User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Have "Superstars" and "All-Pros"
Page:
 
ProfessionalKop
Gangstalicious
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I would prefer something more along the lines of a "hidden talent" that unlocks after a certain level or something, than having people pay more to have a "super" player.


0_0 intense.
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I would prefer something more along the lines of a "hidden talent" that unlocks after a certain level or something, than having people pay more to have a "super" player.


Veteran Ability Breakthrough: Player has X% chance of gaining more than 5 SP when leveling. Max 8. X increases with more SP into the VA.

Something like that?
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Knick
Originally posted by Bort

I would prefer something more along the lines of a "hidden talent" that unlocks after a certain level or something, than having people pay more to have a "super" player.


Veteran Ability Breakthrough: Player has X% chance of gaining more than 5 SP when leveling. Max 8. X increases with more SP into the VA.

Something like that?


Yep, something like that. It'd have to be expensive to level up tho.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I would prefer something more along the lines of a "hidden talent" that unlocks after a certain level or something, than having people pay more to have a "super" player.


I like that better also, and if someone went back they could find a post that I made (I'm slightly editing my own idea here to make it stronger) would work it so that each level-up would be an 85% chance of 5 SP's, 10% of 6 SP's, and 5% of 7 SP's.

Extra SP's gained during the first 20 levels wouldn't be revealed (or used) until Level 20, to mess up minimaxers who might otherwise just create a boatload of players and see who had more at the end of one season and retire the rest.
 
themisterx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jumpman21
There are a lot of loopholes that people have mentioned, but I think the general concept is great and should eventually implemented to some degree.

Originally posted by themisterx

not a bad idea, but i think each user should be limited to one of each, and each team should be limited to 1 superstar and 2 all-pro's


what the hell is up with your avatar.


rex grossman is getting raped by the packers
 
SikoraP13 DTD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by themisterx
Originally posted by jumpman21

There are a lot of loopholes that people have mentioned, but I think the general concept is great and should eventually implemented to some degree.

Originally posted by themisterx


not a bad idea, but i think each user should be limited to one of each, and each team should be limited to 1 superstar and 2 all-pro's


what the hell is up with your avatar.


rex grossman is getting raped by the packers


true...and the panthers beat the packers...therefore, transitively, the panthers rape rex grossman.
 
themisterx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SikoraP13
Originally posted by themisterx

Originally posted by jumpman21


There are a lot of loopholes that people have mentioned, but I think the general concept is great and should eventually implemented to some degree.

Originally posted by themisterx



not a bad idea, but i think each user should be limited to one of each, and each team should be limited to 1 superstar and 2 all-pro's


what the hell is up with your avatar.


rex grossman is getting raped by the packers


true...and the panthers beat the packers...therefore, transitively, the panthers rape rex grossman.


i'm ok with anything that ends with the rape of rex grossman
 
Llyranwyar
offline
Link
 
BOOOOOO!!!!

I am dead set against any concrete hidden or otherwise ability that prevents my player from being good or makes him fundamentally better than another. Why would you even want to make a player who wasn't a superstar? "well, teams would need regular joes to fill out their roster." That's BS.

Who among you thinks there would be enough people out there who want to make crappy players so that other people's superstars could look good?

A build is a build. The idea that some players would just get more SP per level only means that they just get to the build faster than the next guy.

I play GLB with a group of guys that all play games together for years. This would force us to choose amongst the 2 dozen or so personalities to make a few Superstars.

The rich WOULD get RICHER. Think about it if some hidden attribute was revealed at some higher level. You discover that yours sucks and now your guy is gimped at high levels. Time to reroll. Think about how many players would do that and how many teams would gut or fold because of the player market at high levels. The highest levels would just be amassed with guys who all had Superstar quailties. Then they would all be collected on the top teams who had the most superstars because the other teams would fold under the divide in available talent.

But, wait....you said limits on how many per team. Yeah, ok. Try filling out a team with regular joes at high levels. People will want to reroll when they discovered how awesome they aren't going to be. let's just say for instance that the trait gets revealed at level 32. There you go. You will have superstars of level 45+ playing on teams filled out with level 20's and 30's because they are just playing the regular Joe roll until they find out if how awesome they are/aren't.

The only way I would be able to tolerate some sort of extra points to make your guy awesome is make it random for all equally and on a by level basis.

That or implement some sort of biorhythm for players. No extra points, just fluctuations from where their points are. You could have some sort of various physical, mental, and spiritual(confidence, vision, stam) wave patterns that could improve or undermine your build for a given day. Then you could have convergent highs for 'chances' at great performances. Convergent lows could be disasterous. Or you could just simply play to your abilities at a convergence in the middle.

Anywhich way, you are just taking the destiny out of the user's hands to some degree or another and gambling it or adding some sort of 'cheese' factor.

Still hanging onto the superstar stats mirage? Here's another idea for you. How about your superstar player has a EGO attribute that he developed when he realized how awesome he was and pulls a Plaxico Burress every once in a while? Have him loose points because he went into a strip club tossing cash about and some stripper grabs his junk and discharges his fire arm that was tucked in his pants leg. Your superstar dream was a gamble and lost. Teams then have to consider the risk of taking on a big pain in the ass as well. Perhaps some of these guys will just end up being super-failures and only gaining 3-4 pts per level averaged out over the course his career.

