difference between 80 speed and 90 speed. To me 10 is 10 in a stat.


I guess the argument really is about scaling. But I don't see why, other than to retroactively justify current builds, you can say that everyone should need soft-capped Speed (if O-Linemen need it, so does everyone else) but not soft-capped Strength when even WR's and DB's have fairly decent real life Strength.

I say let the less important attributes be 25 or 30, and scale as such. Let people specialize. As it is, you really can't have realistic O-Line Strength, Blocking, Vision, and Confidence if they have to soft-cap Speed.

Originally posted by TheInfinity
And yes, they do value strength heavily at those positions, hence the large sizes of people. But its definitely not the only attribute, its a primary, and I'd say that's why you need it for Pass Blocking and especially need it for Run Blocking while Speed is a minor attribute for Pass Blocking and not much of an attribute in Run Blocking. Strength > Speed at Offensive Line, I agree there.


I'd say very minor for pass blocking and not at all for run blocking. And after seeing the 3-cone drill stats, I'd have to say that Blocking should be the key for pass blocking and at most Agility should equal Strength for it. Otherwise, we'd see better 3-cone drill results from O-linemen.

Originally posted by TheInfinity
For Defensive Line, we see people sacrificing Strength for Speed, hence the big difference in size between Offensive Tackles and Defensive Ends and even Defensive Ends and Defensive Tackles. They're still valuing strength but speed has definitely come into the equation for them, especially for the Pass Rushers who tend to be the fastest of the linemen.


I told you why, though, at least IMO: Once you get past the blocker, if you do, you have to catch someone. That's, to me, about the only reason.

 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1

You see, here's a problem related to how we think things should be. I don't think Speed should be a factor for DE's in anything except getting to the QB if he gets by the blocker. If it were, we'd see a lot of CB to DE conversions in real life and both positions would weigh about the same.

I think Agility should be slightly more important to a DE than Strength in pass rushing, and strong DE's should dominate in run rushing. Speed shouldn't matter in either (except as noted above).

Same with OT's, who are 300+ pounds in real life because being slow is perfectly okay for them, and absolutely should be in GLB. To run block should be Strength/Blocking and to pass block should be Agility/Blocking but also the chance to manhandle a guy that has much less Strength than you.


Ken,

I seriously disagree with you if you believe speed isn't at least a piece of the equation in deciding if a DE gets around a tackle. So, is Agility, and strength, and the ability to break blocks, but if you are dirt slow, you simply aren't going to be able to get around the end.

It has nothing to do with a CB conversion as long as you make sure strength also plays a part in the equation. The idea here isn't to force a build on people, and I think you tend to miss that in some of the threads I've seen you in. The idea is to present a bunch of options for a position with real advantages and consequences for training choices.

If Agility and Block decided pass blocking and strength/agility run blocking how boring would that be? You've just forced every single tackle/DE into the same cookie cutter build you believe is correct.

If you incorporate Agility/Speed/Strength/Block/shed Block into Pass Blocking with consequences if the player is seriously lacking one of the three, then it gives the user more choices, same for a rushing attack. Depending on the type of play, each would be weighted differently, but you need a wide variety of inputs to keep the system flexible.

Many of the OP's ideas are very good ideas. Heck, there were some that wouldn't really require a rewrite (the DB coverage, BUT you can't have both the offense and defense substitution like that or you end up in an endless loop).

PinTBC
 
yomama17
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheInfinity
Seems no one understands the point of this post. I thought I made it clear. Its a mechanics overhaul based on the progress made through the last 7 seasons. Based on the progress made through the last 7 seasons. Based on the progress made through the last 7 seasons. Need I say it again?


Why shouldn't he just make some fixes? Why would he need to redo the entire code because of a few complaints about o lineman, defensive ends and whatever?
 
TheInfinity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by yomama17
Originally posted by TheInfinity

Seems no one understands the point of this post. I thought I made it clear. Its a mechanics overhaul based on the progress made through the last 7 seasons. Based on the progress made through the last 7 seasons. Based on the progress made through the last 7 seasons. Need I say it again?


Why shouldn't he just make some fixes? Why would he need to redo the entire code because of a few complaints about o lineman, defensive ends and whatever?


Well, not all of those complaints are just O-Line and D-Line or even specific single players. They go all the way to the way in which the players move around on the field.

