User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > FFA needs its own mod
Page:
 
imnott
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by LifeJuice
hai! imnotthatstupid


I will be signing ur DT in teh offseason right?


Oh and wanna have a an avatar bet for Bucs Panthers game
 
LifeJuice
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by imnotthatstupid
Originally posted by LifeJuice

hai! imnotthatstupid


I will be signing ur DT in teh offseason right?


Oh and wanna have a an avatar bet for Bucs Panthers game


ya

and

no

I'm not confident in this game and I don't want a homo av for a week.
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bartholomew
Ah well. I tried. I don't think you're going to get what I'm saying, therefore you will continuously be baited into locking threads. Have fun with that.


I get what you're saying, it's just not the right mindset to be in for, well, life. I mean if I have a kid, I'm not going to send him to school and say "now son, if a bully picks on you, curl up in a ball and do nothing. Eventually, he'll get tired of wailing on you and go away." No, I'm going to tell him to do something about it.

Now on GLB, unlike our public school system, if someone breaks the rules like that, Mods actually do something about it. So that's what I do.

If you honestly think the best way to combat a troll is to curl up into a ball and make it boring for him to wail on your till he gets bored and leaves, then you're just flat-out wrong.

The best way to make sure someone who trolls Suggestions doesn't do so anymore? Warn/Suspend him when he does it till he either stops or gets banned from posting completely. either way, he's then either reformed or leaves and it's an example to others who want to try crap like that.

Originally posted by Bartholomew
PS- The regulars are snobby assholes. Not just to FFAers, but to anyone making a suggestion they've already seen and debated or just don't approve of. They put up short , snippy rude replies to people who are not being rude to them.

They could try politely telling people an idea has already been rejected or why they don't think it will work. Or they could just not say anything.


So wait, if a thread is against the rules, been suggested many times (and still on page 1), or is a bad idea, people aren't supposed to say something against it? The same regulars you seem to think are all evil are the same ones who post more and push harder for good ideas than probably anyone else in the game. You can't have passion for something without being passionate against things which will hurt it.

And after the 75th thread on the same topic, anyone is going to get snippy.
 
ProfessionalKop
Gangstalicious
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed


So wait, if a thread is against the rules, been suggested many times (and still on page 1), or is a bad idea, people aren't supposed to say something against it? The same regulars you seem to think are all evil are the same ones who post more and push harder for good ideas than probably anyone else in the game. You can't have passion for something without being passionate against things which will hurt it.

And after the 75th thread on the same topic, anyone is going to get snippy.


this
 
Link
 
Originally posted by prokop
Originally posted by Jed



So wait, if a thread is against the rules, been suggested many times (and still on page 1), or is a bad idea, people aren't supposed to say something against it? The same regulars you seem to think are all evil are the same ones who post more and push harder for good ideas than probably anyone else in the game. You can't have passion for something without being passionate against things which will hurt it.

And after the 75th thread on the same topic, anyone is going to get snippy.


this


 
Bartholomew
offline
Link
 
If a thread is against the rules, why should they post to it at all? Just step back and let the mods delete it later or let it roll back to page four. Calling for it to be locked or blasting the poster just keeps it up top longer and attracts trolls.

If something gets suggested constantly by people who are not in this forum 24/7 and don't know it's being suggested constantly... Hrm... maybe a LOT of people think it's a good idea. Maybe that idea or something like it should be considered without being dicks to someone who is honestly trying to be helpful and has no clue that you've been ripping people up three times a week for saying it.

I did not say the regulars are evil. I said they are snobby assholes. There's a difference.
 
Yukon Don
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bartholomew
If a thread is against the rules, why should they post to it at all? Just step back and let the mods delete it later or let it roll back to page four. Calling for it to be locked or blasting the poster just keeps it up top longer and attracts trolls.

If something gets suggested constantly by people who are not in this forum 24/7 and don't know it's being suggested constantly... Hrm... maybe a LOT of people think it's a good idea. Maybe that idea or something like it should be considered without being dicks to someone who is honestly trying to be helpful and has no clue that you've been ripping people up three times a week for saying it.

I did not say the regulars are evil. I said they are snobby assholes. There's a difference.


You can call it 'snobby assholes'...most of us prefer to think of it as passionate protectors. I personally enjoy this game and want to see it continue to improve. As such I view the Suggestions forum as a vital part of that process. However to suggest that we should ignore those that are trying to crap on the suggestions forum seems a bit ludicrous. The 'trolls' threads may eventually roll off the front page, but their mere existence rolls a valid suggestion off the front page.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by rbedgood
Originally posted by Bartholomew

If a thread is against the rules, why should they post to it at all? Just step back and let the mods delete it later or let it roll back to page four. Calling for it to be locked or blasting the poster just keeps it up top longer and attracts trolls.

If something gets suggested constantly by people who are not in this forum 24/7 and don't know it's being suggested constantly... Hrm... maybe a LOT of people think it's a good idea. Maybe that idea or something like it should be considered without being dicks to someone who is honestly trying to be helpful and has no clue that you've been ripping people up three times a week for saying it.

I did not say the regulars are evil. I said they are snobby assholes. There's a difference.





You can call it 'snobby assholes'...most of us prefer to think of it as passionate protectors. I personally enjoy this game and want to see it continue to improve. As such I view the Suggestions forum as a vital part of that process. However to suggest that we should ignore those that are trying to crap on the suggestions forum seems a bit ludicrous. The 'trolls' threads may eventually roll off the front page, but their mere existence rolls a valid suggestion off the front page.