This idea just seems weak and not ultimately well thought out.
 
britdevine316
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I would prefer something more along the lines of a "hidden talent" that unlocks after a certain level or something, than having people pay more to have a "super" player.


If something like this is implemented the extra SP's need to be given out at Lvl 24 at the very least, more likley Lvl 32.

Having the SP's released early will just create a mass of players being retired at that level and people starting over. You don't want that.

I would say Lvl 29-32..Leaning more towards 29 as that's when leveling up becomes stagnant and could give us something to look forward to, while 29 being a high enough level that those playing the game would probably not retire their player if they only got 1 extra SP or something as they would be pretty invested into them by now.
 
flames54
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by britdevine316
Originally posted by Bort

I would prefer something more along the lines of a "hidden talent" that unlocks after a certain level or something, than having people pay more to have a "super" player.


If something like this is implemented the extra SP's need to be given out at Lvl 24 at the very least, more likley Lvl 32.

Having the SP's released early will just create a mass of players being retired at that level and people starting over. You don't want that.

I would say Lvl 29-32..Leaning more towards 29 as that's when leveling up becomes stagnant and could give us something to look forward to, while 29 being a high enough level that those playing the game would probably not retire their player if they only got 1 extra SP or something as they would be pretty invested into them by now.


Problem with Borts idea. You could stack a team with "breakthrough" players, and it would probably just end up with the exact same system we have now anyway, just with a few more sp's in it.

At least my idea would limit the number of superstars a team can field, in Bort's porposition it would be easy for owners to farm 3 or 400 players on various teams to create a completely stacked and 100% unbeatable team. Don't say it isn't possible to get that many players created to get breakthroughts for the top 40 to be on a real team, because I could do that in a second with just the people I know and many others would be able to as well.

Randomness will make this game lean much more towards an RPG than a football sim and that would make me quit for "real".
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Excellent idea.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by flames54
Originally posted by britdevine316

Originally posted by Bort


I would prefer something more along the lines of a "hidden talent" that unlocks after a certain level or something, than having people pay more to have a "super" player.


If something like this is implemented the extra SP's need to be given out at Lvl 24 at the very least, more likley Lvl 32.

Having the SP's released early will just create a mass of players being retired at that level and people starting over. You don't want that.

I would say Lvl 29-32..Leaning more towards 29 as that's when leveling up becomes stagnant and could give us something to look forward to, while 29 being a high enough level that those playing the game would probably not retire their player if they only got 1 extra SP or something as they would be pretty invested into them by now.


Problem with Borts idea. You could stack a team with "breakthrough" players, and it would probably just end up with the exact same system we have now anyway, just with a few more sp's in it.

At least my idea would limit the number of superstars a team can field, in Bort's porposition it would be easy for owners to farm 3 or 400 players on various teams to create a completely stacked and 100% unbeatable team. Don't say it isn't possible to get that many players created to get breakthroughts for the top 40 to be on a real team, because I could do that in a second with just the people I know and many others would be able to as well.

Randomness will make this game lean much more towards an RPG than a football sim and that would make me quit for "real".


It wouldn't make the game less realistic. Some prospects break through, and some don't; and even experts (such as NFL GM's) have a hard time telling which ones will or won't.

You're idea is also something I could support, if there are stricter limits per agent than you proposed (and multi-accounts can be policed well enough).

Without some very strict per agent limits (e.g. two superstars and four All-Pros per agent), then the game will tilt too much toward those who can spend the most money on it. With strict enough per-agent limits, I'm fine with your idea although I'd prefer the random method.

I also don't see that much need to restrict them per team for non-level-capped teams, as they'd essentially be higher level players with lower nominal levels.
 
R.Williams 34
offline
Link
 
i kind of like what Llyranwyar is saying, with the random selection, i was think what if you paid a few more FP when you first build a character to get a better starting build? like lets say a normal center gest a build of 17 strength and 18 blocking, well you could pay a lil bit more when you creat him to start with 23 strength and 25 blocking or somethin like that, that way they wont be incredibly far ahead of the "average joe" i do like the superstar thing where each lvl you get more SP, but see not every one has the money to keep up with a superstar player or even be able to buy one. and if a normal guy gets 5SP a lvl, and a super star gets 8sp a lvl, by lvl 10 he already has 27 SP more than an average joe, so really the superstar would actually be playing as good as a lvl 15-16 average joe player. by lvl 20 the superstar would have 57 more SP, thats a lvl 30-31 average joe player. and then the game would make a lot of players mad if their lvl 36 HB and bein caused to fumble by a lvl 19 LB.
 
britdevine316
offline
Link
 
It has to be random flames, Bort is never going to and should never raise the price of anything.

Getting a "superstar" or 'Allpro" player neds to be totally random if this is ever going to come into affect.

I also would support another attribute or a new SA Tree unlocking at Lvl 29. Anything to give the boosting player something more to do after 3 seasons. Right now we have 3 seasons of growth, then 7 seasons of not much to do.
 
hoyaboy1
offline
Link
 
I very much like this idea - there needs to be more differentiation between players.

If you don't want to charge more for SSs, have them be "revealed" at lvl 24 or 32 or something, and get a bunch of extra points.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.