Originally posted by TheInfinity
Originally posted by Ken1
Note only two O-Linemen on that list are 5.0 or faster, plus:
Speed can be scaled however one wants to scale it. One can easily scale a 5 second 40 yard dash to be 25 Speed. Bort messed up on that one IMO, letting different Speeds be far too different in how fast the dot moves.
If you don't value Strength much more than Speed, you don't have 300 pound players playing at a position in real life.
And look at the reps some WR's and a number of CB's can do. Should they have to soft-cap Strength? Look at the vertical leap at, say, HB. Either no one has realized it or Jumping is very much undervalued in RB's.
Back to Strength, Speed, and 300 pounds: In baseball Strength (for power hitting) is more important than Speed at corner infield positions and catcher, and often teams will play slow power hitters at corner outfield positions as well, even knowing they are sacrificing defense to do so.
But you very rarely see 300 pounders playing baseball, because they might hit home runs, but they're extremely slow and can't run the bases, etc., even though again, only CF's, SS's, and 2Bmen truly have to be fast.
You never see in basketball anyone nearly as heavy for their height as in football, because basketball, like soccer, truly is a speed over strength sport (because too much contact in either results in a foul). Some basketball players weigh a lot because they're so tall, as height is a big deal there. But none look like O-linemen.
But in football, it's a sport of hitting other players, and most positions need to be strong as much as fast. WR's and DB's are exceptions, although it's surprising how strong on that same site one can see that a lot of DB's are.
One other note from the site: O-linemen in real life are even much less agile than other positions, more so than I thought. They suck (relatively speaking) at the 3-cone drill, although D-linemen definitely seem to need to be good in that area.
They're definitely the slow pokes of the league and the least athletic (due to their size). But I guess we're yelling about scaling here. To me 25 speed is way to slow and taking it to the first cap 48 is reasonable, only because you can do that with training alone over time. I also don't want the difference between 25 speed and 35 speed to be greater than the difference between 80 speed and 90 speed. To me 10 is 10 in a stat.
I guess the argument really is about scaling. But I don't see why, other than to retroactively justify current builds, you can say that everyone should need soft-capped Speed (if O-Linemen need it, so does everyone else) but not soft-capped Strength when even WR's and DB's have fairly decent real life Strength.
I say let the less important attributes be 25 or 30, and scale as such. Let people specialize. As it is, you really can't have realistic O-Line Strength, Blocking, Vision, and Confidence if they have to soft-cap Speed.
Originally posted by TheInfinity
And yes, they do value strength heavily at those positions, hence the large sizes of people. But its definitely not the only attribute, its a primary, and I'd say that's why you need it for Pass Blocking and especially need it for Run Blocking while Speed is a minor attribute for Pass Blocking and not much of an attribute in Run Blocking. Strength > Speed at Offensive Line, I agree there.
I'd say very minor for pass blocking and not at all for run blocking. And after seeing the 3-cone drill stats, I'd have to say that Blocking should be the key for pass blocking and at most Agility should equal Strength for it. Otherwise, we'd see better 3-cone drill results from O-linemen.
Originally posted by TheInfinity
For Defensive Line, we see people sacrificing Strength for Speed, hence the big difference in size between Offensive Tackles and Defensive Ends and even Defensive Ends and Defensive Tackles. They're still valuing strength but speed has definitely come into the equation for them, especially for the Pass Rushers who tend to be the fastest of the linemen.
I told you why, though, at least IMO: Once you get past the blocker, if you do, you have to catch someone. That's, to me, about the only reason.
Originally posted by Ken1
Note only two O-Linemen on that list are 5.0 or faster, plus:
Speed can be scaled however one wants to scale it. One can easily scale a 5 second 40 yard dash to be 25 Speed. Bort messed up on that one IMO, letting different Speeds be far too different in how fast the dot moves.
If you don't value Strength much more than Speed, you don't have 300 pound players playing at a position in real life.
And look at the reps some WR's and a number of CB's can do. Should they have to soft-cap Strength? Look at the vertical leap at, say, HB. Either no one has realized it or Jumping is very much undervalued in RB's.
Back to Strength, Speed, and 300 pounds: In baseball Strength (for power hitting) is more important than Speed at corner infield positions and catcher, and often teams will play slow power hitters at corner outfield positions as well, even knowing they are sacrificing defense to do so.
But you very rarely see 300 pounders playing baseball, because they might hit home runs, but they're extremely slow and can't run the bases, etc., even though again, only CF's, SS's, and 2Bmen truly have to be fast.
You never see in basketball anyone nearly as heavy for their height as in football, because basketball, like soccer, truly is a speed over strength sport (because too much contact in either results in a foul). Some basketball players weigh a lot because they're so tall, as height is a big deal there. But none look like O-linemen.
But in football, it's a sport of hitting other players, and most positions need to be strong as much as fast. WR's and DB's are exceptions, although it's surprising how strong on that same site one can see that a lot of DB's are.
One other note from the site: O-linemen in real life are even much less agile than other positions, more so than I thought. They suck (relatively speaking) at the 3-cone drill, although D-linemen definitely seem to need to be good in that area.
They're definitely the slow pokes of the league and the least athletic (due to their size). But I guess we're yelling about scaling here. To me 25 speed is way to slow and taking it to the first cap 48 is reasonable, only because you can do that with training alone over time. I also don't want the difference between 25 speed and 35 speed to be greater than the difference between 80 speed and 90 speed. To me 10 is 10 in a stat.
I guess the argument really is about scaling. But I don't see why, other than to retroactively justify current builds, you can say that everyone should need soft-capped Speed (if O-Linemen need it, so does everyone else) but not soft-capped Strength when even WR's and DB's have fairly decent real life Strength.
I say let the less important attributes be 25 or 30, and scale as such. Let people specialize. As it is, you really can't have realistic O-Line Strength, Blocking, Vision, and Confidence if they have to soft-cap Speed.
Originally posted by TheInfinity
And yes, they do value strength heavily at those positions, hence the large sizes of people. But its definitely not the only attribute, its a primary, and I'd say that's why you need it for Pass Blocking and especially need it for Run Blocking while Speed is a minor attribute for Pass Blocking and not much of an attribute in Run Blocking. Strength > Speed at Offensive Line, I agree there.
I'd say very minor for pass blocking and not at all for run blocking. And after seeing the 3-cone drill stats, I'd have to say that Blocking should be the key for pass blocking and at most Agility should equal Strength for it. Otherwise, we'd see better 3-cone drill results from O-linemen.
Originally posted by TheInfinity
For Defensive Line, we see people sacrificing Strength for Speed, hence the big difference in size between Offensive Tackles and Defensive Ends and even Defensive Ends and Defensive Tackles. They're still valuing strength but speed has definitely come into the equation for them, especially for the Pass Rushers who tend to be the fastest of the linemen.
I told you why, though, at least IMO: Once you get past the blocker, if you do, you have to catch someone. That's, to me, about the only reason.






























