User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > A real fix to speed
Page:
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by turnerhero
Who's gonna bless his soul if he's a god?!

You, my friend, are more fucked up than I


Dont get into the nitty gritty of religious details. We dont know the answers.
 
Ilok
offline
Link
 
I think I'm already past the point where this thread is relevant, but I want to add my two cents.

People that have loaded up their builds with nothing but speed can complain all they want if their build becomes obsolete with making strength and tackling more important. Those people have been taking advantage of a broken system and if there player breaks because the system is fixed, so be it.

The best way to add balance to this game is have every position need 4 to 5 attributes to be a well rounded build. The person can chose to raise 1 or 2 attributes super high, but at the expense of another skill the position needs.

Deon Sanders and Darrel Green made their living as super fast defensive players. They pretty much got destroyed if a running play came right at them, but no one was better at chasing someone down and making a tackle from behind. For power backs running all over teams for 25 YPC, make a bonus to tackling from behind. It gives the super fast defensive players a usefulness and it cuts down with the super strong running back effectiveness.

As for the all speed/agility no strength DEs, yes occasionally they should get around the corner untouched, but with 20 or 30 strength, if a 75+ strength tackle even lays a finger on them, they should be pancaked. Des should be built like CBs. If you line a cb at De in real football, they may occasional get around a tackle, but most of the time they would be thrown to the 200 level of the stands. I'll cry no tears over a DE that gets nerfed to hell after he built his player around an exploit.
 
czman
offline
Link
 
No wonder this thread died. Hijacking good ideas is uncool.
 
Link
 
Still Epic, once you get past the previous 2-3 pages of other discussion.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Bort's read it, acknowledged it, is aware of it. And there are many threads on that topic. No one intended to derail. I wouldnt either seeing as I fully support the anti-speed/agility campaign.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I have tried to increase the value of strength and tackling, etc, in
the past. All I get in return is 100 bug threads about how players miss
too many tackles, because everyone's 20 tackling CB is god's gift to
GLB.

Maybe I just need to let those go, but I also don't want to see power backs get 50 ypc all the time.

I'd like to add bump coverage for sure at some point, which would require strength for sure.


Yes, you really need to stop worrying about the people who whine about "my unrealistic player is no good anymore" and be willing to say, "He shouldn't be any good. He can't tackle."
 
Zadith
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by Bort

I have tried to increase the value of strength and tackling, etc, in
the past. All I get in return is 100 bug threads about how players miss
too many tackles, because everyone's 20 tackling CB is god's gift to
GLB.

Maybe I just need to let those go, but I also don't want to see power backs get 50 ypc all the time.

I'd like to add bump coverage for sure at some point, which would require strength for sure.


Yes, you really need to stop worrying about the people who whine about "my unrealistic player is no good anymore" and be willing to say, "He shouldn't be any good. He can't tackle."


But he makes a good point about power backs getting 50 ypc too. He needs to figure out a nice balance area before he changes it so the power backs do not over power the offense anymore than it already is right now.
 
ELGRAN11
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by czman

I do not think anyone minds 90 speed 35 strength DEs running around OTs that much. What they mind is that the 35 strength DE can hold his own at the LOS in the run and does not miss many tackles. If their was a negative equal to the positive I think most people would be OK with it.

i agree 100%.
 
djc6535
offline
Link
 
The real issue here is that you, Bort, need to figure out what reasonable builds are. What reflects reality. Does a 90 strength 30 speed running back reflect reality? does a 90 speed 30 strength DE reflect reality? The answers to both are no. You don't see any running backs as powerful and slow as offensive linemen and you don't see any defensive ends as fast and weak as corner backs.

 
GG
offline
Link
 
Speed DEs with 30 strength often just walk all over strength OTs too. Let alone beating them around the edge without a finger laid on them, they also power right thru them. And this whole thing of running the ball at the DEs is moot because they stop pretty much everything outside as well...especially since they're already in the backfield by the time the HB gets the hand-off.