Also, I'm not talking about just modifying the numbers used with attributes and abilities to come out with outcomes, I'm talking about modifying the entire equations. Basically I'm not saying "Strength should matter more in blocking" I'm saying "The way blocking happens in the game has to be rethought". Its a different type of change and one that I think will be beneficial, because, in the end, the fact that Strength doesn't matter much in blocking and the fact that every time he tries to make it matter more all that happens is you get a complete nerf of Defensive Linemen shows that something in the logic is screwed.
 
TheInfinity
offline
Link
 
Hoping to eventually have Bort come in and say one of three things here:

1) I'll do it!
2) You actually don't know how much time/effort it would take. GLB would be down for too long, tweaks are the only way to go.
3) Go screw yourself.

I can live with any of those responses, just so long as I get one to know that he's paid the thread some attention. I know he can't read everything, but I'm going to keep it alive long enough so he can get to this one.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PinTBC
Originally posted by Ken1


You see, here's a problem related to how we think things should be. I don't think Speed should be a factor for DE's in anything except getting to the QB if he gets by the blocker. If it were, we'd see a lot of CB to DE conversions in real life and both positions would weigh about the same.

I think Agility should be slightly more important to a DE than Strength in pass rushing, and strong DE's should dominate in run rushing. Speed shouldn't matter in either (except as noted above).

Same with OT's, who are 300+ pounds in real life because being slow is perfectly okay for them, and absolutely should be in GLB. To run block should be Strength/Blocking and to pass block should be Agility/Blocking but also the chance to manhandle a guy that has much less Strength than you.


Ken,

I seriously disagree with you if you believe speed isn't at least a piece of the equation in deciding if a DE gets around a tackle. So, is Agility, and strength, and the ability to break blocks, but if you are dirt slow, you simply aren't going to be able to get around the end.

It has nothing to do with a CB conversion as long as you make sure strength also plays a part in the equation. The idea here isn't to force a build on people, and I think you tend to miss that in some of the threads I've seen you in. The idea is to present a bunch of options for a position with real advantages and consequences for training choices.

If Agility and Block decided pass blocking and strength/agility run blocking how boring would that be? You've just forced every single tackle/DE into the same cookie cutter build you believe is correct.

If you incorporate Agility/Speed/Strength/Block/shed Block into Pass Blocking with consequences if the player is seriously lacking one of the three, then it gives the user more choices, same for a rushing attack. Depending on the type of play, each would be weighted differently, but you need a wide variety of inputs to keep the system flexible.

Many of the OP's ideas are very good ideas. Heck, there were some that wouldn't really require a rewrite (the DB coverage, BUT you can't have both the offense and defense substitution like that or you end up in an endless loop).

PinTBC


The problem is the importance of Speed throughout GLB, for every position, when football is not a speed sport, especially in the trenches.

Can things other than Strength/Blocking/Agility/Shed Block be incorporated? Yes. Vision is a good one. If you figure what the opponent is doing, that gives you an advantage in shedding the block.

The big thing with Speed here is there should virtually always be a block to be shed. Sure, if a DE is dirt slow he won't get around the OT even if he sheds the block. If he's no faster than the OT then the OT just has to re-initiate the block.

But the main reason that DE's have more speed than other linemen in real life is that if they do get past the line they have to tackle to QB or RB. Even with a QB, unless you completely blind-side him he's not going to just stand there and let you sack him. You have to chase him down. And even if he just stood there, you'd be rushing to get there before he could get a pass off.

But it doesn't help you specifically shed the block.
 
TheInfinity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by PinTBC

Originally posted by Ken1



You see, here's a problem related to how we think things should be. I don't think Speed should be a factor for DE's in anything except getting to the QB if he gets by the blocker. If it were, we'd see a lot of CB to DE conversions in real life and both positions would weigh about the same.

I think Agility should be slightly more important to a DE than Strength in pass rushing, and strong DE's should dominate in run rushing. Speed shouldn't matter in either (except as noted above).

Same with OT's, who are 300+ pounds in real life because being slow is perfectly okay for them, and absolutely should be in GLB. To run block should be Strength/Blocking and to pass block should be Agility/Blocking but also the chance to manhandle a guy that has much less Strength than you.


