User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Promotion/Demotion at the end of the off-season and the problems associated with it - need ideas
Page:
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Reduce the way the sim treats level disparity between players.
Currently a 5 level difference results in consistent 70-7 scores.
So make everything from 1 to 5 levels difference treated like no difference.
Treat 6-10 like it's 3 levels of difference.
Treat 11-15 like 5 levels of difference.
Etc.

This will go a long way to a) reducing those humungous 70-7 and 210-0 scores, and b) make it not so much of a hair-pulling aggravation this whole thing about ensuring higher level'd teams/players arent in lower level leagues and vice versa.

Because the differences will be so minimal that it wont matter as much anymore.
Last edited Dec 20, 2008 02:42:34
 
Colin Mochrie
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Reduce the way the sim treats level disparity between players.
Currently a 5 level difference results in consistent 70-7 scores.
So make everything from 1 to 5 levels difference treated like no difference.
Treat 6-10 like it's 3 levels of difference.
Treat 11-15 like 5 levels of difference.
Etc.

This will go a long way to a) reducing those humungous 70-7 and 210-0 scores, and b) make it not so much of a hair-pulling aggravation this whole thing about ensuring higher level'd teams/players arent in lower level leagues and vice versa.

Because the differences will be so minimal that it wont matter as much anymore.


I agree with these sentiments. An average lv.20 team should be able to beat a lv.30 team, with better gameplanning, with builds being the controlled variable.

Right now Experience points have too much control of the outcome. Gameplanning should have more say in in the results. Instead of who just has as the players that have earned the most XP's.

I guess it is a matter of whether we an RPG or Football sim. Right now GLB is favouring an RPG because the avg lv.30 team will always beat the lv.25 team. If this was a football sim then football knowledge would allow the lv.25 to bridge the gap and cause an upset.
Last edited Dec 20, 2008 04:01:14
 
Homsar16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by prokop
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by Knick


Why not just move the terrible team down to the lowest uncapped league.

I don't really enjoy seeing teams forced to disband because of promotion anyway.


Erm, so the CPU's get moved to the first uncapped league? Doesn't that kind of defeat the purpose of letting people start at the bottom? You gotta promote from the bottom up.


leave them at higher leagues destroys all the fun. my Conference had 2 cpu teams and 2 slow build teams. 4 free wins. i dont know why they were in my league.


 
Raiders12
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dvolution
Originally posted by mike2686

The only answer to solve all of these problems in a complete league shakeup. Since the offseason should be longer anyways. I'd Leave the top teams in their respective leagues.

But for the most part alot of teams need to be added and dropped for every league and rearranged. That way the league will be as competetive as they are supposed to be atleast level and talent wise. All CPU Teams GLB wide should be sent to an entire new league such as A new BBB league, reset and handed out first. Move teams up accordingly, rearrange them as stated before.

I truly think this is the only way to fix the current problem. The slowbuilds should also be moved.

It would look something like this:

USA PRO- Same concept
USA AAA- Same concept
USA AA- Same concept
USA A- Uncapped But also rearange it so that the teams are equal.
USA BBB- Level 24 Cap (Rearange all the teams to where this wont screw anyone over and put every team with players 18-21 avg in these leagues,)
USA BB- level 13 Cap (New teams, slowbuilds, and Ex CPU teams)

I think this is the only way, but its very complicated and would take a while to complete. At this point I'm not sure much else can be done. We do have some very intellegent people on here though who will probably come up with something easier and better. This is just my thought.


This is one of the best concept yet proposed, with a league level always capped at level 13, every resetted team would get a fair chance at doing well. The promotion of teams wouldn,t be as painful as it is at this time. it'd still be tough to come out of a 13th capped league to a lvl 24 capped league, but not as tough as going straight to an uncapped league.


I think one of the problems with the BBB/BB leagues, is the cap issue. If I have a team of all 20 or below guys and have one 32 and one 29 player, that should not kick me up to the next league. That would suddenly make my team a door mat of this higher league because my one/two guys aren't going to make me competitive against a bunch of teams full of level 30+ guys.

I think there needs to be a better way than what I have seen to rank an overall team strength level, this would then make the positioning of teams in more equal leagues a lot easier.
 
Mowie Rad
offline
Link
 
The league issues are going to be a full time one due to financial, temper, and unreliable issues that arise from human ownership...gee, it's like real life or something. So far Bort has done a tremendous job of dealing with the constant issues that arise due to these factors, and constantly trying to come up with new ways to make it better. My hopes would be for a nice level per league system that would help recruiting for all level guys, instead of everyone just wants the lvl 35 guy and the lvl 28's are left without any team cause they're not great for the league they are in...this will never happen, so sadly I'm left watching teams disband and lvl 35's walk all over lvl 21 guys in what is not a fun sim to participate in. There is a way to fix the issue of lvl differential and that's to only block Free Agent signing above a certain level for the league they're in, but to be able to retain current players that exceed it to encourage people to stick with their team rather then constantly jump around creating Free Agent chaos and constant stupid requests for player salaries that Donald Trump doesn't make in year (although Bort might, I'm not sure).