Yep. And I've advocated for several seasons now that the "Suggestions" forum have different rules for who can and can't post here--its the future of the game we're discussing here.
Last edited Dec 4, 2008 15:25:52
 
Bartholomew
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
Originally posted by Bartholomew

Ah well. I tried. I don't think you're going to get what I'm saying, therefore you will continuously be baited into locking threads. Have fun with that.


I get what you're saying, it's just not the right mindset to be in for, well, life. I mean if I have a kid, I'm not going to send him to school and say "now son, if a bully picks on you, curl up in a ball and do nothing. Eventually, he'll get tired of wailing on you and go away." No, I'm going to tell him to do something about it.

Now on GLB, unlike our public school system, if someone breaks the rules like that, Mods actually do something about it. So that's what I do.

If you honestly think the best way to combat a troll is to curl up into a ball and make it boring for him to wail on your till he gets bored and leaves, then you're just flat-out wrong.

The best way to make sure someone who trolls Suggestions doesn't do so anymore? Warn/Suspend him when he does it till he either stops or gets banned from posting completely. either way, he's then either reformed or leaves and it's an example to others who want to try crap like that.


I DO have a kid. If someone hits him he hits them back hard enough that they don't do it again, just like I told him to do. I've also told him that he shouldn't go around acting like he's superior to anyone. Eventually that catches up to you one way or another, or somebody decides you need to be taken down a notch.

That's the part I'm talking about. Your actions attract trolls. Your response to them keeps them coming back. By stomping on them, you're just fueling the fires. FFA baits you to lock threads constantly and you never disappoint. It's a game. Your heavy handed methods might get one guy banned, but then five of his friends are going to mess with you.

Read something, kiddo. Rule with an iron fist NEVER works. It keeps you constantly stressed and sooner or later you get a full scale rebellion. Oh.... wait... we almost had that once, didn't we?

 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader

Yep. And I've advocated for several seasons now that the "Suggestions" forum have different rules for who can and can't post here--its the future of the game we're discussing here.


Not entirely keen on that idea...random unseen people can make great suggestions, just like Bort can make bad suggestions (See: Weight Classes).
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bartholomew
If something gets suggested constantly by people who are not in this forum 24/7 and don't know it's being suggested constantly... Hrm... maybe a LOT of people think it's a good idea. Maybe that idea or something like it should be considered without being dicks to someone who is honestly trying to be helpful and has no clue that you've been ripping people up three times a week for saying it.


1) Glance at NGTH list (maybe ctrl+f to quickly see if your idea is there)
2) Glance at page 1 (again, ctrl+f is your friend, that's why we lock hook threads)
3) Post new thread.

and

1) Glance through thread
2) Post

If those simple steps were taken, people would get less annoyed at people not here all the time.


And no, something getting suggested a lot doesn't = good suggestion. It is the reason we have a NGTH list linked in all caps at the top of the page. All those things at once time or another were suggested VERY frequently and are not going to happen.

Originally posted by Bartholomew
I did not say the regulars are evil. I said they are snobby assholes. There's a difference.


Oh much better. <eyeroll>
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bartholomew


Read something, kiddo. Rule with an iron fist NEVER works. It keeps you constantly stressed and sooner or later you get a full scale rebellion. Oh.... wait... we almost had that once, didn't we?




What utter nonsense. If FFA had been run correctly from the get go, nobody would have ever had the illusion that they were allowed to piss on the carpet and poop on the floors of this site without fear of reaction. Instead, folks looked the other way for so long that the place is a blight on the rest of the site.

 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bartholomew
I DO have a kid. If someone hits him he hits them back hard enough that they don't do it again, just like I told him to do. I've also told him that he shouldn't go around acting like he's superior to anyone. Eventually that catches up to you one way or another, or somebody decides you need to be taken down a notch.

That's the part I'm talking about. Your actions attract trolls. Your response to them keeps them coming back. By stomping on them, you're just fueling the fires. FFA baits you to lock threads constantly and you never disappoint. It's a game. Your heavy handed methods might get one guy banned, but then five of his friends are going to mess with you.

Read something, kiddo. Rule with an iron fist NEVER works. It keeps you constantly stressed and sooner or later you get a full scale rebellion. Oh.... wait... we almost had that once, didn't we?


So....kid should stand up for himself, you made that step, but can't take it a step further to the comparison here? Oh well, I'll try another comparison later in the thread and see if that works better.

No stress here, it's pretty damn simple to keep things under control. And I don't know what rebellion you're talking about off-hand.

And I still love the "don't enforce rules, it'll make people follow the rules better" schtick. I mean seriously, do you say that outloud and it makes sense to you?

Squashing 1 also doesn't make 5 of his friends try harder. This isn't Braveheart. If you see someone get pulled over on your commute to work, you don't then say "fuck this, I'm gonna get 5 other people to speed through here till they stop pulling people over!" Because then, they'll just put more cops there till people stop speeding and you'll run out of points on your license before they'll run out of cops. Same idea here.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed

Squashing 1 also doesn't make 5 of his friends try harder.


It actually does with FFA. Have seen it first hand tbh

Then when the 5 others get banned, they start yelling that you are abusing your power.
Last edited Dec 4, 2008 15:37:56
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed


And I still love the "don't enforce rules, it'll make people follow the rules better" schtick. I mean seriously, do you say that outloud and it makes sense to you?





He probably thinks the United Nations is a useful entity.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.