Ken,

I seriously disagree with you if you believe speed isn't at least a piece of the equation in deciding if a DE gets around a tackle. So, is Agility, and strength, and the ability to break blocks, but if you are dirt slow, you simply aren't going to be able to get around the end.

It has nothing to do with a CB conversion as long as you make sure strength also plays a part in the equation. The idea here isn't to force a build on people, and I think you tend to miss that in some of the threads I've seen you in. The idea is to present a bunch of options for a position with real advantages and consequences for training choices.

If Agility and Block decided pass blocking and strength/agility run blocking how boring would that be? You've just forced every single tackle/DE into the same cookie cutter build you believe is correct.

If you incorporate Agility/Speed/Strength/Block/shed Block into Pass Blocking with consequences if the player is seriously lacking one of the three, then it gives the user more choices, same for a rushing attack. Depending on the type of play, each would be weighted differently, but you need a wide variety of inputs to keep the system flexible.

Many of the OP's ideas are very good ideas. Heck, there were some that wouldn't really require a rewrite (the DB coverage, BUT you can't have both the offense and defense substitution like that or you end up in an endless loop).

PinTBC


The problem is the importance of Speed throughout GLB, for every position, when football is not a speed sport, especially in the trenches.

Can things other than Strength/Blocking/Agility/Shed Block be incorporated? Yes. Vision is a good one. If you figure what the opponent is doing, that gives you an advantage in shedding the block.

The big thing with Speed here is there should virtually always be a block to be shed. Sure, if a DE is dirt slow he won't get around the OT even if he sheds the block. If he's no faster than the OT then the OT just has to re-initiate the block.

But the main reason that DE's have more speed than other linemen in real life is that if they do get past the line they have to tackle to QB or RB. Even with a QB, unless you completely blind-side him he's not going to just stand there and let you sack him. You have to chase him down. And even if he just stood there, you'd be rushing to get there before he could get a pass off.

But it doesn't help you specifically shed the block.


In order of importance for block shedding by type of block:

Pass Blocking:

Agility, Skills, Strength, Vision, Speed

Run Blocking:

Strength, Agility, Skills, Vision, Speed

Trouble is that in GLB the movement mechanics are automatically Speed/Agility, meaning the way dots move around is some combination of those two attributes, so where you see Agility for "Getting around the block" you have to include Speed. As a result, some guy named TheInfinity is petitioning for Bort to rethink this and Re-Program the Simulation to alter the mechanics behind each type of blocking but more importantly the mechanics behind player movement.

A guy with high agility is like a dancer or boxer. He's nimble, he can move from side to side, has excellent footwork and positioning ability. He moves in small distances extremely efficiently and quickly. GLB doesn't reflect this because Agility is not its own movement thing at all, its only a modifier for Speed in movement.
 
Tom Condon
offline
Link
 
DO OVER
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheInfinity
Originally posted by Ken1

Originally posted by PinTBC


Originally posted by Ken1




You see, here's a problem related to how we think things should be. I don't think Speed should be a factor for DE's in anything except getting to the QB if he gets by the blocker. If it were, we'd see a lot of CB to DE conversions in real life and both positions would weigh about the same.

I think Agility should be slightly more important to a DE than Strength in pass rushing, and strong DE's should dominate in run rushing. Speed shouldn't matter in either (except as noted above).

Same with OT's, who are 300+ pounds in real life because being slow is perfectly okay for them, and absolutely should be in GLB. To run block should be Strength/Blocking and to pass block should be Agility/Blocking but also the chance to manhandle a guy that has much less Strength than you.


Ken,

I seriously disagree with you if you believe speed isn't at least a piece of the equation in deciding if a DE gets around a tackle. So, is Agility, and strength, and the ability to break blocks, but if you are dirt slow, you simply aren't going to be able to get around the end.

It has nothing to do with a CB conversion as long as you make sure strength also plays a part in the equation. The idea here isn't to force a build on people, and I think you tend to miss that in some of the threads I've seen you in. The idea is to present a bunch of options for a position with real advantages and consequences for training choices.

If Agility and Block decided pass blocking and strength/agility run blocking how boring would that be? You've just forced every single tackle/DE into the same cookie cutter build you believe is correct.

