User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Weight Classes
Page:
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheInfinity
How about fixing the value of strength and carrying.


Maybe if people didn't bitch to high heaven every time their guy misses a tackle or two, I could ramp that up. That should be another thread, though.
 
TheInfinity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dianwei32
Originally posted by TheInfinity

This weight thing will be slanted to the lighter dudes, I'm sure of it. I know I'm not giving up speed on my WR for a marginal gain in his tackle breaking ability. And honestly, its totally not needed, its another thing for Bort to have to balance and tweak, for people to potentially exploit and pretty much gives us an option to do what we've always been able to do, sacrifice speed/agility for another attribute (not that many have ever had to really consider that trade off until the 3rd soft cap).


Ok, so you can make your WR be 160 lb and have all kinds of speed, but someone may make a CB that is a little heavier and be able to jam you at the line effectively and keep you from being a viable passing target (assuming jamming WR's at the line is implemented)

Someone else may choose to make their WR a little heavier and be able to beat the jam, get open, make the catch and truck some poor 160 lb FS en route to a TD.

Granted, these wouldn't happen every time, but it illustrates the benefit of sacrificing a small amount of speed to gain a little wieght.


Ok so the First Wide Receiver in your story is the Super Fast Light Dude. The Second Wide Receiver in your story is the Not as Fast Heavier Dude. The difference is that one guy is a bit stronger than the other.

Tell me, how is that different from a guy with 95/90/20 Spd/Agi/Str and a guy with 85/70/35 Spd/Agi/Str? I'll ruin it for you, its not different.
 
TheInfinity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by TheInfinity

How about fixing the value of strength and carrying.


Maybe if people didn't bitch to high heaven every time their guy misses a tackle or two, I could ramp that up. That should be another thread, though.


I'm all for letting them bitch all they want. Build a player according to what is needed, not some predetermined formula that you swear is going to work. If my FS started missing tackles, I'd be all over his strength and tackling ratings, not here yelling about it, I'm sure a ton of people would do the same.

And if this weight thing makes Power Backs more effective and they start missing tackles.. its just the more complicated and troublesome way for you to end up with them bitching at you.
Last edited Nov 23, 2008 20:47:22
 
czman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by TheInfinity

How about fixing the value of strength and carrying.


Maybe if people didn't bitch to high heaven every time their guy misses a tackle or two, I could ramp that up. That should be another thread, though.


http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1497993

If they complain let them. They will just fix their players strength and tackling.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by TheInfinity

How about fixing the value of strength and carrying.


Maybe if people didn't bitch to high heaven h.


That'd be the best solution. I never had a problem with my Olinemen, yet people complained, now people complain about dlinemen, and tbh, it doesn't matter anymore because there's always going to be someone out there who thinks he/she has the perfect build, and isn't getting rewarded enough for it, and they'll come in here bitching.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheInfinity
Originally posted by Dianwei32

Originally posted by TheInfinity


This weight thing will be slanted to the lighter dudes, I'm sure of it. I know I'm not giving up speed on my WR for a marginal gain in his tackle breaking ability. And honestly, its totally not needed, its another thing for Bort to have to balance and tweak, for people to potentially exploit and pretty much gives us an option to do what we've always been able to do, sacrifice speed/agility for another attribute (not that many have ever had to really consider that trade off until the 3rd soft cap).


Ok, so you can make your WR be 160 lb and have all kinds of speed, but someone may make a CB that is a little heavier and be able to jam you at the line effectively and keep you from being a viable passing target (assuming jamming WR's at the line is implemented)

Someone else may choose to make their WR a little heavier and be able to beat the jam, get open, make the catch and truck some poor 160 lb FS en route to a TD.

Granted, these wouldn't happen every time, but it illustrates the benefit of sacrificing a small amount of speed to gain a little wieght.


Ok so the First Wide Receiver in your story is the Super Fast Light Dude. The Second Wide Receiver in your story is the Not as Fast Heavier Dude. The difference is that one guy is a bit stronger than the other.

Tell me, how is that different from a guy with 95/90/20 Spd/Agi/Str and a guy with 85/70/35 Spd/Agi/Str? I'll ruin it for you, its not different.


The second guy has 15 fewer skill points for one...
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheInfinity

Ok so the First Wide Receiver in your story is the Super Fast Light Dude. The Second Wide Receiver in your story is the Not as Fast Heavier Dude. The difference is that one guy is a bit stronger than the other.

