User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Medium Coverage is totally f'ed up right now
Page:
 
Yellow
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by islander1

Originally posted by RAPB


Agreed so far:

- CB should play close
(- CB should even jump the route if he's absolutely sure to swat down the ball)
- normally, the CB should try to swat the ball down as soon as the WR touches it (=avoid the pass interference), then immediately tackle
- stepping back to allow the catch shouldn't be a choice (unless severely overmatched)

Question: what would it look like if the CB tried to stay close to swat the ball out of WRs hands, but doesn't have the agility to break/turn in time to do so?

Maybe (just maybe) the CB didn't have enough agility before, but since he was jumping the route anyway it just looked a lot closer. Now he's not jumping the route anymore, but can't turn as fast as needed?

(Maybe confidence and vision are in the equation too, so it might not be agility based...)

Just trying to find out what's going on. This might be a bug, but just coincidence. The first play I posted a CB failed that I consider very well build. Then again, even the best CB should miss vision/confidence based checks once in a while.


This, is exactly what I've been getting at all along.

The other factor is this. Before, medium coverage style implied that the CB would play aggressively IF he had help.

What happens if the CB is in a scenario where he is not? Well, according to the Bort change, he'll play less aggressively.

Solution: Don't blitz both of your safeties, actually allow your FS to play centerfield, etc etc


It's a solution, but not a great one if you have a built a defense around the Cover 0/Cover 1 premise.

I can go to Cover 2 and even Cover 3, but that is not what my defense is supposed to look like...we are not really built for that style.


No taut, you should have to change your entire defensive philosophy because some people want to argue with something obvious that is right in front of their faces.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Well, to be fair, RAPB often has good insights and I think it is worthwhile to listen to his arguments.

I don't know that it is 100% obvious, though it does seem at least 75% obvious from my seat.

It does seem as though my defense was hurt by this change, so it makes me a little pissed. I try not to let that emotion cloud my judgement and analysis of the changes in the sim, however.
 
Yellow
offline
Link
 
So for one of my games today, i played my CB on Medium/Loose.

This is what it looks like:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=213815&pbp_id=6809976

Hey, if people were worried about their CBs getting beaten too much, why wouldn't they just use this coverage? It's basically the exact same thing that Medium style is now.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Yellow
So for one of my games today, i played my CB on Medium/Loose.

This is what it looks like:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=213815&pbp_id=6809976

Hey, if people were worried about their CBs getting beaten too much, why wouldn't they just use this coverage? It's basically the exact same thing that Medium style is now.


Exactly.
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by RAPB
...

Question: what would it look like if the CB tried to stay close to swat the ball out of WRs hands, but doesn't have the agility to break/turn in time to do so?

Maybe (just maybe) the CB didn't have enough agility before, but since he was jumping the route anyway it just looked a lot closer. Now he's not jumping the route anymore, but can't turn as fast as needed?

(Maybe confidence and vision are in the equation too, so it might not be agility based...)
...


Your reasoning is sound, but if my CBs were in fact jumping the route before, and swatting the ball with incredible consistency, then that suggests that they have sufficient agility/vision/jumping/confidence, does it not?
...


As crazy as it sounds: not neccessary!

If the CB starts jumping the route as soon as the pass is thrown, he got more time to get in place than if he's trying to stick to the WR. A "last second" move of the WR might just throw him off (while in the past he'd not care for any WR moves after the ball was thrown).

(Your CBs were taking the risk of failing the deflection and letting the WR take off for 6. But this risk was very small for your CBs were/are very good at deflecting the ball. Since the WR is heading for the ball too, the dots might just appear as the CB sticking to the WR - when in fact both are playing the ball.)

To explain why the new "medium" is really needed:
Last season, the CBs of the Charleston Tigers didn't have much problems deflecting when playing the "old medium" in AAA. They were just doing what you describe for your CBs. This year in SA Pro, they always tried but failed way too much... and that's a problem when having no help over the top (cover 0 or cover 1). So we really want them not to try when beeing the last line of defense themselfes - while we want to encourage them to go for it when our safeties are around. So just what the description of "medium" says (playing loose obviously isn't a solution in this case).

Again: maybe the best solution would be a to have the "old medium" setting as a fourth coverage style (maybe like: "go for the deflection: the CB will jump the route frequently, but aim for a deflection instead of a interception"). For those guys that setting worked fine - it should just continue to work fine. On the other hand, maybe the new medium setting needs some work; there should be a difference between medium and loose for sure.
 
Yellow
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB

Again: maybe the best solution would be a to have the "old medium" setting as a fourth coverage style (maybe like: "go for the deflection: the CB will jump the route frequently, but aim for a deflection instead of a interception"). For those guys that setting worked fine - it should just continue to work fine. On the other hand, maybe the new medium setting needs some work; there should be a difference between medium and loose for sure.


Sounds like a great idea.

As it is now, the problem is that there is no compromise. You can either play Aggressive and have your guy get beat often over the top, or play Medium and have your guy get beat often underneath.

CBs should have a viable option when they don't have Safety help, and right now they do not have an option.



 
islander1
offline
Link
 
leave it to RAPB to wrap up 7 pages of whining within a few posts.
Well done.

and while Bort is readding that option back in, he can add the bump and run coverage tactic too
 
Link
 
Thanks for fkin this one up Bort!
 
Link
 
Not noticing a difference personally. Both of my CBs just had excellent weeks.
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Not noticing a difference personally. Both of my CBs just had excellent weeks.


Well. One of your game's wasn't much of a game:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=249184

And your other CB hasn't played a game in 2 days, so that game wouldn't have the bug in it.

So.. Not sure exactly what game you are talking about.
Last edited Nov 28, 2008 20:43:40
 
HydrOshocK
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1528123&page=21

the problem is being addressed
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.