User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Suggestion to slow down gutting and killing teams
Page:
 
greengoose
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by didymus
There is no "cure" for gutting.

You are wasting your time.

The only positive thing that could come from a thread like this is ways that GLB can make it more appealing to owners to keep a team.

I'm telling you that there is no stick thats going to help gutting.

Try some carrots.


You may be 100% right - but it doesn't take a rocket scientist to see the game getting exploited out the Ying-Yang.

When someone can get rid of all their USA PRO players, have that team with it's maxed stadium intact get moved down to the BBB league to start over with 50 million in the coffers (it's now up to 84 million and counting) - tell me thats a level playing field for the rest of the teams in BBB - especially the new owner who gets a gutted stadium and is expected to compete with Old Trafford.

They are nowhere close to being on the same planet financially with any other startup team - anything they want to give their players they can (and will). 4 sets of gear each? no problem. 15,000 a week salary to exploit fame? no problem.

This game is as much or more about exploitation as it is about playing the game - at nearly every phase of it from player building, tactics, you name it.

Yep, theres nothing we can do about it - except speak with our pocketbook and leave.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by didymus
There is no "cure" for gutting.

You are wasting your time.

The only positive thing that could come from a thread like this is ways that GLB can make it more appealing to owners to keep a team.

I'm telling you that there is no stick thats going to help gutting.

Try some carrots.


You're right, there is no fool proof cure for gutting, but there are ways, just as you stated, to encourage owners to learn and gain the knowledge of how to properly operate a team before purchasing one, and upon purchasing one, operate that team appropriately.

The only 'sure fire' way you could stop FIRE SALES is by limiting teams to possibly limit a team to trading 4-5 players per season. Not 4-5 trades, 4-5 players, on a 40 man roster, with a 5 player limit, it would take you 8 seasons just to fire sale on complete. If that length of time is worth it to you, have fun.

It doesn''t stop gutting, but the only real option there i forsee is to limit cuts as well, to a certain # of cuts per season. Again, there is nothing that is going to completely eliminate gutting.

Having said that, this idea needs to be implemented because it does a lot of other things for the better good of this game.

Start penalizing people who sell their teams and you'll see a lot less teams being sold. Put limits on the amount of overall players you can trade, you'll see Fire Sales virtually disappear.

If you put a limit on cuts, it does 2 things, one positive, one not so much. It would limit your ability to gut a team, but it would also limit your ability to release players in general (aka off season moves for the right reasons). However, that, imo, isn't necessarily a bad thing, because it also encourages people to do alot smarter recruiting.
 
Viscount
offline
Link
 
I can't help but notice that the majority (not all) of the people who agree with this suggestion don't actually own a team, whereas most of the people who disagree with it do actually own a team.
 
Luckeroll
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Viscount
I can't help but notice that the majority (not all) of the people who agree with this suggestion don't actually own a team, whereas most of the people who disagree with it do actually own a team.


LOL
 
Link
 
I like it.
 
Raiders12
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Viscount
I can't help but notice that the majority (not all) of the people who agree with this suggestion don't actually own a team, whereas most of the people who disagree with it do actually own a team.


Most of the people against would be the ones who want to continue to take advantage of the situation...IMO

(and BTW, I own a team)

I like the idea, although it does require some tweaking..especially in the number of own players on your team issue.
Last edited Jan 13, 2009 10:08:03
 
Viscount
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Raiders12
Originally posted by Viscount

I can't help but notice that the majority (not all) of the people who agree with this suggestion don't actually own a team, whereas most of the people who disagree with it do actually own a team.


Most of the people against would be the ones who want to continue to take advantage of the situation...IMO

(and BTW, I own a team)

I like the idea, although it does require some tweaking..especially in the number of own players on your team issue.


I'm not trying to be a dick, but I'd like to see if you still feel the same way in 2 seasons time when you still haven't made the playoffs because you can't catch up and compete with the level 40+ teams....
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
There are just too many exploits. Now we have teams getting a level 13 capped league, signing a slow build team, extending contracts for all the players, multiple times in a season so they have 200k or more in the bank, selling team, then resigning all the players for a new capped league.