If you incorporate Agility/Speed/Strength/Block/shed Block into Pass Blocking with consequences if the player is seriously lacking one of the three, then it gives the user more choices, same for a rushing attack. Depending on the type of play, each would be weighted differently, but you need a wide variety of inputs to keep the system flexible.

Many of the OP's ideas are very good ideas. Heck, there were some that wouldn't really require a rewrite (the DB coverage, BUT you can't have both the offense and defense substitution like that or you end up in an endless loop).

PinTBC


The problem is the importance of Speed throughout GLB, for every position, when football is not a speed sport, especially in the trenches.

Can things other than Strength/Blocking/Agility/Shed Block be incorporated? Yes. Vision is a good one. If you figure what the opponent is doing, that gives you an advantage in shedding the block.

The big thing with Speed here is there should virtually always be a block to be shed. Sure, if a DE is dirt slow he won't get around the OT even if he sheds the block. If he's no faster than the OT then the OT just has to re-initiate the block.

But the main reason that DE's have more speed than other linemen in real life is that if they do get past the line they have to tackle to QB or RB. Even with a QB, unless you completely blind-side him he's not going to just stand there and let you sack him. You have to chase him down. And even if he just stood there, you'd be rushing to get there before he could get a pass off.

But it doesn't help you specifically shed the block.


In order of importance for block shedding by type of block:

Pass Blocking:

Agility, Skills, Strength, Vision, Speed

Run Blocking:

Strength, Agility, Skills, Vision, Speed


I can agree with those for block shedding, although for blocking itself, the site you linked to convinced me that a pass blocking O-lineman should need less Agility in both cases (they do horribly compared to other positions in the cone drill).

Again, for block shedding, I'd take those as correct, and then just set things up to make sure there always was a a block to be shed, that Speed couldn't allow you to avoid being blocked.

For O-linemen, a run block would be just:

Skills, Strength, Vision-- in a way that Bort once posted, that Blocking helps you hold the block but Strength is needed if you're going to move anyone.

For an O-lineman, a pass block would be:

Skills, Vision, Strength, Agility. I'd have put Agility higher, but then O-Linemen are so poor at cone drills that it can't matter that much, even in pass blocking.

Skills wouldn't just be blocking, but also relevant SA's, which would distinguish run block from pass block specialists.
 
TheInfinity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by TheInfinity

Originally posted by Ken1


Originally posted by PinTBC



Originally posted by Ken1





You see, here's a problem related to how we think things should be. I don't think Speed should be a factor for DE's in anything except getting to the QB if he gets by the blocker. If it were, we'd see a lot of CB to DE conversions in real life and both positions would weigh about the same.

I think Agility should be slightly more important to a DE than Strength in pass rushing, and strong DE's should dominate in run rushing. Speed shouldn't matter in either (except as noted above).

Same with OT's, who are 300+ pounds in real life because being slow is perfectly okay for them, and absolutely should be in GLB. To run block should be Strength/Blocking and to pass block should be Agility/Blocking but also the chance to manhandle a guy that has much less Strength than you.


Ken,

I seriously disagree with you if you believe speed isn't at least a piece of the equation in deciding if a DE gets around a tackle. So, is Agility, and strength, and the ability to break blocks, but if you are dirt slow, you simply aren't going to be able to get around the end.

It has nothing to do with a CB conversion as long as you make sure strength also plays a part in the equation. The idea here isn't to force a build on people, and I think you tend to miss that in some of the threads I've seen you in. The idea is to present a bunch of options for a position with real advantages and consequences for training choices.

If Agility and Block decided pass blocking and strength/agility run blocking how boring would that be? You've just forced every single tackle/DE into the same cookie cutter build you believe is correct.

If you incorporate Agility/Speed/Strength/Block/shed Block into Pass Blocking with consequences if the player is seriously lacking one of the three, then it gives the user more choices, same for a rushing attack. Depending on the type of play, each would be weighted differently, but you need a wide variety of inputs to keep the system flexible.

Many of the OP's ideas are very good ideas. Heck, there were some that wouldn't really require a rewrite (the DB coverage, BUT you can't have both the offense and defense substitution like that or you end up in an endless loop).

PinTBC


The problem is the importance of Speed throughout GLB, for every position, when football is not a speed sport, especially in the trenches.

Can things other than Strength/Blocking/Agility/Shed Block be incorporated? Yes. Vision is a good one. If you figure what the opponent is doing, that gives you an advantage in shedding the block.