Tell me, how is that different from a guy with 95/90/20 Spd/Agi/Str and a guy with 85/70/35 Spd/Agi/Str? I'll ruin it for you, its not different.


So are you saying don't put the Weight Classes in simply because you can do the same thing with SP?

Because that's fairly weak. (HINT: lvl 30 players don't get many SP)

I like the idea, and am sad to see this hit the same road as every Weight thread so far
 
TheInfinity
offline
Link
 
Bah, darn maths..

But yeah, why go through all the trouble to do something we can already do. If you want to make the game more exciting for players at higher levels add in something that I can't already do and that really adds to the experience. All this will lead to is me finding the right weight for my player and moving on or exploiting it and making my player lose and gain weight as needed to win (though I highly doubt the latter will even be an option).
 
czman
offline
Link
 
Weight classes do not fix anything if everyone takes the lightest class. It actually exacerbates the problem of player being all speed based.

Until the reason people take speed over strength is addressed there is no fix.
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Try looking at it from the team level. You can recruit players based on speed and have a great pass D, but they cannot stop the run for the life of them (the Colts, for the most part). They were smaller, but faster. Is this your defensive philosophy? Or do you want heavy hitters that can shut down the run - Monsters of the Midway or the Steel Curtain?

Now you have to recruit players that fit your DC's philosophy. If you do not work together as a team, you will now pay more of a price. I fail to see why this is a problem, but I am semi-retarded. I work at Burger King, I wear paper hats.
 
xhail2skinsx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by TheInfinity

Originally posted by Dianwei32


Originally posted by TheInfinity



This weight thing will be slanted to the lighter dudes, I'm sure of it. I know I'm not giving up speed on my WR for a marginal gain in his tackle breaking ability. And honestly, its totally not needed, its another thing for Bort to have to balance and tweak, for people to potentially exploit and pretty much gives us an option to do what we've always been able to do, sacrifice speed/agility for another attribute (not that many have ever had to really consider that trade off until the 3rd soft cap).


Ok, so you can make your WR be 160 lb and have all kinds of speed, but someone may make a CB that is a little heavier and be able to jam you at the line effectively and keep you from being a viable passing target (assuming jamming WR's at the line is implemented)

Someone else may choose to make their WR a little heavier and be able to beat the jam, get open, make the catch and truck some poor 160 lb FS en route to a TD.

Granted, these wouldn't happen every time, but it illustrates the benefit of sacrificing a small amount of speed to gain a little wieght.


Ok so the First Wide Receiver in your story is the Super Fast Light Dude. The Second Wide Receiver in your story is the Not as Fast Heavier Dude. The difference is that one guy is a bit stronger than the other.

Tell me, how is that different from a guy with 95/90/20 Spd/Agi/Str and a guy with 85/70/35 Spd/Agi/Str? I'll ruin it for you, its not different.


The second guy has 15 fewer skill points for one...


OMG, I actually LOL'd on that one
 
Link
 
Originally posted by TheInfinity
Bah, darn maths..

But yeah, why go through all the trouble to do something we can already do. If you want to make the game more exciting for players at higher levels add in something that I can't already do and that really adds to the experience. All this will lead to is me finding the right weight for my player and moving on or exploiting it and making my player lose and gain weight as needed to win (though I highly doubt the latter will even be an option).


That would need to be fixed somehow tbh.
 
SwagOnLock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheInfinity
If you want to make the game more exciting for players at higher levels add in something that I can't already do and that really adds to the experience.


That's the very bottom line for me.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by kretchfoop
Try looking at it from the team level. You can recruit players based on speed and have a great pass D, but they cannot stop the run for the life of them (the Colts, for the most part). They were smaller, but faster. Is this your defensive philosophy? Or do you want heavy hitters that can shut down the run - Monsters of the Midway or the Steel Curtain?

Now you have to recruit players that fit your DC's philosophy. If you do not work together as a team, you will now pay more of a price. I fail to see why this is a problem, but I am semi-retarded. I work at Burger King, I wear paper hats.


do you make flame-broiled whoppers as well?
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheInfinity
Bah, darn maths..

But yeah, why go through all the trouble to do something we can already do. If you want to make the game more exciting for players at higher levels add in something that I can't already do and that really adds to the experience. All this will lead to is me finding the right weight for my player and moving on or exploiting it and making my player lose and gain weight as needed to win (though I highly doubt the latter will even be an option).


It just adds some DEPTH to players attributes. Speed would extend PAST just the build.

And I really don't see an "exploit". Each side has their respective benifits and weaknesses.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.