Now since most are thinking this has nothing to do with the current topic, I'll bring it all back around. Truly Free Agency destroys some teams, as people want the "big money", but if you slowed the desire for that, then more teams could remain competitive and there would be less team turnover. If the incoming Fame has a huge impact by current years with the same team, this too could help with the issue. The leagues themselves could be more evened out with a simple lvl average per team, and go +/- 3 or so and that would determine the level of competition that the team would be good for. So you wouldn't have lvl 21 guys trying to compete with 30's or whatever. That would involve some work by Bort to have an average level calculation for each team, but hey, that's why he makes the big bucks. This also could lead to the ability to jump regions. If USA Pro (the supposedly elite) is the top one, then make it so the highest level average teams play there, then create a ladder system through the pro's down to AAA's etc until you have a basic level structure that would adjust each season per league as well. This is a lot of work, and would create a lot of whining, but keeping things even would also provide the most competition and even play throughout the leagues.

As to when to do this, it doesn't truly matter, as any way you do it, people will complain, argue or otherwise be upset. Hence day 41 is the best time, as it sticks with the plan to let people who have moved up have the most time to adjust during the offseason. Teams that are dropped and re-owned are going to have a hard time recruiting, but anyone who doesn't set their ownership preferences to avoid this is kinda taking what they get, and should expect some trouble to start. The only other way to avoid that is to setup the stop gap measure of CPU teams remaining CPU teams until a time where a message board could be setup saying x CPU team is available, apply here for it. And that's too much work for people to get in over the head and quit anyway. Now as I've babbled endlessly and probably did nothing more then come up with ideas Bort can't use, I'll stop and go deal with my screaming 4 month old.
 
tgy1369
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Usama
Originally posted by GG

Reduce the way the sim treats level disparity between players.
Currently a 5 level difference results in consistent 70-7 scores.
So make everything from 1 to 5 levels difference treated like no difference.
Treat 6-10 like it's 3 levels of difference.
Treat 11-15 like 5 levels of difference.
Etc.

This will go a long way to a) reducing those humungous 70-7 and 210-0 scores, and b) make it not so much of a hair-pulling aggravation this whole thing about ensuring higher level'd teams/players arent in lower level leagues and vice versa.

Because the differences will be so minimal that it wont matter as much anymore.


I agree with these sentiments. An average lv.20 team should be able to beat a lv.30 team, with better gameplanning, with builds being the controlled variable.

Right now Experience points have too much control of the outcome. Gameplanning should have more say in in the results. Instead of who just has as the players that have earned the most XP's.

I guess it is a matter of whether we an RPG or Football sim. Right now GLB is favouring an RPG because the avg lv.30 team will always beat the lv.25 team. If this was a football sim then football knowledge would allow the lv.25 to bridge the gap and cause an upset.


I dont csre if you has god as your coach, if you took 2 of the best teams from different levels of football...lets say the Florida Gators vs the New York Giants....the Giants would crush them by 70 points.....maybe not 200 like this game but it would be a blood bath...the reason why coaching (gameplanning) is important is when the talent IS EQUAL or close.....theres a saying old saying in college football......."its not about the Xs and Os its about the Jimmies and the Joes".
You need talent first THEN good gameplanning.
Last edited Dec 20, 2008 09:12:31
 
merenoise
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tgy1369
I dont csre if you has god as your coach, if you took 2 of the best teams from different levels of football...lets say the Florida Gators vs the New York Giants....the Giants would crush them by 70 points.....maybe not 200 like this game but it would be a blood bath...the reason why coaching (gameplanning) is important is when the talent IS EQUAL or close.....theres a saying old saying in college football......."its not about the Xs and Os its about the Jimmies and the Joes".
You need talent first THEN good gameplanning.


Exactly.
 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by merenoise
Originally posted by tgy1369

I dont csre if you has god as your coach, if you took 2 of the best teams from different levels of football...lets say the Florida Gators vs the New York Giants....the Giants would crush them by 70 points.....maybe not 200 like this game but it would be a blood bath...the reason why coaching (gameplanning) is important is when the talent IS EQUAL or close.....theres a saying old saying in college football......."its not about the Xs and Os its about the Jimmies and the Joes".
You need talent first THEN good gameplanning.


Exactly.


The Giants would beat the Gators by a lot more than 70, any NFL team would.
 
boilerup
offline
Link
 
We're less than a day away from the normal offseason, and there's still no official word?

Leave it the same as last year, and make the changes next season.