I don't think it can be fixed. people in these type of games will always find the latest exploit and run with it. I think it might be beyond repair since this has turned into an owners game. The players are just an afterthought.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Viscount

I'm not trying to be a dick, but I'd like to see if you still feel the same way in 2 seasons time when you still haven't made the playoffs because you can't catch up and compete with the level 40+ teams....


well I just recently got my team, and we wont be making the playoffs this season, or most likely next season, because I got a new team in an uncapped league with a reset stadium, doesn't mean I'm gonna sell it back, all that means is that I have a lot of hard work to do, is it fair no, but that doesn't mean we shouldn't attempt to stop midseason sellbacks and gutting, teams should not be allowed to "firesale"
 
Link
 
assign a value to am owner like chemistry that follows him around and every personnel move he makes impacts that value... after it gets to a certain point it impacts his teams play..encourages smart management discourages fire sales and moving players at will give them a crtain number of reasonable moves say 5 moves in the offseason for example if he makes 5 moves or less there is no hit.. moves after that all decrease his value. 5 is just a fictional number of course.. and base it on players in the move not the move itself.. you sell 5 guys to one team thats fine but next 5 guys you sell are gonna get you 5 hits.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Viscount
I can't help but notice that the majority (not all) of the people who agree with this suggestion don't actually own a team, whereas most of the people who disagree with it do actually own a team.


LOL? I've been in this suggestion the ENTIRE TIME, did you notice I AM a team owner.

Give me a break, seriously.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Mightyhalo
There are just too many exploits. Now we have teams getting a level 13 capped league, signing a slow build team, extending contracts for all the players, multiple times in a season so they have 200k or more in the bank, selling team, then resigning all the players for a new capped league.

I don't think it can be fixed. people in these type of games will always find the latest exploit and run with it. I think it might be beyond repair since this has turned into an owners game. The players are just an afterthought.


There's too many exploits because right now, with all due respect to him, Bort allows shitty, classless owners, to make the decisions in GLB.
 
Viscount
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jackriley
Originally posted by Viscount

I can't help but notice that the majority (not all) of the people who agree with this suggestion don't actually own a team, whereas most of the people who disagree with it do actually own a team.


LOL? I've been in this suggestion the ENTIRE TIME, did you notice I AM a team owner.

Give me a break, seriously.


Did you even read my post? I said the majority, majority does not mean every person. I even put a part in brackets just for you......
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Viscount
Originally posted by jackriley

Originally posted by Viscount


I can't help but notice that the majority (not all) of the people who agree with this suggestion don't actually own a team, whereas most of the people who disagree with it do actually own a team.


LOL? I've been in this suggestion the ENTIRE TIME, did you notice I AM a team owner.

Give me a break, seriously.


Did you even read my post? I said the majority, majority does not mean every person. I even put a part in brackets just for you......


I read what you said. I know what you said, and I still don't agree with you. And I also think its irrelevant. That's almost, an 'owners way' of saying, I should be allowed to keep doing the things i'm doing that i should be penalized for, because the only people thinking i should not be allowed to do it, is the players.

What do you think Gene Upshaw would have said to that a few years ago in the NFL? Just think about it.
 
Raiders12
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jared
Originally posted by Viscount


I'm not trying to be a dick, but I'd like to see if you still feel the same way in 2 seasons time when you still haven't made the playoffs because you can't catch up and compete with the level 40+ teams....


well I just recently got my team, and we wont be making the playoffs this season, or most likely next season, because I got a new team in an uncapped league with a reset stadium, doesn't mean I'm gonna sell it back, all that means is that I have a lot of hard work to do, is it fair no, but that doesn't mean we shouldn't attempt to stop midseason sellbacks and gutting, teams should not be allowed to "firesale"


My team is in the same situation, and short of a complete restructuring of the leagues (which I would hope happens and soon), I guess my team will do the best we can and move up as far as we can as a team...If I can't ever catch up to those teams..then so be it...but that doesn't mean there should continue to be the firesale gutting as it has been.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.