The big thing with Speed here is there should virtually always be a block to be shed. Sure, if a DE is dirt slow he won't get around the OT even if he sheds the block. If he's no faster than the OT then the OT just has to re-initiate the block.

But the main reason that DE's have more speed than other linemen in real life is that if they do get past the line they have to tackle to QB or RB. Even with a QB, unless you completely blind-side him he's not going to just stand there and let you sack him. You have to chase him down. And even if he just stood there, you'd be rushing to get there before he could get a pass off.

But it doesn't help you specifically shed the block.


In order of importance for block shedding by type of block:

Pass Blocking:

Agility, Skills, Strength, Vision, Speed

Run Blocking:

Strength, Agility, Skills, Vision, Speed


I can agree with those for block shedding, although for blocking itself, the site you linked to convinced me that a pass blocking O-lineman should need less Agility in both cases (they do horribly compared to other positions in the cone drill).

Again, for block shedding, I'd take those as correct, and then just set things up to make sure there always was a a block to be shed, that Speed couldn't allow you to avoid being blocked.

For O-linemen, a run block would be just:

Skills, Strength, Vision-- in a way that Bort once posted, that Blocking helps you hold the block but Strength is needed if you're going to move anyone.

For an O-lineman, a pass block would be:

Skills, Vision, Strength, Agility. I'd have put Agility higher, but then O-Linemen are so poor at cone drills that it can't matter that much, even in pass blocking.

Skills wouldn't just be blocking, but also relevant SA's, which would distinguish run block from pass block specialists.


3-Cone Drill is deceptive, there's a lot of running speed involved there - Check it out: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sLs6CxMGV0A

Now watch Jake Long: http://www.thephinsider.com/story/2008/3/29/22051/5141

See how he always has to move around, both pass and run blocking involve quick movements forward, backwards and laterally. Agility would govern this. He wouldn't need 80+ Agility to do what he does, but somewhere around 48-61 would be what's needed for an Offensive Tackle to be elite when dealing with very fast Defense Ends (which is fine because it is an Attribute that gets points as they level up and is thus indicated to be important, but not as important as Strength and Blocking).

Here's my system:

Offensive Lineman Pass Blocking: Blocking / Agility-Strength (tie) / Vision
Offensive Lineman Run Blocking: Blocking / Strength / Agility / Vision

Blitz Pick-Up: Vision. - While Vision isn't going to be very high on the list for making and holding blocks, its going to be big for catching a blitzer.

Either way, I think we can agree that the movement mechanics need work seeing as how right now there is no way to eliminate Speed from the equation and thus are stuck with Defensive Ends trying to literally Run around Offensive Tackles rather than engage and get around them. RE-DO THE SIM! >O
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheInfinity
Originally posted by Ken1

Originally posted by TheInfinity


Originally posted by Ken1



Originally posted by PinTBC




Originally posted by Ken1






You see, here's a problem related to how we think things should be. I don't think Speed should be a factor for DE's in anything except getting to the QB if he gets by the blocker. If it were, we'd see a lot of CB to DE conversions in real life and both positions would weigh about the same.

I think Agility should be slightly more important to a DE than Strength in pass rushing, and strong DE's should dominate in run rushing. Speed shouldn't matter in either (except as noted above).

Same with OT's, who are 300+ pounds in real life because being slow is perfectly okay for them, and absolutely should be in GLB. To run block should be Strength/Blocking and to pass block should be Agility/Blocking but also the chance to manhandle a guy that has much less Strength than you.


Ken,

I seriously disagree with you if you believe speed isn't at least a piece of the equation in deciding if a DE gets around a tackle. So, is Agility, and strength, and the ability to break blocks, but if you are dirt slow, you simply aren't going to be able to get around the end.

It has nothing to do with a CB conversion as long as you make sure strength also plays a part in the equation. The idea here isn't to force a build on people, and I think you tend to miss that in some of the threads I've seen you in. The idea is to present a bunch of options for a position with real advantages and consequences for training choices.

If Agility and Block decided pass blocking and strength/agility run blocking how boring would that be? You've just forced every single tackle/DE into the same cookie cutter build you believe is correct.