Last edited Nov 26, 2008 17:33:40
 
jprietman
offline
Link
 
What I love most about this topic, is that I have been building balanced characters from the very beginning, and have been investing into whatever attributes I felt a REAL player of that position should have.

My players have all sucked for quite awhile, but they are getting better, and they are starting to come into their own.

I have come into plenty of arguments with pro-Speed enthusiasts over how to build a character. They laugh at me because their characters results are always so much better than mine.

Secretly I laugh at them, because Bort wants to nerf their characters and strengthen mine. It's only a matter of time before Bort finally redevelops a backbone, and the game will swing over to the players who are playing this game the RIGHT way.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Another thing that plays into this is that if you have a bunch of good well built balanced players, but you're outleveled by like 5 levels across the whole team, the game makes your players suck...slower, weaker, less agile, less effective. Fixes to the speed/agility thing also should entail forcing a reduction in the disparity between level differences.

Like a level 25 OT with a good and balanced 50-50-50 type of build should be able to play very well against a level 38 DE who has 1,453 in speed/agility but 20 in everything else. Just because he's level 38 and has x amount of more SPs in his player shouldnt necessarily mean BY DEFAULT he will pwn a well built player who purely due to his age just hasnt accrued the same amount of SPs---but he DID apply them more wisely/correctly. That should mean something. Should be more competitiveness forced into the code by saying that 10 levels of difference isnt as big as it used to be. So that it comes down to more the right APPLICATION of SPs rather than the AMOUNT of SPs.
 
iMan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Another thing that plays into this is that if you have a bunch of good well built balanced players, but you're outleveled by like 5 levels across the whole team, the game makes your players suck...slower, weaker, less agile, less effective. Fixes to the speed/agility thing also should entail forcing a reduction in the disparity between level differences.

Like a level 25 OT with a good and balanced 50-50-50 type of build should be able to play very well against a level 38 DE who has 1,453 in speed/agility but 20 in everything else. Just because he's level 38 and has x amount of more SPs in his player shouldnt necessarily mean BY DEFAULT he will pwn a well built player who purely due to his age just hasnt accrued the same amount of SPs---but he DID apply them more wisely/correctly. That should mean something. Should be more competitiveness forced into the code by saying that 10 levels of difference isnt as big as it used to be. So that it comes down to more the right APPLICATION of SPs rather than the AMOUNT of SPs.


obviously build > level but to a certain point, Level is to much to overcome
a lvl 25 should NOT be able to contain an at least average DE
 
domenick2x
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Another thing that plays into this is that if you have a bunch of good well built balanced players, but you're outleveled by like 5 levels across the whole team, the game makes your players suck...slower, weaker, less agile, less effective. Fixes to the speed/agility thing also should entail forcing a reduction in the disparity between level differences.

Like a level 25 OT with a good and balanced 50-50-50 type of build should be able to play very well against a level 38 DE who has 1,453 in speed/agility but 20 in everything else. Just because he's level 38 and has x amount of more SPs in his player shouldnt necessarily mean BY DEFAULT he will pwn a well built player who purely due to his age just hasnt accrued the same amount of SPs---but he DID apply them more wisely/correctly. That should mean something. Should be more competitiveness forced into the code by saying that 10 levels of difference isnt as big as it used to be. So that it comes down to more the right APPLICATION of SPs rather than the AMOUNT of SPs.


What, you mean an average OT can keep Mike Mamula from getting any sacks? That's.... so realistic....
 
GG
offline
Link
 
I think i said "should be able to play very well".

Like, he's not gonna be a superstar, or contain the raging defensive beasts all game, but he'll play very well all game.

Just trying to think of ways where you reward the application of SPs a little more, because currently, there's none of this. A DE with 90 speed/agility but 20 vision etc, shouldnt be making childsplay of a well built (but young) OT who has a good proportionate build. Because by concept alone, that DE is not well-built in realistic terms. This might coerce players with those sorts of freakish builds to spend some SPs developing other attributes to make them even better, rather than continuing to increase speed/agility above 90 and above 100 as the way "to make them better".

Just a suggestion!
Last edited Nov 26, 2008 17:58:49
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.