This change it as we go stuff needs to stop.
Last edited Dec 20, 2008 10:15:37
 
ryan_grant-25
offline
Link
 
i dont think its fair for CPU teams to all go to the lvl 21 capped leagues. this season there were teams with 7 CPU teams in the league. thats a free playoff spot basically. spread it out more imo.
 
the hurricane
offline
Link
 
Something needs to be done to address teams that are trying to rebuild in leagues with a level minimum. The pro team I GM for has 40 lowish level players lined up to start the rebuilding process and CAN'T SIGN ANY OF THEM. Surely something needs to be done, whether its moving the team, or allowing the players to sign.
 
voegma
offline
Link
 
I personally find it kind of stupid for a team that was in a 13 cap league to move up to a league with no cap at all. Why should the team that moved up have to completely disband to become competitive? Can't you just take all the winners from the 16 leagues and make them move in to one league within their own geographical area, then all those that finished second move in to another league and down the line. There all the teams that start in BBB together can essentially stay together. Essentially that allows all players who would be of a similar level to move together.

Let's use Western Europe as an example.

At the end of season 1 Winners go to a level 24 cap in BBB #1 and then 2nd place to BBB #2 etc....this begins season 2

Then at the end of season 2 winners and 2nd place teams move to two leagues and that is the new BBB#1-2 (trying to account for teams levels distribute accordingly) and it is capped at lets say 30-32 this begins season 3. So you take 2 teams from each leagues 1-16 and use some sort of program that would look at levels and say top team goes into league 1 and then next goes 2, then next goes 1 then back to 2 etc...this allows for the league to stay competitive and does not make a team gut themselves to move up. Teams that go CPU move to league 15-16.

Now finally in season 4 the league goes uncapped. No team has to be gutted and the competitive balance remains. Essentially as the teams move up in this fashion the leagues start to define themselves. 1st and 2nd would be pro 3-6 would be AAA, 7-14 would be AA. That leaves 2 leagues that you move CPU teams to. It gives free agents a chance to play and continue to improve their players with those of the same creation date time frame. At this level then all the teams may move up or down as they do now. The balance can still be there. So a diagram that helps out start at the bottom.

season 4................ no cap.......1-2..Pro
......................no cap.........3...4..5...6...AAA
...................no cap....7..8..9..10..11..12..13..14...AA
........................................15-16 CPU
season 3 cap 30-32 winners league.1.2.3.4.5.6.7.8.9.10.11.12.13.14.(15-16 CPU)
...
season 2..cap 24..winners league.1.2.3.4.5.6.7.8.9.10.11.12.13.14.(15-16 CPU)
...
season 1 all level capped 13 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Ok

1) Let's say a team a team expires. We flag it, and flag all the teams below to move up. The team owner contacts support and says "Ooops! I forgot to renew my team!" or "I wanted to transfer to my GM" or whatever. Now there is one less team flagged to move down, so one of the "fringe" capped teams is now un-flagged. Problem is: they've been able to recruit above the cap, and now they're not moving. Hrm.



Ideas? Thoughts?


If they let it expire then oh well, thats on them, not on the game or the admins, I'm sure they get enough warning. If they want to keep the team then move them down and have them recruit a new team. Balance in the leagues is more important than a owner forgetting about his team to begin with.
People can't use this excuse when the trade/cut deadline passes.

If they decide to keep the team and start from ground one on recruiting, then more power to them, I bet they won't forget about renewing next time.
If they don't keep the team then oh well, it was going cpu anyways. No loss there.

 
Guppy, Inc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort

This season I did put a "your team is expiring soon" warning on the team page, which I'm sure helped, but there's always going to be that one doofus who waited one day too long because he didn't get paid or just plum forgot.


this is a major problem in GLB. We pander to the doofuses way too much. Build a crappy player, bitch until the opposing position gets nerfed. Cant remember that you need to renew your team, inconvenience all of GLB. Meanwhile, there are some MAJOR issues with the game that could better use the time spent on them.
 
reddogrw
HOOD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Guppy, Inc
Originally posted by Bort


This season I did put a "your team is expiring soon" warning on the team page, which I'm sure helped, but there's always going to be that one doofus who waited one day too long because he didn't get paid or just plum forgot.


this is a major problem in GLB. We pander to the doofuses way too much. Build a crappy player, bitch until the opposing position gets nerfed. Cant remember that you need to renew your team, inconvenience all of GLB. Meanwhile, there are some MAJOR issues with the game that could better use the time spent on them.


agreed

you cannot spend 95% of your efforts trying to address 5% of the people

if you take care of the people that are active all the time and pay attention, this will continue to grow

if you spend all your effort trying to address the slackers, the hard core people will get frustrated and some will leave

if some of the slackers leave because the 17 notices that their team was up for renewal were not enough, the entire GLB is likely better off in the long run

you cannot make and change rules to accommodate the slackers; it's impossible to legislate competitive intelligence
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.