If you incorporate Agility/Speed/Strength/Block/shed Block into Pass Blocking with consequences if the player is seriously lacking one of the three, then it gives the user more choices, same for a rushing attack. Depending on the type of play, each would be weighted differently, but you need a wide variety of inputs to keep the system flexible.

Many of the OP's ideas are very good ideas. Heck, there were some that wouldn't really require a rewrite (the DB coverage, BUT you can't have both the offense and defense substitution like that or you end up in an endless loop).

PinTBC


The problem is the importance of Speed throughout GLB, for every position, when football is not a speed sport, especially in the trenches.

Can things other than Strength/Blocking/Agility/Shed Block be incorporated? Yes. Vision is a good one. If you figure what the opponent is doing, that gives you an advantage in shedding the block.

The big thing with Speed here is there should virtually always be a block to be shed. Sure, if a DE is dirt slow he won't get around the OT even if he sheds the block. If he's no faster than the OT then the OT just has to re-initiate the block.

But the main reason that DE's have more speed than other linemen in real life is that if they do get past the line they have to tackle to QB or RB. Even with a QB, unless you completely blind-side him he's not going to just stand there and let you sack him. You have to chase him down. And even if he just stood there, you'd be rushing to get there before he could get a pass off.

But it doesn't help you specifically shed the block.


In order of importance for block shedding by type of block:

Pass Blocking:

Agility, Skills, Strength, Vision, Speed

Run Blocking:

Strength, Agility, Skills, Vision, Speed


I can agree with those for block shedding, although for blocking itself, the site you linked to convinced me that a pass blocking O-lineman should need less Agility in both cases (they do horribly compared to other positions in the cone drill).

Again, for block shedding, I'd take those as correct, and then just set things up to make sure there always was a a block to be shed, that Speed couldn't allow you to avoid being blocked.

For O-linemen, a run block would be just:

Skills, Strength, Vision-- in a way that Bort once posted, that Blocking helps you hold the block but Strength is needed if you're going to move anyone.

For an O-lineman, a pass block would be:

Skills, Vision, Strength, Agility. I'd have put Agility higher, but then O-Linemen are so poor at cone drills that it can't matter that much, even in pass blocking.

Skills wouldn't just be blocking, but also relevant SA's, which would distinguish run block from pass block specialists.


3-Cone Drill is deceptive, there's a lot of running speed involved there - Check it out: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sLs6CxMGV0A

Now watch Jake Long: http://www.thephinsider.com/story/2008/3/29/22051/5141

See how he always has to move around, both pass and run blocking involve quick movements forward, backwards and laterally. Agility would govern this. He wouldn't need 80+ Agility to do what he does, but somewhere around 48-61 would be what's needed for an Offensive Tackle to be elite when dealing with very fast Defense Ends (which is fine because it is an Attribute that gets points as they level up and is thus indicated to be important, but not as important as Strength and Blocking).

Here's my system:

Offensive Lineman Pass Blocking: Blocking / Agility-Strength (tie) / Vision
Offensive Lineman Run Blocking: Blocking / Strength / Agility / Vision

Blitz Pick-Up: Vision. - While Vision isn't going to be very high on the list for making and holding blocks, its going to be big for catching a blitzer.

Either way, I think we can agree that the movement mechanics need work seeing as how right now there is no way to eliminate Speed from the equation and thus are stuck with Defensive Ends trying to literally Run around Offensive Tackles rather than engage and get around them. RE-DO THE SIM! >O


I agree about movement mechanics, although I don't think that re-doing the sim is necessary-- although if current players and builds are kept and it helped Bort make bigger changes without as much whining, then maybe it's okay.

As to the blocking, I'd make a couple of minor changes in your chart, even with the knowledge that Agility might work more as I intuited: I'd change "Skills" for "Blocking," which would include Blocking and appropriate specials, and in run blocking I'd swap Vision with Agility, as no one thinks much of Agility in terms of run blocking. It can be equal to Strength in pass blocking, though.
 
SwagOnLock
offline
Link
 
holy walls of texts, guys.
 
TheInfinity
offline
Link
 
Le-Bump.

Paired with a 100% Flex Refund and a reset, Bort could actually make a full new sim with things he always wanted like an "acceleration" attribute.

I'd be up for that. So long as I got all of my Flex back I'd definitely stick around.

Also a bump so I can get the man's opinion on it. I haven't seen his opinion on any threads in this section in ages. Actually, not since he posted one himself. Lemme know you're alive and well, Bort. Just gimmie a bone and post a message here, it can be blank for all I care. Just lemme know you read it.
 
sushil33t
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dudesogood
Originally posted by TheInfinity

Originally posted by Ken1


Originally posted by TheInfinity



Originally posted by Ken1




Originally posted by TheInfinity





Originally posted by Ken1






Originally posted by TheInfinity







Originally posted by Ken1








Originally posted by TheInfinity









Seems no one understands the point of this post. I thought I made it clear. Its a mechanics overhaul based on the progress made through the last 7 seasons. Based on the progress made through the last 7 seasons. Based on the progress made through the last 7 seasons. Need I say it again?

So:

1) Its not going to require a re-spec. Its new mechanics, not an entirely new attributes system. If someone is proposing that here, make your own thread and don't hi-jack this one.

2) Its not going to take us to the stone age. Bort wouldn't do it blindly, he would use the data and knowledge from the past seasons. Saying we'd be back at Square One is saying that he will start as if he was Bort from a year ago and not Bort from today. Its like editing a paper, you can only edit it word by word or sentence by sentence for so long before you might as well just write a new one.

3) Sure, there will be disagreements as to what the mechanics should work like, but the overall consensus is not what we need. What we need is a coherent system that doesn't have to change all the time. Basically, don't have a simulation mechanic so weak that the creation of 90Speed/Agility Defensive Ends turns the entire game upside down onto its head and causes massive changes in the code. If the game's core logic is proper then you don't need to change everything as a reaction to a single type of player being made, you just wait for the other players to adapt.


So you're saying the same attributes system and all (if one starts changing the attributes, that's when re-specs and wipes start being discussed)?

I guess I'm among those who don't understand-- just what do you propose changing?


I'll illustrate with #1) Blocking.

Pass Blocking: Make it rely on Agility/Blocking/Strength with some Speed. Make getting around Pass Blocks involve Agility/Speed and Some Strength.

Run Blocking: Make it rely more on Blocking/Strength with some Agility. Make getting through Run Blocks involve Agility/Strength and Some Speed.

So when you have the 90speed/agility defensive end that's creating hell for Quarterbacks you can simply go "Aha, the speed DE, lets run against him" and shove the ball down his throat, thus taking advantage of his weakness.

The way it works now Defensive Ends that are Speed/Agility and Some Strength are useless against the Pass and the Run while Defensive Ends that are Strength/Agility and Some Speed have always been useless against the Pass and the Run. This is because a DE that was good against the Pass was also dominant against the Run, cause the mechanics of both types of blocking were the same when in real life they are not and in a practical sense for the simulation they shouldn't be, and prompted Bort's nerfing.


You see, here's a problem related to how we think things should be. I don't think Speed should be a factor for DE's in anything except getting to the QB if he gets by the blocker. If it were, we'd see a lot of CB to DE conversions in real life and both positions would weigh about the same.

I think Agility should be slightly more important to a DE than Strength in pass rushing, and strong DE's should dominate in run rushing. Speed shouldn't matter in either (except as noted above).

Same with OT's, who are 300+ pounds in real life because being slow is perfectly okay for them, and absolutely should be in GLB. To run block should be Strength/Blocking and to pass block should be Agility/Blocking but also the chance to manhandle a guy that has much less Strength than you.


Some Speed, dude. Everyone runs the 40-yard dash and has to do so in a reasonable time for their position.


And everyone does the bench press and has to do a reasonable amount for their position. But WR's and CB's don't need soft-capped Strength, nor should they.

I'd call a "reasonable speed" for an O-lineman about 25 Speed in GLB terms. But right now it pretty much has to be soft-capped, which is messed up.

And you called for pass rushing for DE's to be mostly Speed and Agility. DE's do need some Speed, because if they do get by the O-Line they have to get to the QB before he unloads the ball (or on a sweep to the RB before he turns the corner).


You must not be aware of the fact of just how fast Defensive Ends are, and the fact that most elite pass rushers are ridiculously fast guys.

Julius Peppers: 40 Yard Dash Time: 4.6 - 22 Bench Reps.
Jevon Kearse: 40 Yard Dash Time: 4.6 - Can't find his bench reps but he's 250, significantly lighter than Peppers.
Robert Mathis: Can't find his 40-Time but he's a small DE at 245lbs.

And 25 speed? Seriously? Watch the D-Leagues, do you see Linemen in the NFL moving like that? Here, check these out:

http://www.nfl.com/combine/top-performers

See how they care how fast the linemen are? And a 5-second 40-yard dash isn't 25 speed, its more like 50 speed, which is first soft cap, not too bad of a place to have to put your attribute when the people who intend to get by you have to run in the 4.6-second 40-yard dash range, meaning it has to be around 75-85 speed.


Note only two O-Linemen on that list are 5.0 or faster, plus:

Speed can be scaled however one wants to scale it. One can easily scale a 5 second 40 yard dash to be 25 Speed. Bort messed up on that one IMO, letting different Speeds be far too different in how fast the dot moves.

If you don't value Strength much more than Speed, you don't have 300 pound players playing at a position in real life.

And look at the reps some WR's and a number of CB's can do. Should they have to soft-cap Strength? Look at the vertical leap at, say, HB. Either no one has realized it or Jumping is very much undervalued in RB's.

Back to Strength, Speed, and 300 pounds: In baseball Strength (for power hitting) is more important than Speed at corner infield positions and catcher, and often teams will play slow power hitters at corner outfield positions as well, even knowing they are sacrificing defense to do so.

But you very rarely see 300 pounders playing baseball, because they might hit home runs, but they're extremely slow and can't run the bases, etc., even though again, only CF's, SS's, and 2Bmen truly have to be fast.

You never see in basketball anyone nearly as heavy for their height as in football, because basketball, like soccer, truly is a speed over strength sport (because too much contact in either results in a foul). Some basketball players weigh a lot because they're so tall, as height is a big deal there. But none look like O-linemen.

But in football, it's a sport of hitting other players, and most positions need to be strong as much as fast. WR's and DB's are exceptions, although it's surprising how strong on that same site one can see that a lot of DB's are.

One other note from the site: O-linemen in real life are even much less agile than other positions, more so than I thought. They suck (relatively speaking) at the 3-cone drill, although D-linemen definitely seem to need to be good in that area.


They're definitely the slow pokes of the league and the least athletic (due to their size). But I guess we're yelling about scaling here. To me 25 speed is way to slow and taking it to the first cap 48 is reasonable, only because you can do that with training alone over time. I also don't want the difference between 25 speed and 50 speed to be greater than the difference between 80 speed and 90 speed. To me 10 is 10 in a stat.

And yes, they do value strength heavily at those positions, hence the large sizes of people. But its definitely not the only attribute, its a primary, and I'd say that's why you need it for Pass Blocking and especially need it for Run Blocking while Speed is a minor attribute for Pass Blocking and not much of an attribute in Run Blocking. Strength > Speed at Offensive Line, I agree there.

For Defensive Line, we see people sacrificing Strength for Speed, hence the big difference in size between Offensive Tackles and Defensive Ends and even Defensive Ends and Defensive Tackles. They're still valuing strength but speed has definitely come into the equation for them, especially for the Pass Rushers who tend to be the fastest of the linemen.

As for Vertical Jumps and Broad Jumps, those are products of Leg Strength in the combine and is what they actually measure. Except for Defensive Backs, Wide Receivers and some Linebackers, the number that comes out of the jumping measurement isn't so much for the height of the jump but for a measure of explosiveness. This is why I wouldn't link the Jumping Attribute to much for Running Backs even though in real life the Vertical and Broad Jumps are indicative of explosive running ability.


To those that just scrolled through this post without reading, I hope you took shrooms in order to appreciate what you just scrolled past


 
Aholewanker
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheInfinity
Le-Bump.

Paired with a 100% Flex Refund and a reset, Bort could actually make a full new sim with things he always wanted like an "acceleration" attribute.

I'd be up for that. So long as I got all of my Flex back I'd definitely stick around.

Also a bump so I can get the man's opinion on it. I haven't seen his opinion on any threads in this section in ages. Actually, not since he posted one himself. Lemme know you're alive and well, Bort. Just gimmie a bone and post a message here, it can be blank for all I care. Just lemme know you read it.


Good luck with that. He's currently researching what else he can implement before fixing what is broken.
Last edited Jan 14, 2009 13:11:18
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.